Guy and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

Guy and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 3029 (28 August 2024)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number:2023/1649          

Re:Shaun Guy  

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member S Smith

Date:28 August 2024

Place:Brisbane

Pursuant to section 43(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.............................[SGD]...............................

Member S Smith

Catchwords

NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – reasonable and necessary supports – value for money - request for regular access to a sex worker – sex therapy - autism spectrum disorder - social and communication deficits – long-term effects of a sex worker on functional capacity - distinction between sex worker and sex therapist – where allied health therapies represent value for money – purpose of the scheme - disability needs of the applicant – decision under review affirmed.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (Cth)

Cases

G v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 1229
HTDD and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 725 
McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308
MDCT and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 697
Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Agency [2015] FCA 544
National Disability Insurance Agency v Davis [2022] FCA
National Disability Insurance Agency v KKTB [2022] FCAFC 181
National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF [2020] FCAFC 79
NJSC and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 4449
Re Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 60
Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286
Spires and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 1230
WRMF and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 1771

Secondary Materials

Operational Guidelines - Reasonable and necessary supports, as of 6 October 2023

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member S Smith

28 August 2024

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Shaun Guy is a 31-year-old Indigenous Australian who identifies as transgender and uses she/her pronouns. Ms Guy lives with her two dogs, three pet snakes, bird and two lizards in public housing accommodation in a coastal area of Queensland. Ms Guy prefers to be called Shaunee.

  2. Ms Guy became a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (the scheme) on 18 December 2018 on the basis of impairments resulting from a diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder (ASD) and an unspecified intellectual disability.

  3. Ms Guy enjoys woodwork and also runs a business catching wild snakes in her local community.[1] Ms Guy relies on her support workers to transport her to snake ‘callout’ jobs, and if they are unavailable she asks clients to transport her to ‘catch and relocate’ the snake.[2] Ms Guy reported ten callouts since January 2024[3] for which she charges a callout fee however her main source of income is the disability support pension.[4]

    [1] Transcript of proceedings, page 39 line 20-22; EB1, T Documents, T1A: Initial Assessment Report of Ms Chelsea Dunne dated 7 September 2022, page…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Guy and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3029
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal reviewed a decision by the National Disability Insurance Agency (NDIA) to affirm its refusal to fund Ms Guy's request for regular access to a sex worker. Ms Guy sought funding for one-hour sessions per fortnight, which included intimate activities, at a cost of $560 per session. The NDIA had initially declined this support, and Ms Guy applied to the Tribunal for a review of that decision.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether the requested support, namely access to a sex worker, constituted "reasonable and necessary supports" under section 34 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth). This involved assessing whether the support would assist Ms Guy in pursuing her goals, facilitate her social and economic participation, represent value for money, be effective and beneficial, consider informal supports, and be most appropriately funded by the NDIS. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider if the proposed support achieved comparable outcomes to alternative supports at a substantially lower cost, if it would substantially improve life stage outcomes and be of long-term benefit, and if it was likely to reduce the overall cost of supports in the long term.

The Tribunal reasoned that the proposed support did not represent value for money. It noted that Ms Guy could independently perform personal care tasks such as showering and already engaged in social interaction through a transgender group and personal friendships. Furthermore, evidence indicated Ms Guy did not suffer from physical sexual dysfunction and could achieve sexual release independently. Expert evidence suggested that a sex worker would not improve Ms Guy's functional capacity or provide long-term benefits, especially given her history of engaging such services without substantiated improvement. The Tribunal accepted expert opinion that psychologist supports, rather than sex worker services, were more appropriate for addressing Ms Guy's social and emotional impairments stemming from her Autism Spectrum Disorder.

Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the NDIA's decision to decline the requested support. It concluded that the proposed expenditure was not justified on the evidence, as it did not meet the criteria of being reasonable and necessary, particularly concerning value for money and the likelihood of achieving substantial long-term functional improvement.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The proposed support provides for one-hour sessions per fortnight of the GFE including activities of showering together, kissing, talking and having penetrative sex for an hourly total cost of $560.00. In considering whether there are comparable supports which would achieve the same outcomes I note the following:·Ms Guy’s home has a shower facility and she is able to independently complete all showering and bathing tasks independently;[53]·Ms Guy attends a monthly transgender group meeting which provides her with meaningful social interaction.[54] These meetings run for two hours and are free of charge. Ms Guy has friends at the transgender group and also three close friends including Mr Harkonen. She also maintains weekly phone contact with her foster parents, an uncle and an aunt;[55] and·Ms Guy does not suffer physical sexual dysfunction and is able to independently achieve an erection and also sexual release with the assistance of pornographic materials.[56] No submissions were made in regard to the cost, if any of these materials.Evidence that the support will substantially improve the life stage outcomes for, and be of long-term benefit to Ms Guy[53] T Documents, T5, pages 72 and 83.[54] Transcript of proceedings, page 44 lines 23-25.[55] D2, page 502.[56] Transcript of proceedings, page 63 lines 19-24. The evidence of Dr Barnett was that a sex worker would not improve upon Ms Guy’s functional capacity and that there is no evidence of long-term improvement. I note that Ms Guy has been seeking paid services of sex workers since 2017 with no substantiated improvements to her functional capacity including behaviours of concern and social and emotional deficits, and that during this period Ms Guy’s support workers have continued to choose not to remain working with her. I accept Dr Barnett’s evidence and the substantial reasoning she provided.[57]Whether funding or provision of the support is likely to reduce the cost of the funding of supports for the participant in the long term[57] Respondent’s Closing Submissions at [25-32]. I accept Dr Barnett’s opinion outlined at [30-35] above that a sex worker will not provide Ms Guy with the appropriate supports required to address her particular disability needs.[58] Dr Barnett stated in her report that, as a result of her ASD (which Ms Guy was granted access to the scheme on the basis of) Ms Guy experiences social and emotional impairments including the following:·difficulty with social interactions and communication;·difficulty seeing other people’s perspectives;·expressing her distress and frustration aggressively;·difficulty establishing and maintaining relationships;·fixated interests;·comfort with routines and patterns and difficulty managing unexpected change; and·repetitive behaviours.[58] WRMF and National Disability Insurance Agency [2019] AATA 1771 at [24]. Ms Doyle, Dr Stephenson, Ms Dunne and Dr Barnett made clear recommendations for psychologist supports and I accept their evidence that Ms Guy requires these supports to address her social and emotional impairments so that she can participate in all aspects of personal and community life.[59] Historically Ms Guy has disengaged from psychologist supports[60] and this is somewhat understandable in the context of her disability. Relevantly, in the matter of HTDD and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 725 the Tribunal observed that:[61]‘Counsel for HTDD submits that she requires supports to address her disability notwithstanding that intrinsic to her disability is resistance to supports. This submission is made sensibly and perceptively, in recognition and understanding of the complex nature of HTDD’s disability and the interplay of her impairments.’ (Tribunal emphasis)[59] National Disability Insurance Agency v Davis [2022] FCA at [69].[60] C9, page 301.[61] At [207].

