Hamcor Pty Ltd v The State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Hamcor Pty Ltd and Anor v The State of Queensland and Ors [2013] QSC 9

PARTIES:

HAMCOR PTY LTD
ACN 010 141 429
(First Plaintiff)
TERENCE ARTHUR ARMSTRONG
(Second Plaintiff)
v
THE STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(First Defendant)
MARSH PTY LTD
ABN 86 004 651 512
(Second Defendant)
OTAGO PTY LTD
ABN 90 010 161 501
(Third Defendant)

FILE NO:

BS 5764 of 2011

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

11 February 2013

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

5 November 2012

JUDGE:

Boddice J

ORDER:

The separate question is answered “no”.

CATCHWORDS:

INSURANCE – THE POLICY – PRINCIPLES OF CONSTRUCTION – hearing for determination of a separate question –where the respondents incurred costs in remediating their land – where the costs were incurred in complying with statutory notices and court orders – whether it is a claim made “against” the insured - whether the words “liability to pay compensation” requires a liability “at law” to pay “damages” – whether costs incurred by the respondents were capable of being the subject of indemnity

Environmental Protection Act 1994 (Qld)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999 (Qld)

Australian Casualty Co Ltd v Federico (1986) 160 CLR 513
Bartoline Ltd v Royal & Sun Alliance Insurance plc [2006] EWHC 3598
Dixon v Calcraft (1892) 1 QB 458
McCann v Switzerland Insurance Australia Ltd (2000) 2003 CLR 579
Monarch Insurance Co Ltd v Steel Mains Pty Ltd [1986] VR 381
Wilkie v Gordian Runoff Ltd (2005) 221 CLR 522
Yorkshire Water Services v Sun Alliance & London Insurance plc & Ors [1997] 2 Lloyd’s Law Reports 21

COUNSEL:

P Dunning SC, with P Telford, for the plaintiffs/respondents
I Faulkner SC for the second and third defendants/applicants

SOLICITORS:

Everingham Lawyers for the plaintiffs/respondents
Thynne & Macartney for the second and third defendants/applicants

  1. The second and third defendants (“the applicants”) make application, pursuant to r 483, Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, for the separate determination of a question said to arise out of proceedings instituted by the plaintiffs (“the respondents”) against the first, second and third defendants claiming damages for negligence.

  1. The question to be determined is whether the costs incurred by the respondents in remediating their own land in response to statutory notices and court orders, were capable of being the subject of indemnity under certain specified policies of insurance. 

  1. The Court is to determine the separate question on the assumption of specified facts and documents, and in the event the respondents had been named as insured or as interested parties in the specified policies of insurance.

  1. The respondents do not oppose the separate determination of the question on the bases proposed by the applicants.

Background

  1. The respondents are the owners of land at Narangba in the State of Queensland.  In 2005, the land contained a chemical manufacturing plant operated by Binary Industries Pty Ltd (“Binary”).  A director of that company was the second plaintiff.

  1. On 25 August 2005, the plant building and its contents were…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hamcor Pty Ltd v The State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QSC 9
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hamcor Pty Ltd v The State of Queensland, the respondent, Hamcor Pty Ltd, sought indemnity from the appellant, the State of Queensland, under an insurance policy for costs incurred in remediating their land. These costs arose from compliance with statutory notices and court orders. The matter was brought before the court to determine whether these costs constituted a claim made “against” the insured party, and if the policy terms regarding “liability to pay compensation” required a “liability at law” to pay “damages”. The court was also required to decide if the costs incurred by the respondents were capable of being the subject of indemnity under the policy.

The court considered the principles of construction applicable to insurance policies, focusing on the wording of the policy and the circumstances surrounding the claim. The central issue was whether the costs incurred by the respondents in complying with statutory notices and court orders could be considered a liability to pay compensation, as defined in the policy. The court examined whether these costs could be regarded as a claim made “against” the insured, and if they were capable of being indemnified under the policy. The interpretation of the phrase “liability to pay compensation” was crucial, particularly whether it required a liability “at law” to pay “damages”.

After careful consideration, the court found that the costs incurred by the respondents in complying with statutory notices and court orders did not constitute a claim made “against” the insured within the meaning of the policy. The court held that the words “liability to pay compensation” required a liability “at law” to pay “damages”, which the respondents’ costs did not meet. Consequently, the court determined that the costs incurred by the respondents were not capable of being the subject of indemnity under the policy. The separate question presented was answered “no”, denying the respondents’ claim for indemnity.

Orders

Orders of the court

The separate question is answered “no”.

Background

Background to the litigation

Hamcor Pty Ltd, the insured, sought indemnity from the insurer, the State of Queensland, for costs incurred in remediating their land. The remediation was undertaken in response to statutory notices and court orders, which required the respondents to take certain actions to address environmental contamination on their land. The insured claimed that the costs incurred were a result of a liability to pay compensation, as outlined in their insurance policy. The insurer argued that the remediation costs were not compensable because they did not arise from a liability "at law" to pay "damages." The central issue was whether the remediation costs were capable of being the subject of indemnity under the terms of the insurance policy.

The matter came before the court for a determination of a separate question regarding the interpretation of the insurance policy. The insured had previously sought a declaration that the remediation costs were covered by the policy. The court was tasked with deciding whether the remediation costs were a claim made "against" the insured and whether they constituted a claim for "liability to pay compensation." The matter had not proceeded to a full trial but was determined on the basis of written submissions and arguments presented by both parties.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the remediation costs incurred by the respondents are a claim made "against" the insured within the meaning of the insurance policy.
2. Whether the words "liability to pay compensation" require a liability "at law" to pay "damages" and, if so, whether the remediation costs meet this criterion.
3. Whether the remediation costs incurred by the respondents are capable of being the subject of indemnity under the insurance policy.

Held
1. The court held that the remediation costs incurred by the respondents are not a claim made "against" the insured within the meaning of the insurance policy.
2. The court found that the words "liability to pay compensation" do require a liability "at law" to pay "damages," and that the remediation costs do not meet this criterion.
3. Consequently, the court concluded that the remediation costs incurred by the respondents are not capable of being the subject of indemnity under the insurance policy.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court approached the question of whether the remediation costs incurred by the respondents constituted a claim made "against" the insured by examining the plain meaning of the term "against" within the context of the insurance policy. The court held that for a claim to be considered "against" the insured, it must involve a direct demand for payment of a sum of money by a third party as a result of the insured's liability. In this case, the remediation costs were incurred by the respondents to comply with statutory notices and court orders, and not as a direct result of a third-party demand against the insured. Therefore, the remediation costs did not qualify as a claim made "against" the insured.

Further, the court interpreted the phrase "liability to pay compensation" and found that it required a liability "at law" to pay "damages." The remediation costs incurred by the respondents did not arise from a legal liability to pay damages but rather from statutory obligations. As such, the remediation costs did not meet the criterion of a liability "at law" to pay "damages."

Finally, given that the remediation costs did not constitute a claim made "against" the insured and did not meet the criterion of a liability "at law" to pay "damages," the court concluded that these costs were not capable of being the subject of indemnity under the insurance policy. The binding legal principle established in this decision is that remediation costs incurred to comply with statutory notices and court orders, without a direct third-party demand for payment, do not constitute a claim made "against" the insured under an insurance policy.