HMXZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

HMXZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2021] AATA 520 (16 March 2021)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL              )
  )             Nos: 2019/8139
GENERAL DIVISION  )  2020/0581

Re: HMXZ
Applicant

And: Child Support Registrar
Respondent

And: NDQP
Other Party

DIRECTION

TRIBUNAL:  Senior Member P J Clauson AM

DATE OF CORRIGENDUM: 23 March 2021

PLACE:           Brisbane

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to section 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), to alter the text of the decision in this application to remove the paragraph numbering assigned to paragraph [50] on page 17 of the text, and subsequently reduce each paragraph number by 1.

......................................[SGD].............................
Senior Member P J Clauson AM

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:          2019/8139

2020/0581

Re:HMXZ

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndNDQP

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Senior Member P J Clauson AM

Date:16 March 2021

Place:Brisbane

The reviewable decisions dated 7 November 2019 and 21 January 2021 are affirmed.

...............................[SGD]...................................

Senior Member P J Clauson AM

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.

Catchwords

SOCIAL SECURITY – Child Support and Family Assistance – Percentage of Care Determination – Consideration of correct Percentage of Care – existence of special circumstances – decision affirmed.

Legislation

Child Support (Assessment Act) 1989 (Cth)

Family Law Act 1975 (Cth)

Cases

Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 46 FLR 409

Re Drake v the Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

Gillson and Secretary, Department of Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs [2011] AATA 473

Polec and Staker [2011] (SSAT Appeal) FMCAfam 959

P v Child Support Registrar (2014) 225 FCR 378

Secondary Materials

Guide to Social Security, Child Support Guide

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member P J Clauson AM

16 March 2021

BACKGROUND

  1. HMXZ (“the Applicant”) and NDQP (“the Other Party”) in these matters are the mother and father respectively of the three children relevant to this review: “Child N”, “Child J”, and “Child C”. The first application (numbered 2019/8139) concerns Children N and J and the second application (numbered 2020/0581) concerns Child C.

  2. On 13 July 2016,[1] the Federal Circuit Court of Australia issued parenting orders which dictated inter alia, that both parents [the Applicant and Other Party] were to have equally shared care of the three children. Order 5 specified that in the absence of agreement between the parents, the children were to stay with each parent on alternating weeks from one Friday to the next.[2] Consequently, the Child Support Registrar (“CSR” or “the Respondent”) recorded equal care for each parent from a start date of 15 July 2016.[3]

    [1] Exhibit 2, T Documents in matter 2020/0581 (“Exhibit 2”),…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HMXZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 520
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned two reviews brought by the Applicant (HMXZ) concerning decisions of the Child Support Registrar regarding the percentage of care for three children. The Applicant sought to revoke existing care determinations and substitute them with new ongoing determinations, and also sought interim care determinations. The Applicant had unilaterally withheld care of the children from the Respondent (the Other Party) on multiple occasions, citing concerns about the children's safety and alleging abuse. The Respondent maintained that the Applicant's actions were retaliatory and unfounded, and that he had attempted to enforce existing court orders.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the existing care determinations should be revoked and substituted with new ongoing determinations, and whether interim care determinations should be issued. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider if there were "special circumstances" that would prevent an interim care period from applying in favour of the Respondent, as contemplated by subsection 51(5) of the relevant Act. The Tribunal was required to assess the evidence presented by both parties, including affidavits, court documents, and oral testimony, to determine the appropriate care arrangements.

The Tribunal considered the evidence presented by both parties, including the Applicant's claims of abuse and the Respondent's assertions that these were unfounded and that he had acted on legal advice. The Tribunal noted that while allegations of abuse were made, no court orders had been issued as a consequence of these allegations. The Tribunal found that the Applicant's actions in withholding care were not supported by evidence of special circumstances that would warrant refusing an interim care period in favour of the Respondent. Consequently, the Tribunal agreed that the requirements for an interim determination were satisfied for all three children.

The Tribunal affirmed the decisions in both review matters. The decision in the first matter, 2019/8139, concerning Children J and N, was affirmed. The decision in the second matter, 2020/0581, concerning Child C, was also affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

In this case, the material facts revolve around disputes over care arrangements and allegations of abuse concerning three children: J, N, and C. The children were subject to care arrangements established by the Federal Circuit Court on 13 July 2016. In February 2019, the mother, HMXZ, withheld the children J and N from the father, leading to a new care determination being sought by HMXZ. For child C, HMXZ had already changed the care arrangement to 100% in October 2018 by withholding the child from the father. Both parents attended a hearing before the Tribunal on 23 September 2020 to address the care arrangements.

