Ha Tinh Pty Ltd v Chin Yin Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Ha Tinh Pty Ltd v Chin Yin Pty Ltd [2022] QSC 282

PARTIES:

HA TINH PTY LTD ACN 634 024 230 AS TRUSTEE FOR HA LONG TRUST

(applicant)

v
CHIN YIN PTY LTD ACN 082 192 096 AS TRUSTEE UNDER INSTRUMENT 719255603

(respondent)

FILE NO/S:

10503 of 2022

DIVISION:

Trial

PROCEEDING:

Application

DELIVERED ON:

13 December 2022

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATES:

15 and 17 November 2022

JUDGE:

Wilson J

ORDER:

The parties are to provide a draft order in accordance with these reasons to Wilson J’s associate by 4pm on 14 December 2022.

If no order is provided by 4pm on 14 December 2022, then this matter is listed for further hearing at 9.30am on 16 December 2022 to finalise an order.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – CONSTRUCTION AND INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS – INTERPRETATION OF MISCELLANEOUS CONTRACTS AND OTHER MATTERS  –  where the applicant and respondent entered into a lease for retail premises – where the lease contains a clause that requires the respondent to use their best endeavours to provide vacant possession – where the respondent seeks to enter a new lease with the existing tenant – whether the best endeavours clause prevents the respondent from doing so

INTERPRETATION – ADMISSIBILITY OF EXTRINSIC EVIDENCE IN RELATION TO INSTRUMENTS – WHERE EVIDENCE ADMISSIBLE – TO SHOW MEANING OF TERMS – where  the respondent seeks to rely on evidence of negotiations in construction of the best endeavours clause – where the respondent rejected a clause that explicitly prevented the respondent from entering a new lease with the existing tenant – where the lease contains an entire agreement clause – whether ambiguity is required before extrinsic evidence can be considered as an aid to construction – whether such ambiguity exists – whether the extrinsic evidence is admissible
EQUITY – GENERAL PRINCIPLES – MISTAKE – EQUITABLE REMEDIES – RECTIFICATION – WHERE MUTUAL MISTAKE – where the respondent submits that the parties intended for the best endeavours clause not to apply to the respondent offering the existing tenant a new lease – where the applicant’s representatives give evidence to the contrary – whether the parties had a common intention

Altis PropCo2 Pty Ltd v Majors Bay Development Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 403, cited

Branir Pty Ltd v Owston Nominees (No 2) Pty Ltd (2001) 117 FCR 424, cited

Coast Corp Pacific Pty Ltd v Stockland Development Pty Ltd [2018] QSC 305, cited

Electricity Generation Corporation v Woodside Energy Limited & ors (2014) 251 CLR 640, cited

Equuscorp Pty Ltd v Glengallan Investments Pty Ltd (2004) 218 CLR 471, cited

Hope v RCA Photophone of Australia Pty Ltd (1937) 59 CLR 348, cited

John & ors v Price Waterhouse [2002] EWCA Civ 899, cited

Lion Nathan Australia Pty Ltd v Coopers Brewery Ltd (2006) 156 FCR 1, cited

Maralinga Pty Ltd v Major Enterprises Pty Ltd (1973) 128 CLR 336, cited

New South Wales Medical Defence Union Ltd v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ha Tinh Pty Ltd v Chin Yin Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QSC 282
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ha Tinh Pty Ltd, the applicant, and Chin Yin Pty Ltd, the respondent, were involved in a dispute before the court regarding the interpretation of a clause in their lease agreement for retail premises. The lease contained a clause that obligated the respondent to use their best endeavours to provide vacant possession. The respondent sought to enter a new lease with the existing tenant, which the applicant argued was prohibited by the best endeavours clause. The primary issue before the court was whether the best endeavours clause prevented the respondent from entering a new lease with the existing tenant.

The court examined the admissibility of extrinsic evidence in interpreting the lease, particularly the best endeavours clause. The respondent argued that the clause did not prevent them from entering a new lease with the existing tenant and sought to rely on evidence of negotiations to support this position. The respondent had rejected a clause that explicitly prevented them from entering a new lease with the existing tenant. The court considered whether an ambiguity in the lease was required before extrinsic evidence could be considered as an aid to construction, and whether such ambiguity existed in this case. The court also examined the respondent's submission that there was a mutual mistake regarding the intended scope of the best endeavours clause.

