Gould v Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Board

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Gould v Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Board

[2009] FCA 475

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – appeal from Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) on questions of law and application under s 39B of Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) for relief in respect of AAT’s decision – AAT affirmed decision Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Board (Board) suspending registration of applicant (G) as a liquidator for three months – Board had found that G had failed to carry out “adequately and properly” duties as liquidator and as administrator of certain companies, so that the power given by s 1292(2)(d) of Corporations Law (Law) and of Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act) was enlivened – proceeding before Board and later before AAT had proceeded on Contentions as formulated by Australia Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) – each of Board and AAT found some Contentions established and others not established –

(1)  whether G had failed to satisfy a “professional standard” by failing to include a “cap” or “upper limit” in his remuneration submitted to creditors for approval at time of his appointment – status of guidance and statement of best practice issued by Insolvency Practitioners Association of Australia (IPAA) – whether those documents, standing alone and unsupported by expert evidence, established a professional standard in relevant sense –

(2)  whether contravention of s 450E(2) established by G’s writing on his Chartered Accountant’s letterhead to creditors informing them of progress of administration under deed of company arrangement (DOCA) – letters referred to company “in administration” rather than “subject to deed of company arrangement” – whether the letters were “business letters” for purposes of s 88A(1)(c) of Law (and of Act) – whether letters were signed or issued by or on behalf of companies subject to DOCA –

(3)  whether G was entitled to charge as an expense of liquidation a late fee that he had been charged by ASIC for lodging documents later than the last day of period allowed for lodgement – liquidator’s lien – effect of fact that G was owed thousands of dollars for remuneration that would never be paid –

(4)  whether G had contravened s 539(1) of Law (and of Act) by including a wrong monetary amount in his Forms 524 (six-monthly accounts) – Forms 524 showed amount available for unsecured creditors as $1,246,306 (which was also shown as the amount owing to them) rather than “Nil” – difference between a statement that is “misleading” and one that is “false” – whether failure to supervise staff properly and adequately established –

(5)  whether AAT should have entertained certain amended Contentions where ASIC had been refused leave to amend them by Board – double jeopardy – nature of hearing before AAT –

(6)  nature of requirement that registered liquidator consent in writing to be appointed as administrator before being appointed or acting as administrator – whether resolution can have a latent or contingent operation to be enlivened once the registered liquidator gives the consent in writing.

CORPORATIONS – appeal from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gould v Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Boar... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 475
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the Court involves Mr. Gould, who was appointed as an administrator of three companies – Trinbay, Sisterella, and Popwing – and the Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Board. The dispute centers around the remuneration resolutions passed by the creditors of these companies, which Mr. Gould approved, and whether these resolutions complied with the requirements set by the Institute of Public Accountants Australia (IPAA) guidelines. The Court was tasked with deciding various legal issues pertaining to the interpretation and application of the IPAA guidelines and the effect of the resolutions on Mr. Gould's remuneration.

The primary legal issues addressed by the Court included whether the resolutions merely set the basis or hourly rates for Mr. Gould's fees rather than determining or fixing the amount of his fees, whether the IPAA guidelines required an upper limit or cap to be included in the resolutions, and whether the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) erred in its interpretation of the IPAA guidelines and the resolutions. Additionally, the Court examined whether the AAT properly applied the onus of proof, whether it considered relevant and irrelevant evidence, and whether it acted contrary to law in its findings.

In its reasoning, the Court considered the arguments presented by both Mr. Gould and ASIC, focusing on the content and interpretation of the IPAA guidelines and the resolutions. The Court determined that the AAT's findings regarding the resolutions were not erroneous and that the IPAA guidelines did not mandate a specific cap on remuneration. The Court upheld the AAT's conclusion that the resolutions set the basis or hourly rates rather than the total amount of Mr. Gould's fees and that the AAT correctly interpreted the IPAA guidelines. The Court found no procedural unfairness or misapplication of the onus of proof by the AAT.

The Court ordered that the proceeding be stood over to a later date for further directions. This decision ensures that the matter will be revisited to address any remaining issues or to proceed with the next steps in the legal process.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding be stood over to Wednesday 20 May 2009 at 9.30 am for directions.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

