Gerah Imports Pty Ltd v The Duke Group Ltd (in Liquidation)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

GERAH IMPORTS PTY LTD v THE DUKE GROUP LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)

[2012] SASC 63

Reasons for Decision of The Honourable Justice Sulan

18 April 2012

CORPORATIONS - WINDING UP - CONDUCT AND INCIDENTS OF WINDING UP - APPLICATIONS TO COURT FOR DIRECTIONS OR ADVICE

Application by liquidator for directions pursuant to s 379(3) of the Companies (South Australia) Code - originally an insolvent liquidation - intangible assets were recovered to achieve a surplus - all creditors paid in full - surplus available for distribution - liquidator previously called for proofs of debt from potential shareholder claimants who were unable to prove in the insolvent administration - extent of liquidator's duties to provide information to potential claimants and to respond to queries - form of information to be given to shareholders.

Companies (South Australia) Code s 379(3), s 387, s 438, s 438(1), s 438(2); Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 82(2); Corporations Act 2000 (Cth) s 439A, referred to.
Sons of Gwalia Ltd (subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) v Margaretic (2007) 231 CLR 160; Re Kershaw [2005] NSWSC 313; Re ION Ltd (2010) 80 ACSR 302; [2010] FCA 1119, discussed.
Gerah Imports Pty Ltd v Duke Group Ltd (in liq) (2004) 88 SASR 419; Re Sullivans Cove IXL Nominees Pty Ltd; Crawford v de Kantzow (No 2) [2011] TASSC 53; Re Allebart Pty Ltd (in liquidation) and The Companies Act [1971] 1 NSWLR 24, considered.

GERAH IMPORTS PTY LTD v THE DUKE GROUP LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)
[2012] SASC 63

  1. SULAN J: This is an application by the liquidator of The Duke Group Limited (in liquidation) (“the Duke Group”, “the Company”) for directions pursuant to s 379(3) of the Companies (South Australia) Code (“the Code”). 

  2. At the hearing of the application, representatives appeared for the shareholders of the Company and Genoa Resources and Investment Limited (in liquidation) (“GRAIL”), a creditor making a claim for post-liquidation interest.  GRAIL was granted leave by a Master of this Court on 17 November 2011 to be heard on the application without becoming a party.  Further orders were made on 23 December 2011 and 27 January 2012 determining that it is appropriate for shareholders to be represented at the application.

    Background

  3. Mr John Sheahan was appointed provisional liquidator of the Duke Group on 30 May 1989 and official liquidator on 11 July 1989 by order of this Court.   

  4. At the date of liquidation, the Company had no tangible assets and debts of approximately $35 million.  The liquidator successfully brought two sets of proceedings which resulted in the payment in full of the creditors’ claims which had been allowed by the liquidator.  As at January 2000, after the creditors had been paid in full, there was a surplus of funds in the liquidation.  There remained substantial claims by seven creditors, admitted by the liquidator, for post-liquidation interest (“the PLI Creditors”).[1]  These claims, in combination, exceed the $10 million currently held by the liquidator.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gerah Imports Pty Ltd v The Duke Group Ltd (in Liquidation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Gerah Imports Pty Ltd v The Duke Group Ltd (in Liquidation) involved the liquidator of The Duke Group Ltd, Mr John Sheahan, applying to the Supreme Court of South Australia for directions concerning potential claims by the company's shareholders. These claims, if admissible, would take priority over the outstanding claims by creditors for post-liquidation interest. The application was heard by The Honourable Justice Sulan, who provided directions on the procedure the liquidator should adopt to notify prospective creditors of the right to lodge a proof of debt in the liquidation.
The legal issues before the court were the extent of the liquidator's duties to provide information to potential claimants and the form of information to be given to shareholders. The court was required to determine the appropriate procedure for notifying shareholders of the right to lodge a proof of debt and whether the liquidator should take further action to identify claims by shareholders whose previous correspondence had been returned unopened. Additionally, the court considered whether it was sufficient for the liquidator to publish a Notice of Intention to Declare a Dividend in the Gazette and on the Liquidator’s website.
The court held that it was appropriate and justified for the liquidator to adopt the procedure outlined in the directions, including sending a circular to shareholders in the form annexed to the orders and expanding the Liquidator’s website to contain information on how to complete and formally lodge a proof of debt, the Defendant’s share register as at the date of liquidation, and all legal advice received by the liquidator relating to the admissibility of Sons of Gwalia-type claims. The court also determined that it was sufficient for the liquidator to discharge his duties under Companies Regulation 137 by publishing a Notice of Intention to Declare a Dividend in the Gazette and on the Liquidator’s website. The costs of the liquidator, Genoa Resources and Investment Limited (in liquidation) and the shareholder representative on the application were ordered to be costs in the liquidation.
In summary, the court provided clear directions to the liquidator on the procedure to be followed in notifying shareholders of the right to lodge a proof of debt in the liquidation and the information to be provided to shareholders. The court also confirmed that it was sufficient for the liquidator to publish a Notice of Intention to Declare a Dividend in the Gazette and on the Liquidator’s website. The case serves as a useful guide for liquidators dealing with similar situations in future cases.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

