HTDD and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

HTDD and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 725 (12 April 2024)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:          2022/6251

Re:HTDD

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member J Collins

Date:12 April 2024

Place:Brisbane

Pursuant to section 43(1)(c)(ii) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) the decision under review is set aside. The matter is remitted to the Agency for reconsideration with a direction that within 28 days of this decision HTDD’s statement of participant supports specifies for Specialist Disability Accommodation as follows:

·SDA Building type: Villa/Townhouse, 1 resident

·Design Category: Robust (with breakout space)

·Location: Queensland Statistical Area (SA4), 304 (QLD – Brisbane- West).

.............................[SGD].............................

Senior Member J Collins

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – Specialist Disability Accommodation - whether Applicant is eligible for SDA - whether Applicant has extremely reduced functional capacity or psychosocial functioning in undertaking self-care and self-management – psychosocial impairment - whether Applicant has high need for person-to-person supports in undertaking self-care and self-management – whether Applicant meets SDA needs requirement – whether SDA is a reasonable and necessary support - what form of SDA is appropriate if Applicant is eligible  - Robust class - decision set aside and remitted.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) section 43
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) sections 3, 4, 34, 100, 103, 209
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Specialist Disability Accommodation) Rules 2020
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013

Cases

G v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 79
G v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1229
MDCT and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 697
Mulligan v NDIA [2015] FCA 544; (2015) 233 FCR 201
National Disability Insurance Agency v Foster [2023] FCAFC 11

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) [1979] 24 ALR 577

Secondary Materials

The Applied Principles and Tables of Support to determine the responsibilities of the NDIS and other service systems dated 19 April 2013
Australia’s Disability Strategy 2021-2031
NDIS Operational Guidelines – Specialist Disability Accommodation, as of 25 July 2022
Queensland Housing and Homelessness Action Plan 2021-2025

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member J Collins

12 April 2024

  1. HTDD is a 52-year-old woman and a participant of the National Disability Insurance Scheme (‘the Scheme’). HTDD is homeless and has effectively been so for the past 10 years.

  2. HTDD was granted access to the Scheme on the basis of her psychosocial impairments.[1]

    [1] R2: Respondent’s First Statement of Issues dated 26 October 2022.

  3. On 17 June 2021 a delegate of the National Disability Insurance Agency (‘the Agency’) conducted an unscheduled review of HTDD’s plan. At the time of this review HTDD sought funding for Specialist Disability Accommodation (‘SDA’).

  4. SDA is defined as follows:[2]

    ‘accommodation for a person who requires specialist housing solutions, including to assist with the delivery of supports that cater for the person’s extreme functional impairment or very high support needs’.

    [2] Rule 5, National…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HTDD and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 725
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal reviewed a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to refuse funding for Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA) for the applicant, HTDD. The NDIA had affirmed its original decision, asserting that HTDD did not meet the requirements for SDA, specifically that it would not be more effective than other supports alone and would not substantially improve her life stage outcomes or provide long-term benefit. HTDD sought a review of this decision, contending that she met the statutory criteria for SDA and that a specific type of SDA, a one-bedroom villa/duplex/townhouse in the Robust design category, located in Brisbane-West, Queensland, was appropriate.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether HTDD was eligible for SDA as a reasonable and necessary support under the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) and associated instruments, and if so, what form of SDA would be appropriate. The NDIA argued that SDA was not a reasonable and necessary support for HTDD, that her request exceeded what is generally provided under the NDIS, and that her needs could be met through other universal systems or service providers.

The Tribunal considered the evidence presented, including HTDD's lived experience and expert reports detailing her diagnoses of Autism Spectrum Disorder (Level 3), Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, severe generalised anxiety disorder, severe major depressive disorder, paranoia complicated by thought disorder, and avoidant personality disorder. These conditions resulted in significant impairments, including extreme sensory processing difficulties, inappropriate and avoidant behaviours, emotional dysregulation, social isolation, poor self-care, and severe deficits in communication. The Tribunal noted that while it was not bound by the NDIA's Operational Guidelines, it should consider them if they were not inconsistent with the NDIS Act and its objects. The Tribunal found that the NDIA's decision was not well-founded and that the matter should be remitted for reconsideration.

