Hanna v Minister for Health

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hanna v Minister for Health [2013] FCA 303

Citation: Hanna v Minister for Health [2013] FCA 303
Parties: BISHOY HANNA, BISHOY HABIL, MAGGIE ROUCHDI and CHRISTEEN SEIDHOM v MINISTER FOR HEALTH
File number(s): NSD 1486 of 2012
Judge: JAGOT J
Date of judgment: 5 April 2013
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - judicial review – Minister’s decision not to approve pharmacy – decision process under National Health Act – discretion – irrelevant considerations – procedural fairness
Legislation:

Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth)
Guidelines for Ministerial Discretion June 2006
Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth)
National Health Act 1953 (Cth)

National Health (Australian Community Pharmacy Authority Rules) Determination 2006

Cases cited:

Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321; 1990 HCA 33
Commissioner for ACT Revenue v Alphaone Pty Ltd (1994) 49 FCR 576
Kioa v West (1985) 159 CLR 550; [1985] HCA 81
Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24; [1986] HCA 40
Parramatta City Council v Pestell (1972) 128 CLR 305
Plaintiff M61/2010E v Commonwealth of Australia; Plaintiff M69 of 2010 v Commonwealth of Australia (2010) 243 CLR 319; [2010] HCA 41
Plaintiff S10/2011 v Minister for Immigration and Citizenship (2012) 290 ALR 616; [2012] HCA 31
Re Brian Lawlor Automotive Pty Ltd & Collector of Customs (1978) 1 ALD 167
Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Miah  (2001) 206 CLR 57; [2001] HCA 22

Yu v Minister for Health [2013] FCA 261

Date of hearing: 2 April 2013
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 65
Counsel for the Applicants: P Menzies QC with B Nolan
Solicitor for the Applicants: Allsop Glover
Counsel for the Respondent: M Allars
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1486 of 2012

BETWEEN:

BISHOY HANNA
First Appellant

BISHOY HABIL
Second Appellant

MAGGIE ROUCHDI
Third Appellant

CHRISTEEN SEIDHOM
Fourth Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR HEALTH
Respondent

JUDGE:

JAGOT J

DATE OF ORDER:

5 APRIL 2012

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The originating application as amended be dismissed.

2.The applicants pay the respondent’s costs of the proceeding, as agreed or taxed.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1486 of 2012

BETWEEN:

BISHOY HANNA
First Appellant

BISHOY HABIL
Second Appellant

MAGGIE ROUCHDI
Third Appellant

CHRISTEEN SEIDHOM
Fourth Appellant

AND:

MINISTER FOR HEALTH
Respondent

JUDGE:

JAGOT J

DATE:

5 APRIL 2012

PLACE:

SYDNEY

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

THE PROCEEDING

  1. This proceeding concerns the capacity to review and, if reviewable, the validity of a decision or decisions of the Minister for Health under ss 90A and/or 90B of the National Health Act 1953 (Cth) (the National Health Act), as well as the question of the relief, if any, which may or should be granted in the circumstances.

  2. Sections 90A…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hanna v Minister for Health and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 303
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hanna v Minister for Health, the applicants sought judicial review of a decision by the Minister for Health not to consider their application for ministerial approval to supply pharmaceutical benefits at a proposed pharmacy. The applicants argued that the Minister had made an error in her decision-making process, both in terms of jurisdictional error and by considering irrelevant matters. The Minister contended that the decision was not subject to judicial review due to its discretionary and non-compellable nature, and that any consideration of the application of the Rules and the views of the Pharmacy Guild of Australia were not irrelevant.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the Minister's decision not to consider the applicants' request was subject to judicial review under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth). The court held that the decision was a final and substantive one, with a direct practical impact on the applicants, and therefore subject to judicial review. The court further found that the Minister's consideration of the application of the Rules and the views of the Pharmacy Guild of Australia were not irrelevant, as nothing in the subject-matter, scope, and purpose of the statute suggested that the Minister was prohibited from having regard to these matters when exercising a power under the National Health Act.

