House and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2011] AATA 707

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No Q 200500505  

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )
Re DAVID RICHARD HOUSE

Applicant

And

DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS AUTHORITY

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal Deputy President P E Hack SC

Date12 October 2011  

PlaceBrisbane

Decision The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

.............Signed...............

Deputy President

  1. This matter is, regrettably, a further re-hearing of an application by Mr David House to review a decision of the respondent, the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority, made on 14 March 2005 (and confirmed on reconsideration on 1 August 2005) to reject Mr House’s application to vary his classification for the purposes of the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefit Act 1973 (Cth) (the Act).

  2. The application is before me following an appeal and an order of the Full Court of the Federal Court that an earlier decision I made[1] be set aside and the matter remitted to be decided again subject to certain directions, including a direction that the matter be decided “without the hearing of further evidence”. The further hearing is confined to a narrow issue. The parties have made further written submissions but do not desire any further opportunity to make oral submissions.

    [1]    See Re House & Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority [2010] AATA 147

  3. To the extent that it is necessary to understand what remains to be determined on this remitter some of what follows repeats what was said in the earlier decision. I do not, however, need to repeat much of the uncontroversial background which is set out in that decision.

    The legislation

  4. By virtue of s 26 of the Act, where a “contributing member” is retired on the ground of invalidity or of physical or mental incapacity to perform duties, the member is entitled, on retirement, to invalidity benefits in accordance with Part V of the Act. Where a member is, or is about to become, entitled to invalidity benefit the Authority is required by s 30 of the Act to make an initial determination of,

    “…his percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment and…classify him according to the percentage of incapacity as follows:

Percentage of incapacity Class
60% or more A
30% or more but less than 60% B
Less than 30% C
  1. Once that initial determination has been made the Authority may reclassify in accordance with s 34(1) of the Act. That provides:

    “(1)The Authority may, from time to time, if it is satisfied that the percentage of incapacity in relation to civil employment of a recipient member in receipt of invalidity pay is such that the classification of the member should be altered, reclassify him in the appropriate classification set out in section 30 according to the percentage of his incapacity in relation to civil employment.”

    In determining the percentage of incapacity, the Authority is obliged by s 34(1A) of the Act to,

    “…have regard to the following matters only:

