[2014] TASSC 23
COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
CITATION: Gadon v Police Review Board [2014] TASSC 23
PARTIES: GADON, Joseph Reonal
v
POLICE REVIEW BOARD
COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
FILE NO: 1235/2013
DELIVERED ON: 16 May 2014
DELIVERED AT: Hobart
HEARING DATE/S: 6 May 2014
JUDGMENT OF: Porter J
CATCHWORDS:
Administrative Law – Administrative Tribunals – Functions of tribunals – Police Review Board – Review of decisions of Police Commissioner relating to disciplinary matters – Nature of review – Review is a merits review and not an appeal by way of rehearing in which error needs to be shown.
Aust Dig Administrative Law [1096]
Police – Internal administration – Discipline and dismissal for misconduct – Tasmania – Police Review Board – Review of decisions of Police Commissioner relating to disciplinary matters – Nature of review – Review is a merits review and not an appeal by way of rehearing in which error needs to be shown.
Aust Dig Police [1020]
Police Service Act 2003 (Tas), s60.
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Applicant: M E O'Farrell SC
Second Respondent: P Turner
Solicitors:
Applicant: Wallace Wilkinson & Webster
First Respondents: Director of Public Prosecutions
Second Respondent: Director of Public Prosecutions
Judgment Number: [2014] TASSC 23
Number of paragraphs: 42
Serial No 23/2014
File No 1235/2013
JOSEPH REONAL GADON v POLICE REVIEW BOARD
and COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT PORTER J
16 May 2014
Introduction
This application for judicial review concerns the nature of a "review" of a decision relating to a disciplinary matter under the Police Service Act 2003 ("the Act"). Such a review is carried out by the Police Review Board. Relevantly, under the Act the Board is to determine applications for the review of decisions, determinations, orders or recommendations which have been made by the Commissioner of Police in respect of specified disciplinary matters. Termination of an appointment as a police officer is one of those matters.
The applicant was a constable in the Police Service. On 22 May 2013, the Commissioner terminated the applicant's appointment as a police officer. On 24 May 2013, the applicant sought a review by the Board of the termination of his appointment. On 29 November 2013, after hearing submissions, the Board effectively determined that the nature of the review which it was to carry out was not an unlimited merits review, but a review which required the applicant to demonstrate error on the part of the Commissioner. To the extent that the Commissioner's decision was discretionary, the Board determined that the applicant needed to show that the exercise of the discretion had miscarried.
The applicant seeks judicial review of that determination. There is no dispute that, by its determination, the Board has engaged in reviewable conduct within the meaning of s18 of the Judicial Review Act 2000. The applicant contends that the Act requires the Board to carry out a full merits review. The Board has submitted to the Court's jurisdiction. The Commissioner appeared by counsel and contends…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gadon v Police Review Board and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2014] TASSC 23
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the review by the Police Review Board is a merits review, not an appeal by way of rehearing. This means that the Board is not limited to identifying errors in the decision-making process but can instead assess the merits of the case anew. This conclusion was based on the language used in the legislation, which refers to "review" rather than "appeal," and the general nature of these terms. The court also noted that the Police Review Board has the authority to consider new material and make orders as necessary to give effect to its decision. The Board's review is not confined to identifying errors but can involve a full reassessment of the case.
The court's decision clarified the scope of the Police Review Board's powers and the nature of its review process. By confirming that the Board conducts a merits review, the court ensured that the Board can fully assess the merits of disciplinary decisions made by the Police Commissioner. This approach allows for a more comprehensive review and can lead to fairer outcomes for police officers facing disciplinary action. The court also emphasised the importance of considering new material and the Board's ability to make orders to enforce its decisions.
The final orders of the court confirmed the Board's authority to conduct a merits review, consider new material, and make orders as necessary. The court's decision provides clarity for both the Police Review Board and police officers involved in disciplinary proceedings, ensuring that the review process is fair and comprehensive.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The question of new material is dealt with separately in s75C. That provides as follows:"75C Provision and consideration of new material (1) If a police officer, in respect of whom a recommendation is made under section 30 or an action or determination is taken or made under section 31 or section 43(3) — (a) lodges an application for review; and(b) subsequently becomes aware of new material relevant to the Commissioner's recommendation, action or determination before the matter is finalised by the Police Review Board; and(c) intends to rely on that material –the officer is to submit that material to the Commissioner. (2) If the Commissioner intends to rely on material in addition to that already supplied by or to the police officer referred to in subsection (1), the Commissioner, subject to the requirements of any other relevant legislation, is to provide that material to the police officer — (a) not less than 7 days before the review; or(b) if the material is not available within that period, as soon as practicable after the material becomes available.(3) The Commissioner must consider any new material submitted to him or her under subsection (1) within 7 days after its submission, unless of the opinion that the new material should be considered by the Police Review Board. (4) The Commissioner or the applicant may apply to the Police Review Board for a matter to be deferred for a reasonable period to allow for any new material to be considered." What the Board may do on the determination of the application for review is set out in s75A(2) and (3). Subsection (2) is a general provision, whilst subs(3) provides that, without limiting subs(2), specified orders (which relate to certain types of case) may be made. Subsection (2) provides as follows:"(2) On determining an application for review under Division 3, the Police Review Board may uphold the application for review in whole or in part, or may dismiss the application, and may make such orders as it considers necessary or desirable for the purpose of giving effect to its decision." Section 75(4) makes "final" the Board's decision upon the determination of the application for review. Also of some significance is s75(6) which requires the Board, when determining an issue of remuneration, to take into account any employment undertaken and income received by an applicant during a period of suspension or termination. Lastly, in this analysis, I note s75B which gives to the applicant or the Commissioner a right of appeal against a decision of the Board, but only on a point of law. Parliament has adopted the use of the word "review" rather than "appeal" to describe both the Board itself and the process which the Board conducts. "The word 'review', like the word 'appeal', is general, and, on that account, somewhat elastic. It takes colour from its context.": Victoria Legal Aid v Kuek [2010] VSCA 29 per Buchanan JA (with whom Weinberg JA and Ross AJA agreed) at [21]. A so-called "merits review" can be restricted or confined in some way, and as explained by Glass JA in Turnbull v New South Wales Medical Board [1976] 2 NSWLR 281 at 297, the concept of an appeal can have at least six manifestations. One of those is a full hearing de novo.