Holt v Dental Board of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

CITATION:Holt v Dental Board of Australia [2023] NTSC 28

PARTIES:HOLT, Myles Edward

v

DENTAL BOARD OF AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF THE NORTHERN TERRITORY

JURISDICTION:  SUPREME COURT exercising Territory jurisdiction

FILE NO:2022-01022-SC

DELIVERED:  30 March 2023

HEARING DATE:  10 February 2023

JUDGMENT OF:  Brownhill J

CATCHWORDS:



CIVIL PROCEDURE – Leave to appeal – Northern Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal – Finding of professional misconduct – Where questions of law identified – No evidence for findings or no proper bases for inferences – Denial of opportunity to respond to allegations – Inadequate reasons – Where real or significant argument to be put that there was error – Leave to appeal granted.

CIVIL PROCEDURE – Appeal – Northern Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal – Whether error established on questions of law – No evidence for findings or no proper bases for inferences – Denial of opportunity to respond to allegations – Inadequate reasons – No error established – Appeal dismissed – Decision of Tribunal confirmed.

Adjrun v Chief Executive Officer (Housing) [2022] NTSC 42; King v Commissioner for Consumer Protection [2018] WASCA 194; Myers v Medical Practitioners’ Board of Victoria (2007) 18 VR 48, applied.

Avopiling (NSW) Pty Ltd v Menard Bachy Pty Ltd [2012] NSWSC 1466; Azzopardi v Tasman UEB Industries Ltd (1985) 4 NSWLR 139; Booth v An Assessor [2019] NTSC 89; Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336; Byrne v Legal Services Commissioner [2009] VSC 210; Cmunt v New South Wales Commissioner of Police [2019] NSWCCA 177; Commissioner for Australian Capital Territory Revenue v Alphaone Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 576; Commissioner of Taxation v Crown Insurance Services [2012] FCAFC 153; Eckersley v Medical Board of Queensland [1998] 2 Qd R 453; Hansen v Patrick [2018] QCA 298; John Holland Pty Ltd v TAC Pacific Pty Ltd [2010] 1 Qd R 302; Lavorato v R (2012) 82 NSWLR 568; Meadows v Minister for Immigration & Multicultural Affairs (1998) 90 FCR 370; Medical Board of Australia v Athinodorou [2018] SAHPT 7; Musico v Davenport [2003] NSWSC 977; Perkins v County Court of Victoria (2000) 2 VR 246; Public Service Board (NSW) v Osmond (1986) 159 CLR 656; Roy Morgan Research Centre Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue (Vic) (2001) 207 CLR 72; S v Crimes Compensation Tribunal [1998] 1 VR 83; Saeed v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2010) 241 CLR 252; SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) 228 CLR 152; The Queen v General Medical Council; Ex parte Gee [1986] 1 WLR 226; The Queen v Judge Mullaly; Ex parte Attorney-General (Cth) [1984] VR 745; The Queen v Tennant; Ex parte Woods [1962] Qd R 241; TNT Skypak International (Aust) Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1988) 82 ALR 17; Tracy Sports Village and Social Club v Walker (1992) 111 FLR 32; WACO v Minister…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Holt v Dental Board of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NTSC 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Holt v Dental Board of Australia involves an application for leave to appeal and an appeal against a decision by the Northern Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Tribunal) that the dentist, Dr Holt, engaged in professional misconduct. Dr Holt, a registered dental practitioner, was accused of fabricating documents in support of his case in a civil action in the Local Court and of making a false declaration when he applied for registration as a dentist. The Tribunal found Dr Holt guilty of professional misconduct based on these allegations and the Dental Board of Australia subsequently suspended his registration. Dr Holt is now seeking leave to appeal against the Tribunal's decision, arguing that the Tribunal erred in law by making findings that there was no evidence to support the conclusion that he fabricated documents and that he was not given adequate reasons for the Tribunal's findings.

The primary legal issues in this case are whether the Tribunal erred in law by making findings that there was no evidence to support the conclusion that Dr Holt fabricated documents, failing to notify Dr Holt of that potential finding, thereby denying him procedural fairness, and providing inadequate reasons in relation to that finding. Dr Holt contends that the Tribunal's findings were based on an unreasonable inference and that he was denied procedural fairness by not being notified of the potential findings. Furthermore, Dr Holt argues that the Tribunal's reasons were inadequate and did not adequately explain the basis for the findings.

The court examined the evidence and the reasoning of the Tribunal in detail. The court found that there was evidence to support the Tribunal's findings that Dr Holt fabricated documents, and that the inferences drawn by the Tribunal were reasonable. The court also found that Dr Holt was not denied procedural fairness, as he was given an opportunity to respond to the allegations and to present evidence. Finally, the court found that the Tribunal's reasons were adequate and provided a sufficient explanation for the findings. The court dismissed the appeal and denied leave to appeal.

