In the Matter of SC Pty Ltd (a pseudonym)

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Civil: Application)

IN THE MATTER OF SC PTY LTD (A PSEUDONYM)

[2023] SASC 26

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Kimber  

COURTS AND JUDGES - COURTS - JURISDICTION AND POWERS - CONCURRENT JURISDICTION OF DIFFERENT COURTS - TRANSFER OF PROCEEDINGS UNDER CROSS-VESTING LEGISLATION - WHERE APPROPRIATE AND IN INTERESTS OF JUSTICE - CORPORATION MATTERS

This is an application pursuant to s 1337H of the Corporations Act2001 (Cth) (CA) to transfer proceedings to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (FCFCOA).

The first applicant, VS, and the first respondent, GS, are the joint directors and shareholders of the third respondent, SC Pty Ltd.  The second respondent, ES, is the wife of GS. 

In July 2019, ES instituted proceedings in the FCFCOA with respect to the matrimonial property pool of ES and GS.  Those proceedings remain on foot.  ES contends the property pool includes GS’s 50% shareholding in SC Pty Ltd and two properties in Clarendon owned by GS and VS.  VS holds the balance of the shares in SC Pty Ltd. 

After the commencement of the proceedings in the FCFCOA, VS applied to bring proceedings in this Court pursuant to s 1337H of the CA and applied to join SC Pty Ltd as the second applicant pursuant to s 237 of the CA (the proposed proceedings). VS contends he is owed rent from the two properties and that he was underpaid for his work in SC Pty Ltd over several years. ES then applied in this Court to transfer VS’s proposed proceedings to the FCFCOA. VS and GS oppose that transfer.

Held, per Kimber J:

1.There being relevant overlap between the issues in the FCFCOA proceedings and the proposed proceedings, it is in the interests of justice to transfer the proposed proceedings to the FCFCOA.

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 237, 1337C, 1337H, referred to.
Yeo, in the matter of Armstrong and Shaw Pty Ltd (in liq) v Whiteman [2020] FCA 849; Peter G Ward Industries Pty Ltd (Ward Industries) [2020] NSWSC 339; Valceski v Valceski (2007) 210 FLR 387, applied.

IN THE MATTER OF SC PTY LTD (A PSEUDONYM)
[2023] SASC 26

Civil: Application

  1. This is an application pursuant to s 1337H of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (CA) to transfer proceedings to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (FCFCOA).  As the parties are involved in proceedings in the FCFCOA, I will use initials.

  2. The first applicant in this Court (VS) has filed an application (FDN 1) seeking leave to bring proceedings in the name of the third respondent (SC Pty Ltd) pursuant to s 237 of the CA (the proposed proceedings).  VS is a shareholder and director of SC Pty Ltd (the company).  The first respondent in the proposed proceedings (GS) is the brother of the first applicant and is also a shareholder and director of SC Pty Ltd.  The second respondent in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Matter of SC Pty Ltd (a pseudonym) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involves an application by ES to transfer proposed proceedings from this Court to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (FCFCOA). The proposed proceedings relate to a derivative action by ES on behalf of SC Pty Ltd against VS, GS and MS, alleging unpaid wages and rent. The existing FCFCOA proceedings involve a property settlement between ES and GS. ES seeks the transfer on the basis that it is in the interests of justice to have all related matters heard by one court. The legal issues before the Court were whether the transfer was appropriate under the cross-vesting legislation and whether it was in the interests of justice to transfer the proceedings. The Court found that the FCFCOA has concurrent jurisdiction over the proposed proceedings and that the transfer was appropriate. The Court conducted a balancing exercise between relevant factors to determine whether the transfer was in the interests of justice. The Court found that there was relevant overlap between the issues in the FCFCOA and the proposed proceedings, and that the FCFCOA was better placed to resolve all potential issues. The Court also considered the risk of conflicting findings of fact and the potential unnecessary drain on judicial and other resources. The Court concluded that the transfer was in the interests of justice.

The Court transferred the proposed proceedings to the FCFCOA, noting that the transfer was in the interests of justice. The Court noted that the FCFCOA has jurisdiction over the proposed proceedings and that the transfer was appropriate under the cross-vesting legislation. The Court also noted that the transfer would not end the involvement of VS in the FCFCOA proceedings, and that there remained the issue of the Marino property. The Court further noted that the transfer would not necessarily result in VS incurring costs that he might not otherwise incur if the proposed proceedings were resolved in this Court. The Court ordered that the proposed proceedings be transferred to the FCFCOA and that the parties be heard as to any further orders.

