Gilbert and Australian Securities & Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

Gilbert and Australian Securities & Investments Commission [2020] AATA 191 (18 February 2020)

Division:TAXATION AND COMMERCIAL DIVISION

File Number:           2019/0269

Re:Adam Gilbert  

APPLICANT

Australian Securities & Investments CommissionAnd  

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President I R Molloy

Date:18 February 2020

Place:Brisbane

The decision under review is affirmed.

.................[SGD]......................

Deputy President I R Molloy 

CATCHWORDS

TAX AND COMMERCIAL – period of disqualification – purpose of disqualification - whether corporations are related – disqualification in the public interest – whether duties discharged in good faith – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)

CASES

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Adler [2002] NSWSC 483

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Citrofresh International Ltd (No 3) [2010] FCA 292

Quinlivan v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2010] FCAFC 161

Re Andrews v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2006] AATA 25

Rich v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2004) 220 CLR 129

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President I R Molloy

18 February 2020

INTRODUCTION

  1. This is a review of a decision of a delegate of the Respondent (“ASIC”) made on 19 December 2018 disqualifying the Applicant, Mr Gilbert, from managing corporations for four years.

  2. The decision was made pursuant to s 206F of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“the Act”) and took effect from 20 December 2018.

  3. Section 206F of the Act provides relevantly:

    Power to disqualify

    (1)  ASIC may disqualify a person from managing corporations for up to 5 years if:     

    (a)  within 7 years immediately before ASIC gives a notice under    paragraph (b)(i):

    (i)    the person has been an officer of 2 or more corporations; and

    (ii)  while the person was an officer, or within 12 months after the person ceased to be an officer of those corporations, each of the corporations was wound up and a liquidator lodged a report under subsection 533(1) … about the corporation's inability to pay its debts; and

    (b)          ASIC has given the person:

    (i)a notice in the prescribed form requiring them to demonstrate why they should not be disqualified; and

    (ii)an opportunity to be heard on the question; and

    (c)          ASIC is satisfied that the disqualification is justified.

    (1A)    …

    (2)     In determining whether disqualification is justified, ASIC:

    (a)  must have regard to whether any of the corporations mentioned in subsection (1) were related to one another; and

    (b)         may have regard to:

    (i)  the person's conduct in relation to the management, business or    property of any corporation; and

    (ii)  whether the disqualification would be in the public interest; and

    (iii)  any other matters that ASIC considers appropriate.

    (2A)     …

    (3)        …

    (4)       …

  4. At the time of the decision Mr Gilbert had been a director of a number of corporations, eleven of which had been wound up in the previous three years. Prominent amongst those corporations, for the purposes of this decision, were Ruark Properties Pty Ltd (“Ruark Properties”), Residual Finance Pty Ltd (“Residual Finance”), Promenade…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gilbert and Australian Securities & Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 191
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Adam Gilbert against a decision by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) to disqualify him from managing corporations. Mr Gilbert contended that the period of disqualification imposed by ASIC was excessive, arguing that the financial failures of the corporations were not his fault, that he had not breached his duties as a director, that he had not profited personally or acted dishonestly, and that his personal circumstances, including a prior three-year disqualification due to bankruptcy, should be considered. He also argued that the purpose of disqualification was protective, not punitive, and that he should not be punished twice.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the period of disqualification determined by ASIC was appropriate, considering the purpose of disqualification and the specific circumstances of Mr Gilbert's case. A secondary issue arose regarding whether the eleven corporations in question were "related" for the purposes of the disqualification provisions under the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). This involved determining if the corporations were related by virtue of being holding companies or subsidiaries, or if they were related operationally or as part of a single failure.

The Tribunal accepted ASIC's contention that the corporations were not related as holding companies or subsidiaries. However, it found that two corporations, Ruark Properties and Residual Finance, were operationally related to other failed entities. Regarding the assertion that the corporations were part of one failure, the Tribunal rejected Mr Gilbert's explanation that the failures were solely due to a bank's alleged failure to advance a loan, a downturn in the mining industry, and his bankruptcy. The Tribunal found no evidence of a promised loan from Westpac and concluded that Mr Gilbert had overstated the impact of the mining industry downturn and his bankruptcy on the collapse of the corporations.

