Hansch v Transport Workers' Union of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hansch v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia [2000] FCA 473

INDUSTRIAL LAW - registered organisation - branches - whether valid application for an election inquiry before the Court - whether invalidity in a branch election - whether failure to hold an election due constitutes such an invalidity - doctrine of “holding over”

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) ss218, 219, 258, 259

Bramich v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia (1999) 89 IR 30, [1999] FCA 510 cited

Bramich v Transport Workers Union of Australia [2000] FCA 135 cited

Australian Electoral Commission v Hickson & Ors (1997) 76 IR 399 applied

McLure v Mitchell & Anor (1974) 24 FLR 115 cited

Allshorn v Stapleton & Ors (1984) 4 FCR 236 cited

Grove v Cameron & Ors (1972) 21 FLR 59 followed

Re Gill (Gray J, 4 September 1984, unreported) followed

Re Australian Glass Workers’ Union (1973) 22 FLR 17 followed

Re Professional Radio and Electronics’ Institute of Australasia [1980] Ind Arb Service, Current Review, 169 followed

Jess v Scott & Ors (1986) 14 IR 341 referred to

Porter & Anor v Davis & Ors (1989) 32 IR 110 followed

Morris & Ors v O’Grady & Ors (1991) 37 IR 196 cited

BARRY HANSCH, SEAN SCOTT LAWRENCE AND GARRY JOHN FISHER v TRANSPORT WORKERS’ UNION OF AUSTRALIA AND OTHERS

T2 OF 2000

MARSHALL J
MELBOURNE (HEARD IN HOBART)
6 APRIL 2000

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

TASMANIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

T2 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

BARRY HANSCH
FIRST APPLICANT

SEAN SCOTT LAWRENCE
SECOND APPLICANT

GARRY JOHN FISHER
THIRD APPLICANT

AND:

TRANSPORT WORKERS' UNION OF AUSTRALIA, WILLIAM GEORGE NOONAN, HUGHIE JOHN WILLIAMS, ROBERT JOHN ALLAN, RICHARD DONALD MARLES, BRIAN JOHN McINTOSH, REGINALD WEARING, WAYNE MADER, TREVOR PAUL SANTI, ANTHONY SHELDON, ALASTAIR LYALL, DON CLODE, GEORGE CLARKE, JOHN MORRISON, MARK ANDREW WALKER, RONALD JAMES PORTER, ALEXANDER McEACHIAN GALLACHER, DOUG FROHER, RUSSELL PAUL WORTLEY, HOWARD SMITH, MICHAEL NEALER, JAMES McGIVERON, JOHN RAMSELL, GLENN STERLE
RESPONDENTS

JUDGE:

MARSHALL J

DATE OF ORDER:

30 MARCH 2000

WHERE MADE:

HOBART

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Orders 1 and 2 of orders of the Court made on 23 March 2000 be set aside.

2.The Directions Hearing in the proceeding be adjourned to 9.30 am on Thursday 6 April 2000.

Note:    Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

TASMANIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

T2 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

BARRY HANSCH
FIRST APPLICANT

SEAN SCOTT LAWRENCE
SECOND APPLICANT

GARRY JOHN FISHER
THIRD APPLICANT

AND:

TRANSPORT WORKERS' UNION OF AUSTRALIA, WILLIAM GEORGE NOONAN, HUGHIE JOHN WILLIAMS, ROBERT JOHN ALLAN, RICHARD DONALD MARLES, BRIAN JOHN McINTOSH, REGINALD WEARING, WAYNE MADER, TREVOR PAUL SANTI, ANTHONY SHELDON, ALASTAIR LYALL, DON CLODE, GEORGE CLARKE, JOHN MORRISON, MARK ANDREW WALKER, RONALD JAMES PORTER, ALEXANDER McEACHIAN GALLACHER, DOUG FROHER, RUSSELL PAUL WORTLEY, HOWARD SMITH, MICHAEL NEALER, JAMES McGIVERON, JOHN RAMSELL, GLENN STERLE
RESPONDENTS

JUDGE:

MARSHALL J

DATE:

