Hempel (Wattyl) Australia Pty Ltd v United Workers Union

Link copied
Case Copied 80 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hempel (Wattyl) Australia Pty Ltd v United Workers Union [2024] FCAFC 98  

Appeal from: United Workers Union v Hempel (Wattyl) Australia Pty Ltd [2023] SAET 53
File number: SAD 98 of 2023
Judgment of: RANGIAH, SNADEN AND ABRAHAM JJ
Date of judgment: 22 July 2024
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – appeal from South Australian Employment Court – where primary judge found that employer contravened s 50 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay employees their wages and entitlements in accordance with enterprise agreements – where primary judge found that employees were appropriately classified at higher level – whether primary judge erred in holding that the employer wrongly classified and paid employees at lower level – interpretation of classification criteria – whether employees’ duties correspond to criteria – appeal allowed
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 12, 50, 539, 565 and 570

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 24

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth) reg 1.05

Cases cited:

Allesch v Maunz (2000) 203 CLR 172

Automotive, Food, Metals, Engineering, Printing and Kindred Industries Union v Berri Pty Ltd (2017) 268 IR 285

Bianco Walling Pty Ltd v Construction, Forestry, Maritime, Mining and Energy Union (2020) 275 FCR 385

Choppair Helicopters Pty Ltd v Bobridge [2018] FCA 325

Commissioner for Public Service v Dunk (1999) 66 SAIR 401

Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v Anglo Coal (Callide Management) Pty Ltd [2015] FCA 696

Ghimire v Karriview Management Pty Ltd (No 2) (2019) 290 IR 331

James Cook University v Ridd (2020) 278 FCR 566

Lee v Lee (2019) 266 CLR 129

Logan v Otis Elevator Company Pty Ltd [1997] IRCA 200

Monash Health v Singh (2023) 327 IR 196

Ridd v James Cook University (2021) 274 CLR 514

Ware v O’Donnell Griffin (Television Services) Pty Ltd [1971] AR (NSW) 18

WorkPac Pty Ltd v Skene (2018) 264 FCR 536

Division: Fair Work Division
Registry: South Australia
National Practice Area: Employment and Industrial Relations
Number of paragraphs: 211
Date of last submission: 30 November 2023 (joint statement of agreed facts)
Date of hearing: 15 November 2023
Counsel for the Appellant: Mr M Roder KC with Ms H Veale
Solicitor for the Appellant: Thomson Geer Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr S Blewett
Solicitor for the Respondent: United Workers’ Union

ORDERS

SAD 98 of 2023
BETWEEN:

HEMPEL (WATTYL) AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

Appellant

AND:

UNITED WORKERS’ UNION

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

RANGIAH, SNADEN AND ABRAHAM JJ

DATE OF ORDER:

22 JULY 2024

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The appeal be allowed.

2.The judgment of the South Australian Employment Court in matter ET-22-04296 be set aside and, in lieu thereof, it be ordered that the application in each of that matter and another in that court, matter ET-22-04298, be dismissed.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

The facts

[9]

The 2014 Agreement

[19]

The Agreements

[21]

The reasons of the Employment Court

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hempel (Wattyl) Australia Pty Ltd v United Workers Union and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCAFC 98
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Hempel (Wattyl) Australia Pty Ltd v United Workers Union concerns the classification and payment of employees working in a distribution centre for the employer, Hempel (Wattyl) Australia Pty Ltd. The primary dispute is whether the employees were appropriately classified under the enterprise agreements governing their employment. The South Australian Employment Court had previously found that the employer contravened section 50 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay the employees their wages and entitlements in accordance with the enterprise agreements, holding that the employees were appropriately classified at a higher level. The employer appealed this decision, arguing that the primary judge erred in concluding that the employees should have been paid at a higher classification level.

The legal issues the court needed to decide involved the interpretation of the classification criteria within the enterprise agreements and whether the employees' actual duties corresponded to those criteria. The court was required to determine if the primary judge erred in holding that the employer wrongly classified and paid the employees at a lower level. The appeal necessitated a review of the agreed facts, the terms of the enterprise agreements, and the specific duties performed by the employees to ascertain their appropriate classification under the agreements.