At the hearing of the application, representatives appeared for the shareholders of the Company and Genoa Resources and Investment Limited (in liquidation) (“GRAIL”), a creditor making a claim for post-liquidation interest. GRAIL was granted leave by a Master of this Court on 17 November 2011 to be heard on the application without becoming a party. Further orders were made on 23 December 2011 and 27 January 2012 determining that it is appropriate for shareholders to be represented at the application. Background Mr John Sheahan was appointed provisional liquidator of the Duke Group on 30 May 1989 and official liquidator on 11 July 1989 by order of this Court. At the date of liquidation, the Company had no tangible assets and debts of approximately $35 million. The liquidator successfully brought two sets of proceedings which resulted in the payment in full of the creditors’ claims which had been allowed by the liquidator. As at January 2000, after the creditors had been paid in full, there was a surplus of funds in the liquidation. There remained substantial claims by seven creditors, admitted by the liquidator, for post-liquidation interest (“the PLI Creditors”).[1] These claims, in combination, exceed the $10 million currently held by the liquidator.[1] The liquidator admitted the post-liquidation interest claims in the amount of approximately $56 million. In 2004, the Full Court considered, as a case stated, the liquidator’s application for directions as to the manner with which he should deal with the claims for post-liquidation interest.[2] In accordance with the directions of the Full Court, a further dividend of $8 million was paid in respect of these claims to the PLI Creditors. [2] Gerah Imports Pty Ltd v Duke Group Ltd (in liq) (2004) 88 SASR 419. Following the decision of the High Court of Australia in Sons of Gwalia Ltd (subject to Deed of Company Arrangement) v Margaretic,[3] the liquidator applied to a Master of this Court for directions concerning potential claims by the Company’s shareholders, claims which, if admissible, would take priority over the outstanding claims of the PLI Creditors.[4] There is no dispute between the parties, for the purposes of this application, that such shareholder claims as identified in Sons of Gwalia Ltd would take priority over claims by the PLI Creditors. [3] (2007) 231 CLR 160.[4] Re Kershaw [2005] NSWSC 313. Pursuant to orders made on 28 November 2007, the liquidator published, and posted to certain shareholders, notices in The Australian and The Times newspaper in the United Kingdom. The liquidator received 37 proofs of debt that were adjudicated upon pursuant to s 438(2) of the Code. In September 2010, the liquidator applied to the Court for further directions. On 12 November 2010, the Court directed that it is sufficient for the liquidator to discharge his duties to notify creditors to submit formal proofs of debt by: ·giving written notice to the last known address of the shareholders who, having regard to the legal advice received, might have claims;·cause to be published a notice in The Australian newspaper and a daily newspaper circulating in every jurisdiction disclosed by shareholders on the share register of the Company as their address for notification.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The costs of the liquidator and the other parties on this application be costs in the liquidation.Conclusion Following my hearing of the application, I provided counsel with a draft of the directions I was minded to make in line with these reasons. I heard further submissions from the parties as to the exact form the directions would take. The order setting out my directions and the circular to be sent to shareholders is annexed to these reasons. I order that the costs of the liquidator, Genoa Resources and Investment Limited (in liquidation) and the shareholder representatives on the application be costs in the liquidation.ORDERJudicial Officer(s): The Honourable Justice SulanDate of application: 27 September 2011Application made by: Mr John Sheahan in his capacity as Liquidator of the Defendant (the Liquidator)Date(s) of hearing: 28 March and 16 April 2012 Date of order: 17 April 2012Appearances: RJ Whitington QC and SJ Doyle for the Liquidator BC Roberts for Genoa Resources and Investment Limited (In Liquidation)MC Livesey QC and PJ Adams for the Representative of the Shareholders of the DefendantTHE COURT DIRECTS that:1.It is appropriate and justified for the Liquidator to adopt the following procedure to notify prospective creditors of the Defendant of the right to lodge a proof in the liquidation of the Defendant, namely send a circular to shareholders in substantially the form attached as Annexure A to these Orders (“Circular”), which should be mailed by ordinary pre-paid post to the postal address last known to the Liquidator from the Defendant’s records of those shareholders who were sent the Liquidator’s notice dated 23 February 2011, with the exception of those shareholders to whom such notice was returned unopened or undeliverable and those who have previously lodged a formal proof of debt.2.It is appropriate and justified for the Liquidator to do nothing further to identify a claim in respect of shareholders whose previous correspondence has been returned unopened. 3.It is appropriate and justified for the Liquidator to expand the Liquidator’s website to contain the following:a.General advice on the procedural nature of how to complete and formally lodge a proof of debt in the liquidation;b.The Defendant’s share register as at the date of liquidation;c.All of the legal advice received by the Liquidator relating to the admissibility of Sons of Gwalia-type claims as exhibited to the affidavits of the Liquidator sworn 14 September 2010 and 27 September 2011; andd.A statement that the website does not purport to give the shareholders legal advice and that they should seek their own legal advice if required.4.The Liquidator should allow 28 days after the posting of the Circular for relevant persons to lodge any new or varied proofs of debt. After this date, the Liquidator is not required to take further action either to inform shareholders of any right to prove in the winding up or to elicit any proof or claim from such shareholders even if there is no response or the mail is returned unopened. 