Ultimately, the Tribunal determined that a period of disqualification of four years was appropriate in all the circumstances. Accordingly, the decision under review by ASIC was affirmed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Gilbert relied on his written statement[1] and also gave oral evidence. Additionally, he relied on statements of Mr Stewart Gregory Rodrigues,[2] registered tax agent, and Mr Nathan John Archer,[3] self-employed financial analyst.[1] Exhibit 2, Statement of Adam Gilbert. [2] Exhibit 3, Statement of Stewart Gregory Rodriugues. [3] Exhibit 4. Affidavit of Nathan John Archer.APPLICANT’S STATEMENT OF FACTS, ISSUES AND CONTENTIONS After completion of the evidence, Mr Gilbert, who represented himself, produced to the Tribunal and ASIC a Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions, apparently prepared by counsel although unsigned and undated (“Applicant’s SFIC”). The Applicant’s SFIC,[4] which Mr Gilbert spoke to, commenced with what was described as a synopsis of the issues. The contention was “that a shorter period of disqualification was appropriate” having regard to the following matters: (a)The financial failure of the corporations was not the fault of Mr Gilbert.(b)There were no breaches of Mr Gilbert’s duty as a director as suggested by ASIC.(c)Mr Gilbert has already been disqualified from being a director of a company or managing a company for a period of three years, by reason of his having been declared bankrupt on 19 February 2016.(d)Mr Gilbert did not profit personally from the matters in question and there was no dishonesty on his part. (e)The personal circumstances of Mr Gilbert. [4] Applicant’s SFIC, [1-2] The Applicant’s SFIC concluded that in all the circumstances “the period of disqualification imposed by ASIC is grossly excessive.”[5] The circumstances, as well as the above (with some overlap), were: (a)The purpose of a disqualification under s 206F of the Act is protective rather than punitive.(b)The time Mr Gilbert has already been disqualified from managing a corporation by reason of s 206B(3) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) is a relevant consideration.(c)Mr Gilbert has not benefitted from the corporate structure at all. (d)He has given his guarantee and been declared bankrupt as a result: “Is he to be punished twice for having done so?”(e)There has been no wrongful use of the corporate structure. [6] [5] Applicant’s SFIC, [43].[6] Applicant’s SFIC, [41]-[42]. Mr Gilbert confirmed that the issue before the Tribunal was whether the period of disqualification was excessive.[7] In view of some of the issues raised by Mr Gilbert, however, for example in paragraph 8(b) above, it is necessary to go into matters beyond just the period of disqualification. [7] Transcript 7 November 2019, pages 76.18 to 79.9. PRECONDITIONS FOR DISQUALIFICATION - RELATED CORPORATIONS There was no dispute, and I am satisfied, that the preconditions contained in s 206F(1)(a) and (b) of the Act were satisfied. Under s 206F(2)(a) of the Act, in determining whether disqualification is justified, regard must be had to whether any of the corporations mentioned in subsection (1) were related to one another. I accept ASIC’s contention that a related corporation includes a body corporate related by virtue of s 50 of the Act.[8] Under this provision body corporates are related where one is the holding company or subsidiary of the other. That is not the case here. [8] Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 9.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

I consider that in all the circumstances a period of disqualification of four years is appropriate.CONCLUSION The decision under review is affirmed. I certify that the preceding 102 (one hundred and two) paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Deputy President I R Molloy……[SGD]…………..AssociateDated: 18 February 2020Date of hearing: 7 November 2019Applicant: In person Solicitor for Respondent: Australian Securities and Investment CommissionCounsel for Respondent: Mr Brent Reading

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Gilbert confirmed that the issue before the Tribunal was whether the period of disqualification was excessive.[7] In view of some of the issues raised by Mr Gilbert, however, for example in paragraph 8(b) above, it is necessary to go into matters beyond just the period of disqualification. [7] Transcript 7 November 2019, pages 76.18 to 79.9. PRECONDITIONS FOR DISQUALIFICATION - RELATED CORPORATIONS There was no dispute, and I am satisfied, that the preconditions contained in s 206F(1)(a) and (b) of the Act were satisfied. Under s 206F(2)(a) of the Act, in determining whether disqualification is justified, regard must be had to whether any of the corporations mentioned in subsection (1) were related to one another. I accept ASIC’s contention that a related corporation includes a body corporate related by virtue of s 50 of the Act.[8] Under this provision body corporates are related where one is the holding company or subsidiary of the other. That is not the case here. [8] Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), s 9. Further, for the purposes of s 206F of the Act, body corporates may also be related if they are related operationally,[9] or they are a part of one failure.[10] [9] Quinlivan v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2010] FCAFC 161 (“Quinlivan”), [39].[10] Re Andrews v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2006] AATA 25, [23]. ASIC contends that none of the eleven corporations were related operationally in that they were established for distinct purposes and, so far as they carried on business, were involved in distinct projects.[11] [11] Respondent’s SFIC, [19]. I accept this, except in respect of Ruark Properties, described as “the managing entity for all projects and [to have] failed with the projects it managed”, and Residual Finance, said to have been “the finance company for the projects”.[12] These corporations were operationally related at least to some of the other failed entities. [12] Exhibit 1, T documents, T5, page 1220. ASIC also contends that the eleven corporations were not part of the one failure. In this respect Mr Gilbert attributed the failures of all the corporations to three main factors: ·an alleged failure by Westpac Bank to advance a loan that was promised; ·the downturn in the mining industry; and ·his own bankruptcy (consequent upon personal guarantees) which prevented him from attending to the affairs of the corporations.[13] [13] Transcript 7 November 2019, page 4.37-47. This is Mr Gilbert’s view of events but I am not satisfied that it is correct. There was no “promised” loan from Westpac as Mr Gilbert alleges. I will refer to this in more detail below. As to the second factor, I am satisfied the corporations, for the most part, were involved in different projects. None of them were directly involved in or dependent on mining. The most that can be said, as Mr Archer states, is that Mr Gilbert in respect of some projects or developments counted “on the perceived profitability of the mining industry” and “demand from [miners].”[14] I am satisfied that Mr Gilbert has overstated these matters in the collapse of the corporations. [14] Exhibit 4, Affidavit of Nathan John Archer, [7].