The court concluded that the primary judge had erred in determining that the employees were appropriately classified at a higher level. The classification criteria focus on the duties actually performed by the employees, and if the requisite duties are not performed, the employees do not satisfy the criteria. The court found that the employees were correctly classified as Grade 3 Level 1 employees, not Grade 3 Level 2 or 3, based on their actual duties. Consequently, the employer had contravened certain clauses of the enterprise agreements by failing to pay the employees their wages and entitlements as Grade 3 Level 1 workers. The appeal was allowed, the judgment of the Employment Court was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the Employment Court to determine any remaining issues, including pecuniary penalties and compensation.

The court's decision emphasised the importance of interpreting enterprise agreements purposively, considering the industrial context and the actual duties performed by the employees. By focusing on the employees' actual duties, the court found that the employees' appropriate classification was Grade 3 Level 1, contrary to the primary judge's determination. This conclusion led to the finding that the employer had contravened the enterprise agreements by underpaying the employees.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The judgment of the South Australian Employment Court in matter ET-22-04296 be set aside and, in lieu thereof, it be ordered that the application in each of that matter and another in that court, matter ET-22-04298, be dismissed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I will describe the relevant facts and the reasons of the primary judge before considering the parties’ submissions.The facts Many of the facts are the subject of agreement under a Statement of Agreed Facts. The Employer operates a manufacturing plant and distribution centre at Kilburn. The Kilburn manufacturing plant produces water-based paint which is distributed in Australia and New Zealand. The Employees are Donnato Tronnolone, Carlo Curtale, David Heffernan, Grant Cutler, Philip Hughes and Tony Aurora. They work in the Employer’s distribution centre as store-workers (store-persons). They do not work in the manufacturing plant. Between 2014 and 2018, the Employees were covered by the Valspar (WPC) Pty Ltd (Kilburn) Warehouse and Distribution Agreement (the 2014 Agreement). Under the 2014 Agreement, the Employees were classified as Grade 3.6 employees. The Employees sought a new enterprise agreement because they wanted to be represented by a different union, one that represented the employees working in the Employer’s manufacturing plant, and had evidently received advice that this required that they be covered under a new enterprise agreement. The 2014 Agreement was replaced by the 2018 Agreement, which has been described as a “temporary site-specific agreement”. The 2018 Agreement was then replaced by the 2020 Agreement. The relevant terms of the 2018 Agreement and the 2020 Agreement are the same. The duties of the Employees have remained the same over the course of their employment with the Employer, regardless of which enterprise agreement applied (with the immaterial exception of one employee who acted in higher duties at times). The Employer classified and paid the Employees as Grade 3 Level 1 employees under the Agreements (again, with the one immaterial exception). The Employees all have forklift licences and are required to operate an electric forklift (reach truck) and a gas forklift in their employment. That entitled them to at least Grade 3 Level 1 classification under the Agreements. The Employees also perform duties that are within the criteria for classification under Grade 2. These tasks generally involve using a piece of equipment called a “low-level order picker” or “electric pallet jack”. The Statement of Agreed Facts contains the following: [18]The following agreed facts provide a general overview of the work done by the Employees using a low-level order picker. It is not inclusive of all tasks and duties performed by the Employees.Manual and RF picking and packing[19]One of the tasks performed by each of the Employees is order picking and packing using a low-level order picker. In brief, to pick and pack an order:a.the Employees collect a Pre-Built Label which has been prepared, printed and placed in the Pre-Built Label pigeon hole by a Team Leader or other manager, such as the Operations Controller, from the warehouse desk;b.the Employees use the RF unit to scan the barcode on the Pre-Built Label;c.once the barcode has been scanned on the Pre-Built Label, the RF unit directs the Employees where to go in the warehouse to collect and scan each item relevant to the Pre-Built Label;d.when the Employees scan an item relevant to the