6 APRIL 2000

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR INTERLOCUTORY JUDGMENT

  1. On 17 March 2000 the applicants filed, in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hansch v Transport Workers' Union of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 473
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Hansch v Transport Workers' Union of Australia involves members of the Transport Workers’ Union of Australia in its Tasmanian branch, seeking relief against the union and its Federal Council. The applicants are challenging the union’s decision to disband the Tasmanian branch and the subsequent method of representation. The legal issues at the heart of the dispute centre on the validity of the union's rules and resolutions concerning the disbandment of the branch and the method of representation for its members. Specifically, the court needed to determine whether the union's actions complied with the provisions of the relevant Act and the union's own rules.

The Federal Court considered the statutory framework and the union's rules to assess the legitimacy of the Federal Council's resolutions. The court found that while the Federal Council had the authority to disband the branch under certain circumstances, the method of representation provided by Rule 23(3) was impermissible. Consequently, the court set aside parts of the interim relief previously granted, emphasizing the need for adherence to proper legal procedures for any future inquiries into union elections. The court highlighted the importance of following the correct procedural steps as outlined in the Act and the regulations to ensure that any election inquiry is valid and that the parties are duly notified. The orders of the court reflect the need for compliance with these legal requirements moving forward.

The final orders of the court included setting aside the interim relief granted on 23 March 2000 and directing that the directions hearing be rescheduled for a later date. This decision underscores the necessity for strict adherence to legal processes and the importance of ensuring that any inquiry into union elections is conducted in accordance with the law. The court's ruling aimed to provide clarity and direction for the parties involved, ensuring that future actions comply with the legal framework governing union activities.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Orders 1 and 2 of orders of the Court made on 23 March 2000 be set aside.