HMXZ submitted that she had withheld the children until 3 May 2019 and had filed applications with the Federal Circuit Court seeking new care arrangements on 8 February 2019. She claimed that the father did not make reasonable attempts to comply with the care arrangements and alleged special circumstances, including that the children were at risk of physical and psychological harm if left with the father. The father, on the other hand, argued that his contravention application was not invalid and was dismissed because another application was already in progress. He claimed to have acted on his solicitor's advice and maintained that the allegations of abuse were unfounded. He also stated that he had not attended mediation on his solicitor's advice, as it would not result in the restoration of the care arrangements.

The Tribunal reviewed the evidence provided by both parties and noted that there were no active domestic violence orders or criminal charges against either party. The Tribunal affirmed the decisions from the previous reviews concerning the care arrangements for the children, concluding that there were no special circumstances warranting an interim care period in favour of the father. The Tribunal found that the requirements for an interim determination were satisfied for Child C and, mutatis mutandis, for Children J and N. The Tribunal's decision was based on the evidence and submissions presented by both parties during the hearing.

The case, HMXZ and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review), involves two child support reviews brought by the mother (Applicant) concerning the care arrangements for three children. The initial care arrangement was established by the Federal Circuit Court on 13 July 2016. The Applicant filed an initiating application in the Federal Circuit Court on 8 February 2019 seeking a variation of the existing care arrangements. This application was in response to the withholding of the children by the Applicant, which occurred from 1 February 2019 to 3 May 2019. The father (Other Party) filed a contravention order in response to the initiating application, which was rejected as the issues would be addressed in the resolution of the Applicant’s application.

Both parents attended the hearing on 23 September 2020, providing oral evidence. The Applicant argued that she withheld the children due to concerns about their safety and that the Other Party did not make reasonable attempts to comply with the care arrangements. The Other Party countered that his contravention application was dismissed by a clerk of the court and that he acted on his solicitor's advice. The Tribunal considered the documentary evidence and the testimony provided during the hearing. The Tribunal ultimately affirmed the decisions of the previous reviews, finding no special circumstances warranting an interim care period in favour of the Other Party. The Tribunal will address the Applicant's application to vary the care arrangements at a separate hearing in the Federal Circuit Court in March 2021.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Therefore, with respect to First and Second Reviews, the Tribunal must undertake the task of establishing:(a)whether the existing care determination should be revoked and substituted with a new ongoing determination; and (b)whether there should be an interim care determination issued for the periods established above.[20][20] Supra, [7]. EVIDENCE The Applicant filed a series of documents in relation to both matters, these included: (c)an Application for a Domestic Violence Protection Order dated 24 October 2018; (d)an Initiating Application and notice of risk filed in the Federal Circuit Court on 8 February 2019 naming the mother as the Applicant and the father as the Respondent seeking a variation of the pre-existing care arrangements; (e)an affidavit signed by the mother and dated 4 February 2019 with several attachments. The affidavit was filed in a different Federal Court matter which also identifies the mother as the Applicant. The Other Party did not file any documentation. It is noted that it is not the role of the Tribunal to determine whether there was any abuse in the relationship or the substance of those accusations insofar as they are not relevant to the issues previously identified. However, there are no active domestic violence orders in evidence or any evidence relating to criminal charges against a party to these proceedings. Both parents attended the hearing in these matters on 23 September 2020 and gave oral evidence under affirmation. In summary, the Applicant submitted the following:[21]·that she was caring for the children pursuant to the care arrangements until 1 February when she withheld the Children until 3 May (being the date of the new care determination); ·that on that date she called the police but seemingly no further action was taken other than their presence;[22]·that she filed applications with the Federal Circuit Court to seek new care arrangements on 8 February 2019;[23]·that the Other Party filed a contravention order in response to her initiating application. This application was ultimately rejected as the questions raised therein would be addressed in the resolution of her application; ·that the Other Party did not make reasonable attempts to comply with the care arrangements as his contravention application was made as retaliation to her initiating application; and·that there were special circumstances to refuse interim orders on the basis that the Children were at risk of physical and psychological harm if they were left with the Other Party.[24][21] Transcript of Proceedings, pages 8-15.[22] Exhibit 2, T4 at page 22. [23] Exhibit 5.[24] Exhibit 6. In Summary, the Other Party submitted the following:[25]·that his contravention application was not invalid and was dismissed by a clerk of the court rather than a judge because an application for the matter was already in progress;[26]·that he had attempted to use the police to enforce the care arrangements but had been informed that police did not have the power to do this as it was a federal (rather than state) law issue; ·that he has engaged and consistently acted upon the advice of his solicitor, who informed him that a contravention order was the correct route to take to enforce his rights with respect to the care arrangements; ·that the accusations alleging abuse of any description were unfounded and that “she’s saying that the children were getting – that there was abuse and there was physical harm, so she withheld [Child C], but she happy to let the other two children attend [the Other Party’s home]. Really?” ·that he was not drug or alcohol dependent and that he had test reports corroborating this, however no such reports are before the Tribunal; and ·that whilst the Applicant did arrange and request him to attend mediation, he did not attend on his solicitor’s advice who noted that it would not result in the care arrangements being restored. [25] Transcript of Proceedings, pages 16-l9[26] Supra [22]

