In the Matter of QR

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



IN THE MATTER OF QR (Guardianship) [2018] ACAT 118

GT 151/2018

Catchwords:              GUARDIANSHIP – applications for appointment as guardian and financial manager for a person – statutory criteria for appointment – factors to be taken into account – circumstances in which Public Trustee and Guardian should be appointed rather than an available family member who meets most statutory conditions for appointment – principles to be followed by decision-maker

Legislation cited: ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 s 26

Guardianship and Management of Property Act 1991 ss 4, 5, 5A, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 14, 19, 24, 26, 27

Cases cited:Holt v Protective Commissioner (1993) 31 NSWLR 227

In the matter of AB [2017] ACAT 67

In the matter of LQL [2018] ACAT 53

M v M [2013] NSWSC 1495
Public Trustee for the ACT v Lee [2014] ACAT 69
Re LSC and GC [2016] NSWSC 1896

Tribunal:                   President G Neate AM
  Member R Vassarotti

Date of Orders:  26 November 2018

Date of Reasons for Decision:         26 November 2018

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          GT 151/2018

In respect of

QR

D.O.B 18/10/1924

TRIBUNAL:   President G Neate AM

Member R Vassarotti

DATE:26 November 2018

ORDER

1.The whole of the Enduring Power of Attorney executed by QR on 5 August 2005 is revoked.

Appointment of Guardian

2.VX is appointed guardian for QR (the protected person) with the following powers:

(a)to decide where, and with whom, the protected person is to live;

(b)to give any consent required for a medical procedure or other treatment (other than a prescribed medical procedure);

(c)to give any consent required for medical treatment involving treatment, care or support under the Mental Health Act 2015 (other than a prescribed medical procedure);

(d)to make other personal decisions needed to ensure the protected person’s health and welfare needs are met and to protect her from unreasonable risks to her health and welfare; and

(e)to do things necessary to give effect to decisions about the matters set out above, including (but not limited to):

(i)      giving or receiving information; or

(ii)      giving consent to investigations and assessments; or

(iii)     participating in negotiations; or

(iv)     signing documents.

3.The Tribunal will review this appointment on its own initiative before 26 November 2021.

4.The guardian must notify the Tribunal or any changes to the address of, or of any other significant change in circumstances of, herself or of the protected person.

Appointment of Manager

5.ST is appointed as manager to manage all of the property including finances of QR (the protected person) with the following powers:

(a)all the powers the protected person would have been entitled to exercise if she were legally competent to exercise powers in relation to her property including her finances herself.

6.Any dealings with the real property of the protected person must have prior endorsement of the Public Trustee and Guardian.

7.The Tribunal notes that, before endorsing the sale of any real…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Matter of QR and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] ACAT 118
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) was asked to consider the capacity of QR, who executed an Enduring Power of Attorney on 5 August 2005. The dispute centred around the revocation of the power of attorney and the appointment of a guardian and a manager for QR, who was deemed to lack the mental capacity to manage their own affairs. The QCAT was required to determine whether QR lacked the capacity to manage their own affairs and, if so, who should be appointed to act on their behalf.

The QCAT considered whether QR lacked the capacity to manage their own affairs and, if so, who should be appointed as a guardian and manager. The tribunal found that QR lacked the capacity to manage their own affairs and, therefore, it was necessary to appoint a guardian and a manager to act on their behalf. The tribunal also had to consider the appropriate powers and limitations for the appointed guardian and manager.

In its decision, the QCAT revoked the Enduring Power of Attorney executed by QR on 5 August 2005. VX was appointed as the guardian for QR with specific powers to make decisions about QR's living arrangements and medical treatments, as well as to make other personal decisions to ensure QR's health and welfare. ST was appointed as the manager to manage QR's property and finances, with certain limitations on the sale of real property. The tribunal also set out review dates for the appointments and required notifications of any changes in circumstances.

The final orders of the tribunal included the revocation of the Enduring Power of Attorney, the appointment of VX as guardian with specified powers, and the appointment of ST as manager with certain limitations. The tribunal also set out review dates for the appointments and required notifications of any changes in circumstances.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The whole of the Enduring Power of Attorney executed by QR on 5 August 2005 is revoked.

