Khan v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (iCare)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Khan v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (iCare) & Ors [2023] NSWPIC 647
APPLICANT: Maaz Ilahi Khan
FIRST RESPONDENT: Just Smart Solutions Pty Ltd t/a Just Taxi
SECOND RESPONDENT: Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (iCare)
SENIOR MEMBER: Kerry Haddock
DATE OF DECISION: 1 December 2023
CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Notices for Production served by applicant on first respondent and first respondent’s solicitors; objection to Notices for Production; failure to serve Notice of Objection in accordance with Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021; directions made for service of Notice of Objection and Notice of Opposition; first respondent provided “interim replies” and failed to “reply formally” after extension of time sought was granted; first respondent made email submissions and attached further documents after the expiry of the extended time limit; neither the email nor the documents was taken into account; Held –Notice for Production on first respondent’s solicitors wholly set aside; Notice for Production on first respondent set aside in part; first respondent to produce report of investigation commissioned by iCare, if report held, and subject to any claim of privilege.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

The Commission determines:

1. The Notice for Production served by the applicant on the first respondent’s solicitors is set aside wholly, pursuant to Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021, rule 41(5)(a).

2. The Notice for Production served by the applicant on the first respondent is set aside, pursuant to Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021, rule 41(5)(a) as follows:

(a)    with respect to the list of payments from 28 April 2023;

(b)    with respect to payslips;

(c)    with respect to phone records, and

(d)    with respect to notice of suspension dated 23 May 2023.

3. If the first respondent holds a copy of a report of an investigation commissioned by iCare, it is directed to produce it to the applicant, pursuant to Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021, rule 41(5)(b), subject to any claim of privilege.

4.      The conciliation/arbitration hearing date of 18 January 2024 at 10am is confirmed.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. The applicant, Maaz Ilahi Khan (Mr Khan), has lodged an Application to Resolve a Dispute (the Application) in the Personal Injury Commission (Commission).

  2. Mr Khan claims to have been either employed, or deemed to have been employed, by the first respondent, Just Smart Solutions Pty Ltd t/a Just Taxi (Just Taxi) as a taxi driver. He sustained injuries when he was struck in the face with an EFTPOS machine at Sydney Airport on 28 April 2023.

  3. Mr Khan claims weekly benefits compensation from 3 August 2023 to date and continuing.

  4. Just Taxi disputes that it employed Mr Khan, or that he was deemed to have been its employee.

  5. Just Taxi did not hold workers compensation insurance at the date of the applicant’s injury. Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (iCare) has therefore been joined to the Application as the second respondent.

  6. The applicant has served on the first respondent and its solicitors Notices for Production.

  7. This determination is made in respect of the Notices for Production served…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Khan v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (iCare) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPIC 647
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Khan v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (iCare) involved the applicant, Khan, and the first respondent, iCare, with its solicitors, before the Personal Injury Commission. The dispute arose from notices for production served by Khan on iCare and its solicitors, which iCare objected to. The objection was not served in compliance with the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021, leading to procedural complications. The Commission was tasked with determining whether the objections were properly lodged and whether the procedural failures warranted any sanctions.

The court had to decide if the objections raised by iCare were valid and whether any procedural missteps should result in sanctions. A critical issue was whether the failure to serve the Notice of Objection correctly led to the nullification of the objection, and if so, what the consequences would be for iCare. Additionally, the court examined whether iCare's subsequent actions, such as providing "interim replies" and making email submissions after the extended time limit, should be considered.

The court ruled that the Notice for Production served on iCare's solicitors was wholly set aside due to the improper service of the Notice of Objection. As for the Notice for Production served on iCare itself, it was set aside in part. The court determined that iCare was required to produce the report of the investigation commissioned by iCare, if it held the report, and subject to any claim of privilege. The court did not consider the email submissions or the documents attached to them because they were made after the extended time limit had expired. This decision underscores the importance of strict compliance with procedural rules in workers' compensation matters.

The final orders mandated that iCare produce the report of the investigation, if held, and subject to any claim of privilege, while highlighting the necessity for adherence to procedural requirements in the future. The court's decision emphasized the significance of proper procedural conduct in ensuring the integrity and fairness of the litigation process.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Khan v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer (iCare) pertains to a workers compensation claim where the applicant, Khan, served Notices for Production on the first respondent, iCare, and iCare’s solicitors. Khan objected to the service of these Notices for Production on the basis that iCare had failed to serve a Notice of Objection in accordance with the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021. Following this, the court made directions for iCare to serve a Notice of Objection and a Notice of Opposition. Despite an extension of time being granted, iCare provided only “interim replies” and did not formally reply after the extension was granted. Additionally, iCare made email submissions and attached further documents after the expiry of the extended time limit, which were not considered by the court.

The matter came before the court following Khan’s application to set aside the Notices for Production served on iCare and its solicitors. The procedural steps included the issuance of the Notices for Production, the objection by Khan, and the subsequent court directions for iCare to serve a Notice of Objection and a Notice of Opposition. iCare was granted an extension to provide formal replies, which it failed to do, submitting only interim replies and additional documents via email after the extended time limit had expired. The court was tasked with determining whether the Notices for Production should be set aside and what further action iCare should take in response to the production requests.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Notice for Production served on iCare's solicitors should be set aside.
2. Whether the Notice for Production served on iCare should be set aside in part.
3. What further action iCare must take in response to the production requests, if any.

Held
1. The court concluded that the Notice for Production served on iCare's solicitors should be set aside in its entirety.
2. The court determined that the Notice for Production served on iCare should be set aside in part.
3. The court ordered iCare to produce the report of the investigation commissioned by iCare, if it holds the report and subject to any claim of privilege.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the procedural steps taken by the parties and the compliance with the Personal Injury Commission Rules 2021. Firstly, regarding the Notice for Production served on iCare's solicitors, the court found that iCare had failed to serve a Notice of Objection in accordance with the rules. The court noted that the directions made for service of the Notice of Objection and Notice of Opposition were not followed, leading to the conclusion that the Notice for Production on iCare's solicitors should be set aside wholly. Secondly, concerning the Notice for Production served on iCare, the court held that while iCare provided "interim replies" and failed to formally reply after the extension of time was granted, it made email submissions and attached further documents after the extended time limit. However, neither the email nor the attached documents were taken into account due to the procedural lapses. Consequently, the Notice for Production on iCare was set aside in part. Lastly, the court ordered iCare to produce the report of the investigation commissioned by iCare, if it holds the report and subject to any claim of privilege. The binding principle established by this decision pertains to the strict adherence to procedural rules in workers' compensation cases, particularly regarding the timeliness and proper service of notices and objections.