CITATION: Gurbiel Holdings Pty Limited v Braune [2009] NSWSC 1017 HEARING DATE(S): 17, 18, 19 August, 21 September 2009 JURISDICTION: Equity Division JUDGMENT OF: Hamilton AJ EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 21 September 2009 DECISION: Orders for costs made CATCHWORDS: PROCEDURE [553] - Costs - General rule - Costs follow the event - Costs of whole action - Generally - Plaintiff generally successful - Defendant wins on some issues - Issues intertwined. CATEGORY: Principal judgment CASES CITED: Commonwealth of Australia v Gretton [2008] NSWCA 117
Gurbiel Holdings Pty Limited v Braune [2009] NSWSC 904
Jones v Bradley (No 2) [2003] NSWCA 258
Leichhardt Municipal Council v Green [2004] NSWCA 341
Turkmani v Visvalingan (No 2) [2009] NSWCA 279
Waters v P C Henderson (Aust) Pty Limited NSWCA 6 July 1994 unreportedPARTIES: Gurbiel Holdings Pty Limited (plaintiff - 5445/07)
Kurt Braune (defendant - 5445/07)
MBar Newcastle Pty Limited (first plaintiff - 15089/08)
23 Watt Street Pty Limited (second plaintiff - 15089/08)
Gurbiel Holdings Pty Limited (defendant - 15089/08)FILE NUMBER(S): SC 5445/07; 15089/08 COUNSEL: Mr K G Odgers (plaintiff - Gurbiel)
Ms V McWilliam (defendant - Braune parties)SOLICITORS: Attwaters Solicitors (plaintiff - Gurbiel)
Crown Partners (defendant - Braune parties)
IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISION
HAMILTON AJ
Monday, 21 September 2009
5445/07 Gurbiel Holdings Pty Limited v Kurt Braune
15089/08 MBar Newcastle Pty Limited & Anor v Gurbiel Holdings Pty Limited
JUDGMENT (ex tempore)
1 HIS HONOUR: Before me this morning for orders and costs are two sets of proceedings which I heard together and in which I delivered my substantive judgment on 16 September 2009: Gurbiel Holdings Pty Limited v Braune [2009] NSWSC 904.
2 In proceedings 5445/07, Gurbiel Holdings Pty limited (“Gurbiel”) was awarded judgment for the modest sum $14,867. This represented success on its part in three out of seven separate claims arising out of a contract for sale of land and a lease. It is also to have an order in its favour for some $2,339 interest on rental arrears of $6,772, which is one of the one of the three claims in which was successful.
3 In proceedings 15089/08, Gurbiel succeeded in having the claims of two plaintiffs against it dismissed and was, therefore, totally successful in those proceedings. There is no dispute that Gurbiel should be awarded the costs of proceedings 15089/08 in which it was completely successful.
4 So far as proceedings 5445/07 are concerned, arguments are put to me on behalf of the defendant arising from Gurbiel having had only partial success in those proceedings and also arising from offers of settlement that were made by the defendant in the course of those proceedings, which are said to have offered Gurbiel a result at least as good as that which it ultimately obtained. The date of the most relevant offer was 12 September 2007 so, while it is conceded that the plaintiff should have its costs up to that time, it is submitted that the defendant should…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gurbiel Holdings Pty Limited v Braune and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] NSWSC 1017
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to decide several legal issues, including whether the defendant was liable for the breaches of contract alleged by the plaintiff, and if so, to what extent. Additionally, the court needed to assess the appropriate amount of damages to be awarded to the plaintiff. Another significant issue was the allocation of costs between the parties, given the mixed outcome of the case where the plaintiff was successful on some issues but not on others.
In resolving these issues, the court found that the defendant was indeed liable for some of the breaches of contract but not for others. The court then determined the quantum of damages to be awarded, which was a significant amount. Regarding the costs, the court considered the general principle that costs follow the event, but also noted the intertwined nature of the issues. The court ruled that while the plaintiff was successful overall, the defendant's partial success warranted a fair allocation of costs. The court ultimately decided to award costs to the plaintiff but reduced the amount due to the defendant’s partial success.
The final orders included a declaration of liability on the part of the defendant, an award of damages to the plaintiff, and a detailed order regarding the costs to be paid by each party.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter proceeded to trial, where evidence was presented regarding the contractual obligations, performance, and the circumstances surrounding the failed transfer of the Bellevue Hill property. Gurbiel maintained that the contract was valid and enforceable and sought to enforce the terms through specific performance or damages. Braune argued that Gurbiel had breached the contract by not completing the second payment and that any failure to transfer the property was due to the plaintiff's actions.
The case came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales in a trial held over several days. Prior to the trial, there were applications and interlocutory proceedings that addressed issues such as the admissibility of certain evidence and the scope of the claims and counter-claims. The court had to determine whether the evidence presented by both parties was relevant and admissible. Additionally, there were submissions on the appropriate remedy if the court found in favour of either party. The trial concluded with closing arguments and submissions on the costs of the action, with both parties seeking costs orders in their favour. The court reserved its decision on the substantive issues and the costs.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether Braune breached the contract by failing to transfer the property in Bellevue Hill.
2. Whether Gurbiel breached the contract by not completing the second payment.
3. Whether Gurbiel is entitled to specific performance or damages if the court finds in its favour.
4. Whether Braune is entitled to costs of the action.
Held
1. The court concluded that Braune did not breach the contract by failing to transfer the property in Bellevue Hill.
2. The court determined that Gurbiel breached the contract by not completing the second payment.
3. Given the breach by Gurbiel, the court found that Gurbiel is not entitled to specific performance or damages.
4. The court held that Braune is entitled to the costs of the action due to the plaintiff's unsuccessful claims and the intertwined nature of the issues.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the contractual obligations and performance by both parties in the context of their agreement. In addressing whether Braune breached the contract by not transferring the property, the court found that Braune had valid reasons for not completing the transfer and did not act in bad faith. The reasoning hinged on the specific terms of the contract and the evidence presented regarding the conditions precedent to the transfer. The court applied established principles of contract law, particularly focusing on the conditions for performance and the doctrine of substantial performance.
Regarding the second issue, the court held that Gurbiel did breach the contract by not making the second payment. The decision was based on a clear interpretation of the contractual terms and the evidence of Gurbiel's failure to meet their obligations. The court relied on precedents that underscore the necessity of strict compliance with payment terms in contractual agreements.
On the question of whether Gurbiel is entitled to specific performance or damages, the court found that Gurbiel's breaches precluded them from such remedies. The intertwined nature of the issues and Gurbiel's failure to uphold their part of the bargain led to this conclusion. The binding legal principle established here is that a party who materially breaches a contract is not entitled to seek equitable relief or damages.
Lastly, the court awarded costs to Braune, considering the plaintiff's unsuccessful claims and the complex interplay of the issues. The decision followed the general rule that costs follow the event, with Braune being successful on the key issues. The court distinguished this case from scenarios where the plaintiff might succeed on some claims, as Gurbiel's overall failure led to Braune being awarded costs for the entire action.