The court dismissed the applicants' claims and ordered that the originating application be dismissed, with the applicants to pay the respondent's costs of the proceeding. The decision highlights the importance of considering relevant factors in the decision-making process and the role of the court in reviewing such decisions to ensure they are made in accordance with the relevant statutory provisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The originating application as amended be dismissed.

2. The applicants pay the respondent’s costs of the proceeding, as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

To understand how this confusion arises in the present case it is necessary to make findings of fact and I turn now to the documents evidencing the decision-making process. THE FACTS On the face of things at least, the Minister made a single decision on 14 July 2012. On that day the Minister signed a document which had two options below the place for her signature, being:R1 AGREE NOT TO CONSIDER DECIDE TO CONSIDER The statement “R1 AGREE NOT TO CONSIDER” is circled. Above the Minister’s signature appears a recommendation in these terms:RECOMMENDATIONR1 That you AGREE NOT TO CONSIDER this request…to exercise your discretionary power under section 90A… It might be thought from this that the Minister decided on 14 July 2012 not to consider the applicants’ request. This is the position of the Minister. The applicants contend to the contrary. They rely on the paper to which the recommendation was attached which was put before the Minister and a subsequent statement of reasons under s 13 of the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) (the ADJR Act), as well as the letter notifying the applicants of the decision. The paper which was put before the Minister includes the following information before the recommendation page which the Minister signed as set out above.STAGE 1 – MINISTERIAL DISCRETION REQUEST PURPOSE: For your decision as to whether or not you will agree to consider a request to exercise your discretionary power under section 90A of the National Health Act 1953 (the Act) to approve a pharmacy to supply pharmaceutical benefits at … .…Legislative Power9. When the delegate’s decision, on a recommendation from the Authority, is to reject an application, you have the discretion to override that decision and approve the application, particularly in circumstances where there is an unintended consequence of the Rules. However, the Act only permits you to exercise this discretion if you are satisfied that:1. the delegate’s decision will result in a community being left without reasonable access to pharmaceutical benefits supplied by an approved pharmacist; and2. it is in the public interest to approve the pharmacists to supply pharmaceutical benefits.Stage 1 decision10. If you decide to consider the request, you will then have a further three months in which to decide whether or not to exercise your discretion to approve a pharmacy (Stage 2 decision). An extract from the Guidelines for Ministerial Discretion (the Guidelines), including a flow chart setting out the process for exercising your discretion under the Act is at Attachment D.Factors that you may consider11. You may take a range of factors into account in deciding whether a community has reasonable access to the supply of pharmaceutical benefits by an approved pharmacist and if it is in the public interest to approve the application. These factors include the objectives of the Rules, the reason(s) the application did not meet the criteria of the Rules, the relevant community’s characteristics, current level of access and any other factors you consider relevant.….15. On 27 April 2012, the Department received a valid request from the pharmacists, seeking that you exercise your discretion and approve the proposed premises at … NSW.16.The key factors supporting the pharmacists’ request are:a.the proposed pharmacy has been trading since December 2010;b.the proposed pharmacy is located directly across the road from Canterbury Hospital, an after-hours GP clinic and Canterbury Dental Centre;c.some patients of the after-hours GP clinic (based in the Canterbury Hospital), will not have access to an approved pharmacy upon leaving the clinic;d.the proposed pharmacy provides the longest trading hours of all pharmacies in the Campsie community, providing services until 1.00am; ande.a pharmacy has traded on or near the site of the proposed pharmacy for approximately 54 years.17. In considering whether the community of Campsie will be left without