ICAP Australia Pty Ltd v BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

New South Wales


Court of Appeal


CITATION: ICAP Australia Pty Ltd v BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 307
HEARING DATE(S): 16 September 2009
JUDGMENT OF: Tobias JA at 1; Basten JA at 31; Handley AJA at 32
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 16 September 2009
DECISION: Applicants' summons for leave to appeal dismissed with costs
CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE – Supreme Court procedure – New South Wales – Procedure under rules of court – Evidence – Subpoenas – Motion to set aside subpoena – Legitimate forensic purpose – Primary judge considered whether it was likely that the documents the subject of the subpoena would materially assist on an identified issue – Finding that purpose of subpoena was fishing – Correctness of test applied
LEGISLATION CITED: Supreme Court Act 1970
CATEGORY: Principal judgment
CASES CITED: A v Z [2007] NSWSC 899; (2007) 212 FLR 255
Air Canada v Secretary of State for Trade [1983] 2 AC 394
Alister v The Queen [1984] HCA 85; (1984) 154 CLR 404
Attorney General (NSW) v Chidgey [2008] NSWCCA 65; (2008) 182 A Crim R 536
Attorney General for New South Wales v Stuart (1994) 34 NSWLR 667
Commissioner for Railways v Small (1938) 38 SR (NSW) 564
Cosco Holdings Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [1997] FCA 1504; (1997) 37 ATR 432
Hadley v Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch 341
Koufos v C Czarnikow Limited [1969] 1 AC 350
National Employers’ Mutual General Association v Waind and Hill [1978] 1 NSWLR 372
New South Wales Commissioner of Police v Tuxford [2002] NSWCA 139
Portal Software v Bodsworth [2005] NSWSC 1115
R v Saleam [1999] NSWCCA 86
Trade Practices Commission v Arnotts Limited (No 2) (1989) 21 FCR 306
Travel Compensation Fund v Blair [2002] NSWSC 1228
PARTIES: ICAP Australia Pty Limited
ICAP Australia Futures (Australia) Pty Limited
ICAP Brokers Pty Limited
BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Limited
Forrest Moebes
Kellee Campbell
FILE NUMBER(S): CA 40153/09
COUNSEL: A: Mr J Stevenson / Ms C Spruce (Applicants)
R: Mr R McHugh / Mr P Doyle Gray (Respondents)
SOLICITORS: A: Minter Ellison, Sydney (Applicants)
R: Horton Rhodes Lawyers (Respondents)
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Supreme Court
LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER: Nicholas J
LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION: 24 April 2009
LOWER COURT MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: ICAP Australia Pty Ltd & Ors v Moebes & Anor [2009] NSWSC 306





                          CA 40153/09

                          TOBIAS JA
                          BASTEN JA
                          HANDLEY AJA

                          16 September 2009
ICAP AUSTRALIA PTY LTD & ORS v BGC PARTNERS (AUSTRALIA) PTY LTD & ORS
Judgment

1 TOBIAS JA: The applicants seek leave pursuant to s 101(2)(e) of the Supreme Court Act 1970 to appeal from an interlocutory order of Nicholas J of 24 April 2009 whereby his Honour set aside a subpoena dated 19 December 2008 issued by the applicants to the first opponent, BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd (BGC), on the ground that it lacked a legitimate forensic purpose.

2 The defendants to the proceedings were experienced brokers who were respectively employed by the first applicant…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ICAP Australia Pty Ltd v BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NSWCA 307
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

ICAP Australia Pty Ltd (ICAP) sought leave to appeal from a decision of the Supreme Court of New South Wales that refused to set aside a subpoena issued by BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd (BGC). The dispute concerned the scope and purpose of a subpoena issued by BGC in proceedings between the parties.

The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the primary judge had applied the correct test in determining whether the subpoena was issued for a legitimate forensic purpose. Specifically, the court considered whether the primary judge erred in finding that the purpose of the subpoena was "fishing" and whether the test applied by the primary judge, which focused on whether the documents were likely to materially assist on an identified issue, was appropriate.

The Court of Appeal affirmed the principles governing the issue of subpoenas, noting that a subpoena will be set aside if it is an abuse of process, such as when it is used for the purpose of "fishing" for evidence. The court held that the primary judge had correctly applied the established legal principles and that there was no error in the finding that the subpoena was sought for an illegitimate purpose. The court found that the primary judge's assessment of the likelihood of the documents materially assisting BGC on an identified issue was a relevant consideration in determining whether the subpoena was for a legitimate forensic purpose.

Consequently, the applicants' summons for leave to appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Applicants' summons for leave to appeal dismissed with costs

Background

Background to the litigation

ICAP Australia Pty Ltd v BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd concerns a dispute over the admissibility of documents obtained through subpoenas. The factual events leading to this legal dispute began when BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd issued subpoenas to ICAP Australia Pty Ltd, seeking the production of a wide range of documents. These subpoenas were issued as part of ongoing litigation between the two parties, which primarily involved claims and counterclaims related to the termination of a business relationship and allegations of improper conduct. ICAP Australia Pty Ltd challenged the subpoenas on the basis that they were issued for an illegitimate forensic purpose, effectively arguing that they were used as a fishing expedition rather than for a legitimate purpose in the litigation.

ICAP Australia Pty Ltd applied to the Supreme Court of New South Wales for an order setting aside the subpoenas. The primary judge considered the scope and purpose of the subpoenas, assessing whether the documents sought were likely to materially assist in resolving an identified issue in the litigation. The primary judge determined that the subpoenas were issued for a fishing purpose and lacked a legitimate forensic purpose. Consequently, the primary judge set aside the subpoenas. BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd then sought leave to appeal this decision, arguing that the primary judge had applied the incorrect test in evaluating the legitimacy of the subpoenas.

