Georges v Seaborn International Pty Ltd (Trustee)

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Georges v Seaborn International Pty Ltd (Trustee) [2012] FCA 294

Citation: Georges v Seaborn International Pty Ltd (Trustee) [2012] FCA 294
Parties: GEORGE GEORGES IN HIS CAPACITY AS JOINT AND SEVERAL LIQUIDATOR OF SONRAY CAPITAL MARKETS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 104 482 993, JOHN ROSS LINDHOLM IN HIS CAPACITY AS JOINT AND SEVERAL LIQUIDATOR OF SONRAY CAPITAL MARKETS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 104 482 993 and SONRAY CAPITAL MARKETS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION) ACN 104 482 993 v SEABORN INTERNATIONAL PTY LTD ABN 24 114 085 090 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE SEABORN FAMILY TRUST, MARYLAND PTY LTD ACN 150 886 427 AS TRUSTEE FOR THE NORWEGIAN TRUST, ALISTANTE PTY LTD ACN 067 268 802, BON RIVER PTY LTD ACN 059 666 750, ROLAND MARK WARD AS TRUSTEE FOR THE AWARD SUPERANNUATION FUND ABN 66 473 078 418 EFAX PTY LTD ACN 001 886 120, EAGLE SECURITIES LIMITED and ROBERT JOSEPH SCOLARO
File numbers: VID 160 of 2012
VID 250 of 2012
VID 193 of 2012
Judges: MURPHY J
Date of judgment: 26 March 2012
Catchwords: APPEAL – Application for leave to appeal – whether order for directions was final or interlocutory - application for leave to appeal by non party – refusal of application to be appointed as a representative in the proceedings
Legislation: Corporations Act2001 (Cth)
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth)
Trustee Act 1958 (Vic)
Cases cited: Bishopsgate Investment Management Ltd (In Liquidation) v Homan [1995] Ch 211 at 217
Brady v Stapleton [1952] 88 CLR 322
Carr v Finance Corp of Australia (No 1) (1981) 147 CLR 246
Commonwealth of Australia v Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union (2000) 98 FCR 31
Cuthbertson v Hobart Corporation (1921) 30 CLR 16
Décor Corporation Pty Limited v Dart Industries Inc (1991) 33 FCR 397
Fortress Credit Corporation (Australia) II Pty Ltd v Fletcher & Ors (2011) 281 ALR 38
Georges v Seaborn International (Trustee) in the matter of Sonray Capital Markets Pty Ltd (in liquidation) [2012] FCA 75
In Re Buckton [1907] 2 Ch 406
In ReGoldcorp Exchange Ltd (In Receivership) [1995] 1 AC 74 (PC)
InRe Securities Insurance Company [1894] 2 Ch 410
In Re The Earl of Radnor’s Will Trusts (1890) LR 45 Ch D 402
Johnston v Cameron (2002) 124 FCR 160
Meadow Springs Fairway Resort Ltd (in liq) v Balanced Securities Ltd (2007) 25 ACLC 1,433
Primary Securities Ltd (recs & mgrs apptd) (in liq) v Saker (2010) 191 FCR 277
Re G.B. Nathan & Co Pty Ltd (In liq) (1991) 24 NSWLR 674
Re The Black Stump Enterprises Pty Ltd and Associated Companies (2005) 228 ALR 591
Sons of Gwalia v Margaretic (2006) 232 ALR 119; [2006] FCAFC 92
Warburton v Altson (1889) 15 VLR 94
Wills v Australian Broadcasting Corporation (2009) 173 FCR 284
Date of hearing: 21 March 2012
Date of last submissions: 21 March 2012
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 86
In VID 160 of…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Georges v Seaborn International Pty Ltd (Trustee) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 294
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerns applications for leave to appeal from interlocutory orders made by the Federal Court in a complex administration matter. The primary issue was whether the orders for directions were final or interlocutory and if leave to appeal was required. Additionally, the court had to decide if a non-party could be appointed as a representative in the proceedings. The liquidators and Eagle Securities Limited sought leave to appeal from the Court's directions concerning the distribution of shares held by Efax Pty Ltd and other Sonray Client accounts. They argued that the directions were erroneous because the Court misunderstood their application for directions for pooling the shares rather than a claim for a beneficial interest. The Court found the appeal grounds to be arguable and granted leave to appeal. The Court also decided that the directions, although interlocutory in form, were final in substance, which lowered the threshold for granting leave. Mr Scolaro, who was not a party to the proceedings, applied to be appointed as a representative and to be granted leave to appeal. The Court found that Mr Scolaro was not a party and refused his application for leave to appeal. The Court dismissed Mr Scolaro's application to be appointed as a representative in the proceedings, finding that his position was appropriately represented by the contradictors appointed as defendants. The Court also granted an extension of time for Eagle Securities Limited to apply for leave to appeal. The final orders granted leave to appeal to the liquidators and Eagle Securities Limited, refused Mr Scolaro's application for leave to appeal, and dismissed his application to be appointed as a representative in the proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants be granted leave to appeal from the directions of the Court on 10 February 2012 in proceeding VID 562 of 2010 insofar as they relate to Part E6 paragraphs 249-285 of the Reasons for Judgment in respect of Efax Pty Ltd and like Sonray Client accounts.

