In the Matter of Jane

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL



IN THE MATTER OF JANE (Guardianship) [2019] ACAT 18

GT 134/2018

Catchwords:                GUARDIANSHIP – point in time assessment of decision-making ability – principles to be observed by decision-makers – adequate and proper consideration of all the evidence – unreasonable risk – lack of insight into personal circumstances – supported decision-making – change of circumstances from time to time – material change of circumstances – role of Public Trustee and Guardian – ongoing responsibilities of guardian and manager – protected person’s right to an opportunity to be heard – attendance of protected person at hearing

Legislation cited:        Guardianship and Management of Property Act 1991 ss 4, 5A, 7, 8, 9, 19

Cases cited:A v Guardianship and Management of Property Tribunal [1999] ACTSC 77

Allesch v Maunz [2000] HCA 40
Holt v Protective Commissioner (1993) 31 NSWLR 227
HRI (Guardianship) [2015] VCAT 1140
Hunter and New England Area Health Service v A [2009] NSWSC 761
In the Matter of ER [2015] ACAT 73
In the Matter of QR [2018] ACAT 118
McDonald v Guardianship and Administration Board [1993] 1 VR 521
Moore v Guardianship & Administration Board [1990] VR 902
Qumsieh v Guardianship and Administration Board [1998] VSCA 45
XYZ v State Trustees Ltd [2006] VSC 444

XYZ (Guardianship) [2007] VCAT 1196

List of

Texts/Papers cited:     Australian Law Reform Commission, Elder Abuse – A National Legal Response, ALRC Report No 131 (2017)

Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, opened for signature 30 March 2007, 999 UNTS 3 (entered into force 3 May 2008)

Tribunal:Presidential Member G McCarthy

Date of Orders:  21 September 2018

Date of Reasons for Decision:     31 January 2019

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY  )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )                  GT 134/2018

IN THE MATTER OF JANE

TRIBUNAL:Presidential Member G McCarthy

DATE:21 September 2018

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that:

Appointment of Guardian

  1. The Public Trustee and Guardian is appointed guardian for [name suppressed] (the protected person) with the following powers:

    (a)     to decide where, and with whom the protected person is to live;

    (b)    to give any consent required for a medical procedure or other treatment (other than a prescribed medical procedure); 

    (c)     to make other personal decisions needed to ensure the protected person's health and welfare needs are met and to protect her from unreasonable risks to her health and welfare; 

    (d)    to do things necessary to give effect to decisions about the matters set out above, including (but not limited to):

    (i)giving or receiving information; or

    (ii)giving consent to investigations and assessments; or

    (iii)participating in negotiations; or

    (iv)signing documents.

  1. The Tribunal will review this appointment on its own initiative before 20 September 2021.

  1. The guardian must notify the Tribunal of any changes to the address of, or of any other significant change in circumstances of, itself or of the protected person.

    Appointment of Manager

  1. The Public Trustee and Guardian is appointed as manager to manage all of the property including finances of [name suppressed] (the protected…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Matter of Jane and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ACAT 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved a dispute regarding the appointment of a guardian and manager for an individual under the Guardianship and Administration Act 1986. The court was required to consider the balance between respecting an individual's autonomy and protecting their welfare, in line with the principles outlined in the Act. This included examining the necessity of appointing a guardian or manager and the extent of their powers, as well as the ongoing need for such appointments.

The primary legal issue was whether the appointment of a guardian and manager was appropriate, given the individual's specific circumstances, and if so, the scope of their powers. The court had to weigh the individual's expressed wishes against their overall welfare and interests, as defined by the Act. Furthermore, the court needed to determine if the existing order was still necessary or if it should be varied or revoked due to changes in the individual's condition or circumstances.

The court found that the appointment of a guardian and manager was necessary to protect the individual's welfare and interests. It emphasised that such appointments should not be made "once and for all" but should be subject to regular reassessment. The court granted the Public Trustee and Guardian powers to make personal and financial decisions on behalf of the individual, taking into account her wishes and best interests. The court scheduled a review of the appointment before 20 September 2021 to ensure the ongoing appropriateness of the order.

The court's final orders appointed the Public Trustee and Guardian as the individual's guardian and manager, granting them specific powers to make personal and financial decisions. The orders also required the guardian and manager to notify the Tribunal of any significant changes in circumstances and mandated a review of the appointments before 20 September 2021. This ensures that the individual's situation is regularly reassessed, maintaining the balance between autonomy and welfare protection.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that:

Appointment of Guardian

1.

The Public Trustee and Guardian is appointed guardian for [name suppressed] (the protected person) with the following powers:

(a) to decide where, and with whom the protected person is to live;

(b) to give any consent required for a medical procedure or other treatment (other than a prescribed medical procedure);

(c) to make other personal decisions needed to ensure the protected person's health and welfare needs are met and to protect her from unreasonable risks to her health and welfare;

(d) to do things necessary to give effect to decisions about the matters set out above, including (but not limited to):

(i) giving or receiving information; or

(ii) giving consent to investigations and assessments; or

(iii) participating in negotiations; or

(iv) signing documents.

2.

The Tribunal will review this appointment on its own initiative before 20 September 2021.

3.