The Tribunal set aside the NDIA's decision and remitted the matter to the NDIA for reconsideration according to law. This reconsideration was to include a determination of whether HTDD meets the eligibility requirements for SDA, and if so, what type and form of SDA is appropriate for her.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Accordingly, unless the Agency’s Operational Guidelines are inconsistent with the provisions or objects of the legislation they should be considered in a determination of what is a reasonable and necessary support for HTDD.EVIDENCE ABOUT HTDD HTDD provided a statement of lived experience in support of her application. She also provided oral evidence at the hearing. Allowances for her sensory sensitivities were made in the hearing room, which was adjusted to have no direct electric lighting and only indirect sunlight such that the blinds in the Tribunal hearing room were positioned to occlude approximately 85% of the natural sunlight. Throughout her oral evidence HTDD was observed to rock, pace and click her fingers continually. I am satisfied that HTDD made a genuine effort to provide honest and truthful evidence without exaggeration. This was despite the indeed adversarial approach adopted by the Agency in respect of her oral evidence including under cross-examination.[19][19] National Disability Insurance Agency v Davis [2022] FCA 1002 at [43] and [46] HTDD also provided reports from a number of expert and other witnesses some of whom also provided oral evidence at the hearing. I will refer to this evidence subsequently in this decision. The evidence overwhelmingly supports, and I accept that HTDD has the following psychosocial conditions:[20]·autism spectrum disorder - level 3 (‘ASD-3’), ·post-traumatic stress disorder (‘PTSD’);·severe generalised anxiety disorder (‘GAD’);·severe major depressive disorder;·paranoia complicated by thought disorder; and·avoidant personality disorder.[20] A7: Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issus and Contentions dated 3 November 2023 at [52]; A5: Report of Dr Blair-West dated 23 August 2023. As a consequence of these conditions HTDD I am satisfied that HTDD is affected by the following impairments: [21][21] A7 at [53]; T Documents, T3: Report of Dr Garnett dated 28 February 2020; T4: Report of Dr Lorimer dated 30 October 2020; T5: Letter of Dr Nguyen dated 9 March 2021; T9: Statement of Ms Marie Fitzgibbon dated 9 September 2021; A5: Report of Dr Blair-West; R7: Report of Ms Orla Fox dated 23 August 2023.·extreme tactile sensory processing difficulties;·extreme auditory processing difficulties;·visual sensory difficulties;·severe sensory over-responsivity·inappropriate behaviours including verbal aggression;·avoidant behaviours;·hyper-vigilance, anger and anxiousness; ·emotional dysregulation;·social isolation and withdrawal;·poor self-care;·severe deficits in verbal and non-verbal communication; and·inflexible behaviour including difficulty in coping with change. HTDD explained that, in hindsight, these impairments have existed since childhood with an eventual diagnosis of ASD-3 in her forties. She referred also to diagnoses of paranoia and avoidant personality disorder.[22] In particular, HTDD’s diagnosis of ASD-3 has helped her to better ‘understand’ her impairments.[23] She described the following experiences as a child:[24]·Her preference for being in her bedroom as it provided her with a controlled and confined environment with less sensory disruptions;·Hiding in small and confined spaces such as a storage cupboard under stairs which were dark and quiet;·Moving out of her bedroom at the age of ten into a room underneath the family home on the basis her mother had painted her bedroom in bright colours which ‘felt loud’ to her;·Her preference to reside in the room underneath the family home because ‘sensations, noises and colours were more controlled there’;·As a teenager living in a bedroom ‘with a little window in it that I could keep very dark’ and in which she could block out external noises; and·Distress to the point of rage in respect of certain sounds such as a clock ticking or a dishwasher being stacked or unstacked.[22] A5(c): Applicant’s Statement of Lived Experience dated 24 August 2023 at [2].[23] A5(c) at [123].[24] A5(c) pages 2-3.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 18 May 2022 the Agency affirmed its original decision (‘the decision under review’) thereby continuing to refuse HTDD funding for SDA.[7] This refusal was on the basis the Agency did not consider that HTDD met the requirements for SDA through the Scheme. The Agency relied primarily upon the NDIS Specialist Disability Accommodation Rules (‘SDA Rules’) maintaining that SDA for HTDD:(a)Would not be more effective and beneficial for her when combined with other supports, as compared to other supports alone; and(b)Would not be likely to substantially improve her life stage outcomes and be of long-term benefit to her.[7] T Documents: T1A; T2. Dissatisfied with this decision HTDD applied to the Tribunal for a review of the decision under review.