Background
Background to the litigation
On 24 November 2020, the Tribunal heard the parties’ further brief oral submissions in the Present Application. In particular, the parties expressed their agreement as to the issues that remained for determination, being:(a)whether, as at 15 January 2015, the APC had a present liability to pay compensation to Mr Hickey in respect of the costs of reasonable medical treatment (if any) obtained in relation to an “L5-S1 disc prolapse on the left with a [sequelae] of soft tissue injury right foot”, sustained on 27 September 1993, pursuant to s 16 of the SRC Act; and(b)whether, as at 15 January 2015, the APC had a present liability to pay compensation to Mr Hickey in respect of incapacity for work resulting from an “L5-S1 disc prolapse on the left with a [sequelae] of soft tissue injury right foot”, sustained on 27 September 1993, pursuant to s 19 of the SRC Act.FACTUAL BACKGROUND Mr Hickey is a 62-year-old man who has been employed by the APC for approximately 27 years.[10] In or around 1993, Mr Hickey worked as a Postal Transport Officer (PTO).[11][10]Mr Hickey commenced employment at the APC in or around June 1993 (A1, paragraph 39 and the APC’s SFIC at [2]).[11]R2, T7, page 21.Initial claim for compensation On 27 September 1993, Mr Hickey signed an incident report which stated that on that day he had “pain in lower back, servere [sic] when lifting left leg” following his attempt to pull a hanging mailbag, that was three quarters full, up and away from the mail bag hooks in a street pillar post box.[12][12]R2, T7, page 21; R2, T5, page 18. On 28 September 1993, Dr Aidan Perse (general practitioner) provisionally diagnosed Mr Hickey with facet joint irritation.[13][13]R2, T6. On 29 September 1993, Mr Hickey signed a claim form for compensation for the injury sustained in the incident two days prior. Mr Hickey identified the part of his body affected as the “lower back left side”. Mr Hickey described the events leading to his injury as follows:[14]I WAS REMOVING A HANGING BAG FROM A[N] SPB IT WAS APP ¾ FULL. I REMOVED THE FRONT RINGS FROM HOOKS AND REACHED DOWN AND FORWARD TO REMOVE BACK RINGS. I LIFTED UP AND AWAY FROM MY BODY. I FELT A SLIGHT PAIN IN MY LOWER BACK. THIS PAIN GRADUALLY INCREASED, TOWARDS THE END OF MY SHIFT I FOUND IT SERVERLY [sic] PAIN FULL [sic] TO LIFT MY LEG OR TO BEND FORWARD.[14]R2, T7. On 7 October 1993, Mr Hickey’s claim for rehabilitation and compensation regarding the injury he suffered on 27 September 1993 received signed recommendation by a manager.[15][15]R2, T7.Medical assessments and determinations during employment In a determination dated 18 October 1993 (1993 Determination), the APC accepted liability under s 14 of the SRC Act for Mr Hickey’s injury suffered on 27 September 1993. The injury was at that point in time described as “facet joint irritation”.[16] The 1993 Determination also accepted liability under s 19 of the SRC Act for the period from 28 September 1993 to 5 October 1993. [16]R3, ST2.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
In his statement dated 16 October 2016,[61] Mr Hickey’s describes the events of [61]A1.27 September 1993 as follows:10.On the date of my accident, 27 September 1993, I was doing mail pickups in a van. I was clearing a street posting box. I had only been doing this type of work for a short time. The mail in the bag had been bricked together. This means the bag can look almost empty not withstanding that it had significant weight of mail in it. It was common for businesses and organisations back at that time to arrange their mail together into bricks, all of which were going to the same postcode. This assisted primary sorting of mail by Australia Post.11.In clearing a mailbox, the way in which the internal bag support frames were designed, you needed to reach out across the top of the frame and lift the bag from hooks located at the back. Whilst lifting the bag on this occasion I felt what I would describe as a sharp stinging pain in my lower back on the left side.12.It was just a sting at first, like someone had flicked elastic onto my skin. There was not excruciating pain. 13.I was working my way back towards the depot still having a number of boxes to clear. I did my best to carry on with work as I was nearing the end of my shift.14.By the time I cleared the last box, I was in significant pain. This was within about half an hour. I made it back to the depot but from memory someone else had to drive me home.15.I rested at home, hardly moving for a day or so due to the pain, to the extent that I had to get my partner to bring me a bottle to void in.Mr Hickey’s evidence at hearing Mr Hickey’s counsel, Mr McCabe took Mr Hickey to paragraph [14] of A1 which states, in relation to the events on 27 September 1993, “[b]y the time I cleared the last box, I was in significant pain”. When asked what his symptoms were at this