The court's final orders were that the appeal be dismissed, leave to appeal be refused, and costs be awarded to the Dental Board of Australia. The court found that the Tribunal's decision was not based on an error of law and that the appeal was without merit. The court also found that the Tribunal's reasons were adequate and that Dr Holt was not denied procedural fairness. The court awarded costs to the Dental Board of Australia, as the appeal was dismissed and found to be without merit.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an application for leave to appeal, and an appeal (if leave be granted), against a finding by the Northern Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal that a dentist had engaged in professional misconduct. The issues in the appeal are whether the Tribunal erred in law by: (a) making a finding that the dentist had fabricated documents in support of his case in a civil action in the Local Court when there was no evidence on which that finding could be made; (b) failing to notify the dentist of that potential finding, thereby denying him procedural fairness; and (c) providing inadequate reasons in relation to that finding.Background The applicant (‘Dr Holt’) is a dental practitioner. The respondent (‘the Board’) is the national body which regulates dentists and dentistry pursuant to the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (NT) (‘National Law’).[1] In order to practice dentistry, Dr Holt is required by the National Law to be registered with the Board. Dr Holt has, at all relevant times, been registered with the Board.Allegations of professional misconduct On 8 April 2018, pursuant to s 193(1)(a)(i) of the National Law, the Board referred a matter to the Northern Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal (‘Tribunal’) based on the Board’s belief that Dr Holt had behaved in a way that constitutes professional misconduct.[2] The allegations of professional misconduct made by the Board before the Tribunal were set out in a substituted notice of allegations dated 7 July 2021 (referred to in detail below).[3] In essence, the allegations were that, between 1 and 4 April 2014, Dr Holt gave oral evidence before the Local Court that was false or misleading, and caused documents to be disclosed or tendered as evidence on his behalf in the Local Court that were false or misleading, and, on 3 February 2010, made a false or misleading declaration when he applied for registration as dentist.The Tribunal hearing and decision On 4 April 2022, after six days of hearing at which Dr Holt and three other witnesses gave oral evidence and both parties tendered documents and made written and oral submissions, the Tribunal delivered its decision and written reasons (‘Tribunal’s Reasons’).[4] The Tribunal found that Dr Holt engaged in certain behaviour which was substantially below the standard reasonably expected of a registered health practitioner, and so constituted professional misconduct as defined by s 5(a) of the National Law.[5] On 12 August 2022, the Board suspended Dr Holt’s registration.Application for leave to appeal By s 141 of the Northern Territory Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2014 (NT) (‘NTCAT Act’), a party to a proceeding before the Tribunal may, with the leave of the Supreme Court, appeal to the Supreme Court against a decision of the Tribunal ‘on a question of law’. On hearing an appeal, the Supreme Court must confirm the decision of the Tribunal, vary the decision of the Tribunal, set aside the decision of the Tribunal and substitute its own decision or send the matter back to the Tribunal for reconsideration, or dismiss the appeal (s 141(3)).

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal then proceeded to consider the four documents, and to make the findings about them referred to in paragraph [16] above. The Tribunal’s findings in relation to the four documents are considered in more detail below. It is those findings which are challenged in the appeal.Question 1: No evidence for the findings that Dr Holt fabricated the documents? To succeed in the appeal on a question of law on this basis, Dr Holt must show that: (a) there was: (i) no evidence of the factual findings as set out in paragraph [16] above; or (ii) inferences as set out in paragraph [16] above could not properly be drawn because there were no primary facts upon which they could be inferred; and (b) the findings or inferences were crucial to the Tribunal’s ultimate conclusion that Dr Holt engaged in professional misconduct, ie the Tribunal’s ultimate conclusion depended upon those facts as found by the Tribunal.[37] If there is evidence which, if believed, would support finding those facts, even if it is strongly one way, and even if this Court would make a different finding on that evidence, the error of law is not established.[38] If, on the other hand, there is no evidence to support a finding of fact which is crucial to an ultimate finding (here, of professional misconduct), there is an error of law. Similarly, if there are primary facts upon which the secondary facts might be inferred, the error of law is not established, even if this Court would have drawn a different inference from those primary facts,[39] whereas, if there are no primary facts upon which the secondary facts might be inferred, an error of law is established.[40] In Tracy Village Sports & Social Club v Walker (1992) 111 FLR 32, Mildren J held (at 37-38) as follows:In Instrumatic Ltd v Supabrase Ltd [1969] 1 WLR 519; [1969] 2 All ER 131 at 132, Lord Denning MR, with whom Edmund Davies LJ and Phillimore LJ agreed, said that ‘if a tribunal draws an inference which cannot reasonably be drawn, it errs in point of law, and its decision can be reviewed by the courts. That was settled, once and for all, in Edwards (Inspector of Taxes) v Bairstow [1956] AC 14’ (emphasis mine). The word ‘reasonably’ suggests that this Court could interfere if it thought the inference drawn was unreasonable. With respect, I think difficulty of understanding may arise by the use of pejorative words such as ‘perverse’, ‘unreasonable’, ‘illogical’ and the like expressions which by their nature indicate only that in the opinion of the user, the decision ought not to have been made, and the user holds that opinion rather strongly. In the context of this discussion, if an inference cannot reasonably be drawn, it will be because the inference cannot be drawn from the primary facts. However, if the inference is one about which minds might differ, it being a question of judgment or degree, the inference not only can be drawn but it would not be unreasonable to draw it. SDC letter The SDC letter, dated 9 June 2011, is addressed to Dr Holt, refers to his application for conditional registration made on 18 May 2011 and states it has been approved.[41] The letter was signed by the Registrar, Clin A/Prof Patrick Tseng.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established