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 9 March 2023 the Agency notified Ms Guy that they decided to affirm the decision to decline the requested support (the decision under review).[8] On 11 March 2023 Ms Guy applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) for a review of the Agency’s decision.[9] [8] T Documents, T2: Internal Review Decision; Section 100(2) National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth).[9] T Documents, T1: AAT application for review of decision. The Tribunal must consider whether the requested support is reasonable and necessary in accordance with section 34 of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (the NDIS Act). For the reasons that follow, the Tribunal affirms the decision under review.THE RULES, LEGISLATION AND GUIDELINESNational Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)Section 34: Reasonable and necessary supports(1) For the purposes of specifying, in a statement of participant supports, the general supports that will be provided, and the reasonable and necessary supports that will be funded, the CEO must be satisfied of all of the following in relation to the funding or provision of each such support:(a) the support will assist the participant to pursue the goals, objectives and aspirations included in the participant's statement of goals and aspirations;(b) the support will assist the participant to undertake activities, so as to facilitate the participant's social and economic participation;(c) the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support;(d) the support will be, or is likely to be, effective and beneficial for the participant, having regard to current good practice;(e) the funding or provision of the support takes account of what it is reasonable to expect families, carers, informal networks and the community to provide;(f) the support is most appropriately funded or provided through the NationalDisability Insurance Scheme, and is not more appropriately funded or provided through other general systems of service delivery or support services offered by a person, agency or body, or systems of service delivery or support services offered:(i) as part of a universal service obligation; or(ii) in accordance with reasonable adjustments required under a law dealing with discrimination on the basis of disability.(2) The National Disability Insurance Scheme rules may prescribe methods or criteria to be applied, or matters to which the CEO is to have regard, in deciding whether or not he or she is satisfied as mentioned in any of paragraphs (1)(a) to (f). Section 34(1) is cumulative and therefore all the criteria must be met. Relevant in deciding whether the criteria under section 34(1) are met are the National Disability Insurance Scheme (Supports for Participants) Rules 2013 (the supports rules).[10] Part 3 of the supports rules provides as follows:[10] See also National Disability Insurance Agency v WRMF [2020] FCAFC 79 (WRMF) at [201]; McGarrigle v National Disability Insurance Agency [2017] FCA 308 (McGarrigle) at [41-43]. Value for money3.1 In deciding whether the support represents value for money in that the costs of the support are reasonable, relative to both the benefits achieved and the cost of alternative support, the CEO is to consider the following matters:(a) whether there are comparable supports which would achieve the same outcome at a substantially lower cost;(b) whether there is evidence that the support will substantially improve the life stage outcomes for, and be of long-term benefit to, the participant;(c) whether funding or provision of the support is likely to reduce the cost of the funding of supports for the participant in the long term (for example, some early intervention supports may be value for money given their potential to avoid or delay reliance on more costly supports);(d) for supports that involve the provision of equipment or modifications:(i) the comparative cost of purchasing or leasing the equipment or modifications; and(ii) whether there are any expected changes in technology or the participant’s circumstances in the short term that would make it inappropriate to fund the equipment or modifications;(e) whether the cost of the support is comparable to the cost of supports of the same kind that are provided in the area in which the participant resides;(f) whether the support will increase the participant’s independence and reduce the participant’s need for other kinds of supports (for example, some home modifications may reduce a participant’s need for home care).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Barnett was asked for her comment on the evidence that all people who are Indigenous ‘have the cultural belief that allied health professionals are a waste of taxpayers’ money’ and ‘will not accept working with allied health professionals on cultural grounds’. Dr Barnett responded, as an Indigenous Australian that these are both not correct[45] and suggested that the issue is not accessibility to these services but rather Ms Guy’s willingness to engage.[46][45] Transcript of proceedings, page 128 lines 1-9.[46] D2, page 514 at [17].CONSIDERATION The Tribunal’s task in reviewing the decision under review is to stand in the shoes of the original decision maker[47] and determine whether the requested support is ‘reasonable and necessary’ such as the expenditure of public funds for the requested support is justified on the evidence before it. [47] Spires and National Disability Insurance Agency [2023] AATA 1230 at [6], citing Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority (2008) 235 CLR 286, [37-38], [45-46] (Kirby J), [99] (Hayne and Heydon JJ), [140-143] (Kiefel J); Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 60. The evidence establishes that as a result of her diagnosis of ASD Ms Guy experiences impairments in relation to the following:·her ability to connect with others in the community and build meaningful social networks;·difficulty in communicating with others and managing emotions during interpersonal interactions;·difficulties in establishing and maintaining relationships; and·a lack of interpersonal skills. I consider also the evidence that Ms Guy experiences symptoms of anxiety arising from these impairments which she finds more manageable in predictable environments and a consistent routine.[48] Ms Guy referred to past trauma including growing up in foster care and stated as a result of her anxiety around people she does not trust, that during her regular appointments at the Viper Room she feels ‘safe’ and cared for.[49][48] See [17] Reasons for Decision; D2, page 518.[49] C13, page 320. Notwithstanding, the legislative scheme is based on a functional, practical assessment of what Ms Guy can and cannot do.[50] I have considered how the requested support and alternative supports will address her particular impairments and individual support needs[51] and enable Ms Guy to live as normal a life as possible given her disability, and not to satisfy every want.[52] Assessing proposed supports: Value for money[50] Mulligan v National Disability Insurance Scheme [2015] FCA 544 at [56].[51] National Disability Insurance Agency v KKTB, by her litigation representative CVY22 [2022] FCAFC 181 at [26]; See also WRMF at [141] and [151-152] and Respondent’s Closing Submissions dated 27 August 2024 at [15-16].[52] MDCT and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 697 at [62]; NJSC and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 4449 at [104]; See the Rules, Legislation and Guidelines, [9-12] Reasons for Decision.Comparable supports which would achieve the same outcome at a substantially lower cost.