Public Trustee for the ACT v Lee

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



PUBLIC TRUSTEE FOR THE ACT v LEE (Appeal) [2014] ACAT 69

AA 23 of 2014

Catchwords:             APPEAL – GUARDIANSHIP AND MANAGEMENT OF PROPERTY – variation of order – appointment of Public Trustee as financial manager - substitution of natural person for Public Trustee – interaction of section 9(5) and section 31 – whether section 31 requires some finding of fault before a suitable natural person is substituted as manager for Public Trustee- ambiguity in section 31 - legislative intent that natural person takes precedence over Public Trustee – legislative amendment recommended  

Legislation:Guardianship and Management of Property Act 1991

ss 9(5), 31(1)(a)

Texts/Papers:            Explanatory Statement, Guardianship and Management of Property Bill 1991

Appeal Tribunal:                 Mr W.G Stefaniak AM – Appeal President

Mr H. Hird – Member

Date of Orders:  31 July 2014               

Reasons for Decision:           31 July 2014

Publication of reasons for decision:         5 November 2014

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
CIVIL AND ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL  

Appeal Reference No: AA 14/23 from GT 02/22

RE:PUBLIC TRUSTEE

FOR THE ACT

Appellant

RODNEY JOHN LEE
Respondent

ORDER

Appeal Tribunal:                 Mr W.G Stefaniak AM – Appeal President

Mr H. Hird – Member

Date of Order:  31 July 2014

The Tribunal Orders that:

  1. Appeal dismissed

  2. Order of the original tribunal dated 22 April 2014 is varied and the following orders substituted:

    Appointment of Guardian

    1.      Gregory Thomas Lee is appointed guardian for Rodney John Lee (the protected person) with the following powers:

    (a)to give any consent required for a medical procedure or other treatment (other than a prescribed medical procedure);

    (b)to make other personal decisions and arrangements needed to ensure that the protected person’s health and welfare needs are met and to protect him from unreasonable risks to his health and welfare.

    (c)to do the things necessary to give effect to decisions about the matters set out above, including (but not limited to):

    (i)giving or receiving information; or

    (ii)giving consent to investigations or assessments; or,

    (iii)participating in negotiations; or

    (iv)Signing documents

    2.       The Tribunal will review this appointment on its own initiative before 22 April  2017

    3.      The guardian must notify the Tribunal of any change to the address of, or of any other significant change in circumstances of themselves or of the protected person.

    Appointment of Manager

    The Tribunal finds that Gregory Thomas Lee is suitable for appointment as the protected person’s financial manager and orders as follow:

    4.      Gregory Thomas lee is appointed as manager to manage all of the property of Rodney John Lee (the protected person) with the following powers:

    (i)all the powers that the protected person would have been entitled to exercise if he were legally competent to exercise powers in relation to his property himself.

    5.      The manager is directed to obtain the endorsement of the Public Trustee of any sale, purchase or mortgaging of real property and to provide information as requested by the Public Trustee for the Australian Capital Territory about any such dealing and is further to seek the endorsement of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Public Trustee for the ACT v Lee and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ACAT 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Public Trustee for the Australian Capital Territory appealed against an order of the Guardianship and Management of Property Tribunal of the ACT, dated 22 April 2014. The order appointed Gregory Thomas Lee as the guardian and financial manager of Rodney John Lee, who was unable to manage his own affairs due to significant cognitive impairment. The Public Trustee argued that Mr Lee should not be appointed as the guardian and financial manager because he was not a suitable person to hold those positions. The appeal was heard in the ACT Supreme Court, where the Court was required to determine whether the original decision of the Tribunal was correct and whether Mr Lee was suitable to hold the positions of guardian and financial manager of Mr Lee.

The Court held that Mr Lee was a suitable person to hold the positions of guardian and financial manager. The Court noted that Mr Lee was the only person willing and able to act as the guardian and financial manager of Mr Lee. The Court also noted that the Public Trustee had not provided any evidence to suggest that Mr Lee was not suitable to hold those positions. The Court held that the original decision of the Tribunal was correct and dismissed the appeal.

The Court varied the order of the Tribunal and substituted the following orders: Gregory Thomas Lee was appointed as the guardian and financial manager of Rodney John Lee, with specific powers to give consent for medical procedures and make personal decisions to ensure his health and welfare needs were met. The Court also ordered that the Tribunal review the appointment on its own initiative before 22 April 2017 and that the guardian and financial manager notify the Tribunal of any significant changes in circumstances. The Court further ordered that the financial manager obtain the endorsement of the Public Trustee for any sale, purchase, or mortgaging of real property and to provide information about any such dealings. The Court noted that there may be uncertainty or disagreement about what property forms the pool of property that can be managed under the order and encouraged the manager and the Public Trustee to work together to remove any uncertainty or disagreement.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

Appeal dismissed

2.

Order of the original tribunal dated 22 April 2014 is varied and the following orders substituted:

Appointment of Guardian

1. Gregory Thomas Lee is appointed guardian for Rodney John Lee (the protected person) with the following powers:

(a) to give any consent required for a medical procedure or other treatment (other than a prescribed medical procedure);

(b) to make other personal decisions and arrangements needed to ensure that the protected person’s health and welfare needs are met and to protect him from unreasonable risks to his health and welfare.

(c) to do the things necessary to give effect to decisions about the matters set out above, including (but not limited to):

(i) giving or receiving information; or

(ii) giving consent to investigations or assessments; or,

(iii) participating in negotiations; or

(iv) Signing documents

2. The Tribunal will review this appointment on its own initiative before 22 April 2017

3. The guardian must notify the Tribunal of any change to the address of, or of any other significant change in circumstances of themselves or of the protected person.

Appointment of Manager

The Tribunal finds that Gregory Thomas Lee is suitable for appointment as the protected person’s financial manager and orders as follow:

4. Gregory Thomas lee is appointed as manager to manage all of the property of Rodney John Lee (the protected person) with the following powers:

(i) all the powers that the protected person would have been entitled to exercise if he were legally competent to exercise powers in relation to his property himself.

5. The manager is directed to obtain the endorsement of the Public Trustee of any sale, purchase or mortgaging of real property and to provide information as requested by the Public Trustee for the Australian Capital Territory about any such dealing and is further to seek the endorsement of the Public Trustee before implementing any decision to divest or make any significant change to the protected person’s superannuation scheme investment.

6. If the Public Trustee refuses to provide an endorsement pursuant to order 5 above it shall seek a direction from ACAT pursuant to section 16 of the Guardianship and Management of Property Act 1991.

7. The Tribunal will review on its own initiative before 22 April 2017.

8. The manager must notify the Tribunal of any change of the address of, or of any significant change in circumstances of, themselves or of the protected person.

The Tribunal notes that there may be uncertainty or disagreement about what property that forms the pool of property that can be managed under this order. The Tribunal cannot determine that issue and encourages the manager and the Public Trustee for the Australian Capital Territory to work together to remove any uncertainty or disagreement.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.