2. The Directions Hearing in the proceeding be adjourned to 9.30 am on Thursday 6 April 2000.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 30 March 2000 I heard an application by the applicants to extend the interim relief which was granted on 23 March 2000. I refused to do so and ordered that that part of the order of Heerey J of 23 March 2000 which is quoted above be set aside. What follows are my reasons for making that order.Factual background The applicants are members of the Transport Workers’ Union of Australia (“the TWU”) in its Tasmanian branch (“the branch”). The respondents are the TWU itself and certain of its officers who comprise the Federal Council of the TWU (“the Federal Council”). On 6 July 1998 the Federal Council resolved to disband the branch and provide for representation by persons formerly attached to it “directly by Federal Council”. That method of representation was purportedly permitted by Rule 23(3) of the registered rules of the TWU (“the rules”). On 9 April 1999 I discharged a rule to show cause which I had previously granted. The rule to show cause sought to impugn the resolution of 6 July 1998. See Bramich v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia (1999) 89 IR 30, [1999] FCA 510. An appeal from my judgment succeeded on the narrow point that Rule 23(3) of the rules was invalid as contrary to s196(c) of the Act. See Bramich v Transport Workers Union of Australia [2000] FCA 135. The judgment of the Full Court was delivered on 21 February 2000. The effect of the Full Court’s judgment in Bramich was that the Federal Council was still empowered to disband any of its branches in the specified circumstances referred to in Rule 23(1) of the rules but that the method of representation provided by Rule 23(3) was impermissible. On 6 March 2000 the Federal Council resolved, inter alia:“…to hold a further special meeting of Federal Council on 27 March 2000 to consider whether or not to resolve that the Tasmanian Branch has effectively ceased to function and ought therefore be disbanded pursuant to Rule 23(1)(e) of the Rules and if so:(a)whether or not the Affected Members of the Tasmanian Branch should be attached to the Victorian Branch pursuant to Rule 23(4) of the Rules; and(b)whether or not the Victorian Branch of the Union should be re-named the “Victorian/Tasmanian” Branch pursuant to Rule 23(5)(d) of the Rules …” On 14 March 2000 a solicitor acting for the applicants became aware of the foreshadowed meeting of the Federal Council for 27 March 2000. Shortly thereafter the application in this proceeding was filed.No valid election inquiry At the commencement of the hearing on 30 March 2000 I raised with Mr Green, the solicitor for the applicants, whether any order had been made by a Judge of the Court pursuant to s219(b) of the Act that there is reasonable ground for the application. An examination of the transcript of the hearing before Heerey J on 23 March 2000 reveals that no such order was made. An order under s219(b) of the Act is required before an election inquiry can be said to have been instituted. This issue was thoroughly canvassed by Northrop ACJ in Australian Electoral Commission v Hickson & Ors (1997) 76 IR 399 at 404-405 where his Honour said:“Section 218 of the Act enables a person, being a member of an organisation who claims that there has been an irregularity in relation to an election for an office in an organisation, to make an application for an inquiry by the Court into the matter. In this section, the word “irregularity” is to be given its ordinary meaning but by definition contained in s 4 of the Act, “irregularity” includes, among other meanings, “a breach of the rules of an organisation”. In the present case, the Returning Officer is under a duty to comply with the Rules of the AMWU. If he wrongfully rejected a valid nomination, that action could constitute an irregularity within the inclusive meaning of that word in the Act. Likewise, if he wrongfully accepted an invalid nomination, that action could constitute an irregularity. This aspect will be mentioned further later in these reasons. Likewise, if he wrongfully declared a candidate elected unopposed, that action could constitute an irregularity.Section 219 of the Act is of importance. The section prescribes the method by which an application for an inquiry is to be instituted. On one view, no valid inquiry was instituted by Mr Hickson. Section 219 is set out:“219. Where:(a)an application for an inquiry has been lodged with the Court under section 218; and(b)the Court is satisfied that there is reasonable ground for the application;the Court shall fix a time and place for conducting the inquiry, and may give such directions as it considers necessary to ensure that all persons who are or may be justly entitled to appear at the inquiry are notified of the time and place fixed and, where the Court fixes a time and place, the inquiry shall be taken to have been instituted.”It is noted that an inquiry is instituted after the Court is satisfied there is reasonable ground for the application. This requirement is designed to prevent spurious applications. It is noted that the Court determines who should be given notice of the application.At the time the application in this case was issued on 1 April 1997, O 48 of the Industrial Relations Court Rules (Cth) regulated the procedures to be followed with respect to inquiries under, among other provisions, s 218 of the Act. Order 48, r 2 provided that applications under s 218 were to be in accordance with the form prescribed by reg 62 of the Industrial Relations Regulations, now called the Workplace Relations Regulations. They are in the same form. Regulation 62 imposes time limits on the commencement of applications for an inquiry under s 218 and provides that the application shall be in accordance with Form 4 of the Regulations and shall be accompanied by a statutory declaration made by the applicant verifying the facts set out in the application. Form 4 is not a Court document. It does not specify the naming of parties. It requires the applicant to be named and certain other information to be included. It is a document to be put before the Court to enable the Court to determine whether an application for an inquiry under s 218 should be instituted. In the present case, no application under reg 62 or Form 4 was made. No statutory declaration or affidavit was made. The Court did not fix a time and place for conducting the inquiry. The Court did not give directions to ensure all persons who were or may have been justly entitled to appear at the inquiry be given notice of the inquiry.In the present case, an application for an inquiry dated 1 April 1997 was issued on 4 April in the Industrial Relations Court of Australia, but has been transferred to the Federal Court. This application was a Court document issued in conformity with O 4 and Form 5 of the Court Rules. It named Mr Hickson as applicant and Mr Jones and Mr Bastian as respondents. It gave notice that a directions hearing on the application would be heard by the Court on 10 April 1997 and that if the respondents did not appear judgment might be given in their absence.The Court does not take any action on this matter. It was a procedure which hindered the proper consideration of the application and to some extent led to confusion. It is important that the proper procedures for an election inquiry should be followed. The procedures could affect the entitlement of an application for costs to be paid by the Commonwealth. Reference should be made to the Act for provisions relating to costs of an inquiry into an election. Generally see s 342 and in particular s 342(1), (2)(d) and (f) and s 343(1). In addition ss 346 and 347 may be relevant.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MARSHALL J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MARSHALL J