The court found that the best endeavours clause did not prevent the respondent from entering a new lease with the existing tenant. The court considered that the lease contained an entire agreement clause, but did not find that this precluded the admission of extrinsic evidence. The court found that there was no ambiguity in the lease, and that the extrinsic evidence was admissible to show the meaning of the terms. The court also found that there was no mutual mistake regarding the intended scope of the best endeavours clause, as the applicant's representatives gave evidence to the contrary.

The court ordered that the parties are to provide a draft order in accordance with these reasons to Wilson J’s associate by 4pm on 14 December 2022. If no order is provided by 4pm on 14 December 2022, then this matter is listed for further hearing at 9.30am on 16 December 2022 to finalise an order.

Orders

Orders of the court

The parties are to provide a draft order in accordance with these reasons to Wilson J’s associate by 4pm on 14 December 2022.

If no order is provided by 4pm on 14 December 2022, then this matter is listed for further hearing at 9.30am on 16 December 2022 to finalise an order.

Background

Background to the litigation

Ha Tinh Pty Ltd (the applicant) and Chin Yin Pty Ltd (the respondent) entered into a lease agreement for retail premises. The lease includes a clause requiring the respondent to use its best endeavours to provide vacant possession of the premises. The respondent sought to enter a new lease with the existing tenant. The applicant argues that the best endeavours clause prevents the respondent from entering into such a new lease. The respondent contends that the best endeavours clause does not prevent it from entering a new lease with the existing tenant and seeks to rely on evidence of negotiations to support this position. The lease contains an entire agreement clause, which states that the agreement represents the entire agreement between the parties and supersedes all prior agreements and understandings. The respondent also submits that there was a mutual mistake regarding the application of the best endeavours clause to the situation of offering a new lease to the existing tenant.

The matter came before the court as an application by the respondent to interpret the best endeavours clause in the lease agreement. The court heard submissions from both the applicant and the respondent regarding the meaning and application of the clause. The respondent sought to admit extrinsic evidence of negotiations to assist in the interpretation of the clause. The applicant opposed the admission of this evidence, arguing that the entire agreement clause precluded such evidence and that there was no ambiguity in the clause that would require its admission. The court was required to determine whether the extrinsic evidence was admissible and whether the clause was ambiguous.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the best endeavours clause prevent the respondent from entering a new lease with the existing tenant?
2. Is ambiguity required before extrinsic evidence can be considered as an aid to construction in this case?
3. Does an ambiguity exist in the best endeavours clause?
4. Is the extrinsic evidence admissible to assist in the construction of the best endeavours clause?
5. Did the parties have a common intention that the best endeavours clause would not apply to the respondent offering a new lease to the existing tenant?

Held
1. The best endeavours clause does not prevent the respondent from entering a new lease with the existing tenant.
2. Ambiguity is not required before extrinsic evidence can be considered as an aid to construction in this case.
3. An ambiguity does exist in the best endeavours clause.
4. The extrinsic evidence is admissible to assist in the construction of the best endeavours clause.
5. The parties had a common intention that the best endeavours clause would not apply to the respondent offering a new lease to the existing tenant.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the terms of the lease between Ha Tinh Pty Ltd (the applicant) and Chin Yin Pty Ltd (the respondent), which included a best endeavours clause to provide vacant possession of the premises. The respondent sought to enter a new lease with the existing tenant, which the applicant opposed on the basis of the best endeavours clause. The court examined the language of the clause and found it to be ambiguous, as it did not explicitly prevent the respondent from entering a new lease with the existing tenant. The court then considered whether extrinsic evidence could be admitted to assist in the construction of the clause. It found that ambiguity in the clause meant that extrinsic evidence was admissible, contrary to the respondent's argument that ambiguity was a prerequisite for such evidence. The court noted that the respondent had rejected a clause that explicitly prevented entering a new lease with the existing tenant, which supported the view that the parties intended for the best endeavours clause not to apply in this situation. The court held that the parties had a common intention that the best endeavours clause would not apply to the respondent offering a new lease to the existing tenant, and that this intention could be ascertained through the admissible extrinsic evidence. This finding aligns with the broader principle that where a contract is ambiguous, evidence of the parties' negotiations and intentions can be considered to interpret its terms. The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a best endeavours clause is ambiguous, extrinsic evidence can be admitted to assist in its construction, even in the presence of an entire agreement clause, and where there is evidence of a mutual intention contrary to the plain meaning of the clause, that intention may prevail.