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal considers that there are therefore no “special circumstances” as enunciated by subsection 51(5) of the Act in relation to any of the children which would not warrant an interim care period applying in favour of the Other Party to this application. The Tribunal therefore agrees that in relation to the second review as it applies to the Child C, 2020/0581, that the requirements for an interim determination are satisfied, and mutatis mutandis, also in the matter of the first review herein, 2019/8139 as it applies to the Children J and N.DECISION The decision in the first matter 2019/8139 is affirmed. The decision in the second matter 2020/0581 is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Toward the end of the hearing in these matters, the parties’ palpable contempt for one another redirected discussions toward irrelevant matters which will be addressed at a hearing in the Federal Circuit Court in March 2021 to resolve the Applicant’s application to have the care arrangements varied. CONSIDERATION The Tribunal, in relation to the matter 2019/8139 lodged by HMXZ concerning the Children J born 2008 and N born 2007 respectively, has taken into account the affirmed evidence at the hearing of both the Applicant and the Other Party. It has also had before it the documentary evidence contained in the section 37 tribunal documents and the contents of the exhibits numbered one to nine as entered into the Record of Proceedings. The Tribunal notes further the application of those materials in the matter of the Child C; also the subject of an Application for Review 2020/0581 by the Applicant herein. Both reviews before this Tribunal have been brought by the mother of the children in relation to decisions of the Tribunal in its AAT1 jurisdictional context. There was a Care Arrangement for all three children put in place by the Federal Circuit Court on 13 July 2016 (the Court Orders).[27] The Orders outlined a percentage of care for each of the parties up until the change of care being notified by the Applicant herein to the Child Support Registrar (2 February 2019) in relation to the Children J and N only.[27] Exhibit 1, T4, pages 22 to 29. There were similar circumstances attaching to the way in which care changed in relation to the Child C. The Applicant in the case of Child C caused care to change from a 50/50 arrangement to a 100% arrangement to her by withholding the child from the father on 19 October 2018. The Applicant relied upon an Application for a Protection Order filed on 24 October 2018 as some degree of proof that Child C was under threat from the Other Party.[28] It is to be noted by the Tribunal that allegations of abuse were made, however, no court orders were made as a consequence of the Application. The Applicant advised the Tribunal that no Orders were made because the Application was made by the mother and not Child C on their own behalf. [28] Exhibit 4. Following the withholding of care by the mother from the Other Party of the Child C, the father continued to have care of the Children N and J through the Christmas period of 2018 and January 2019 in compliance with the Court Orders of July 2016. The Other Party returned the Children N and J to the Applicant following the conclusion of his school holiday care period on 5 January 2019. The Other Party was due to have his Court ordered care for the first week of the school year in 2019. The Other Party arrived at the school to collect the child J from after-school care on 1 February 2019 and was following the Court Orders in so doing. He was advised by the after-school care Supervisor that J had been collected by the Applicant’s partner. It transpired further that the Applicant’s partner had also collected the Children C and N from their after-school care facility.