[8][8] T1; Section 103(2) NDIS Act.ISSUES BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL The issues before the Tribunal are whether: ·HTDD is eligible for SDA on the basis that it is a reasonable and necessary support for her; and ·If so, what type and form of SDA is appropriate for HTDD. Determination of these issues is made pursuant to the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (‘NDIS Act’) and several other statutory instruments made under it.[9][9] SDA Rules; Operational Guidelines – Specialist Disability Accommodation; National Disability Insurance Scheme Pricing Arrangements for Specialist Disability Accommodation 2022 – 2023 (1 July 2022) (‘the NDIA Price Guide’). At the hearing both parties were legally represented.Contentions HTDD contends that she satisfies the statutory criteria for eligibility for SDA and that the decision under review should be set aside and substituted with a decision that she be funded for SDA as follows:[10]·SDA Building Type: Villa/Duplex/Townhouse, 1 bedroom/resident;·Design Category: Robust (with breakout space);·Location: Queensland Statistical Area Level (SA4), 304 (QLD – Brisbane-West).[10] A7: Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions at [75] and [123]. The Agency does not accept that SDA is a reasonable and necessary support for HTDD and contends that HTDD does not meet the mandatory statutory criteria.[11] [11] Sections 11, 12, 13, 14(1)(b) and 14(2) SDA Rules; R9: Respondent’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions dated 28 November 2023 at [27] and [28]. The Agency also contends that HTDD’s request for SDA ‘goes beyond what is generally provided under the NDIS and is beyond what is reasonable and necessary’.[12] Further, that ‘appropriate support is more appropriately funded or provided through other universal systems and service delivery or supports services offered, as has been demonstrated by her communications with the Housing Department’.[13][12] R9 at [13] and [28]. [13] R9 at [29]. In closing submissions the Agency also submits ‘HTDD asks of the Scheme something that it can neither provide nor does it fall within the ambit of the qualifying provisions. It is certainly not cost-effective and, in its terms, it does not address the impairment.‘[14][14] Respondents Closing Submissions at [23].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The SDA Rules are of particular relevance in a review of this kind where HTDD’s eligibility for SDA is contested. Operational Guidelines Separate from the NDIS Act, the Support Rules and the SDA Rules, the Agency itself issues ‘Operational Guidelines’ in relation to what it considers are ‘reasonable and necessary supports’ for the purposes of a participant’s plan. There is no power conferred by the NDIS Act for the Agency to make these Operational Guidelines, and they are issued in an exercise of executive power.[16] The Tribunal is therefore not bound by any policy set out in the Agency’s Operational Guidelines. [16] G v Minister for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 79 at [18]. However, in Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2)[17] the Federal Court held that a Tribunal should take into account relevant government policy which is not inconsistent with the provisions or objects of the legislation. Further guidance for the proposition that the Tribunal is not bound by policy is found in G v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection[18] where Mortimer J held: “Justice or injustice is not found within a policy. It is found by looking at the overall circumstances of an individual’s case with the principal focus bring on the purpose and context of the statutory power, not the executive policy framed to guide it …”[17] [1979] AATA 179.[18] [2018] FCA 1229 at [171]. Accordingly, unless the Agency’s Operational Guidelines are inconsistent with the provisions or objects of the legislation they should be considered in a determination of what is a reasonable and necessary support for HTDD.EVIDENCE ABOUT HTDD HTDD provided a statement of lived experience in support of her application. She also provided oral evidence at the hearing. Allowances for her sensory sensitivities were made in the hearing room, which was adjusted to have no direct electric lighting and only indirect sunlight such that the blinds in the Tribunal hearing room were positioned to occlude approximately 85% of the natural sunlight. Throughout her oral evidence HTDD was observed to rock, pace and click her fingers continually. I am satisfied that HTDD made a genuine effort to provide honest and truthful evidence without exaggeration. This was despite the indeed adversarial approach adopted by the Agency in respect of her oral evidence including under cross-examination.[19][19] National Disability Insurance Agency v Davis [2022] FCA 1002 at [43] and [46] HTDD also provided reports from a number of expert and other witnesses some of whom also provided oral evidence at the hearing. I will refer to this evidence subsequently in this decision. The evidence overwhelmingly supports, and I accept that HTDD has the following psychosocial conditions:[20]·autism spectrum disorder - level 3 (‘ASD-3’), ·post-traumatic stress disorder (‘PTSD’);·severe generalised anxiety disorder (‘GAD’);·severe major depressive disorder;·paranoia complicated by thought disorder; and·avoidant personality disorder.[20] A7: Applicant’s Statement of Facts, Issus and Contentions dated 3 November 2023 at [52]; A5: Report of Dr Blair-West dated 23 August 2023.