In the Matter Of Dylan (Guardianship)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

IN THE MATTER OF DYLAN (Guardianship) [2021] ACAT 91

GT 109/1996

Catchwords:               GUARDIANSHIP – application for removal of a guardian – requirements for removal – relevance of views of protected person – relevance of adverse effect on protected person – decision-making principles apply also to decisions of the Tribunal – relevance of who will be the new guardian – application for and appointment of new guardian

Legislation cited:        Guardianship and Management of Property Act 1991 ss 4, 5A, 9, 10, 28, 31

Human Rights Act 2004 ss 8, 10, 28

Cases cited:Holt v Protective Commissioner (1993) 31 NSWLR 227

In the matter of AB [2017] ACAT 67
In the matter of Jane [2019] ACAT 18
In the matter of LQL [2018] ACAT 53

M v M [2013] NSWSC 1495
Re LSC and GC [2016] NSWSC 1896

Tribunal:  Senior Member R Orr QC

Date of Orders:  10 August 2021

Date of Reasons for Decision:      28 September 2021

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. These proceedings began as an application for removal of a guardian under the Guardianship and Management of Property Act 1991 (Guardianship Act). There were at that time three personal guardians for Dylan.[1] He applied for removal of one of them, whom I will call Guardian 1, who had been very active in supporting Dylan. There were two other guardians (whom I will call Guardian 2 and Guardian 3), but they do not live in the ACT and had been less active guardians. The Public Trustee and Guardian (PTG) was Dylan’s financial manager.

    [1] Given that this matter concerns a contested guardianship hearing and considered significant medical and other personal information, in these reasons the Tribunal has chosen a name for the protected person that bears no resemblance to his real name, and has not disclosed facts which would enable him to be identified, and has also used titles for the current guardians and not disclosed facts which would enable them to be identified.

  2. During the consideration of this matter, Guardian 1 indicated that she was no longer willing to carry on as guardian. Given this, during the proceedings Dylan also applied for the appointment of the PTG as his guardian.

Summary of Tribunal decision

  1. This case raised difficult issues. A guardian can be removed if they are no longer suitable (section 31(1)(a) of the Guardianship Act). The matters to be considered in appointing a guardian are relevant to this decision (section 10(4)) as are the decision-making principles (section 4).

  2. It is clear that under the Act Dylan’s views and wishes as to who his guardian should be are relevant, and it was clear he did not want Guardian 1 to be his guardian. In his view he and Guardian 1 were no longer compatible.

  3. But Guardian 1 has provided significant assistance to Dylan, particularly in relation to his dealings with his service provider and health issues. She and Dylan’s service provider have played a significant role in enabling Dylan to look…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Matter Of Dylan (Guardianship) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] ACAT 91
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Dylan (Guardianship), the court addressed the application for the removal of a guardian, the requirements for such removal, and the appointment of a new guardian. Dylan, a protected person with impaired decision-making ability, had expressed his wishes to not have Guardian 1 as his guardian, citing incompatibility. Guardian 1 and the primary carer argued that removing Guardian 1 might lead to Dylan having to give up his independent living, which would be a significant adverse effect on him.

The legal issues revolved around the relevance of Dylan's views, the potential adverse effects on him, and the application of decision-making principles to the Tribunal's decisions. The court had to consider whether acting on Dylan's wishes would significantly adversely affect his interests, as per section 4(2)(a) of the Act. The court also had to balance this with other principles, such as the need to interfere with Dylan's life to the smallest extent necessary and to encourage him to live independently.

The court found that Dylan's views and wishes were relevant but not the sole consideration. It acknowledged that removing Guardian 1 might put Dylan's independent living at risk, which could be a significant adverse effect given his vulnerability, deteriorating health, and difficulty in managing his carers and health. The court ultimately balanced the various factors and made a decision that took into account all relevant considerations.

The orders of the court were made on 10 August 2021, following the hearings. The court removed Guardian 1 and appointed a new guardian for Dylan, taking into account all the relevant factors and principles discussed.

Orders

Orders of the court

10 August 2021

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

At the second hearing she indicated that she was no longer willing to continue to be a guardian. At the third hearing, Guardian 2 also indicated she was unwilling to continue. Decision-making principles (section 4) Section 4 of the Act also sets out some decision-making principles which apply to “the exercise by a person (the decision-maker) of a function under this Act in relation to a person with impaired decision-making ability”. It appears that these principles apply also to the Tribunal when it makes relevant decisions. The first is that the “protected person’s wishes, as far as they can be worked out, must be given effect to, unless making the decision in accordance with the wishes is likely to significantly adversely affect the person’s interests”.[23] The person’s interests are set out in section 5A and include protection of the person from harm, prevention of physical and mental deterioration, the ability the protected person to self-care, to live in the general community, to participate in community activities, and to maintain the non-harmful aspects of the person’s preferred lifestyle, and the promotion of financial security.[24][23] Guardianship Act section 4(2)(a); this approach is also supported by sections 8, 10(2) and 28 of the Human Rights Act 2004.[24] In the matter of Jane [2019] ACAT 18 at [52]-[74] Here the protected person has expressed his wishes. The issue is, however, whether acting on these wishes is likely to significantly adversely affect his interests. This is the issue which in effect was raised by Guardian 1 and the primary carer. It was suggested that removal of Guardian 1 may result in Dylan having to give up his independent living. This would certainly be a significant adverse effect. It was noted that the more likely outcome was that he will not be able to get the access to help and assistance that he gets now.[25] This would also be an adverse effect. When combined with Dylan’s tenuous lifestyle, vulnerability, deteriorating health and difficulty in managing his carers and health, this may be significant. [25] Transcript of proceedings 2 February 2021 pages 23-24 There are other related principles to this. Further the protected person’s life must be interfered with to the smallest extent necessary (section 4(2)(d)). As noted, the decision to remove Guardian 1 may well interfere with his life. The protected person must be encouraged to look after themselves (section 4(2)(e)), and the protected person must be encouraged to live in the general community (section 4(2)(f)). With significant support, Dylan has been able to live independently. As discussed, the removal of Guardian 1 may put this at risk. The factors in sections 10(4) and 4(2) need to be considered and balanced. Some are pulling in different directions, which made this a difficult matter to resolve. As to the position after the first hearing, it was clear that Dylan’s views and wishes as to who his guardian should be were relevant, and it was clear he did not want Guardian 1 to be his guardian, and that in his view they were not compatible (sections 4(2)(a), 10(4)(a) and (c)). While this was an important consideration, it was not the only consideration.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established