Hansch v Transport Workers' Union of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hansch v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia [2000] FCA 1266

INDUSTRIAL LAW - rule to show cause calling upon the respondents to show why the Court should not order that a resolution of the Federal Council of the firstnamed respondent of 31 March 2000 disbanding the Tasmanian Branch of the firstnamed respondent is null and void and that the firstnamed respondent be restrained from taking any steps to disband the Tasmanian Branch - whether sufficient notice had been given to members and office holders of the Tasmanian Branch of the disbandment of the Tasmanian Branch - whether, at the time of the resolution of the Federal Council disbanding the Tasmanian Branch, the Tasmanian Branch had “effectively ceased to function”- whether the question of whether the Tasmanian Branch had “effectively ceased to function” is governed by theoretical considerations of the operation of the rules of the firstnamed respondent or the practical reality facing the Tasmanian Branch including its financial viability, or lack thereof - whether, at the time of the Federal Council resolution disbanding the Tasmanian Branch, the Tasmanian Branch was financially viable.

BIAS - whether invincible bias of Federal Councillors vitiated the resolution of Federal Council disbanding the Tasmanian Branch.

CLAIM IN ACCRUED JURISDICTION OF COURT FOR PAYMENT OF ARREARS - whether the firstnamed respondent owes the firstnamed applicant payment for arrears of wages and superannuation.

Workplace Relations Act 1996 (Cth) ss208, 209, 218, 258, 259

Bramich v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia (1999) 89 IR 30, [1999] FCA 510 referred to

Bramich v Transport Workers Union of Australia (2000) 97 FCR 204, [2000] FCA 135 applied

Hansch v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia [2000] FCA 473 referred to

Re Keely; Ex parte Kingham (1995) 129 ALR 255 followed

Tanner v Maynes (1985) 7 FCR 432 applied

Cains v Jenkins (1979) 42 FLR 188 applied

Nelson v Nelson (1995) 184 CLR 538 distinguished

Stollery v The Greyhound Racing Control Board (1972) 128 CLR 509 distinguished

Allen v Townsend (1977) 31 FLR 431 distinguished

Re McGee (1992) 41 IR 27 referred to

Hansch v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia (1998) 85 IR 310 referred to

Automatic Fire Sprinklers Pty Ltd v Watson (1946) 72 CLR 435 applied

BARRY HANSCH, SEAN SCOTT LAWRENCE and GARRY JOHN FISHER -v- TRANSPORT WORKERS’ UNION OF AUSTRALIA and OTHERS

T 5 of 2000

MARSHALL J
MELBOURNE (HEARD IN HOBART)
15 SEPTEMBER 2000

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

TASMANIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

T 5 of 2000

BETWEEN:

BARRY HANSCH
FIRST APPLICANT

SEAN SCOTT LAWRENCE
SECOND APPLICANT

GARRY JOHN FISHER
THIRD APPLICANT

AND:

TRANSPORT WORKERS' UNION OF AUSTRALIA, WILLIAM GEORGE NOONAN, HUGHIE JOHN WILLIAMS, ROBERT JOHN ALLAN, RICHARD DONALD MARLES, BRIAN JOHN McINTOSH, REGINALD WEARING, WAYNE MADER, TREVOR PAUL SANTI, ANTHONY SHELDON, ALASTAIR LYALL, DON CLODE, GEORGE CLARKE, JOHN MORRISON, MARK ANDREW WALKER, RONALD JAMES PORTER, ALEXANDER McEACHIAN GALLACHER, DOUG FROHER, RUSSELL PAUL WORTLEY, HOWARD SMITH, MICHAEL NEALER, JAMES McGIVERON, JOHN RAMSELL and GLENN STERLE
RESPONDENTS

JUDGE:

MARSHALL J

DATE OF ORDER:

15…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hansch v Transport Workers' Union of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 1266
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hansch v Transport Workers' Union of Australia, the applicants, members of the Transport Workers’ Union of Australia, challenged the decisions of the Union's Federal Council, including the disbandment of the Tasmanian Branch. The Union's actions were taken in response to financial difficulties and a court order from an earlier proceeding. The applicants sought various orders to set aside the decisions made by the Union's Federal Council, including the disbandment of the Tasmanian Branch and the subsequent non-payment of certain monies owed to the first applicant, Mr Hansch.

