SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Civil: Application)
H STANKE & SONS PTY LTD v VON STANKE & ORS (NO M2)
[2007] SASC 130
Reasons of Judge Lunn a Master of the Supreme Court
17 April 2007
PROCEDURE
Contribution notices - R 37.07 - whether contribution notice is so related to issues in action that it should be determined between all parties under subr 37.07(1)(c) - striking out of improper pleadings - abuse of process where duplicationof contribution notice with counterclaim in another action.
H STANKE & SONS PTY LTD v VON STANKE & ORS (NO M2)
[2007] SASC 130
Further reasons on the application by the 1st defendant to strike out the contribution notice of the 2nd defendant.
JUDGE LUNN: On 20 February 2007 I delivered reasons in Judgment [2007] SASC 51 dealing with part of this application. These reasons need to be read as a continuation of those previous reasons. At the conclusion of those reasons I said that paragraph 72.1 of the amended contribution notice was to be struck out on the grounds that this Court did not have power to remove an executor without also revoking his probate. I said I would hear counsel on whether that meant that other paragraphs of the contribution notice should also be struck out. I had in mind that consequentially paragraphs 38-59, and possibly other paragraphs, should be struck out as they only related to the relief in paragraph 72.1 and not also to the other relief sought in paragraph 72.2 for equitable compensation and paragraph 72.3 for the 1st defendant to account to the 2nd defendant for profits derived by him. The point had not been addressed in the earlier submissions.
On 5 March 2007 the 2nd defendant issued a notice for directions seeking leave to amend further her contribution notice. The main thrust of the proposed amendments was to plead an alternative claim for the removal of the 1st defendant as an executor under s 36 of the Trustee Act. This had been foreshadowed by counsel for the 2nd defendant in his original submissions but I had declined to entertain it as it had not then been pleaded. Counsel for the 1st defendant had made it clear that any such amendment would be vigorously opposed.
Further argument on the matters raised by me in my reasons about the contribution notice was set for 15 March 2007. Prior to that hearing counsel for the 1st defendant had lodged written submissions, although they did not come to my attention until that day. A significant part of those submissions were in effect a demurrer that on what the 2nd defendant had pleaded she could not be entitled to the relief claimed in paragraphs 72.2 and 72.3 of the contribution notice and therefore on these grounds alone the balance of the contribution notice should be struck out. This attack on paragraphs 72.2 and 72.3 was open to the 2nd defendant on…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read H Stanke & Sons Pty Ltd v Von Stanke & Ors (No M2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2007] SASC 130
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court issued several orders regarding the contribution notice. It struck out paragraph 72.1 and allowed the first defendant to apply to strike out other consequential paragraphs. It also struck out specific words from paragraph 66.2.3 but granted the second defendant leave to re-plead that allegation with proper particularity within 21 days. Other parts of the first defendant's application were dismissed, and the question of costs was reserved. The application to stay the contribution notice for abuse of process was adjourned to a future date.
Background
Background to the litigation
The second defendant's contribution notice seeks the removal of the first defendant as an executor, equitable compensation, and an accounting of profits derived by the first defendant. The first defendant opposes the contribution notice and seeks to have it struck out on various grounds, including improper pleading and abuse of process. The court has already struck out certain parts of the contribution notice and must now consider the remaining objections raised by the first defendant. The court must also consider whether the second defendant's counterclaim in another action duplicates the relief sought in the contribution notice and constitutes an abuse of process. The court has found that the contribution notice is related to the issues in the action and should be determined between all parties, as it raises at least one common issue which is substantially the same as one issue pleaded in the action. The court has also found that the contribution notice does not constitute an abuse of process, as the second defendant has not yet brought her counterclaim in the other action and it is not clear what proceedings she is otherwise entitled to pursue for the relief which she seeks. The court has struck out certain parts of the contribution notice on the grounds of improper pleading, including allegations of fraud which were not pleaded with sufficient particularity. The court has also ordered that the second defendant re-plead those allegations with proper particularity within 21 days. The question of costs is reserved, and the application to stay the contribution notice for abuse of process is adjourned to a later date.