Pre-Built Label, the RF unit directs the Employees to the next item required in accordance with the Pre-Built Label;e.as directed by the RF Unit, the Employees collect each item required in accordance with the Pre-Built Label and places each of the relevant items onto a pallet;f.once the Employees have finished scanning each relevant item on the Pre-Built Label, the Employees confirm the order is complete by inputting “1 pallet” on the RF Unit. The Employees then input the pallet destination that is written on the Pre-Built Label into the RF Unit, for example “Victoria”.g.when the order is complete, a packing slip listing each of the items which have been scanned is generated by the RF Unit using the data input by the Employees as detailed in 19f above (packing slip);h.when the Employees have finalised the order on the RF Unit as outlined above, the RF Unit then sends the generated packing slip to the printer in the warehouse;i.the Employees go and collect that printed packing slip from the warehouse printer and place it on the pallet with the original Pre-Built Label prepared by the Team Leader or other manager.[20]Once the Employees have picked the items for the order and placed the Pre-Built Label and packing slip next to the pallet, the Employees place the picked pallet on the auto wrapping machine. The Employees are prompted on the RF Unit to choose “yes” or “no” under the prompt “send LPN to auto wrapper”. The Employees choose the option ‘yes’ once the pallet is on the wrapping machine. The auto wrapping machine then wraps the pallet in plastic wrap and applies certain barcode stickers to the pallet wrapping. [21]If the auto wrapping machine is malfunctioning or out of operation, the Employees will wrap the pallets using a manual wrapping machine and apply the barcode stickers onto the pallet manually.[22]Once a pallet has been wrapped, the Employees place the wrapped pallet onto a conveyer belt. The conveyer belt takes the pallet outside, where the person operating the gas forklift reads and checks the packing slip for ‘dangerous goods’ and applies the relevant stickers.[23]Sometimes Employees will not need to pick and pack orders on an empty pallet and the pre-prepared order ticket will tell them to scan and place items onto an existing pallet or a pallet that is specifically being built as a pallet of mixed items. The process of using the RF unit is the same when this is required.Replenishment [24]Another task often completed by the Employees is replenishment using a low-level order picker. In order to complete replenishment, the RF unit sends the Applicant Member to certain locations in the warehouse to collect items. Once the items are found and scanned by the Applicant Member, the RF unit tells the Applicant where those items need to be placed in the warehouse bays. The Applicant Member then takes those items to the bay indicated on the RF unit.Receipt and dispatch of goods [25]The Employees often operate low level order pickers to-perform receipt and dispatch of goods. This work involves organising the stock that is to be loaded off of, or onto, distribution trucks by the person operating the gas forklift.Work not undertaken by Employees [26] Other than when David Heffernan undertook higher duties as set out in paragraph 12 above, the Employees do not undertake the following tasks:a.printing a manifest which details an overview of each consignment in the relevant geozone group, including the products, weight and whether or not the pallet contains dangerous goods;b.printing the consignment note for each consignment within the geozone group;c. printing an Emergency Procedure Guide card for each consignment;d.printing and completing a multimodal dangerous goods form as required;e.logging onto the Ports Victoria DG Hub and filling out the details in relation to orders as required (for pallets travelling over waters within Australia);f.collating the manifest, consignment note, EPG Card, multimodal dangerous goods form or DG Hub information (if required) (together, the documents) and emailing to freight carriers;g.liaising with freight carriers and separating out from the documents various items based on location (geozone) of consignments;h. providing the documents to freight carriers;i.assessing customer returned stock and determining whether stock is good (and can be resold) or bad (ie damaged);j.determining whether stock returned from other stores has quality issues and is good (and can be resold) or bad (ie damaged);k.reconciling the stock on a returned pallet by recording into the Oracle ERP System its status as good or bad, and then placing the stock (or causing it the stock to be placed) in either the ‘damages area’ of the warehouse, or back into the general area of the warehouse for resale; and l.replacing and/or maintaining beams that are damaged in the pick and reserve locations.