LINDGREN J
Before this Court, counsel structured their submissions around grouped Contentions and the associated questions of law, and I will structure my reasons similarly under “CONSIDERATION” below.REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE AAT In its reasons for decision (Re Gould and Companies Auditors and Liquidators Disciplinary Board (2008) 106 ALD 53; [2008] AATA 814), the AAT quoted at length from the SOFAC filed by ASIC. I will describe the relevant Contentions in the SOFAC and the AAT’s reasons in relation to them under “CONSIDERATION” below. The Contentions fall into the following categories:·those that the AAT found to be established and that Mr Gould submits on substantive grounds it should not have found established (Contentions 2.6, 2.9, 4.4, 4.6, 6.3, 6.5);·those that Mr Gould submits the AAT had no jurisdiction to entertain or ought not to have entertained (Contentions 2.1, 6.5, 6.6 and 6.7A);·those that the AAT dismissed and that ASIC contends in its Notice of Contention the AAT should have found established (Contention 2.11 and, again, Contentions 2.1, 6.6 and 6.7A).THE THREE COMPANIES It is convenient to note now certain facts relating to Trinbay, Sisterella and Popwing.Trinbay As at September 2000 Trinbay had three directors. On 11 August 2000 two of them signed a “circular resolution” appointing Mr Gould as administrator of the company under Pt 5.3A of the Law. The third director signed the resolution on 11 September 2000. On 3 October 2000 Mr Gould provided a written consent to act as administrator of Trinbay: see s 448A of the Law, and on 4 October 2000 he lodged with ASIC a Form 505 signed by him stating that he had been appointed. On 31 October 2000, at the second meeting of Trinbay’s creditors, it was resolved that the company execute a DOCA and a resolution was passed relating to Mr Gould’s remuneration. I will discuss the Trinbay remuneration resolution in Part A below. On 20 November 2000 the DOCA was executed by Trinbay and Mr Gould. By cl 3.1 of the DOCA Mr Gould was appointed, and agreed to act, as administrator of the DOCA. Clause 4 provided for Mr Gould’s remuneration as administrator of the DOCA. It will be noted that all of the events recounted above preceded the commencement of the Act on 15 July 2001, and occurred at a time when the Law was in force.Sisterella As at September 1998 Sisterella had two directors. Mr Gould was appointed as administrator of Sisterella on 11 August 1998. The second meeting of Sisterella’s creditors was held on 4 September 1998 when the creditors resolved that the company should execute a DOCA, and passed a resolution relating to Mr Gould’s remuneration as administrator. I will discuss the Sisterella remuneration resolution in Part A below. On 25 September 1998 Sisterella and Mr Gould executed a DOCA. Clause 3.1 of the DOCA provided that Mr Gould was appointed, and agreed to act, as administrator of the DOCA. Clause 4 of the DOCA provided for his remuneration as administrator of the DOCA.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: LINDGREN J

It will be noted that all of the events recounted above preceded the commencement of the Act on 15 July 2001 and occurred when the Law was in force.CONSIDERATIONA. Failure to cap remuneration – Questions associated with Contentions 2.6, 4.4 and 6.3The Contentions As noted earlier, Contention 2.6 related to Trinbay, 4.4 to Sisterella, and 6.3 to Popwing. Contentions 2.6 and 4.4 were that Mr Gould “failed to cap his remuneration as administrator in accordance with IPAA Guidelines”. Contention 6.3 was also that Mr Gould “failed to cap his remuneration as liquidator in accordance with IPAA Guidelines”. In the cases of Sisterella and Popwing, ASIC relied on the Capping provision in the IPAA Guide published by the IPAA in 1997 (the Guide). In the case of Trinbay, however, ASIC relied on the Capping provision of the IPAA’s Statement of Best Practice – Remuneration: 1 July 2000 that had effect from 1 July 2000 (the Statement). The terms of the two Capping provisions are set out below. Associated Questions raised in the FASNA The following questions were stated in the FASNA in connection with Contentions 2.6, 4.4 and 6.3:Question 1: Whether the true legal effect of the resolutions in issue was merely to set the basis or hourly rates of the applicant’s fees and that they did not determine or approve or fix the amount (or any amount) of his fees?Question 2: Whether the true legal effect or construction of the IPAA Guidelines in question, was that no upper limit or cap was required to be included in the resolutions in issue?Question 3: Whether the Tribunal acting reasonably, judicially and properly instructed as to the law was required to find that the resolutions in issue were not intended by the applicant to determine the amount of his fee?Question 4: Whether the Tribunal, contrary to law, denied the applicant procedural fairness by finding that the resolutions in question were intended by the applicant to determine the amount of his fee?Question 4A: Whether the Tribunal erred in failing to provide reasons for rejecting the Applicant’s evidence that the resolutions were only or merely intended to approve the basis of his fees not any actual remuneration or, alternatively, erred in failing to have regard to the applicant’s evidence to this effect?Question 5: Whether the Tribunal misapplied the onus of proof or otherwise acted contrary to law in drawing an adverse inference from the absence of evidence of the applicant seeking approval of a fee amount later?Question 6: Whether the Tribunal erred in law in taking into account an irrelevant consideration, being the absence of evidence of the applicant seeking approval of the fee amount later and the personal state of mind of the applicant towards the resolutions in question?Question 7: Whether the true legal effect of the IPAA Guidelines in question was not to set a mandatory professional standard and, therefore, they could not be a “duty” or “function” within the meaning of 1292(2)(d)(i) and (ii) of the Corporations Act?Question 8: Whether the Tribunal acting reasonably, judicially and properly instructed as to the law was required to dismiss Contentions 2.6, 4.4 and 6.3?General