44/1998
PARTIES: HORNE, Cherie Jayne
v
WILSON, Graeme James Gregory (No 2)
TITLE OF COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION: ORIGINAL
FILE NO/S: 796/1996
DELIVERED: 30 April 1998
HEARING DATE/S: 9, 11, 12 February, 19 March 1998
JUDGMENT OF: Underwood J
CATCHWORDS:
Limitation of Actions - Contracts, torts and personal actions - When time begins to run - Particular causes of action - Negligence - Cause of action not complete until damage results - Post-traumatic stress disorder of delayed onset.
Limitation Act 1974 (Tas), s5(1).
Jaensch v Coffey (1983 - 1984) 155 CLR 549; Mount Isa Mines Ltd v Pusey (1970) 125 CLR 383, applied.
Swan v Williams (Demolition) Pty Ltd (1987) 9 NSWLR 172, followed.
Aust Dig Limitation of Actions [23]
Damages - Particular awards of general damages - Tasmania - Negligence - Breach of duty of care by sexual abuse of the plaintiff when a child - Onset of injury delayed until adult - Post-traumatic stress disorder of delayed onset - General damages $15,000.
Aust Dig Damages [61]
Damages - Exemplary, punitive and aggravated damages - Exemplary damages - Circumstances in which award may be made - Sexual abuse of plaintiff when a child - Onset of psychiatric injury delayed until adult - Post-traumatic stress disorder of delayed onset - Exemplary damages $40,000.
Whitfeld v De Lauret and Company Limited (1920) 29 CLR 71, applied.
Aust Dig Damages [3]
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Plaintiff: C K Brown and R A Browne
Defendant: S P Estcourt and J P E Walker
Solicitors:
Plaintiff: Legal Aid Commission
Defendant: Harry Serpanos & Co
Court Computer Code:
Judgment ID Number: 44/1998
Number of pages: 9
Serial No 44/1998
File No 796/1996
CHERIE JAYNE HORNE v
GRAEME JAMES GREGORY WILSON (No 2)
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT UNDERWOOD J
30 April 1998
Introduction
This is an unusual case. By a writ filed on 23 May 1996, the plaintiff claims damages against the defendant for negligence, assault, battery and breach of fiduciary duty. However, the statement of claim confines the case to one for damages for negligence. The plaintiff, who was born on 12 April 1968, claims that from the age of 5 until the age of 12 (1973 - 1980), the defendant systematically and regularly subjected her to sexual abuse and she thereby suffered loss, psychological injury and damage. Her case is, by this conduct, the defendant, who is her uncle, breached the duty of care he owed her by virtue of their relationship and proximity.
In addition to putting the principal allegation in issue, the defendant relies, in the alternative, upon the provisions of the Limitation Act 1974, s5(1), claiming that if there was a breach of the duty as alleged, it caused damage more than three years before the writ was issued and, consequently, this action is statute barred. In response to this defence, the plaintiff asserts that she suffered no injury as a result of the breach of duty until, at the earliest, 1995.
Only four witnesses gave evidence at…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Horne, Cherie Jayne v Wilson, Graeme James Gregory (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1998] TASSC 44
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
Justice Underwood found that the defendant had not met his onus of proving that the plaintiff suffered recognisable psychiatric illness prior to the statute of limitations period expiring. The plaintiff's sexual development had deviated from the norm due to the abuse, but this did not amount to a psychiatric illness. Therefore, the plaintiff's claim was not barred by the statute of limitations. The court awarded the plaintiff $15,000 in general damages for the injury she suffered and $40,000 in exemplary damages to punish the defendant for his "conscious wrongdoing".
The final orders of the court were that judgment be entered for the plaintiff against the defendant in the sum of $55,000.
Background
Background to the litigation
The court detailed the circumstances of the alleged abuse, which began when Horne was 5 years old. Wilson allegedly engaged in various forms of sexual abuse with Horne on multiple occasions over a period of seven years. The abuse occurred in several locations, including Wilson's utility vehicle, his grandparents' home, and other places. Horne testified that she experienced no immediate emotional distress from the abuse and did not disclose the incidents to anyone until she was 12. She began to repress her memories of the abuse and did not think about it until she learned that her sister had also been abused by Wilson. Following this disclosure in 1994, Horne sought counseling and reported the abuse to the police. As a result, she began to recall the details of the abuse, leading to symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder, including sex avoidance, frequent nightmares, tension headaches, and general irritability.
The court accepted Dr. Sale's evidence that Horne did not suffer from a recognisable psychiatric illness until after the disclosure to her sister in 1995. Although Horne's sexual development deviated from the norm during her adolescence, Dr. Sale opined that this did not constitute a psychiatric illness. The court concluded that Wilson had not discharged the onus of proving that Horne suffered a recognisable psychiatric illness prior to 23 May 1993, and therefore, the action was not statute-barred. The court awarded Horne compensatory general damages of $15,000 and exemplary damages of $40,000, resulting in a total judgment of $55,000 against Wilson.
