HVAC Construction (Qld) Pty Ltd v Energy Equipment Engineering Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

HVAC Construction (Qld)  Pty Ltd v Energy Equipment Engineering Pty Ltd
 [2002] FCA 1638

Corporations – winding up – insolvency – application for review of winding up order – motion for approval for director to bring application in name of company – motion for stay of winding up proceedings – winding up order made by Registrar – nature of review proceedings – non-compliance with statutory demand – presumption of insolvency – court approval of director bringing application for review – whether necessary – criteria – stay of winding up – relevant considerations – merits of argument – necessity to obtain leave in relation to debt in dispute – criteria for leave – balance of interests – stay refused – approval revoked subject to lodgment of security for costs of application for review

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) s 459F, s 459S, s 471A, s 482
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 35A

Re Diamond Fuel Company [1879] 13 Ch D 400 cited
Arafura Finance Corporation Pty Ltd v Kooba Pty Ltd (No 2) (1987) 12 ACLR 331 cited
Anfrank Nominees Pty Ltd v Connell (1989) 1 ACSR 365 cited
Aetna Properties Ltd (in liq) v GA Listing & Maintenance Pty Ltd (1994) 13 ACSR 422 cited
Emanuele v Australian Securities Commission (1995) 63 FCR 54 cited
Object Design Inc v Object Design Australia Pty Ltd (1997) 78 FCR 60 not followed
Emanuele v Australian Securities Commission (1997) 188 CLR 114 cited
Re Rock Bottom Fashion Market Pty Ltd (in liq) (2000) 2 Qd R 573 followed
Vynotas Pty Ltd v Mystic Crystals Franchises (Aust) Pty Ltd [1999] QCA 473 cited
Walker v Midlink Nominees Pty Ltd (2000) 22 WAR 318 followed
Brolrik Pty Ltd v Sambah Holdings Pty Ltd (2001) 164 FLR 91 followed
Rodgers v CJS Panels Pty Ltd [2001] VSC 470 cited
Helljay Investments Pty Ltd  v Deputy Commissioner of Taxation (Cth) (1999) 74 ALJR 68 cited
Dooney v Henry (2000) 74 ALJR 1289 cited
Harris v Caladine (1991) 172 CLR 84
Official Trustee in Bankruptcy v Nedlands Pty Ltd (In Liquidation) (2000) 99 FCR 554
Re Wakim, Ex parte McNally (1999) 198 CLR 511 cited
Trustees of the Franciscan Missionaries of Mary v Weir (2000) 98 FCR 447 cited
Lane Cove Council v Geebung Polo Club Pty Ltd (Green as liq) (No 2) (2002) 41 ACSR 15 cited
Re Warbler Pty Ltd (1982) 1 ACLC 323 cited
David Grant & Co Pty Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation (1995) 184 CLR 265 cited
Chief Commissioner of Stamp Duties v Paliflex Pty Ltd (1999) 17 ACLC 467 cited
House of Tan Pty Ltd v Beachiris Pty Ltd (1996) 14 ACLC 1536 cited
Zan Holdings Pty Ltd v BayView Holdings Pty Ltd (1997) 15 ACLC 1238 cited
Bayview Holdings Pty Ltd v Zan Holdings Pty Ltd (unrep 10/10/98)
Switz Pty Ltd v Glowbind Pty Ltd (2001) 19 ACLC 532

HVAC CONSTRUCTION (QLD) PTY LTD V ENERGY EQUIPMENT ENGINEERING PTY LTD
No W3020 of 2002

FRENCH…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HVAC Construction (Qld) Pty Ltd v Energy Equipment Engineeri... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 1638
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of HVAC Construction (Qld) Pty Ltd v Energy Equipment Engineering Pty Ltd, the primary dispute concerns a winding-up order made against Energy Equipment Engineering Pty Ltd (EEE) for insolvency under the Corporations Act 2001. HVAC Construction (Qld) Pty Ltd, a creditor of EEE, initiated proceedings to wind up EEE after the company failed to comply with a statutory demand for $526,659.03, which was issued under Section 459E of the Corporations Act. The case was heard by the District Registrar, who issued an order for winding up on 6 December 2002. Mr James Kwok, a director of EEE, subsequently filed a motion for review of this decision and sought a stay of the winding-up order pending the determination of the review. The court had to decide on Mr Kwok's application for leave to represent EEE and to stay the winding-up order, as well as address the broader implications for the completion of a power plant project at Yatala in Queensland.