2. The appeal be expedited to be heard on a date as soon as possible together with the appeal in VID 250 of 2012 – Eagle Securities Limited v Efax Pty Ltd & Ors.

3. Liberty to apply.

THE COURT DIRECTS THAT:

4. The liquidators are justified and are acting reasonably in appealing the directions of the Court on 10 February 2012 in proceeding VID 562 of 2010 insofar as they relate to Part E6 paragraphs 249-285 of the Reasons for Judgment in respect of Efax Pty Ltd and like Sonray Client accounts.

5. The liquidators are entitled to be indemnified out of the property and funds they hold on trust in respect of their remuneration and expenses of this application and the appeal.

6. The sixth respondent Efax Pty Ltd is entitled to be indemnified out of the Segregated Accounts for its expenses reasonably incurred in respect of this application and the appeal, in accordance with the Indemnity Costs Protocol filed by the liquidators in proceeding VID 562 of 2010.

Capitalised terms in this Order are as defined in the Reasons for Judgment in proceeding VID 562 of 2010.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

1. The time for service of the application for extension of time and leave to appeal be abridged to 1 day.

2. The time for filing the application for leave to appeal be extended until 20 March 2012.

3. The applicant be granted leave to appeal from the directions of the Court on 10 February 2012 in proceeding VID 562 of 2010 insofar as they relate to Part E6 paragraphs 249-285 of the Reasons for Judgment in respect of Efax Pty Ltd and like Sonray Client accounts.

4. The appeal be expedited to be heard on a date as soon as possible and together with the appeal in VID 160 of 2012 – George Georges (in his capacity as joint and several liquidator of Sonray Capital Markets Pty Ltd (in liquidation) and Ors v Seaborn International Pty Ltd (as trustee for the Seaborn Family Trust) & Ors.

5. The application to be appointed as a party in a representative capacity is dismissed.

6. Liberty to apply.

THE COURT DIRECTS THAT:

7. The applicant is entitled to be indemnified out of the Segregated Accounts for its expenses reasonably incurred in respect of the appeal from the date that it is filed, and in accordance with the Indemnity Costs Protocol filed by the liquidators in proceeding VID 562 of 2010.

8. The first respondent is entitled to be indemnified out of the Segregated Accounts for its expenses reasonably incurred in respect this application and the appeal, in accordance with the Indemnity Costs Protocol filed by the liquidators in proceeding VID 562 of 2010.

9. The liquidators are entitled to be indemnified out of the property and funds they hold on trust in respect of their remuneration and expenses of this application and the appeal.

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

The applicant’s submissions in the appeal are to be restricted to;

(i) those matters not dealt with by the liquidators, and

(ii) the contention that Sonray Clients (including the applicant and Efax) who paid monies into Tainted Segregated Accounts have a beneficial interest which may be traced or followed into the BHP Shares.