reasonable access to pharmaceutical benefits supplied by an approved pharmacist; and approving the application is in the public interest, these factors need to be balanced against the counter arguments of:a.the nearest approved pharmacy to the proposed premises is Bassam’s Pharmacy… Campsie, which is approximately 477 metres north east of the proposed premises by straight line (see Attachment F);b.there are 13 approved pharmacies within 1.5 km (by straight line) of the proposed premises (nine within 1 km) (see Attachment E), with some of these trading for extended hours, weekends and public holidays. Two are open until 10.00pm, seven days per week;c.there are no physical barriers between the proposed premises and any of the nearby existing approved pharmacies;d.the previous pharmacy approval at the same location was relocated under Rule 106: Long Distance Relocation, in November 2009;e.the after-hours GP clinic based in the Canterbury Hospital closes at 10.30pm, Monday to Friday and 10.00pm on Saturday and Sunday, which means that only a small number of patients would not have access to an approved pharmacy upon leaving the clinic;f.the patients of the Canterbury Hospital would be supplied with pharmaceuticals as per the usual arrangements for Public Hospitals, i.e. the state government is responsible for the provision of pharmaceuticals to patients in the hospital.18. The pharmacists have claimed that the proposed pharmacy provides the longest trading hours of all pharmacies in the local Campsie community, providing services until 1.00am. Research by the Department has found that the proposed pharmacy currently trades from 12.00 noon until 1.00am, seven days a week.19. In taking all the above information into consideration, the Department considers that the pharmacists have not provided a sufficiently convincing case for you to consider exercising your discretionary power to approve them to supply pharmaceutical benefits from … NSW. The Department’s detailed summary of the facts and evidence of this request is presented at Attachment B.20. The Department considers that there is no unintended consequence of the application of the (previous) Rules in this case, and the delegate’s rejection of the pharmacists’ original application will not leave the community of Campsie without reasonable access to pharmaceutical benefits.21. The Department considers that the residents of Campsie have reasonable access to the supply of PBS medicine through the 13 existing pharmacies within 1.5 km of the proposed premises (as identified on the map at Attachment E).22. Comments from nearby pharmacists provided to the Authority at the time of the pharmacists’ original application are at Attachment G which in short claimed that the proposed premises were not at least 1.5 km from the nearest approved pharmacy.23. The Department has also received information from a surrounding pharmacist claiming that the owners of the proposed pharmacy are processing PBS prescriptions from their approved pharmacy in Bellevue Hill, for PBS medicines supplied from the proposed pharmacy (Attachment G). This information has been forwarded to the Department of Human Services (Medicare) for investigation.24. If you decide not to consider the request, the decision made by the delegate to not approve the application under the Act will stand.25. The pharmacists and affected third parties may be entitled to request a Statement of Reasons for your decision. If the stated reasons for your decision do not satisfy the parties, they may choose to exercise further legal options such as making an application under the Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (AD (JR) Act) for a review of your decision by the Federal Court.26. An application for a new pharmacy under the amended Rules that commenced on 18 October 2011 would be unlikely to succeed as the 1.5 km distance criteria was retained for the equivalent new pharmacy Rule (Rule 130).Sensitivity27. The Pharmacy Guild of Australia (the Guild) holds the view that your discretion should only be used in exceptional circumstances. Of the 55 valid applications referred for ministerial consideration since the power was introduced on 1 July 2006, 12 applications have been approved.…Timing/Handling:31. You have until 27 July 2012 to decide whether or not to consider the request. If no decision is made by this date, you will be taken to have decided not to consider this request. If you decide to consider the request, you have a further three months in which to decide whether or not to exercise your discretion.…

