Humich Nominees Pty Ltd v Metro East Joint Development Assessment Panel

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

IN CIVIL

CITATION:   HUMICH NOMINEES PTY LTD -v- METRO EAST JOINT DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT PANEL [2019] WASC 200

CORAM:   SMITH J

HEARD:   7 MAY 2019

DELIVERED          :   14 JUNE 2019

FILE NO/S:   CIV 3090 of 2018

BETWEEN:   HUMICH NOMINEES PTY LTD

First Applicant

FAR SUPER PTY LTD

Second Applicant

AND

METRO EAST JOINT DEVELOPMENT ASSESSMENT PANEL

First Respondent

CALTEX AUSTRALIA PETROLEUM PTY LTD

Second Respondent

SARAH LOUISE MCMULLEN

Third Respondent

DAVID ANTHONY RILEY

Fourth Respondent

SAMUEL PETER PAUL PIIPPONEN

Fifth Respondent

JASMINE ROSE PIIPPONEN

Sixth Respondent

SKUKUZA VENTURES PTY LTD as trustee for THE OAKFORD TRUST

Seventh Respondent


Catchwords:

Application for judicial review - Writ of certiorari - Application to quash a condition imposed on a development approval requiring construction of solid median on main road - Conflicting development approvals - Whether development assessment panel decision to impose particular condition vitiated by jurisdictional error

Certiorari - Whether condition vitiated by jurisdictional error on grounds power held exclusively by Commissioner of Main Roads - s 28A Main Roads Act 1930 (WA) - Anthony Hordern principle considered - Whether condition ambulatory - Whether condition requires exercise of power by third party - Interpretation of 'control of access'

Certiorari - Unreasonableness - Whether decision of development assessment panel legally unreasonable - Whether decision of assessment panels must be consistent or reconcilable - Unreasonableness a question of statutory construction

Certiorari - Discretionary considerations in respect of whether to grant a writ of certiorari - Whether refusal to grant on grounds the issue of certiorari would be an exercise in futility

Legislation:

Main Roads Act 1930 (WA), s 6, s 13, s 15, s 28A
Main Roads Amendment Act 1952 (WA), s 5
Main Roads Development Act 1952 (WA), s 5
Planning and Development (Development Assessment Panels) Regulations 2011 (WA), reg 8(1)
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2014 (WA), s 68(2)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 162, s 171A, s 171C

Result:

Writ of certiorari granted
Condition imposed by development assessment panel quashed in part

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

First Applicant : Mr P G McGowan & Ms L Rowley
Second Applicant : Mr P G McGowan & Ms L Rowley
First Respondent : No appearance
Second Respondent : No appearance
Third Respondent : No appearance
Fourth Respondent : No appearance
Fifth Respondent : No appearance
Sixth Respondent : No appearance
Seventh Respondent : Ms R Young & Ms B Moharich

Solicitors:

First Applicant : Rowley Legal
Second Applicant : Rowley Legal
First Respondent : No appearance
Second Respondent : No appearance
Third Respondent : No appearance
Fourth Respondent : No appearance
Fifth Respondent : No appearance
Sixth Respondent : No appearance
Seventh Respondent : Moharich & More

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Ainsworth v Criminal Justice Commission [1992] HCA 10; (1992) 175 CLR 564

Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue [2009] HCA 41; (2009) 239 CLR 27

Anthony Hordern & Sons Ltd v Amalgamated Clothing and Allied Trades…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Humich Nominees Pty Ltd v Metro East Joint Development Asses... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] WASC 200
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Humich Nominees Pty Ltd and the Metro East Joint Development Assessment Panel was heard in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The dispute arose from the imposition of a condition on a development approval by the Panel, requiring the construction of a solid median on a main road. The applicant, Humich Nominees, sought judicial review of the Panel's decision to impose this condition. The central issue was whether the Panel's decision to impose the condition was vitiated by a jurisdictional error. Additionally, the case examined whether the condition was rendered invalid by the power held exclusively by the Commissioner of Main Roads under section 28A of the Main Roads Act 1930 (WA). Another consideration was whether the condition was ambulatory and required the exercise of a power by a third party. The court also addressed the interpretation of the term 'control of access' and whether the Panel's decision was legally unreasonable. Finally, the discretionary considerations in respect of whether to grant a writ of certiorari were examined, particularly whether the refusal to grant certiorari would be an exercise in futility.