The primary legal issues the court had to address were whether the disbandment of the Tasmanian Branch and the subsequent non-payment of certain monies to Mr Hansch were valid and lawful decisions made by the Union's Federal Council. Additionally, the court had to determine if there was any bias or procedural unfairness in the decision-making process. The applicants argued that the decisions were made hastily and without proper consideration, while the Union maintained that the decisions were necessary and appropriate given the financial and operational difficulties faced by the Tasmanian Branch.

The court found that there was no evidence of bias or procedural unfairness in the decision-making process by the Union's Federal Council. The court held that the Union acted promptly but appropriately in light of the Full Court's judgment and the financial difficulties faced by the Tasmanian Branch. The disbandment of the Tasmanian Branch was deemed necessary to prevent further financial loss and to ensure the Union could continue to provide services to its members. Regarding the non-payment of certain monies, the court ordered the Union to pay Mr Hansch the sum of $4,272.84 within 21 days of the making of this order, reflecting his superannuation entitlements.

In conclusion, the court discharged paragraphs 1 and 2 of the rule to show cause, finding no basis for the applicants' claims. The court also discharged paragraph 4 of the rule to show cause, subject to further order, and ordered the Union to pay Mr Hansch the sum of $4,272.84 within 21 days of the making of this order.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Paragraphs 1 and 2 of the rule to show cause granted on 26 April 2000 be discharged.

2. On the expiry of 21 days after the date of this order and subject to further order, paragraph 4 of the rule to show cause be discharged.

3. In the accrued jurisdiction of the Court, it is ordered that the first respondent pay to the TWU Superannuation Fund on behalf of the first applicant, the sum of $4,272.84 within 21 days of the making of this order.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 11 May 2000, the Court ordered by consent, inter alia, that:“The hearing in this proceeding on 1 August 2000 be confined to the relief sought in paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of the Rule to Show Cause dated 26 April 2000.”Background facts The applicants are members of the first respondent, the Transport Workers’ Union of Australia (“the Union”). The remaining respondents comprise the Federal Council of the Union. The second respondent, Mr Noonan, is the Secretary of the Victorian/Tasmanian Branch of the Union. The fourth respondent, Mr Allan, is the Federal Secretary of the Union. The first applicant, Mr Hansch, was elected to the office of Branch Organiser in the Tasmanian Branch of the Union on 8 March 1995. On 4 July 1998, the Branch Committee of Management of the Tasmanian Branch of the Union (“the Branch Committee of Management”) resolved as follows:“The Tasmanian Branch Committee of Management having heard reports from K. Bacon, Branch Secretary and W. Noonan, Federal Vice President on Branch finances, recognises that maintaining existing Branch structure is impossible. The B.C.O.M. resolves to:-1.Direct the Branch Secretary to reduce staffing by four with the retrenchment of J. Austin, J. Gill, T. Bacon and V. Bushing, effective 31st July 1998, with redundancy payments to total $26,908.00 in addition to annual leave and other entitlements.2.Acknowledge that the current cash flow situation does not allow the Branch to meet ongoing liabilities and continue to provide services to the membership; accordingly the Branch has effectively ceased to function.3.Recommends that the Federal Council immediately review the Branch’s continued operations in accordance with Rule 23(1)(e).4.Calls upon the Federal Secretary to develop a business plan and budget that will provide an adequate level of service to the membership in Tasmania.” At the request of the then Tasmanian Branch Secretary, Mr K Bacon, Mr Allan was present at the meeting on 4 July 1998 in his capacity as Federal Secretary. Mr Allan gave evidence that his purpose in coming to Tasmania at that time “was to have a meeting with the then Branch Committee of Management and be advised on the current situation of the Branch”. Mr Noonan was then the Federal Vice President of the Union and attended the meeting due to the unavailability of the then Federal President. Prior to 4 July 1998, Mr Bacon had made Mr Allan aware “that the branch was in a difficult financial situation and something had to be done”. Mr Allan further stated that he was aware before 4 July 1998 “that the financial situation in Tasmania was in a state that effectively was bankrupt and action had to be taken but the Branch Committee of Management had to make their own decision”. Mr Allan was also of the view that the Tasmanian operations of the Union were unable to be carried out by the Tasmanian Branch without assistance from the Federal Office of the Union. He believed that the Branch Committee of Management had no alternative but to request that the Tasmanian Branch be disbanded.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