The guardian must notify the Tribunal of any changes to the address of, or of any other significant change in circumstances of, itself or of the protected person.

Appointment of Manager

4.

The Public Trustee and Guardian is appointed as manager to manage all of the property including finances of [name suppressed] (the protected person) with the following powers:

(i) all the powers the protected person would have been entitled to exercise if she were legally competent to exercise powers in relation to her property including her finances herself.

5.

The Tribunal will review this appointment on its own initiative before 20 September 2021.

6.

The manager must notify the Tribunal of any changes to the address of, or of any other significant change in the circumstances of, itself or of the protected person.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Explanatory Memorandum to the Bill that became the amending Act states:The [Guardianship] Act provides that in making decisions under the Act about people, their wishes should receive paramount consideration, and their welfare and interests should be appropriately protected. This creates conflict between the person’s wishes and their welfare. Giving effect to the former may endanger an individual’s personal and financial welfare.This Bill clarifies the principles for decision making to be observed by those acting under the [Guardianship Act]. For the purpose of the Act, the person’s interests would include (but not be limited to) the preservation of his or her safety, prevention of physical and mental deterioration, the ability for self-care and to live in the general community and participate in community activities, to maintain the non-harmful aspects of the person’s preferred lifestyle, the promotion of financial security, and prevention of dissipation of financial resources or destitution.Decisions are to be made according to the person’s wishes, unless to do so would significantly adversely affect his or her interests, which are defined in the Act. Where the person’s wishes cannot be determined, then decisions are to be made in accordance with his or her interests. Autonomy, self-care and community participation are the basis for making and applying decisions. These are called the decision-making principles. The decision-making principles apply not only to a person appointed as a guardian and/or manager. They apply also to the tribunal, when deciding whether to appoint a guardian and/or manager. That is clear from section 4(1), which provides that the principles apply in relation to “the exercise by a person … of a function under this Act.” The principles apply therefore when the tribunal is determining whether it is satisfied, for example, of the matters set out in section 7(1)(b)(ii) and 8(b)(ii) and hence whether to appoint a person as a guardian and/or manager. To give effect to a person’s views and wishes unless doing so is likely to significantly adversely affect their interests is easily stated, but can be difficult to apply. Caution should always be exercised to ensure that the proviso does not too easily displace the general rule. In XYZ v State Trustees, Cavanough J said:VCAT’s reasoning in this case shows that there may be a need for VCAT to re-examine the exercise of its guardianship and administration jurisdiction generally to determine whether the balance has swung too far in favour of paternalism or protection as against individual autonomy.[23][23] XYZ v State Trustees Limited and Anor [2006] VSC 444 [66] In Moore v Guardianship & Administration Board, Gobbo J of the Victorian Supreme Court said: Moreover, as is said in the report relied upon by Parliament in framing the legislation and referred to in Hansard, it must be a very rare case that will see an order made against the wishes of a represented person.[24][24] Moore v Guardianship & Administration Board [1990] VR 902 [916]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In XYZ (Guardianship), Deputy President Billings of VCAT made the following observation:Just as each person is unique so is each proceeding under the Guardianship and Administration Act 1986 unique.When the statutory definition of “disability” is considered (intellectual impairment, mental disorder, brain injury, physical disability or dementia: section 3(1)), it can be recognised immediately that disability can be mild, moderate or severe. So too can the impact of the disability on a person’s cognitive or decision-making capacity be mild, moderate or severe. Then, depending on the person’s circumstances (including not only family or other support or the existence of an EPA but also the person’s actual exposure to risk of exploitation), there may be greater or lesser need for an administrator. Even the person’s wishes, if the person can express them, may be more or less strongly held. And what the person’s best interests require may change over time. When it is also considered that the person’s condition can be static, progressive, fluctuating or improving it will be obvious that, as the legislation requires, an administration order should never be made “once and for all” but should be reassessed later on.…Even where an administrator has been appointed, the legislation recognises that the issues may still not be totally clear. The Tribunal may make a limited administration order, tailored to the needs of the person with a disability. Whether or not the order is limited, the administrator must exercise power in such a way as to encourage and assist the represented person to become capable of administering his or her estate: section 49(2)(a). This indicates a realisation that there will be people on the verge of no longer needing an administrator but who for the time being still do need one. All this justifies an approach by the Tribunal, in appropriate cases, to make or continue an administration order even though the person’s disability may be mild, or the impact of the disability on the person’s capacity may be mild, or the need for an administrator may not be absolute. The Tribunal has discretion that it must exercise in the person’s best interests having taken into account matters including the person’s wishes. If the Tribunal makes an administration order, nevertheless the circumstances may soon warrant reassessment of the order. Any person can apply for a reassessment. This may actually be the administrator who, if properly exercising power under the Act, would be especially well placed to see that the order may no longer be necessary or in the person’s best interests.[31][31] XYZ (Guardianship) [2007] VCAT 1196 [47]-[51] As Deputy President Billings observed, a guardian or management order should never be made “once and for all”. In recognition of that principle, section 19(1)(a) of the Guardianship Act states:(1) The ACAT may at any time, on application or on its own initiative, hold a hearing to consider—(a) whether an order appointing a guardian or manager should be—(i)varied; or(ii)revoked on the ground that the need for guardianship or management no longer exists