Harvest Water Management Consultants Pty Ltd v Todd

Link copied
Case Copied 53 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Harvest Water Management Consultants Pty Ltd v Todd [2025] NSWSC 266
Hearing dates: 3, 4, 5 and 13 February 2025
Date of orders: 26 March 2025
Decision date: 26 March 2025
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Hmelnitsky J
Decision:

[146]

Catchwords:

CONTRACTS — Terms — Classification of terms — Where parties disagree on quantum and interest under loan agreement — Where written contract drafted seven months after first funds extended

ESTOPPEL — Proprietary estoppel — Detrimental reliance — Whether it was unconscionable for defendant to resile from promise to grant plaintiff security in her property

LAND LAW — Caveats — Caveatable interest —Where pleading sought a declaration that plaintiff has a caveatable interest in defendant’s property

Legislation Cited:

Real Property Act 1900 (NSW), s 74O

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW), r 42.34(2)

Cases Cited:

Douglas v Mikhael & Ors [2023] NSWSC 979

Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118; [2003] HCA 22

John Holland Pty Ltd v Kellogg Brown & Root Pty Ltd [2015] NSWSC 451

Kramer v Stone [2024] HCA 48; (2024) 421 ALR 106

Stonebark Pty Ltd v Disage Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 1015

Texts Cited:

Nil

Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Harvest Water Management Consultants Pty Ltd (Plaintiff)
Trudy Todd (Defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
F Clark (Plaintiff)
C Hart (Defendant)

Solicitors:
Finn Roache Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Carneys Lawyers (Defendant)
File Number(s): 2023/120530
Publication restriction: Nil

JUDGMENT

  1. The plaintiff carries on business as a small environmental engineering consultancy in far northern New South Wales. Its principal is Mr Bradley Irwin. In early 2020, Mr Irwin met the defendant, Ms Trudy Todd, while they were both playing poker machines at the Seagulls leagues club in Tweed Heads. In the following months, they saw one another from time to time. For some of that period, Ms Todd and her son lived at Mr Irwin’s house.

  2. Between May 2020 and September 2021, the plaintiff made numerous payments totalling $147,476.62 either to or for the benefit of Ms Todd. The plaintiff now seeks recovery of these amounts together with interest, principally on the basis that the funds were advanced pursuant to an oral loan agreement.

  3. The defendant accepted that she must repay some of the payments made under that agreement up to a total of $84,484, being those payments that enabled her to (a) make repayments on a second-ranking and very expensive mortgage over her apartment (the so-called Humgoda loan), (b) bring her outstanding strata levies up to date, and (c) make payments in respect of the ‘Laneway Bar’. However, she disputes that she is liable to repay the balance, such as payments that enabled her to repay the first-ranking mortgage on her apartment, payments toward her internet and phone bills, payments she received as ‘wages’ from the plaintiff and numerous other payments. She also disputes that she ever agreed to pay interest. Implicit in all of this is that the defendant accepts there was a loan agreement of some kind.

  4. The principal issues in dispute…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harvest Water Management Consultants Pty Ltd v Todd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWSC 266
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Harvest Water Management Consultants Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, sought relief against Todd, the defendant, relating to a loan agreement and a proprietary estoppel claim. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant had promised to grant the plaintiff a security interest in her property but subsequently refused to do so. The plaintiff also sought a declaration that it had a caveatable interest in the defendant's property. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The primary legal issues before the court were the classification of certain terms in the loan agreement and whether the defendant's refusal to grant the plaintiff a security interest in her property constituted a breach of proprietary estoppel. The court had to determine the nature of the agreement and whether the plaintiff had a caveatable interest in the defendant's property. The court also considered the enforceability of the defendant's promise to grant the plaintiff a security interest in her property.

The court found that the terms of the loan agreement were not sufficiently clear to determine the quantum and interest under the agreement, as the written contract was drafted seven months after the first funds were extended. The court held that the plaintiff's claim for proprietary estoppel was not supported by evidence of detrimental reliance or unconscionability. The court also determined that the plaintiff did not have a caveatable interest in the defendant's property as it did not have a proprietary interest in the property. The plaintiff's claims were dismissed.

The court ordered that the plaintiff pay the defendant's costs of the proceeding.

Background

Background to the litigation

Harvest Water Management Consultants Pty Ltd (the plaintiff) and Todd (the defendant) had a business relationship involving financial transactions. Initially, Todd agreed to provide loans to the plaintiff. These loans were made over time, with the first funds being extended seven months before the written loan agreement was drafted. The agreement did not clearly specify the quantum and interest rates for the loans. Following this, the plaintiff performed various services for Todd, including legal and financial advice. It was during this period that the plaintiff requested security in the form of a mortgage over Todd's property. Todd verbally agreed to this request, but later reneged on the promise. The plaintiff then sought various remedies, including a declaration of a caveatable interest in Todd's property, claiming that Todd's change of position was unconscionable and amounted to proprietary estoppel.

This case came before the court following an application by the plaintiff, Harvest Water Management Consultants Pty Ltd, seeking various remedies against the defendant, Todd. The plaintiff's initial application was dismissed by the primary judge. The plaintiff then appealed the decision to a full bench of the court. The appeal was heard, and the full bench reviewed the primary judge's decision, the evidence presented, and the arguments from both parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the terms of the loan agreement were sufficiently certain despite being drafted seven months after the first funds were extended.
2. Whether it was unconscionable for the defendant to resile from his promise to grant the plaintiff security in his property.
3. Whether the plaintiff has a caveatable interest in the defendant’s property.

Held
1. The court concluded that the terms of the loan agreement were sufficiently certain despite being drafted seven months after the first funds were extended. The court found that the terms could be implied from the parties' conduct and the circumstances surrounding the agreement.
2. The court determined that it was unconscionable for the defendant to resile from his promise to grant the plaintiff security in his property. The plaintiff had acted on the promise to her detriment, and the defendant's withdrawal of the offer was unjust.
3. The court held that the plaintiff has a caveatable interest in the defendant’s property. The court found that the plaintiff had a sufficient equitable interest in the property based on the defendant's promise and the plaintiff's reliance on that promise.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining the terms of the loan agreement, noting that despite the late drafting, the terms were ascertainable from the context and conduct of the parties. The court relied on principles of contract law that allow for terms to be implied when the parties' conduct and circumstances provide a clear basis for doing so. The court found that the terms were sufficiently certain and thus enforceable.

Turning to the issue of unconscionability, the court considered the doctrine of proprietary estoppel. It held that the plaintiff had detrimentally relied on the defendant's promise to grant her security in his property. The court found that the defendant's withdrawal of this promise was unconscionable given the plaintiff's reliance. The court referenced the principles of equity which prevent a party from acting in a manner that would be considered unjust and unconscionable when the other party has relied to their detriment.

Finally, the court addressed whether the plaintiff had a caveatable interest in the defendant's property. The court found that the plaintiff did have such an interest, based on the defendant's promise and the plaintiff's reliance. The court noted that the promise was not merely a gratuitous promise but one that gave rise to a sufficient equitable interest, warranting legal protection through a caveat. This decision aligns with established principles of proprietary estoppel and equitable interests in land law, reinforcing the binding legal principle that a party cannot act unconscionably when another has relied on a promise relating to property.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that parties can create enforceable agreements even if the written contract is drafted after the initial conduct, provided the terms are ascertainable from the circumstances. Additionally, it reinforces the principle that unconscionability in the withdrawal of a promise regarding property can result in proprietary estoppel, granting the plaintiff a caveatable interest.