Harris Scarfe Ltd (Receivers & Managers Appointed) (in Liq) v Ernst & Young (Reg)

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court: Application)

HARRIS SCARFE LTD (RECEIVERS & MANAGERS APPOINTED) (IN LIQ) AND ORS v ERNST & YOUNG (REG) AND ORS

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Justice Perry, The Honourable Justice Debelle and The Honourable Justice Sulan)

12 July 2005

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PRACTICE UNDER RULES OF COURT - PLEADINGS

The plaintiff company (in liquidation) alleged that as a result of negligent audits by the defendants, a firm of accountants, it had incurred losses by continuing to trade when it would otherwise have ceased trading – the defendants sought leave to appeal against an order of a single judge giving leave to the plaintiffs to file an amended statement of claim – the defendants contended that the proposed pleadings failed to disclose a causal connection between the trading losses and any wrongful conduct on the part of the defendants – consideration of the questions whether the proposed amended statement of claim would disclose a reasonable cause of action, had a tendency to cause prejudice, embarrassment or delay and whether it complied with the rules as to pleadings – held that the statement of claim disclosed an arguable cause of action – application for leave refused.

Supreme Court Rules r 46.18(a), r 46.18(b) and r 46.18(c); Fair Trading Act 1987 (SA) s 56; Supreme Court Act 1935 s 50(1a)(a)(ii), referred to.
Alexander and Ors v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd and Anor (1987) 9 NSWLR 310; Sew Hoy & Sons Ltd (In Receivership and In Liquidation) v Coopers & Lybrand (1996) 1 NZLR 392; Adam P Brown Male Fashions Pty Ltd v Philip Morris Inc (1981) 148 CLR 170; Doyle v Olby (Ironmongers) Ltd and Ors [1969] 2 QB 158; Gould and Anor v Vaggelas and Ors (1985) 157 CLR 215; Bateman and Anor v Slatyer and Ors (1987) 71 ALR 553; Galoo Ltd (In Liq) v Bright Grahame Murray [1994] 1 WLR 1360, considered.

HARRIS SCARFE LTD (RECEIVERS & MANAGERS APPOINTED) (IN LIQ) AND ORS v ERNST & YOUNG (REG) AND ORS
[2005] SASC 255

Full Court:  Perry, Debelle and Sulan JJ

  1. PERRY J. This is an application by the defendants for leave to appeal to the Full Court from the order of a single judge giving leave to the plaintiffs to file an amended statement of claim.

  2. When the plaintiffs applied for leave to amend the statement of claim, leave to amend was opposed by the first defendant on the ground that the proposed amended pleading would disclose no reasonable cause of action (SCR r 46.18(a)), and by the second and third defendants on the further ground that the amended pleading would have a tendency to cause prejudice, embarrassment or delay (SCR r 46.189(c)), and that it did not comply with the rules of pleading (SCR r 46.18(b)).

  3. Effectively, the argument presented by the defendants before the judge at first instance, was in the nature of a strike-out application. That…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Harris Scarfe Ltd (Receivers & Managers Appointed) (in Liq)... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 255
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved Harris Scarfe Ltd (Receivers & Managers Appointed) (in Liq) as the plaintiff and Ernst & Young (Reg) as the defendant. The plaintiff, Harris Scarfe, alleged that the defendant, Ernst & Young, had incurred losses by continuing to trade negligently audited financial statements. The plaintiff sought damages for the losses sustained from the time the true financial position should have been revealed until the assets were realized. The defendants, Ernst & Young, sought leave to appeal against an order that allowed the plaintiffs to file an amended statement of claim. The defendants argued that the proposed pleadings failed to establish a causal connection between the trading losses and any wrongful conduct by the defendants.

The legal issues that the court needed to decide included whether the proposed amended statement of claim would disclose a reasonable cause of action, whether it had a tendency to cause prejudice, embarrassment or delay, and whether it complied with the rules as to pleadings. The court had to consider the precedent set by the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales in Alexander and Ors v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd and Anor. The court had to determine whether the pleadings sufficiently demonstrated a causal link between the defendants' alleged negligence and the plaintiffs' losses.

The court held that the statement of claim disclosed an arguable cause of action. The court found that the proposed pleadings sufficiently established a causal connection between the trading losses and the defendants' alleged wrongful conduct. The court held that the pleadings complied with the rules and did not have a tendency to cause prejudice, embarrassment, or delay. The court held that the defendants' arguments were not persuasive, and the application for leave to appeal was refused.

The final orders of the court were that the plaintiffs be heard on the appeal, and the application for leave to appeal was dismissed. The court found that the amended statement of claim disclosed an arguable cause of action and that the defendants' arguments were not persuasive. The court held that the pleadings complied with the rules and did not have a tendency to cause prejudice, embarrassment, or delay.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The court directed that the plaintiffs be heard on the appeal.Background The first three plaintiffs, whom I will call collectively “Harris Scarfe”, and the fourth plaintiff, ANZ Banking Group Ltd (“ANZ”), claim damages from the defendants, who are three firms of chartered accountants, with respect to various losses said to have been incurred in consequence of the preparation by the defendants of half-yearly reviews and audits of Harris Scarfe for the period between the year ended 31 July 1996 and 31 July 1999. The reviews and audits were said to have been prepared negligently, in breach of a contractual duty of care and in circumstances amounting to misleading conduct in breach of s 56 of the Fair Trading Act 1987 (SA). The plaintiffs allege that in the preparation of the various reviews and audits, the defendants failed to detect that senior management of Harris Scarfe had fraudulently manipulated the accounts so as to show substantial operating profits, whereas in reality throughout the relevant period the group had sustained significant losses. Likewise, the net assets of Harris Scarfe were substantially overstated and liabilities understated. In essence, the case pleaded by Harris Scarfe is that in reliance upon the reviews and audits conducted by the defendants, they continued to trade in the manner in which they had previously traded, which included the implementation of a policy of expansion of the business by acquisition or opening of new stores, whereas if the parlous financial position of Harris Scarfe had been laid bare at the beginning of the period, a controller would have been appointed and there would have been an orderly realisation of Harris Scarfe’s then assets. A controller was in fact appointed in April 2001, by which time the net asset position of Harris Scarfe had substantially deteriorated. As it was summarised by the judge at first instance:What is claimed by way of damages is in effect the total trading losses sustained by Harris Scarfe from the date when the true position ought to have been revealed until the time when it was in fact revealed a controller was appointed and the assets were in fact realised. The claim of ANZ is predicated upon the assertion that if they had known the true position at the outset of the period in question, they would not have made various loans which were advanced to Harris Scarfe during that period. ANZ alleges that it suffered loss and damage being the shortfall in the recovery of moneys owed to it by Harris Scarfe on the ultimate realisation of the assets of Harris Scarfe.The application On the hearing of the application for leave to appeal, the defendants effectively repeated the arguments which they had put unsuccessfully to the judge at first instance. In doing so, they relied heavily upon the decision of the Full Court of the Supreme Court of New South Wales in Alexander and Ors v Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd and Anor[4] which they contended was indistinguishable from the present case.[4] (1987) 9 NSWLR 310.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

PERRY J DEBELLE J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PERRY J, DEBELLE J