MARSHALL J
Mr Green also attacked the resolution of 31 March 2000 to disband the Tasmanian Branch because it was made too quickly. He cited no authority to support that submission. Although it was not clear from his submissions, this appeared to be another alleged manifestation of bias, it would seem not just in Mr Noonan and Mr Allan, but in the whole Federal Council. This submission of Mr Green is misplaced. The Union went to great lengths to put the issue before its Tasmanian membership as soon as it received legal advice on the effect of the Full Court’s judgment. It acted promptly but appropriately in the circumstances to remedy the practical difficulties which flowed from the Full Court’s order. I address those difficulties separately in the judgment on the validation issue, being a judgment also delivered this day.Conclusion on paragraphs 1 and 2 of the Rule to Show Cause It follows from the above analysis that there is no basis on what has been advanced by the applicants, upon which paragraphs 1 and 2 of the rule to show cause can be made absolute. Accordingly, I will order that each such paragraph of the rule to show cause be discharged. There was no debate on paragraph 4 of the rule to show cause as it was agreed to reserve consideration of that issue until a later occasion if necessary. I see no basis upon which that paragraph of the rule to show cause can be sustained if paragraphs 1 and 2 are discharged. I am prepared to also discharge that paragraph of the rule but will not make the order operable for a period of 21 days after the delivery of reasons for judgment so that any contrary submission may be advanced in writing in the interim. Any issue on that matter, if it arises, can be dealt with by the duty Judge or list Judge in Melbourne during my imminent leave. On reflection, paragraph 3 of the rule to show cause should not have formed part of the rule to show cause but should have been noted as an order which was sought in the accrued jurisdiction of the Court. That is because it is not an order which requires performance and observance of any rules of the Union. I will now turn to the question whether any such order should be made and if so, its contents.The claim in the accrued jurisdiction The applicants applied for an order in the accrued jurisdiction of the Court that the Union pay Mr Hansch the sum of $56,981.12 and pay to the “TWU Super Fund” (sic), on behalf of Mr Hansch, the sum of $13,311.54. That claim is calculated in the following way:· 7 September 1998 to 31 March 2000 = 81 weeks salary at $1,160.88 per week, leaving a sum which Mr Green contended to be $94, 193.28 but which is actually $94, 031.28.· From $94, 031.28 is deducted a sum of $37,212.60 being the amount of severance pay ordered by the Commission and conceded by Mr Green to be properly deducted from any award of damages flowing to Mr Hansch.· Superannuation entitlements are based on a $164.34 weekly entitlement multiplied by 81 weeks. After the 6 July 1998 resolution of Federal Council, Mr Hansch was granted a rule to show cause on 10 July 1998 in which, inter alia, he challenged the bona fides of that resolution. That aspect of the rule to show cause was discharged in a judgment of the Court delivered on 6 August 1998. See Hansch v Transport Workers’ Union of Australia (1998) 85 IR 310 at 312-313. The Court also rejected a submission that Mr Hansch’s office survived the disbandment. At 314 the Court said:“The applicant holds no such office. The current situation is that he is employed pursuant to a duty statement dated 1 July 1998 by the federal organisation and is directed through Federal Council to perform enumerated duties as an organiser. The applicant is in such employment. It was the evidence of Mr Allan, subject to further legal advice, that such employment would continue if the appeal from Ryan J’s judgment was dismissed and again, subject to further legal advice, such employment would in any case be terminated in the event that the appeal was upheld. Those matters are not particularly germane to this judgment but I mention them in the context of determining the current status of the applicant in the context of his position vis-à-vis members of the organisation who reside in Tasmania, particularly in the southern region.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MARSHALL J