Background

Background to the litigation

These are my reasons for granting the application by ES to transfer the proposed proceedings. BackgroundFCFCOA Proceedings ES and GS were married on 10 December 2000 but separated in August 2017. ES instituted proceedings in the FCFCOA on 3 July 2019. The Initiating Application was accompanied by a supporting affidavit by ES dated the same day. The respondents to the Initiating Application were GS, his mother MS and VS. The matrimonial assets and issues to be addressed as part of the property settlement between ES and GS as identified in the supporting affidavit of ES were: 1.The matrimonial home; 2.Two properties at Clarendon owned by GS and VS as tenants in common in joint shares (the Clarendon properties) from which the business of SC Pty Ltd (the company), is conducted; 3.GS’ fifty per cent shareholding in the company (the other fifty per cent being held by VS); 4.A property located at Marino (the Marino property) owned by MS and VS as joint owners and tenants in common (in respect of which ES contends that MS holds her half share on trust for GS such that the Marino property forms part of the pool of matrimonial assets); and 5.Motor vehicles, a boat, bank accounts and superannuation. In her affidavit, ES deposed that GS had threatened that if she sought a divorce VS would pursue proceedings against SC Pty Ltd claiming unpaid wages to denude the company of assets. ES sought orders restraining VS from pursuing proceedings against the company. Interim orders were made on 13 August 2019 requiring GS to provide a vehicle to ES, restraining GS from dealing with the various properties and providing for a timetable. GS filed an affidavit of 1 November 2019 in response to the affidavit of ES of 3 July 2019. In that affidavit, GS relevantly set out that he denied any interest in the Marino property and appeared to accept that VS was entitled to substantial unpaid wages from the company. Further orders were made on 1 November 2019 for a partial property settlement to ES and further timetabling. VS subsequently received extensions of time to file his responding material. On 31 January 2020, VS filed a response to the Initiating Application and the supporting affidavit of ES. The response of VS sought orders that he obtain discovery of the accounting records of the company and that the property settlement proceedings otherwise be adjourned pending the resolution of his claims against the company, GS and ES. In VS’s supporting affidavit he:1.Denied that GS had any interest in the Marino property and opposed orders sought by ES that a half share in the Marino property held by MS formed part of the pool of matrimonial assets; and 2.Set out at length the basis for a claim that he was owed outstanding entitlements by the company and reserved the right to pursue those proceedings in another court. Subsequently, VS obtained an expert accounting report which was exhibited to an affidavit of his solicitor filed in the FCFCOA proceedings on 11 September 2020.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Further, this is not a case in which the resolution of the proposed proceedings in this Court will end the involvement of VS in the FCFCOA proceedings. Even were the proposed proceedings resolved in this Court, there will remain, at least, the issue of the Marino property. On the material before me, VS is involved in the issues surrounding the Marino property and those issues can only be resolved in the FCFCOA. Conclusion It is in the interests of justice the proposed proceedings in this Court be transferred to the FCFCOA. I am satisfied there is relevant overlap between the issues in the FCFCOA and the proposed proceedings in this Court. That overlap relates to issues surrounding the property which is said to be part of the matrimonial pool of property available to GS and ES. I am not satisfied the issues in the proposed proceedings are of a complexity necessitating this Court assuming responsibility. Assuming VS may incur costs in the FCFCOA which he might not incur if the proposed proceedings were resolved in this Court, that is not a consideration which outweighs the interests in limiting the risk of further delay; the risk of conflicting findings of fact and the ability of the FCFCOA to resolve all potential issues. Orders 1.The proposed proceeding in this Court (FDN 1) is transferred to the FCFCOA pursuant to s 1337H of the CA.2.I will hear the parties as to any further orders.