Decision

Reasons for decision

However, the classification criteria focus on the duties actually performed by the Employees. If the requisite duties are not performed, the Employees do not satisfy the criteria. The fact that the Employer may choose to have a duty performed by an employee at a higher Grade does not mean that there was no intention when the Agreements were made that the duty should form one of the criteria for a lower Grade. Accordingly, the fact that the Employer has a Team Leader who performs the duty of, “Export Order Paperwork and coordination” cannot mean that an employee who does not perform those duties can be classified at Grade 3 Level 3. Conclusion I conclude that the primary judge erred in determining that the Employees are appropriately classified at Grade 3 Level 3 of the classification criteria under the Agreements. In my opinion, their appropriate classification is Grade 3 Level 2. It is not in contest that if the Employees’ appropriate classification is Grade 3 Level 2, the Employer has contravened cl 14, 20 and 25 of the 2018 Agreement and cll 12, 18 and 20 of the 2020 Agreement. Consequently, I would set aside the declaratory order made by the primary judge and replace it with a declaration that:Hempel (Wattyl) Australia Pty Ltd contravened s 50 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) by failing to pay Donnato Tronnolone, Carlo Curtale, David Heffernan, Grant Cutler, Philip Hughes and Tony Aurora their wages and entitlements as Grade 3 Level 2 workers in breach of clauses 14, 20 and 25 of the Valspar Paint (Australia) Pty Ltd (Kilburn) Warehouse and Distribution Enterprise Agreement 2018 and clauses 12, 18 and 20 of the Sherwin-Williams National Operations Enterprise Agreement 2020. I would remit the matter to the Employment Court to determine any remaining issues, including any pecuniary penalties and compensation. I am fortunate to have had an opportunity to review in draft the reasons of Rangiah J. I am indebted to his Honour for the way in which he has recited the background to the present appeal, the findings of the learned Deputy President and the issues that fall for determination. Adopting the same defined terms as those that his Honour has employed, I respectfully agree that the learned Deputy President erred by concluding that the Employees ought to have been paid at the grade 3, level 3 classification described in Appendix J of the 2020 Agreement (or the equivalent and materially identical clause of its predecessor). I am unable, however, to agree that they were engaged to perform tasks consistent with the grade 3, level 2 classification. Instead, I consider that they were correctly classified as grade 3, level 1 employees. Those baseline conclusions stated, it follows that I would allow the appeal, set aside the judgment of the Employment Court and, in its place, order that the respondent’s application to that court be dismissed with no order as to costs (in reality, there appear to have been two such applications—both dated 1 September 2022—one for compensation and interest, and one for the imposition of pecuniary penalties).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It may be seen that the ground of appeal begins by alleging that the primary judge reached the wrong conclusion and then goes on to allege four specific errors. Consideration The appeal is brought under s 565(1) of the FW Act, which provides that an appeal lies to the Federal Court from a decision of an eligible State or Territory court exercising jurisdiction under that Act. In Ghimire v Karriview Management Pty Ltd (No 2) (2019) 290 IR 331, Colvin J held at [19]–[21] that such an appeal is an appeal by way of rehearing. I respectfully agree. In an appeal by way of rehearing, the powers of the appellate court are only exercisable where the appellant demonstrates that the judgment is the result of error: Allesch v Maunz (2000) 203 CLR 172 at [23]. In Lee v Lee (2019) 266 CLR 129, the plurality observed at [55]:A court of appeal is bound to conduct a “real review” of the evidence given at first instance and of the judge’s reasons for judgment to determine whether the trial judge has erred in fact or law. Appellate restraint with respect to interference with a trial judge’s findings unless they are “glaringly improbable” or “contrary to compelling inferences” is as to factual findings which are likely to have been affected by impressions about the credibility and reliability of witnesses formed by the trial judge as a result of seeing and hearing them give their evidence. It includes findings of secondary facts which are based on a combination of these impressions and other inferences from primary facts. Thereafter, “in general an appellate court is in as good a position as the trial judge to decide on the proper inference to be drawn from facts which are undisputed or which, having been disputed, are established by the findings of the trial judge”.…(Footnotes omitted.) At first instance, the Employment Court declared that the Employer had contravened s 50 of the FW Act by failing to pay the Employees their wages and entitlements as Grade 3 Level 3 workers in breach of the Agreements. The central question in the appeal is whether the primary judge erred in holding that the Employer had wrongly classified and paid the Employees as Grade 3 Level 1 employees. That question requires consideration of whether their correct classification is in fact Grade 3 Level 3 or, alternatively, Grade 3 Level 2. It will be necessary to undertake a comparison of the duties stipulated under Grade 3 Levels 1, 2 and 3 with the duties actually performed by the Employees. There is little dispute about what duties they actually perform. What is in contest is how the classification criteria should be interpreted and whether the duties performed correspond to the criteria. The appropriate approach to construction of the classification criteria It is necessary to bear in mind the principles applicable to construction of an enterprise agreement. A number of relevant principles were summarised in WorkPac Pty Ltd v Skene (2018) 264 FCR 536 at [197] as follows:The starting point for interpretation of an enterprise agreement is the ordinary meaning of the words, read as a whole and in context. The interpretation “turns on the language of the particular agreement, understood in the light of its industrial context and purpose”. The words are not to be interpreted in a vacuum divorced from industrial realities; rather, industrial agreements are made for various industries in the light of the customs and working conditions of each, and they are frequently couched in terms intelligible to the parties but without the careful attention to form and draftsmanship that one expects to find in an Act of Parliament. To similar effect, it has been said that the framers of such documents were likely of a “practical bent of mind” and may well have been more concerned with expressing an intention in a way likely to be understood in the relevant industry rather than with legal niceties and jargon, so that a purposive approach to interpretation is appropriate and a narrow or pedantic approach is misplaced.(Citations omitted.)