The matter before the Supreme Court of South Australia in H Stanke & Sons Pty Ltd v Von Stanke & Ors (No M2) [2007] SASC 130 is an interlocutory application concerning the validity and scope of a contribution notice issued under the Supreme Court Civil Procedure Rules. This application arose out of an ongoing family dispute involving multiple family members and companies over the ownership and management of property and business assets. The application was brought by the first defendant to strike out the contribution notice issued by the second defendant, arguing it was improperly pleaded and constituted an abuse of process. The second defendant sought leave to amend her contribution notice, while the plaintiff supported the first defendant's application to strike out parts of the contribution notice. The matter was initially heard on 20 February 2007, with further submissions and arguments made on 5 and 15 March 2007. The judge reserved certain decisions pending further submissions on the effect of striking out particular paragraphs of the contribution notice and on the question of abuse of process. The judge ultimately struck out certain paragraphs of the contribution notice, denied the application to strike out other parts of the contribution notice, and adjourned the application to stay the contribution notice for abuse of process pending further clarification of the second defendant's intended proceedings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the contribution notice qualifies under Rule 37.07(1)(c) of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2006 (SA)?
2. Whether the contribution notice should be struck out as improperly pleaded under the Rules of the Supreme Court 1978 (SA)?
3. Whether there is an abuse of process due to the duplication of proceedings between the contribution notice and the counterclaim in another action?
Held
1. Whether the contribution notice qualifies under Rule 37.07(1)(c) of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2006 (SA)?
The Court concluded that the contribution notice does qualify under Rule 37.07(1)(c). The result was that the contribution notice was not struck out on this ground.
2. Whether the contribution notice should be struck out as improperly pleaded under the Rules of the Supreme Court 1978 (SA)?
The Court found that the majority of the objections raised by the first defendant did not merit striking out any parts of the contribution notice. The result was that apart from specific paragraphs, the application to strike out the contribution notice was dismissed.
3. Whether there is an abuse of process due to the duplication of proceedings between the contribution notice and the counterclaim in another action?
The Court held that the question of whether there is an abuse of process should be determined once the pending applications for amendments to the contribution notice and the application to strike out specific paragraphs are resolved. The result was that the application to stay the contribution notice for abuse of process was adjourned.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In the matter of H Stanke & Sons Pty Ltd v Von Stanke & Ors (No M2), the court addressed three primary issues regarding the contribution notice issued by the second defendant. The first issue pertains to whether the contribution notice qualifies under Rule 37.07(1)(c) of the Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2006 (SA). The court determined that the second defendant’s contribution notice was sufficiently related to the issues in the main action to qualify under Rule 37.07(1)(c), which allows a defendant to issue a contribution notice against any person who is already a defendant or subsequent party to the action, seeking the determination of any question or issue relating to or connected with the original subject matter, provided it should be properly determined as between other parties. The court held that at least one common issue between the plaintiff and defendants was substantially the same as one issue raised in the contribution notice. The court exercised its discretion under Rule 37.07(1)(c) to allow the contribution notice to proceed, balancing the principle of avoiding multiplicity of proceedings against the need for comprehensive and final determination of all issues.
The second issue addressed whether the contribution notice should be struck out as improperly pleaded under the Rules of the Supreme Court 1978 (SA). The court dismissed the first defendant’s objections to various parts of the contribution notice, finding that they did not meet the grounds for striking out improper pleadings. The court held that the pleadings provided fair notice of the case the second defendant intended to present at trial and did not amount to scandalous, frivolous, or vexatious claims. The court struck out only the specific allegation of fraud in paragraph 66.2.3, directing the second defendant to re-plead it with proper particularity.
The third issue concerned whether there was an abuse of process due to the duplication of proceedings between the contribution notice and the counterclaim in another action. The court deferred ruling on this issue until it was clear what proceedings the second defendant intended to pursue, emphasizing that if there was significant duplication amounting to abuse of process, the second defendant should be put to her election as to which set of proceedings should be stayed. The court held over the application to stay the contribution notice for abuse of process pending further clarification on the proceedings in the other action.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this decision is that a contribution notice qualifies under Rule 37.07(1)(c) if it raises at least one issue substantially the same as an issue in the main action, and the court retains a broad discretion to determine whether such issues should be decided as part of the main action. Additionally, the court will strike out improperly pleaded parts of a contribution notice but will otherwise allow it to proceed unless there is clear evidence of an abuse of process due to duplicative proceedings.