Capitalised terms in this Order are as defined in the Reasons for Judgment in proceeding VID 562 of 2010.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

1. The application for leave to appeal be dismissed.

2. There be no order for costs against the applicant.

3. The liquidators are entitled to be indemnified out of the property and funds they hold on trust in respect of their remuneration and expenses of this application.

4. The ninth respondent Efax Pty Ltd is entitled to be indemnified out of the Segregated Accounts for its expenses reasonably incurred in respect of this application, in accordance with the Indemnity Costs Protocol filed by the liquidators in proceeding VID 562 of 2010.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Based on these facts, the Court made directions that the Efax shares were not within the administration, and therefore should be delivered to Efax in specie instead of being placed into the pooled fund to be rateably distributed to all relevant Sonray Clients.Background relevant to Scolaro application It is uncontroversial that Mr Scolaro and his company Travel Arcade Pty Ltd are Sonray Clients. The Court received written submissions from them at first instance. Mr Scolaro and Travel Arcade traded through Sonray on the Interactive Brokers trading platform. He contends that Travel Arcade was the only investor who transferred shorted exchange traded options to Interactive Brokers at the same time that shares were transferred. He says that the funds were transferred directly to Interactive Brokers and did not go through a Tainted Segregated Account. Accordingly he argues that this investment should be treated in an identified manner and not be put into the pooled fund. Mr Scolaro contends that his and Travel Arcade’s position is unique but the Court found that the position of Mr Scolaro and Travel Arcade was appropriately represented by the contradictors appointed as defendants. It did find one unusual feature of Travel Arcade’s claim but considered that the factual differences could be dealt with at the adjudication stage provided for by the orders. Mr Scolaro argues that he is a party and he is described as a party in the judgment. If he is not a party he now seeks to be made one, and seeks leave to appeal.The results in the applications The proposed appeals by the liquidators and Eagle seek to overturn only the discrete part of the judgment which relates to the Efax shares. For the reasons I set out I have determined to grant an extension of time within which Eagle may apply for leave to appeal. I have determined to grant leave to appeal to the liquidators and Eagle. I have refused Eagle’s application to be appointed in a representative capacity. I have found that Mr Scolaro is not a party. I have determined to refuse his application for leave to appeal. Despite his lack of success I have made no costs order against him. The respondents did not seek that I do so. IS LEAVE TO APPEAL REQUIREDThe liquidators’ position The liquidators consider that leave to appeal is necessary because s 24(1A) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (“FCA”) requires leave before an appeal can be brought from an interlocutory judgment. There is some question as to whether directions by a court to a liquidator or to a trustee under s 511 of the Corporations Act or s 63 of the Trustee Act constitute final or interlocutory relief, and accordingly whether leave is required. In Re The Black Stump Enterprises Pty Ltd and Associated Companies (2005) 228 ALR 591 an appeal against directions to a liquidator was heard with no mention of a requirement for leave to appeal. In the trustee case In Re The Earl of Radnor’s Will Trusts (1890) LR 45 Ch D 402 that appeal too was heard without reference to leave having been sought or granted.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