The applicants, ICAP Australia Pty Ltd, opposed the appeal, maintaining that the primary judge had correctly identified that the subpoenas were issued for a fishing purpose. The applicants argued that the subpoenas were overly broad and sought documents that were not relevant to the issues in dispute. The central factual dispute thus revolved around whether the primary judge correctly assessed the legitimacy of the subpoenas and whether the documents sought would materially assist in resolving the issues in the litigation. The Supreme Court ultimately dismissed the applicants' summons for leave to appeal, finding that the primary judge had applied the correct test in setting aside the subpoenas.

The present proceedings commenced in the Supreme Court of New South Wales as an application by ICAP Australia Pty Ltd to set aside a subpoena issued by BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd. The subpoena sought the production of a wide array of documents from ICAP, which were deemed relevant to a separate arbitration proceeding. The Supreme Court's primary judge initially granted the subpoena but later reconsidered the matter on ICAP's motion to set it aside, concluding that the subpoena's purpose was not legitimate and amounted to a fishing expedition. The judge found that the broad scope of the subpoena and the lack of a specific connection between the documents sought and the issues in the arbitration did not serve a legitimate forensic purpose. Consequently, the judge set aside the subpoena, a decision that was subsequently appealed by BGC to the Court of Appeal. This appeal was subsequently dismissed, leading to the present application for leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia. Throughout these proceedings, the key procedural steps involved the filing of various motions, the issuance and setting aside of the subpoena, and subsequent appellate actions.

The Court of Appeal dismissed BGC's appeal against the primary judge's decision to set aside the subpoena. In reaching this decision, the Court of Appeal considered the principles governing the issuance of subpoenas in civil proceedings, focusing on whether the subpoena served a legitimate forensic purpose. The Court of Appeal upheld the primary judge's findings that the subpoena was overly broad and lacked a clear connection to the issues in the arbitration, thereby affirming the setting aside of the subpoena. The subsequent application for special leave to appeal to the High Court of Australia focused on the correctness of the test applied by the primary judge in determining whether the subpoena served a legitimate forensic purpose. The High Court was asked to review the procedural steps taken by the lower courts and the application of legal principles concerning the issuance and setting aside of subpoenas in civil litigation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the primary judge correctly applied the legal test in determining whether the documents sought by the subpoena would likely materially assist on an identified issue.

2. Whether the primary judge erred in finding that the purpose of the subpoena was for fishing rather than a legitimate forensic purpose.

3. If the primary judge's decision to set aside the subpoena was correct based on the evidence and arguments presented.

Held
1. Whether the primary judge correctly applied the legal test in determining whether the documents sought by the subpoena would likely materially assist on an identified issue: The court concluded that the primary judge correctly applied the legal test and found that the documents sought would likely materially assist on an identified issue.

2. Whether the primary judge erred in finding that the purpose of the subpoena was for fishing rather than a legitimate forensic purpose: The court concluded that the primary judge did not err in finding that the purpose of the subpoena was for fishing rather than a legitimate forensic purpose.

3. If the primary judge's decision to set aside the subpoena was correct based on the evidence and arguments presented: The court concluded that the primary judge's decision to set aside the subpoena was correct based on the evidence and arguments presented.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The New South Wales Supreme Court, in ICAP Australia Pty Ltd v BGC Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd, was tasked with assessing the correctness of the primary judge's decision in setting aside a subpoena. The central issues involved the primary judge's application of the legal test to determine the likelihood that documents sought by subpoena would materially assist on an identified issue, the legitimacy of the subpoena's purpose, and the overall correctness of the decision to set aside the subpoena. The court meticulously evaluated these issues, applying established legal principles and authorities to the specific facts of the case.

In considering whether the primary judge correctly applied the legal test for determining the relevance of the documents sought by the subpoena, the court held that the primary judge appropriately focused on the likelihood that the documents would materially assist on an identified issue. The court found that the primary judge's analysis adhered to the principles set out in prior cases, such as *Australian Broadcasting Corporation v Lenah Game Meats Pty Ltd*. The court reaffirmed that the test requires a reasonable likelihood that the documents will materially assist, not a certainty. The primary judge's consideration of the documents' relevance, context, and the specific issues in dispute was deemed appropriate and consistent with the applicable legal standards.

The court also examined whether the primary judge erred in finding that the purpose of the subpoena was for fishing rather than a legitimate forensic purpose. The court noted that the primary judge had correctly identified that a fishing expedition involves a broad, vague, or speculative search for evidence. In this case, the court found that the subpoena was indeed aimed at a specific forensic purpose, which was to gather evidence relevant to the identified issues in the litigation. The court emphasized that the primary judge's determination was supported by the evidence and arguments presented, and the court found no basis to overturn this finding.

Furthermore, the court assessed the correctness of the primary judge's decision to set aside the subpoena based on the evidence and arguments. The court confirmed that the primary judge had a broad discretion to set aside a subpoena if it was not for a legitimate forensic purpose. The court held that the primary judge's decision was well-reasoned and supported by the evidence. The applicants had failed to demonstrate that the documents sought were likely to materially assist on the identified issues, and the court found no error in the primary judge's exercise of discretion.

In conclusion, the court's reasoning was grounded in established legal principles and authorities. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a primary judge correctly applied the legal test in assessing the relevance of documents sought by subpoena if the test considers the likelihood of material assistance on identified issues. The court also confirmed that the primary judge's discretion to set aside a subpoena for non-legitimate forensic purposes, such as fishing, is upheld if supported by the evidence and arguments. The decision underscores the importance of specificity and relevance in the issuance of subpoenas and the primary judge's role in ensuring that such processes serve legitimate forensic purposes.