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As set out above, the proposed proceedings in this Court were filed on 11 April 2022. In summary, the proposed proceedings allege that VS was underpaid for his work for the company over many years and the company did not pay rent in respect of the Clarendon properties owned in partnership between VS and GS. The effect of the proposed derivative action is to claw back for SC Pty Ltd alleged overpaid entitlements to GS and ES, so that the company would then be able to pay VS. On 29 April 2022 ES filed the application to transfer the proposed proceedings (FDN 6). The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) The FCFCOA has jurisdiction with respect to the proposed proceedings. Section 1337C(1) of the CA provides: (1)Jurisdiction is conferred on the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 1) with respect to civil matters arising under the Corporations legislation. This Court has the power to transfer proceedings to the FCFCOA in the exercise of its discretion. Section 1337H relevantly provides:(1) This section applies to a proceeding (the relevant proceeding) in a court (the transferor court) if: (a)the relevant proceeding is: (i)a proceeding with respect to a civil matter arising under the Corporations legislation; or (ii)a subsection 1337B(3) proceeding; and (b)the transferor court is: (i)the Federal court; or (ii)a State or Territory Supreme Court. (2) Subject to subsections (3), (4) and (5), if it appears to the transferor court that, having regard to the interests of justice, it is more appropriate for: (a)the relevant proceeding; or (b)an application in the relevant proceeding; to be determined by another court that has jurisdiction in the matters for determination in the relevant proceeding or application, the transferor court may transfer the relevant proceeding or application to that other court. Section 1337H(3), (4) and (5) are not relevant to the application before me. The interests of justice In Yeo, in the matter of Armstrong and Shaw Pty Ltd (in liq) v Whiteman [2020] FCA 849 (Yeo), Anderson J summarised the principles with respect to the exercise of the power conferred by s 1337H(2) of the CA and the concept of the ‘interests of justice’. Anderson J held:Section 1337H(2) confers a wide discretion to transfer proceedings where, “having regard to the interests of justice”, it is “more appropriate” for the proceeding to be heard by the other court. The meaning of “the interests of justice” in the context of the transfer of proceedings has been considered on many occasions in different statutory schemes: see, in particular, BHP Billiton Ltd v Schultz [2004] HCA 61; 221 CLR 400.Recent examples of the consideration of the transfer of proceedings from this Court to other courts under s 1337H(2) of the Corporations Act include Hancock Prospecting Pty Ltd v 150 Investments Pty Ltd [2017] FCA 520; 120 ACSR 495 per Yates J and Bell Group NV v Bell Group Finance Pty Ltd, Re Western Interstate Pty Ltd [2018] FCA 1440; 130 ACSR 586 per McKerracher J. Both of those decisions referred to the following guiding principles summarised by McKerracher J in Yara Pilbara Fertilisers Pty Ltd (formerly known as Burrup Fertilisers Pty Ltd) v Oswal (No 8) [2015] FCA 49 (in which his Honour transferred a proceeding to the Supreme Court of Victoria):The leading authority which canvasses many of the issues to be taken into account is BHP Billiton Limited v Schultz (2004) 221 CLR 400. As the case law reflects, it is necessary to conduct a balancing exercise between relevant factors that inform as to whether or not it is in the interests of justice to transfer a proceeding. The weighing of considerations, such as cost, expense and convenience, even when they conflict, is a familiar aspect of the kind of case management involved in many cross-vesting applications: BHP per Gleeson CJ, McHugh and Heydon JJ (at [19]). While BHP considered the cross-vesting regime, for practical purposes the criteria for determining whether a proceeding should be transferred are broadly consistent with the criteria for determining cross-vesting: see Dwyer v Hindal Corporate Pty Ltd (2005) 52 ACSR 335 per Debelle J (at [13]). The question is essentially practical, or in the words used in BHP, it is essentially a 'nuts and bolts' management decision as to which court, in the pursuit of the interests of justice, is the more appropriate to hear and determine the substantive dispute: BHP per Gleeson CJ, McHugh and Heydon JJ (at [13]); Bankinvest AG v Seabrook (1988) 14 NSWLR 711 per Street CJ (at 713-714). The ‘interests of justice’ is an expression to be interpreted broadly: BHP per Gleeson CJ, McHugh and Heydon JJ (at [15]).The Court should not approach the transfer question with any presumption as to where the interests of justice lie: BHP per Gleeson CJ, McHugh and Heydon JJ (at [25]). It is not a circumstance in which an applicant has an onus of persuasion analogous to an onus of proof: BHP per Gummow J (at [71]). The disposition of an application for transfer of a proceeding does not require weight to be given to the plaintiff's choice of forum, which is essentially a neutral factor: BHP per Kirby J (at [168]) and per Gummow J (at 77).As I noted in Commissioner of Taxation v Residence Riverside Proprietary Limited as Trustee for the D& J Discretionary Trust and as Trustee for the D& J Investment Trust [2013] FCA 720 (at [17]), this Court has previously recognised many factors as being relevant to the decision, which will vary in weight from case to case, including:1.the stage of the proceedings in the respective courts;2.the commonality or diversity of the parties;3.the nature of the proceedings;4.the commonality or diversity of issues;5.the risk of conflicting findings of fact or conflicting orders;6.a costs benefit analysis;7.the potential unnecessary drain on judicial and other public and private resources; and 8.whether there is any particular judicial expertise residing in one court of the other.