Appointment of Guardian

2. VX is appointed guardian for QR (the protected person) with the following powers:

(a) to decide where, and with whom, the protected person is to live;

(b) to give any consent required for a medical procedure or other treatment (other than a prescribed medical procedure);

(c) to give any consent required for medical treatment involving treatment, care or support under the Mental Health Act 2015 (other than a prescribed medical procedure);

(d) to make other personal decisions needed to ensure the protected person’s health and welfare needs are met and to protect her from unreasonable risks to her health and welfare; and

(e) to do things necessary to give effect to decisions about the matters set out above, including (but not limited to):

(i) giving or receiving information; or

(ii) giving consent to investigations and assessments; or

(iii) participating in negotiations; or

(iv) signing documents.

3. The Tribunal will review this appointment on its own initiative before 26 November 2021.

4. The guardian must notify the Tribunal or any changes to the address of, or of any other significant change in circumstances of, herself or of the protected person.

Appointment of Manager

5. ST is appointed as manager to manage all of the property including finances of QR (the protected person) with the following powers:

(a) all the powers the protected person would have been entitled to exercise if she were legally competent to exercise powers in relation to her property including her finances herself.

6. Any dealings with the real property of the protected person must have prior endorsement of the Public Trustee and Guardian.

7. The Tribunal notes that, before endorsing the sale of any real property, the Public Trustee and Guardian will require evidence that:

(b) the sale price is the true market value of the property; and

(c) the sale is in the best interests of the protected person.

8. The Tribunal will review this appointment on its own initiative before 26 November 2021.

9. The manager must notify the Tribunal of any changes to the address of, or of any other significant change in the circumstances of, herself or the protected person.

Background

Background to the litigation

QR is an individual who has been the subject of a legal dispute regarding her capacity to manage her own affairs. On 5 August 2005, QR executed an Enduring Power of Attorney, which granted someone the authority to make decisions on her behalf. However, concerns have arisen about QR's capacity to make such decisions, leading to this legal matter. The dispute has necessitated the appointment of a guardian and a manager to oversee QR's personal and financial affairs respectively. The case has come before the Tribunal to determine the appropriate course of action regarding QR's capacity and the allocation of responsibilities for her care and property management.

The matter was brought before the Tribunal by interested parties who had concerns about QR's capacity to manage her own affairs. The Tribunal was required to assess QR's capacity and determine the appropriate steps to protect her interests. This involved considering evidence and submissions from various stakeholders, including medical professionals, family members, and legal representatives. The Tribunal conducted hearings to gather information and make findings on QR's capacity and the necessity for the appointment of a guardian and a manager. The Tribunal has now made orders appointing VX as guardian and ST as manager for QR, with specific powers and conditions outlined in the orders.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether QR lacks the capacity to manage her own affairs.
2. If so, who should be appointed as guardian for QR and what powers should be granted to that guardian.
3. If so, who should be appointed as manager for QR's property and what powers should be granted to that manager.
4. What conditions should be attached to the appointments of the guardian and manager to ensure they act in QR's best interests.

Held
1. The court held that QR lacks the capacity to manage her own affairs.
2. The court held that VX should be appointed as guardian for QR with the specified powers outlined in the decision.
3. The court held that ST should be appointed as manager for QR's property with the specified powers outlined in the decision.
4. The court held that the appointments of the guardian and manager should include conditions that they act in QR's best interests and that they notify the Tribunal of any significant changes in circumstances.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found that QR lacked the capacity to manage her own affairs based on the evidence presented, including medical assessments and expert opinions. This finding was crucial in determining the need for an appointed guardian and manager. Regarding the appointment of a guardian, the court considered the wishes of QR, the recommendations of health professionals, and the suitability of the proposed guardian, VX. The powers granted to VX were tailored to meet QR's specific needs and ensure her health, welfare, and protection from unreasonable risks. The court also mandated that the Tribunal review the appointment of the guardian before 26 November 2021 and that VX notify the Tribunal of any significant changes in circumstances. For the appointment of a manager, ST was deemed suitable to manage QR's property and finances, with powers mirroring what QR could exercise if competent. The court emphasised the need for the Public Trustee and Guardian to endorse any dealings with QR's real property to ensure that sales are at true market value and in QR's best interests. The court similarly mandated a Tribunal review of the manager's appointment before 26 November 2021 and required ST to notify the Tribunal of any significant changes in circumstances. The ratio decidendi of this case is the careful balancing of the need to protect incapacitated individuals with the rights of guardians and managers to act in the protected person's best interests, subject to oversight by the Tribunal. The court followed established principles in guardianship and property management, ensuring that the appointments are in line with the statutory framework and the specific needs of QR. The court distinguished this case from others by focusing on QR's unique circumstances and the suitability of the proposed guardian and manager.