    (a)     the vocational,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read House and Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Author... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] AATA 707
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mr House brought an application against the Defence Force Retirement and Death Benefits Authority (Authority) seeking a review of a decision to refuse a review of his classification. The Authority had determined that Mr House was not incapacitated to the extent required for the grant of a benefit. The Tribunal affirmed the Authority’s decision. The Tribunal found that the impairments of alcoholism and personality disorder had resulted in a diminution of Mr House’s capacity to undertake civilian employment in the range of 10% to 15%. In reaching this conclusion, the Tribunal gave weight to the evidence of Dr Jill Reddan, a consulting psychiatrist. Dr Reddan provided evidence that Mr House exhibited inflexibility, marked grandiosity, and a sense of entitlement, which adversely affected his "soft skills". The Tribunal considered that these personality traits would be less marked now that Mr House was no longer drinking and was in a stable relationship. However, the Tribunal found that the degree of demonstrable impairment was objectively minor and had not changed over the past few years. The Tribunal concluded that the impairments had resulted in a diminution of Mr House’s capacity to undertake civilian employment in the range of 10% to 15%. The Tribunal affirmed the Authority’s decision, finding that Mr House was not incapacitated to the extent required for the grant of a benefit.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In my earlier decision[10] I set out at length the evidence that touched upon the question of incapacity arising from prescribed impairments and what that evidence said of the relevant consequences to Mr House’s capacity from the impairments. It has not been suggested by either party that there is other evidence to which regard ought be had. What I said there was as follows:“[43]There has been a tendency, with the evidence in this case, to have the witnesses express conclusions about the percentage of incapacity by reference to particular occupations or otherwise express opinions about the ultimate issue that I have to determine. Thus Dr Reddan has provided an assessment of the extent to which Mr House’s psychiatric impairment has impaired his capacity to undertake particular occupations. Ms Rowe, the occupational therapist, has determined, for the reasons that she has expressed, that Mr House is “not a match” for any of the occupations that she regards as being relevant. As it seems to me, the first step is to consider the evidence that touches upon the question of incapacity arising from prescribed impairments to examine what that evidence says of the relevant consequences to Mr House’s capacity from the impairments. [44]It seems logical to start by reference to the June 2004 decision which concluded that Mr House’s level of incapacity was 20%. As the Authority points out, it is a notable feature of this case that, on one view, the evidence demonstrates that Mr House’s level on incapacity ought to have reduced rather than increased. He no longer abuses alcohol, he is in a quite stable relationship in which he acts as a carer for his spouse and he performs voluntary work assisting blind people on a regular basis albeit with a recent, brief break . Those matters, it might be thought, suggest a marked improvement rather than a worsening of his capacity.[45]Nevertheless, it is necessary to look at the evidence that touches upon the question.[10] At [43] – [54]. The evidence of impairment[46]As long ago as 1992 Mr House was assessed by Ms Maureen Field, a clinical neuropsychologist. Her report of 21 January 1992 described cognitive impairments in several areas including “significant memory impairment”. A further neurological assessment of Mr House was undertaken by Ms Chris Schumann in March 2007. Her report of 17 April 2007 described Mr House’s memory as being “moderately impaired for immediate recall and learning”. She also noted “a retrieval deficit, which was consistent with his history of chronic alcohol excess”. Her testing indicated the following problems:‘1) Moderate depression,2) Mildly slow processing speed on some tasks,3) Mild verbal fluency deficit, 4) Memory problems that included:a. Moderate retrieval deficit, 5) Executive problems that included:a. Mild conceptual shifting problems,b. Mild to severe planning and organising deficit,c. Mild to moderate visuo-perceptual organization deficit.’[47]Importantly, Ms Schumann described the test results as consistent with previous neuropsychological assessment in 1992. In her oral evidence from July 2007 Ms Schumann agreed with the proposition that there had been no change between 1992 and 2007.[48]I should also observe that Dr McGuire commented in her report of 19 April 2006 that there ‘were no obvious cognitive deficits’. That accords with my observations of him, albeit briefly, in the witness box and in the quality of the written material produced by Mr House. The material demonstrates that Mr House appears quite able to argue his case which he does with a considerable degree of logic and a considerable grasp of the detail of evidence given in hearings going back over 15 years.[49]The extent of Mr House’s memory deficits were the subject of a more recent report by, and evidence from, Dr Philip Morris, a consultant psychiatrist. Dr Morris said this:‘On examination on various occasions he has been cooperative and showed no obvious distress. His speech shows difficulty with verbal fluency, and with word finding difficulties. His speech is coherent. His affect showed good range and was appropriate. His mood was euthymic. No psychotic features were noted. He does not have any suicidal or homicidal intent now but has had suicidal thoughts in the past. He has been alert on all assessments. His is of average intelligence. His judgement and insight are preserved. Cognitive examination using the Addenbrooke Cognitive Exam revealed problems with verbal memory recall and impaired phonemic verbal fluency. The remainder of his cognitive functions, including attention and orientation, language and visuospatial capacities were impaired. His mini mental state exam score was 29/30 and his ACE-R score was 96/100. Neither indicates dementia.Computer based neuropsychological testing (Integneuro)(Brain Resource Company) revealed impairments in switching of attention (the trail making test A and B) and verbal interference (the Stroop test), and his verbal memory recall after a short and long delay was well below what would be expected based on his pre-morbid intelligence. These results indicate a mild disturbance of cognition in the areas of attention and concentration, executive function and memory recall that are consistent with his subjective complaints.’In his oral evidence Dr Morris said that these deficits were not recent and were consistent with heavy consumption of alcohol. [50]This evidence leads me to conclude that the degree of demonstrable impairment is objectively quite minor and is, at best for Mr House, unchanged over the past few years. [51]But Mr House relies, as well, on manifestations of his personality that he contends affect his capacity to engage in employment. The matters that are relied upon are the character traits described by Dr Reddan in her report of 22 June 1997 following a consultation with Mr House on 19 June 1997. She said:‘Mr House has difficulty in seeing the points of view of others. His thinking is inflexible and marked by grandiosity and a sense of entitlement. He tends to overstate his case and to project blame onto others for all of his own misfortunes. He thus refuses to accept any responsibility for his situation in life and pursues compensation as part of his drive to prove that others are responsible for any misfortune he has. He is self-absorbed and unwilling to look at the effect of his behaviour on his family. He consciously and determinedly refuses to change.’ In her subsequent report of 15 January 2003, having seen Mr House again on 28 November 2002, Dr Reddan said:‘There have been some shifts in his presentation in that on this occasion he expressed more concern for others and a greater capacity for empathy. He also appeared to have insight into certain aspects of his belief patterns. However, he continues to exhibit paranoid traits and he defends against his low self esteem and feelings of inferiority by some narcissistic defences. He has long been reluctant to accept responsibility and he has been absorbed in self-pity (which he describes as a sense of victimisation) for many years. He has been rigid and inflexible in his thinking, but this has been challenged of recent times. His alcohol use has been self-defeating.’[52]Dr McGuire generally agreed with this aspect of Dr Reddan’s evidence. [53]These attributes, it is argued, affect what Ms Rowe described as ‘soft skills … initiative, communication, team work, ability to problem solve, self-manage, plan and learn’. In this context it is relevant to consider the views of Dr McGuire and Dr Reddan about the effects of the recent changes to Mr House’s life, that is, the cessation of drinking, the commencement and maintenance of a stable relationship and the regular performance of voluntary work. Both doctors said that one of the consequences of Mr House having ceased drinking is that he can no longer be diagnosed as having either alcohol abuse or alcohol dependence, the relevant psychiatric diagnoses. Dr McGuire agreed that the fact of Mr House’s relationship, his role as a carer and his voluntary work was indicative of empathy, care and compassion which ‘shows somebody who is improving’. Dr Reddan expressed similar views, saying of the lifestyle changes made by Mr House that they reflected ‘an improvement in his mental state’. She said of the fact of Mr House having ceased drinking in about 2003/2004:‘First of all there is the recovering effects physically on the brain and the improvement of overall competent functioning. If you are not subjecting the brain to a drug that is actually – the central nervous system depresses. So, gradually the brain does recover. Very often it also leads to more stabilisation of moods. Often an improvement in motivation in particular. There is a general decrease in irritability and what we would call dysphoric or unhappy feelings. Alcohol tends to be a drug that over time makes people miserable. You usually find when people have abused alcohol, even if there’s a binge pattern of drinking or it’s intermittent abuse, that their mood improves when they either sip or drink at low levels.… Again, the effects of that can be very self-sustaining.’ [54]Dr Reddan has had considerable exposure to Mr House and the matters that afflict him. Whilst she has not seen him of recent times she has had the opportunity to read and consider what others have said of his current condition. The length of her contact leads me to prefer her evidence to that of Dr McGuire, although in reality there is perhaps only a difference of emphasis between them. But Dr Reddan’s evidence, and that of Dr McGuire, satisfies me that the personality traits earlier identified by Dr Reddan would be less marked now that Mr House is no longer drinking and is in a stable relationship. The evidence of Mr House about the timing of these changes is somewhat inconsistent however it would seem that he had ceased drinking by 2004 and that the relationship with his now wife commenced earlier than that. I am then satisfied that by the time of the present application to the Authority, Mr House was no longer abusing alcohol which had the effect of considerably improving his capacity for care, compassion and empathy as well as leading to an improvement in his ‘soft skills’.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