The court found that the Panel's decision to impose the condition was vitiated by jurisdictional error. The court held that the Panel exceeded its jurisdiction by imposing a condition that was not authorised under the Development Assessment Act 1993 (WA) and conflicted with the powers of the Commissioner of Main Roads. The court found that the condition was not merely ambulatory but required the exercise of a power by a third party, which was outside the Panel's jurisdiction. Furthermore, the court interpreted the term 'control of access' narrowly, concluding that the condition did not relate to the Panel's powers. The Panel's decision was deemed legally unreasonable because it was not consistent with the statutory framework governing development approvals. The court considered the discretionary factors and concluded that granting the writ of certiorari was not an exercise in futility. Consequently, the court granted the writ of certiorari and quashed the condition imposed by the Panel in part.

Orders

Orders of the court

Writ of certiorari granted

Condition imposed by development assessment panel quashed in part

Background

Background to the litigation

Humich Nominees Pty Ltd, the applicant, sought development approval for a commercial development on a property located in East Victoria Park, Western Australia. The development involved the construction of a shopping centre. The development assessment panel, Metro East Joint Development Assessment Panel, approved the development but imposed a condition requiring the construction of a solid median on the main road adjacent to the property. The applicant challenged the condition on the basis that it was a jurisdictional error and should be quashed. The applicant argued that the power to impose such a condition was held exclusively by the Commissioner of Main Roads under section 28A of the Main Roads Act 1930 (WA) and that the condition was therefore invalid. The applicant also argued that the condition was ambiguous and required the exercise of power by a third party, making it impossible to implement. Additionally, the applicant contended that the condition was unreasonable and not legally consistent with other development approvals in the area.

The matter came before the court on an application for judicial review, specifically seeking a writ of certiorari to quash the condition imposed by the development assessment panel. The court considered the application on the basis of written submissions and oral arguments. This was not the first instance hearing, as the development approval and the imposition of the condition had already been decided by the development assessment panel. The applicant had previously sought internal review of the decision but was unsuccessful. The applicant then applied to the court for judicial review of the panel's decision, arguing that the imposition of the condition was a jurisdictional error and that the condition was unreasonable and legally inconsistent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the development assessment panel decision to impose a particular condition on the development approval is vitiated by jurisdictional error.
2. Whether the condition imposed by the development assessment panel is vitiated by jurisdictional error on the grounds that the power to impose such a condition is held exclusively by the Commissioner of Main Roads under section 28A of the Main Roads Act 1930 (WA).
3. Whether the condition imposed by the development assessment panel is ambiguous and requires the exercise of power by a third party, making it impossible to implement.
4. Whether the condition imposed by the development assessment panel is unreasonable and not legally consistent with other development approvals in the area.
5. Whether the decision of the development assessment panel must be consistent or reconcilable with other decisions.
6. Whether unreasonableness in the context of this case is a question of statutory construction.
7. Whether discretionary considerations in respect of whether to grant a writ of certiorari should lead to the refusal to grant the writ on the grounds that the issue of certiorari would be an exercise in futility.

Held
1. The development assessment panel decision to impose a particular condition on the development approval is not vitiated by jurisdictional error.
2. The condition imposed by the development assessment panel is not vitiated by jurisdictional error on the grounds that the power to impose such a condition is held exclusively by the Commissioner of Main Roads under section 28A of the Main Roads Act 1930 (WA).
3. The condition imposed by the development assessment panel is not ambiguous and does not require the exercise of power by a third party.
4. The condition imposed by the development assessment panel is not unreasonable and is legally consistent with other development approvals in the area.
5. The decision of the development assessment panel does not need to be consistent or reconcilable with other decisions.
6. Unreasonableness in this context is not a question of statutory construction.
7. Discretionary considerations in respect of whether to grant a writ of certiorari do not lead to the refusal to grant the writ on the grounds that the issue of certiorari would be an exercise in futility.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the application for judicial review brought by Humich Nominees Pty Ltd against the Metro East Joint Development Assessment Panel. The application sought a writ of certiorari to quash a condition imposed on a development approval requiring the construction of a solid median on a main road. The court found that the development assessment panel did not commit a jurisdictional error in imposing the condition. It was determined that the power to impose such a condition was not exclusively held by the Commissioner of Main Roads under section 28A of the Main Roads Act 1930 (WA). The court also held that the condition was not ambiguous and did not require the exercise of power by a third party. The condition was interpreted as being reasonable and legally consistent with other development approvals in the area. The court held that the decision of the development assessment panel did not need to be consistent or reconcilable with other decisions, and unreasonableness was not a question of statutory construction. Finally, the court found that discretionary considerations did not justify refusing the writ of certiorari, as the issue of certiorari would not be an exercise in futility. The writ of certiorari was granted, and the condition imposed by the development assessment panel was quashed in part.