5.After completion of the process referred to in paragraphs 1-4 above it would be appropriate and justified for the Liquidator to proceed with and complete the winding up of the Defendant on the footing that any claim for a shareholder or shareholders not lodged by way of formal proof of debt under regulation 120 has not been and will not be proved in the winding up, that the property otherwise divisible amongst any such potential claimants shall be available for application and distribution in the winding up and that no further steps need be taken either to inform shareholders of any right to prove in the winding up or to elicit any proof or claim from any such shareholders.6.It is sufficient for the Liquidator to discharge his duties under Companies Regulation 137, to publish a Notice of Intention to Declare a Dividend, in accordance with Form 142, in the Gazette and on the Liquidator’s website.7.The costs of the Liquidator, Genoa Resources and Investment Limited (in liquidation) and the shareholder representative on the application be costs in the liquidation.Annexure ACIRCULAR TO SHAREHOLDERSTHE DUKE GROUP LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION)(FORMERLY KIA ORA GOLD CORPORATION NL)On 11 July 1989 The Duke Group Limited (Duke) was placed into liquidation by order of the Supreme Court of South Australia (Court) and I was appointed Duke’s Liquidator. Until 1988 Duke was named Kia Ora Gold Corporation NL (Kia Ora). I have previously called for and admitted claims by creditors owed debts by Duke as at the date of my appointment. Following the decision of the High Court of Australia in Sons of Gwalia Ltd v Margaretic (2007) 231 CLR 160 and following directions made by the Court, notices were published inviting claims by shareholders of Duke. As directed by the Court, notices inviting claims were sent to those shareholders at their last known addresses, whose shareholding arose as a result of the takeover by Kia Ora (as Duke was then known) of Western United Limited in 1987 as it was considered only those shareholders might be able to make a claim against Duke that was admissible in the winding up of Duke in insolvency.All admitted claims as at the date of liquidation have been paid in full. There remain approximately AUD [insert current amount] available to creditors in the liquidation. Accordingly, Duke has been returned to a condition of solvency for the purposes of considering claims by creditors of Duke, including shareholders of Duke.A number of shareholders of Duke have written to me in terms that either:(a)do not make clear whether or not the claim is to be pressed; and/or(b)expressed disinclination to press a claim but do so apparently on the basis of some misapprehension as to the procedure for pressing a claim and/or the basis upon which it might be pressed.As a result of the responses received from shareholders referred to above, I obtained further orders from the Court seeking directions to communicate further with those shareholders and to circulate one final notice informing all shareholders of their right to lodge a claim in the liquidation of Duke.Which shareholders may have a claim? You may have a claim in the liquidation of Duke for the reduction in the value of your shares following two takeovers completed by Kia Ora Gold Corporation NL (as Duke was then called) in 1987 and 1988. Specifically, shareholders who held shares immediately before Kia Ora’s:1.takeover of Western United in 1987 may have a claim for 37 cents per share held; and2.acquisition of the assets of the Duke Holdings Limited Group of Companies may have a claim for 21 cents per share held.Additional information to assist in completing a formal Proof of Debt, if applicable, is available on the website you should do if you wish to make a claim in the liquidation of Duke?If you wish to make a claim in the liquidation of Duke, you need to complete and sign a Proof of Debt form and lodge the form with me by [insert date]. A Proof of Debt form is available from You should also attach to the Proof of Debt form copies of share certificates and any other documents you still have relating to your acquisition of shares in Kia Ora / Duke.Attached to this Circular is an example of a completed Proof of Debt form. Information from Duke’s share register is available to confirm the number of shares held by each shareholder as at 11 July 1989, being the date that I was appointed Liquidator of Duke (and therefore the relevant date for provable claims in the liquidation of Duke). However, the Share Registry does not assist in determining how many shares were held at earlier dates (including the dates of the takeover of Western United in 1987 and the acquisition of the assets of the Duke Holdings Limited group of companies in 1988). You should send a copy of the completed Proof of Debt to me by [insert date]. After that date, I intend to declare a final dividend. Any Proofs of Debt received after [insert date] may not be admitted to proof.Neither I nor the website purports to give any shareholder of Duke legal advice. I recommend that any shareholder who is uncertain whether they have a claim in the liquidation of Duke, or how to make a claim, should seek legal advice.Attached to the website is:(a)a copy of Duke’s share registry as at the date of Duke’s liquidation;(b)the legal advice obtained by me relating to the admissibility of shareholders’ claims; and(c)a Proof of Debt form to be completed by any shareholder or other creditor of Duke wishing to submit a claim. Dated this day of April 2012 John SheahanLiquidator

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established