The matter of Cherie Jayne Horne v Graeme James Gregory Wilson (No 2) was heard in the Supreme Court of Tasmania, proceeding as an original jurisdiction case under file number 796/1996. The case was brought before the court via a writ filed on 23 May 1996, asserting claims for damages due to negligence, assault, battery, and breach of fiduciary duty, though the statement of claim narrowed the case to one for damages for negligence. The defendant contested the claim, asserting that if a breach of duty occurred, it caused damage more than three years before the writ was issued, rendering the action statute-barred under the Limitation Act 1974, s5(1). The plaintiff contended that she suffered no injury until at least 1995. The case was heard over several dates, including 9, 11, 12 February, and 19 March 1998, before Justice Underwood, who delivered the judgment on 30 April 1998. The judgment addressed the procedural history, findings of fact, and legal considerations leading to the final determination of liability and damages awarded to the plaintiff.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the defendant owe a duty of care to the plaintiff, and if so, was that duty breached?
2. When did the plaintiff first suffer loss, injury, or damage as a result of the defendant's breach of duty?
3. Does the Limitation Act 1974, s5(1), bar the plaintiff's claim for damages?
4. If the plaintiff's claim is not barred by the Limitation Act, what is the appropriate amount of compensatory general damages to award?
5. Is an award of exemplary damages warranted in this case, and if so, what is the appropriate amount?
Held
1. The defendant owed a duty of care to the plaintiff and breached that duty by subjecting her to systematic and regular sexual abuse. Result: Duty of care owed and breached.
2. The plaintiff first suffered loss, injury, or damage in 1995 when she began to experience symptoms of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder after disclosing the abuse to her sister and receiving counseling. Result: Loss, injury, or damage first suffered in 1995.
3. The Limitation Act 1974, s5(1), does not bar the plaintiff's claim for damages as the plaintiff did not suffer a recognisable psychiatric illness until after the statutory period had elapsed. Result: Claim not barred by the Limitation Act.
4. The appropriate amount of compensatory general damages to award is $15,000, taking into account the extent of the plaintiff's injury, the recency of the injury, and the hopeful prognosis. Result: General damages awarded: $15,000.
5. An award of exemplary damages is warranted in this case, and the appropriate amount is $40,000, to punish the defendant for his wrongful conduct and to visit him with retribution for his conscious wrongdoing. Result: Exemplary damages awarded: $40,000.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Supreme Court of Tasmania, in the case of Horne v Wilson, held that the defendant, Graeme James Gregory Wilson, owed a duty of care to the plaintiff, Cherie Jayne Horne, and that this duty was breached by his systematic and regular sexual abuse of her from the age of five until she was twelve. The court found that the defendant's actions constituted a breach of the duty of care owed to the plaintiff due to their relationship and proximity. Furthermore, the court accepted the plaintiff's testimony and that of her cousin, Mrs Jacobs, regarding the abuse and rejected the defendant's alternative defence based on the Limitation Act 1974, s5(1).
Regarding when the plaintiff first suffered loss, injury, or damage as a result of the defendant's breach of duty, the court found that the plaintiff did not suffer any recognisable psychiatric illness until after the disclosure by her sister Leanne in 1995. The court relied on the medical evidence of Dr Sale, who opined that the plaintiff's adolescent sexual conduct was a manifestation of sexual abuse and not a psychiatric illness. The court held that the plaintiff's claim was not barred by the Limitation Act 1974, s5(1), as the defendant had not discharged the onus of proof that the plaintiff suffered from a recognisable psychiatric illness prior to 23 May 1993.
As for the appropriate amount of compensatory general damages, the court assessed the plaintiff's injury as substantial and her loss grave. However, considering the extent of the plaintiff's injury, the fact that she had only suffered injury since about 1995, and the reasonably hopeful prognosis, the court awarded general damages in the sum of $15,000.
Finally, the court found that an award of exemplary damages was warranted in this case to punish the defendant for his wrongful conduct and to visit him with retribution for his "conscious wrongdoing in contumelious disregard of [the plaintiff's] rights". The court assessed exemplary damages at $40,000, resulting in a total judgment for the plaintiff against the defendant for $55,000.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that a defendant who systematically and regularly sexually abuses a child may be held liable for compensatory and exemplary damages for the harm caused to the child, even if the child does not suffer recognisable psychiatric illness until years later. Additionally, the court found that the plaintiff's claim was not barred by the Limitation Act 1974, s5(1), as the defendant had not established that the plaintiff suffered from a recognisable psychiatric illness prior to the limitation period.