The legal issues central to the case involved the interpretation and application of the Corporations Act 2001, particularly Section 459E concerning statutory demands and Section 459A regarding the winding-up of insolvent companies. The court needed to determine whether Mr Kwok was appropriately authorised to bring the application on behalf of EEE, whether there were sufficient grounds to justify a stay of the winding-up order, and whether the disputed debt and the proposed funding arrangement could provide a viable solution to EEE's insolvency issues. The court also had to consider the potential impact of the winding-up order on the completion of the Yatala power plant project, which was in administration.

The court's reasoning focused on the procedural aspects of Mr Kwok's application and the merits of granting a stay of the winding-up order. It was determined that Mr Kwok had the necessary authority to represent EEE, given his role as a director. However, the court was cautious about the merits of the stay, given that the undisputed portion of the debt could be paid within a short period. The court also considered the broader implications of the winding-up order on the Yatala power plant project, which was in voluntary administration. The court concluded that the application for leave to apply for a review of the winding-up order was granted but required Mr Kwok to provide a bank guarantee of $10,000 to secure HVAC Construction's costs of the motion, including those related to the interlocutory relief claim. The motion was set down for further directions.

The final orders of the court included granting leave to Mr Kwok to apply on behalf of EEE for a stay of the winding-up order, abridgement of the time for service of the notice of motion, dismissal of the claim for interlocutory relief, and a requirement for Mr Kwok to provide a bank guarantee. The motion was set for further directions, allowing the court to reassess the situation in light of the provided guarantee and any new developments in the funding proposal for EEE.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave is granted to James Kwok to apply on behalf of the defendant for a stay of the winding up order made on 6 December 2002 by Registrar Jan.

2. The time for service of the defendant’s notice of motion filed on 9 December 2002 is abridged to enable it to be dealt with on 9 December 2002.

3. The claim for interlocutory relief is dismissed.

4. Mr Kwok is to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the claim for interlocutory relief forthwith.

5. The leave granted to Mr Kwok to apply for review of the winding up order on behalf of the defendant is revoked and the motion dismissed unless on or before 4pm on Friday 13 December 2002 he has lodged with the Registrar a bank guarantee in the sum of $10,000 by way of security for the plaintiff’s costs of the motion, including costs incurred in respect of the claim for interlocutory relief.

6. The motion is set down for further directions at 4.30pm on 13 December 2002.

Background

Background to the litigation

On Friday 6 December 2002, the District Registrar made an order that Energy Equipment Engineering Pty Ltd (EEE) be wound up in insolvency under the provisions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). On Monday 9 December 2002, Mr James Kwok, a director of EEE, filed a motion for review of the District Registrar’s decision and for a stay of his orders pending determination of the review. I heard argument on the motion for approval for Mr Kwok to bring the application on behalf of the company and for a stay of the winding up on 9 December. Argument was concluded at 5.15pm and, after reviewing the materials, I made orders at 8.30am on 10 December 2002. I now publish the reasons for those orders. Factual Background EEE is a company incorporated in New South Wales on 10 March 1998. At some time prior to April 2002 it entered into a contract with EnviroStar Energy Limited (EnviroStar) relating to the installation of a power plant at Yatala in Queensland. On 2 April 2002, EEE made a contract with HVAC Construction Pty Ltd (HVAC) for the supply, manufacture and installation of all major equipment in connection with the project for a total price of $1,180,000. The two companies fell into a dispute over payments due under the contract. On 2 September 2002, solicitors acting for HVAC served on EEE a Creditors Statutory Demand pursuant to s 459E of the Corporations Law for payment of a debt said to be $526,659.03. This amount was described in the following way in a schedule to the Demand: “The debt is the sum of $526,659.03, being for construction work carried out by the Creditor for and on behalf of the Debtor at the Yatala Power Station site in Queensland, pursuant to an agreement between the Creditor and the Debtor made on or about April 2002 by the Debtors Purchase Orders YAT-070 and YAT-071 respectively, full particulars of which debt are set out in Annexure A to this Demand.”The notice required payment within 21 days. No payment being made as required by the Demand and no action having been taken to set it aside, HVAC, on 17 October 2002, filed an application for the winding up of EEE on the ground of insolvency in that it had failed to comply with the Statutory Demand. On 2 December 2002, EEE filed a notice of appearance and set out the grounds of its opposition to the winding up application in the following terms: “1.The defendant is able to pay its debts as and when they fall due, and is thereby solvent. 2.To the extent necessary, the defendant seeks leave under section 459S of the Corporations Act 2001(Cth) to rely on a genuine dispute as to part of the alleged debt the subject of the plaintiff’s statutory demand dated 28 August 2002 as follows: (a)by the plaintiff’s statutory demand the plaintiff claimed the defendant owed it the sum of $526,659.03;(b)the defendant admits it owes the plaintiff the sum of $286,920.70; (c)the defendant disputes the balance claimed of $239,738.33 and says there is a genuine dispute as to that amount.” The application was supported by an affidavit of Gary William Massey, the solicitor for EEE. It was based upon information given to him by James Kwok and Bill Lamont, the Manager Technical and Operations with EEE, who was said to have been personally involved in the matters the subject of the HVAC claim. This affidavit was superseded by an affidavit sworn by Mr Kwok and filed on 5 December. In that affidavit he admitted his company’s indebtedness to HVAC in the sum of $286,920.70 but disputed the balance claimed of $239,738.33. He said: “The reason the admitted part of that claim has not yet been paid is that the defendant has been attempting to reach agreement as to the entire dispute and because the plaintiff retains the defendants’ equipment and refuses to release that equipment until it is paid the full amount claimed. The defendant will pay the plaintiff the admitted sum of $286,920.70 within 7 days of the plaintiff agreeing to release the equipment upon the sum being paid.”He said EEE had been paying the plaintiff pursuant to the contract to date on all undisputed amounts totalling approximately $410,000.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