time while being in significant pain, whether his symptoms changed after that, and what he feels when he experiences an inflaming event, Mr Hickey said:[62][62]Transcript, page 17 at [35] and page 18 at [5]–[45] and 19 at [5].MR HICKEY: I had pain going down my left leg from my left buttock. There was like jolts of pain …At first, those symptoms continued for a few days. I had my partner, Lara, bringing me bottles so I could urinate in them because I couldn’t get out of bed and get to the toilet. But when I was able, I made my way to see a doctor and after a few - after a few weeks the spasming attacks of pain subsided substantially. I was just left with a - just a constant like gnawing. I’ve described it in the past as like - like ants eating away at the base of my spine. It’s difficult to put in terms that others would understand but it was just a constant thing and that subsided somewhat over a period of time but it’s never abated. It’s always - there’s always a pain in my left buttock and that’s sort of the situation I have remained with today. I think the only thing that’s changed is over the years I have learned what I should and shouldn’t do in order to avoid inflaming the area because once I stir things up enough, then the problem becomes more constant and more difficult for me to manage. …MR McCABE: Can you just describe what you feel when you [have] an inflaming event?MR HICKEY: Well, if I stand for an extended period just in the one spot, and I keep my weight evenly on both feet, what can often happen is after a period of an hour or so, I don’t know three-quarters of an hour, it just depends, when I lift my left foot off the ground I get a sciatic discharge down my leg and that ‑ ‑ ‑MR McCABE: What’s that? Can you just explain, what do you mean by a sciatic discharge?MR HICKEY: Well, it’s like - it’s like back in the van when the injury first happened, when I first was trying to get in and out of the van using the bar work, it’s excruciating. It’s like almost an electric discharge but it’s violent and extremely painful. It lasts for a very short-term, like a bolt of electricity, but then I’m more susceptible to further discharges the same and that constant pain that’s in my left buttock is magnified until things settle down and that can be a coin toss in the air. It just depends on some many variables that I still can’t predict to this day. Sometimes it can settle down within the day, or the day after, and sometimes I’m stuck with it for a week, just the increased pain in my left buttock, and I’ve got a nursemaid through to make sure that I don’t do anything that’s going to trigger that discharge, as I call it, like that shooting pain. Once - that’s a trigger for greater pain. I pay for that. Once that happens I’m - I have to watch myself more carefully.MR McCABE: Is that what you’re describing even to this day? Is that what you’re trying to say?MR HICKEY: Yes, pretty much but I just learnt over the period of years what I’m - what I should avoid more so than others and it can also just be a matter of managing things on how I’m feeling that day and also I set myself up to do something. I’ve got to be a lot more careful. I mean I’ve got to think about things that I do before I do them. I can’t just go and grab something and hike it up like - you know, it’s not like that for me anymore. Now, I have to work out like a plan B. I sort of - if I want to move that object I’ll look at it, and if it can be sort of tilted and spun on one point and then tilted and then spun on the next point, so I’m not actually lifting so much but walking an item using its own weight for momentum. I’ve just - the benches in my workshop have - like all those have been set up now about 1100 millimetres - between 1000 and 1100 millimetres. …During cross-examination, Mr Woulfe directed Mr Hickey to a reference in a report by Mr Schaeffer, consultant neurosurgeon, dated 12 September 1997.[63] The reference was to previous covert surveillance of Mr Hickey showing him performing a range of activities, including erecting a shed on his property.[64] Mr Hickey’s evidence on this footage was as follows:[65][63]R2, T46, pages 106 to 108.[64]R2, T46, page 106. [65]Transcript, page 67 at [30]–[45] and 68 [5]–[30]. See also A1 at [48].MR WOULFE: Now, you were the subject of covert surveillance in a previous matter weren’t you?MR HICKEY: Yes.MR WOULFE: And that footage showed you doing a range of activities didn’t it?MR HICKEY: Yes.MR WOULFE: One of those activities was the erection of a shed on your property wasn’t it?MR HICKEY: Well, the supervising thereof.MR WOULFE: Yes, and you did undertake some periods of heavy manual work, didn’t you?MR HICKEY: It would depend on who’s making the determination because they’re talking about a wheelbarrow that they calculated the weight of by the size of the person who was pushing it, which is what they state. That person was