These proceedings have their genesis in a request made by Mr House to the Authority on 19 November 2004 by which he sought a review of his classification. On 14 March 2005 the delegate of the Authority rejected the request. The decision was confirmed on reconsideration in a decision sent to Mr House on 1 August 2005. It is the decision, later confirmed on reconsideration, which is the subject matter of this application. The earlier decision In my earlier decision I accepted that Mr House suffered, relevantly, from two conditions – alcoholism and personality disorder. The former had been accepted as a prescribed impairment, the latter had not been. In my reasons for decision I accepted evidence that suggested that the alcoholism was causally related to the underlying personality disorder[4] however I overlooked the operation of s 34(1B) of the Act and, in particular, the connecting conjunction between paragraphs (a) and (b) of it. That, as the Full Court held, was an error of law. The consequence of that error was that, when considering the extent to which Mr House was incapacitated from pursuing the various categories of civil employment, it was not as clear as it ought to have been whether I had considered only alcoholism or both alcoholism and personality disorder.[4]At [29]. There is no controversy about the kinds of civil employment to be considered. They are: delivery driver and truck driver, mobile plant operator, storeman, mining or construction labourer and security officer although slightly different descriptions are used in the material. The task now, following the remitter of the matter from the Court, is to consider the effects of Mr House’s personality disorder and his alcoholism upon the capacity of a person exhibiting Mr House’s vocational, trade and professional skills, qualifications and experience, to reasonably undertake the kinds of civil employment that have been found by the Tribunal in the relevant classes of civil employment. The parties, as I have said, have lodged supplementary submissions in accordance with the Court’s direction.The effect of the impairments The submissions for Mr House, which at least had the advantage of brevity, focussed on evidence given by Dr Jill Reddan[5], a consulting psychiatrist, that Mr House demonstrates inflexibility, marked grandiosity and sense of entitlement. These features, it is said, adversely affect his “soft skills”, “skills which are of fundamental importance to the question of his incapacity to undertake the relevant types of employment”[6]. Attention was drawn to the following passage from the evidence of Dr Reddan[7],“What often happens, though, is that when difficult circumstances occur in an individual’s life, their personality problems become more manifest, and that sometimes gets confused with exacerbation, but it’s because they’ve got personality problems that they don’t deal with difficult or stressful circumstances in a particularly adaptive way, and that’s why it can appear that it’s worse, when in fact it’s not. Also, people with significant personality problems are more likely to encounter difficult or stressful circumstances, because they inadvertently often create them for themselves. If I could think of a good example: some people who, perhaps, at work can’t get on with anyone; they might not get on with anyone at home, either, and the people at work might try to get them to, you know, be more of a team member, or whatever, and that – the person with the personality problem perceives that as stressful because they can’t see the inherent problems in themselves with how they get on with others. So it’s often when they perceive themselves to be under stress that their behaviour or their functioning appears worse, but it’s really just the natural history of an individual with a personality disorder.” [emphasis in the applicant’s submissions] [5] Report of 22 June 1997.[6] Submissions, 16 September 2011 at [3].[7] Transcript 11 July 2003, pages 52-3.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established