A table at [286] of the judgement records that Mr Scolaro and Travel Arcade are substantial claimants, with their trading account balances with Sonray providing a total claim of $783,219.57. I was provided with no information as to the effect of the directions on the quantum of any entitlement, although the directions do not apparently affect the whole claim. If I presume for the purposes of this application that the whole of the claim is affected by the directions, then the applicants stand to receive about $399,442 or 51% of that amount if the directions stand, and about $485,596 or 62% if the directions are successfully appealed. For an individual claimant such as Mr Scolaro the difference would amount to a substantial injustice if the judgment is wrong, but I have insufficient information to decide this question. Nothing turns on this because, as I set out, I have determined to reject Mr Scolaro’s application for leave on the other discretionary grounds.Is the decision in regard to the Efax sub-class attended with sufficient doubt This case is one where, while the Court’s decision is interlocutory in form, it is final in substance. In such circumstances, the threshold for a grant of leave is not high: Johnston at [8]; Wills v Australian Broadcasting Corporation (2009) 173 FCR 284 per Rares J at [31] with whom North and Emmett JJ agreed. I do not presume to form a view as to the probability of success of the proposed appeals by the liquidators and Eagle with regard to the shares of the Efax Sub-class. The matter is complex, the Court’s judgment at first instance is detailed and considered, and the arguments for the liquidators and Eagle on the one hand and Efax on the other each have some force. However, in my view the appeal grounds are arguable and leave should be granted. Liquidators and Eagles’ proposed appeal ground 1 The liquidators and Eagle contend that the learned primary judge treated the application for directions, in relation to the BHP shares ordered by Efax, as a claim by Sonray to a legal or beneficial interest in or right to those shares in its own right in competition with Efax. They point to the transcript at [T-182] and [T-211] to show that their application was for a direction that the shares be pooled for the benefit of investors. They contend that at all times the contest was between Sonray Clients who had all contributed to a mixed fund such as the relevant Tainted Segregated Account (or any common pool that might include that Tainted Segregated Account) as against those of that class who believe that they had purchased shares. As at the date of administration the liquidators and Eagle argue there is a pool of investors that claim beneficial ownership of these assets in common, and that their claim is not about who has a better title. They argue that the Court did not determine the real question raised by the liquidators, or at least misunderstood their submissions on a core issue, and therefore erred: Warburton v Altson (1889) 15 VLR 94.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The funds and assets of the Sonray Clients, most of which are or were the subject of a statutory trust or trusts (s 981B of the Corporations Act2001 (Cth) (“the Corporations Act”)) of which Sonray is trustee were spread over a number of Segregated Accounts with various financial institutions (as defined in the judgment), nominated in various currencies with numerous shareholdings and open trading positions held by or with a range of third party institutions and custodians. The investor’s funds and assets held on trust (save for Distinguishable Accounts as defined in the judgment) were mixed from the outset and the subject of thousands of authorised deposits, withdrawals and transfers and other dealings. Unfortunately for the Sonray Clients, the trust funds and assets were subject to substantial unauthorised withdrawals, dealings and tradings over some years, resulting in a deficiency of $45.6m. The liquidators were appointed administrators of Sonray on 22 June 2010 and became the liquidators on 27 October 2010. They achieved recoveries from various parties, including the principal recovery from Saxo Bank A/S) (“Saxo”) and the HLB Mann Judd (Vic) Partnership. Under this settlement reached in October 2011, those two parties agreed to pay Sonray $18.5 million, to release all shares (and dividends relating to those shares) held on account by Saxo, having been purchased by Sonray on instructions from its clients (“Saxo Shares”), and agreed not to prove in the liquidation in respect of any claims they had. These recoveries together with the other trust funds and assets are for distribution in the administration. There were a number of different agreements between Sonray and Sonray Clients, and between Sonray and third party providers. Sonray Clients had conflicting characterisations of the legal relationship between the parties arising from the terms and conditions of the agreements. The funds and assets of Sonray had been subject to unauthorised trading and dealing by Sonray which its clients considered affected their funds and assets differently. This led to conflicting views and claims amongst the Sonray Clients as to their respective entitlements to the trust funds and assets or parts of those funds and assets. Some Sonray Clients assert an entitlement to trace or claim directly against a particular fund or asset which they contend should not be included in any pool. Other Sonray Clients accept that the available funds and assets should be pooled and any distribution made to them rateably. In an attempt to deal with these competing claims the liquidators applied to the Court pursuant to s 511 of the Corporations Act and s 63 of the Trustee Act 1958 (Vic) (“the Trustee Act”) for directions and other relief. The directions sought included directions for pooling of various funds and assets. The Court joined five Sonray Clients as defendants to provide the necessary contradictors to the course proposed by the Liquidators. It also heard submissions from Mr Robert Scolaro and Travel Arcade Pty Ltd pursuant to r 2.13 of the Federal Court Corporations Rules 2000.Facts relevant to the three applicationsEagle Securities