actually a 14 year old boy and he was a tall boy, but he was 14 years old. He had no experience using a wheelbarrow, he had problems balancing it even when it was just about empty. I showed him on a number of occasions how you’re best off using a wheelbarrow because I had had a fair bit of experience with one in the past.MR WOULFE: If you go to the bottom paragraph please?MR HICKEY: The bottom? Yes.MR WOULFE: You see there Mr Schaeffer acknowledges that you were mostly supervising?MR HICKEY: Yes.MR WOULFE: Words to that effect?MR HICKEY: Yes.MR WOULFE: He states also though that on two or three occasions you’d raise the handles of a wheelbarrow heavily laden with cement?MR HICKEY: Well, no, I disagree with that.MR WOULFE: But you did lift a wheelbarrow with cement in it?MR HICKEY: I did but it wasn’t heavily laden with cement. It had some cement in it that we - this was a shed being constructed here and the cement was to make footings for poles. The whole idea is to pour the cement into the hole - the hole is only this round. You need that much cement in the barrow. It’s not like heavily laden. They calculated that - like I said - by the size of the boy who I was showing how to use a wheelbarrow and [name omitted] was 14 years of age. He’s taller than me at that time but he’s just a boy - he’s not a strong boy.MR WOULFE: Well, perhaps we can just cut to the chase. What was seen on the video was different from what you told work you were limited to do, wasn’t it?MR HICKEY: No.MR WOULFE: Because you were doing more in your physical endeavours in terms of supervising and assisting with their erection ‑ ‑ ‑?MR HICKEY: I was - I was ‑ ‑ ‑MR WOULFE: Sir, can I just finish? The supervising and the erection of a shed?MR HICKEY: M’mm.MR WOULFE: Than you had led your work to believe was within your physical capacity?MR HICKEY: No.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Mr Hickey seeks review of a decision made by a delegate of the Australian Postal Corporation (the APC) on 30 June 2015 (the Reviewable Decision).[1] In the Reviewable Decision, the delegate affirmed an earlier determination dated 15 January 2015 in relation to Mr Hickey’s “L5-S1 disc prolapse on the left with a [sequelae] of soft tissue injury right foot” sustained on 27 September 1993. The January 2015 determination found that the APC had no present liability to pay compensation under ss 16 and 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) (SRC Act).[2][1]R2, T110.[2]R2, T109.PROCEDURAL HISTORY The application was originally made to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) on 27 July 2015, with a second, separate application seeking review of an additional decision of a delegate of the APC being made to the Tribunal on 13 February 2015.[3] Both applications were heard at the same time by the Tribunal on 20, 21 and 22 June 2017 and on 12, 13 and 14 December 2017. Written closing submissions were provided by the parties in February, March and June 2018.[3]The second, separate application being AAT Application 2015/0729. This second application related to Mr Hickey’s claim regarding a psychological condition. While the Present Application relates to Mr Hickey’s “L5-S1 disc prolapse on the left with a [sequelae] of soft tissue injury right foot” injury he claims was sustained on 27 September 1993, the Tribunal has retained some of the background materials relating to AAT Application 2015/0729 in its decision in order to preserve the factual and chronological picture. By a decision dated 18 October 2018, the Tribunal:[4](a)found that it did not have jurisdiction to review the decision in relation to AAT Application 2015/3786 (the Present Application); and(b)affirmed the decision under review in relation to the second, separate application (being AAT Application 2015/0729).[4]Hickey and Australian Postal Corporation [2018] AATA 3930. Mr Hickey appealed the Tribunal’s decision to the Federal Court of Australia with regard to the Present Application.[5] By orders made by his Honour Stewart J on 2 December 2019, and with the consent of the parties:1. The appeal from the Tribunal’s decision in Application 2015/3786 is allowed;2. That decision of the Tribunal is set aside;3. The matter in Application 2015/3786 is remitted to the Tribunal for reconsideration according to law in light of the parties’ agreed notes…;[6]4. The cross-appeal is dismissed; and5. The respondent is to pay the applicant’s reasonable costs as between party and party of the appeal and cross-appeal, to be agreed or taxed.[5]Mr Hickey did not appeal from the Tribunal’s decision in AAT Application 2015/0729.[6]The agreed notes included in the orders made on 2 December 2019 contained the parties’ agreement that a question of law arises from the Tribunal's decision in Application 2015/3786, that the Tribunal erred in law and that such error vitiated its decision in Application 2015/3786.