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons I find that the Minister made one decision on 14 July 2012, being a decision not to consider the applicants’ request under s 90B(4) of the National Health Act. IS THE DECISION REVIEWABLE? The Minister submitted that the decision could not be the subject of judicial review under the ADJR Act because the decision lacks the requisite qualities of finality and substance (Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321; 1990 HCA 33 at 337). Alternatively, there is no “matter” founding the court’s jurisdiction under s 39B of the Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) the Judiciary Act) because the ultimate power of the Minister involves a non-compellable discretion. I do not accept either submission. Leaving aside the fact that any such issue should have been raised by way of a notice of objection as to competency rather than in submissions for the hearing, the Minister’s decision under s 90B(4) (in common with decisions under s 90B(5) and s 90A(2) if the Minister had made them) is a final decision which had a direct practical impact on the applicants. By her decision the Minister finally and substantively dealt with the applicants’ request. In so doing the Minister discharged the duty imposed on her under s 90B(4), a duty which continued until the expiry of the period of 3 months from the request having been made. The duty was discharged by the Minister under federal law and the decision was made under federal law. The fact that a power is discretionary and non-compellable does not mean there is no “matter” as the Offshore Processing case discloses, although it may mean that the relief which can be granted is confined. It follows that the court has before it a proper claim for judicial review under the ADJR Act and a “matter” in accordance with s 39B of the Judiciary Act. GROUNDS OF CHALLENGEConstructive jurisdictional error (ground 1) This ground depends on the notion that the Minister was confused about what she was doing. It proposes that although the Minister said she was deciding not to consider the request she in fact considered the request and decided to exercise the power under s 90A(2) but, when she came to exercise that power, she failed to do what was required of her, namely: - (i) to ask herself and thus form an opinion about what the community was for the purposes of s 90A(2), and (ii) to find that she was satisfied that “the Secretary's decision will result in a community being left without reasonable access to pharmaceutical benefits supplied by an approved pharmacist” because the contrary finding would be irrational and illogical. This ground fails at the outset on the basis that the Minister decided only not to consider the applicants’ request under s 90B(4). Nevertheless, for the purpose of resolving this issue and all of the subsequent issues, it may be assumed either that because of the way in which she made that decision the Minister was engaging with s 90A(2) or, as the applicants would have it, the Minister was in fact exercising the power under s 90A(2). Either way, the result is the same.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Read fairly and in context it cannot be inferred that the Minister treated her finding of the lack of unintended consequence of the application of the Rules as a bar to a favourable exercise of discretion. The Minister may be inferred to have taken that finding into account in reaching her decision (in my view, a decision under s 90B(4) only) but, whether under ss 90B(4), 90B(5) or 90A(2), nothing in the statute prohibited the Minister from taking that consideration into account. Considering whether the application of the Rules had unintended consequences could hardly be said to be an irrelevant consideration for the Minister. Nor can it be accepted that this consideration inevitably denies the discretion because it leads to application of the Rules rather than an exercise of discretion if there are no unintended consequences. The finding about no unintended consequences was one of a series of findings the Minister made. But it is clear from the paper and the statement of reasons that the Minister never lost sight of the terms of s 90A(2) or, for that matter, s 90B(4). Unless it can be said that the Minister was prohibited from taking into account the question whether the application of the Rules had unintended consequences, which it cannot, this ground of challenge must fail.Irrelevant considerations (ground 5) Ground 5 alleges that the Minister considered irrelevant matters, being view of the Pharmacy Guild of Australia and statistics about how many requests under s 90A had been made to and approved by the Minister. The views of the Pharmacy Guild of Australia and the statistics are contained in the paper which was put before the Minister. The views of the Pharmacy Guild of Australia were that that power in s 90A(2) should only be used in exceptional circumstances. The statistics were that the Minister had received 55 applications or requests under s 90A and approved 12 of them. According to the applicants the Minister was prohibited from taking these matters into account because they are irrelevant considerations. I disagree. Consistent with the reasoning in Peko-Wallsend at p 40 the Minister’s discretions under ss 90B(4), 90B(5) and 90A(2) were unconfined in terms of matters that may not be considered “except in so far as there may be found in the subject-matter, scope and purpose of the statute some implied limitation on the factors to which the decision-maker may legitimately have regard”. Nothing in the subject-matter, scope and purpose of the statute suggests that the Minister is prohibited from having regard to the view of the Pharmacy Guild of Australia and statistics about how many requests under s 90A had been made to and approved by the Minister when exercising a power under ss 90B(4), 90B(5) or 90A(2) of the National Health Act. If the Minister had done something other than merely take these matters into account, such as accepting that the discretion may only be exercised in exceptional circumstances or deciding that this application should not be considered because 12 had already been approved or only 12 had been approved, then there might be scope for a valid challenge to the decision. In such a case, the Minister would have illegitimately confined the discretion. But it cannot be that the statute prohibits the Minister from considering these matters.