FRENCH J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: FRENCH J

EnviroStar, as it turns out, is in voluntary administration. Mr Kwok says that he, on behalf of EEE, has arranged for funding of $4,500,000 to be provided to EEE by Investec Bank. He has presented a proposal to the administrators of EnviroStar which would see EEE borrow the $4,500,000 from Investec Bank and pay out the creditors of EEE and EnviroStar so that the power plant project could proceed to completion. He claimed that an order has been made in the Equity Division of the Supreme Court of New South Wales giving the administrators until 10 January 2003 to either accept the proposal or present an alternative to the creditors. If the winding up is not stayed, then the funding of the payment of the creditors of EnviroStar and the completion of the project will almost certainly not proceed. At the hearing of the motion for leave for Mr Kwok to apply for review on behalf of EEE and for a stay of the winding up, the Court was told by counsel for EEE that the undisputed part of the claim could be paid within forty eight hours and the disputed balance paid into court within two weeks. Mr Kwok offered no personal undertaking in relation to HVAC’s costs of the proposed proceedings. Statutory Framework – The Corporations Act 2001 Part 5.4 of the Corporations Act relates to the winding up of companies in insolvency. Section 459A authorises the Court, on an application under s 459P “… order that an insolvent company be wound up in insolvency”. Persons who may apply for such an order under s 459P(1) include “a creditor (even if the creditor is a secured creditor or is only a contingent or prospective creditor)” (s 459P(1)(b)). Contingent or prospective creditors may only apply with leave of the Court (s 459P(2)(a)). The condition on the power conferred on the Court to wind up a company in insolvency is that the company be insolvent. By operation of s 459C(2), which applies to applications under s 459P by force of s 459C(1), the Court must presume that a company is insolvent if one of a number of sufficient conditions is fulfilled. The first such condition, set out in s 459C(2)(a) is that “the company failed (as defined by section 459F) to comply with a statutory demand”. The presumption, if applicable, “operates except so far as the contrary is proved for the purpose of the application” (s 459C(3)). Section 459E provides that a person may serve on a company a demand relating to a debt or debts that are due and payable and which in total amount to at least the statutory minimum. The demand must specify the debt or debts and their amount or total amounts and must require the company to pay the amount or total amounts, or to secure or compound for that amount or total to the creditors reasonable satisfaction within twenty one days after service of the demand. It must be in writing and in a prescribed form and signed by or on behalf of the creditor (s 459E(2)). Except in the case of a judgment debt, the demand must be accompanied by an affidavit that verifies that the debt or debts are due and payable by the company and that complies with the rules (s 459E(3)).