JURISDICTION : SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
IN CHAMBERS
CITATION: G & R ROSSEN PTY LTD -v- BUCHANAN [2019] WASC 373
CORAM: KENNETH MARTIN J
HEARD: 20 SEPTEMBER 2019
DELIVERED : 16 OCTOBER 2019
FILE NO/S: CIV 1898 of 2016
BETWEEN: G & R ROSSEN PTY LTD
Plaintiff
AND
PETA ANN BUCHANAN
Defendant
Catchwords:
Practice and procedure - Application for further and better discovery - Redacted documents - Relevance of redacted information - Relevance to equitable account of profits against defendant - Further and better discovery ordered
Costs - Application for security for costs - Whether jurisdictional threshold of s 1335(1) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) is met - Alleged delay - Reason to believe inability to pay legal costs - Further security ordered - Turns on own facts
Legislation:
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Result:
Plaintiff's application for further and better discovery granted in part
Plaintiff to provide security for the defendant's costs in the further amount of $75,000
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Plaintiff | : | Mr P Mendelow |
| Defendant | : | Mr J M Healy |
Solicitors:
| Plaintiff | : | Williams & Hughes |
| Defendant | : | Bailiwick Legal |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Christou v Stanton Partners Australasia Pty Ltd [2011] WASCA 176
FFE Minerals Australia Pty Ltd v Mining Australia Pty Ltd [2000] WASCA 69
Fiduciary Ltd v Morningstar Research Pty Ltd [2004] NSWSC 664; (2004) 208 ALR 564
Gartner v Ernst & Young (No 3) [2003] FCA 1437
M'Intosh v Great Western Railway Co [1850] 2 Mac & G 74; (1850) 42 ER 29
Opes Prime Group Ltd (in liquidation) v Niako Investments Pty Ltd [2014] VSC 414
Rowe v National Australia Bank Ltd [2019] WASCA 140
Swansdale Pty Ltd v Whitcrest Pty Ltd [2010] WASCA 129
Western Areas Exploration Pty Ltd v Streeter [No 2] [2008] WASC 217
KENNETH MARTIN J:
I am dealing with two distinct interlocutory applications in this action (the applications). The litigation was commenced in 2016 and is edging towards an anticipated trial of seven days' duration, although the matter is not yet entered for trial. There is a likelihood that after the present applications the plaintiff's amended statement of claim of 27 February 2019 ('ASOC') will require some further adjustment.
Plaintiff's application for further and better discovery
The first interlocutory dispute concerns the plaintiff's application by a chamber summons of 19 September 2019, seeking further and better discovery (the application for further and better discovery). Further and better discovery was sought under par 1(a) of the chamber summons in respect of three documents which have been discovered by the defendant, documents numbered 25, 31 and 44, being Western Suburbs Real Estate ('WSRE') management agreements. WSRE is controlled by the defendant and is a corporate entity established by the defendant after she left the employ of the plaintiff in March 2016. In effect, she left then to set up her own competitive real estate management…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read G and R Rossen Pty Ltd v Buchanan and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] WASC 373
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court had to determine whether the redacted information sought by the plaintiff was relevant to their claim for an equitable account of profits, and thus should be disclosed. The court also had to assess whether the defendant met the jurisdictional threshold for an order for security for costs, which required the court to determine if there was reason to believe that the plaintiff would be unable to pay the defendant's costs if successful. The court found that the redacted information was relevant to the plaintiff's claim and ordered further and better discovery of the documents. In assessing the application for security for costs, the court considered the plaintiff's financial position and concluded that the defendant had met the jurisdictional threshold. The court therefore ordered the plaintiff to provide further security for costs.
The court's decision highlighted the importance of considering the relevance of information sought in discovery to the merits of a case, as well as the factors to be considered in determining whether a party meets the jurisdictional threshold for an order for security for costs. The court's order for further and better discovery and for further security for costs would have significant implications for the parties' legal costs and the progression of the case.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
I also mention generally the observations made by Le Miere J in assessing a security for costs application in Western Areas Exploration Pty Ltd v Streeter [No 2] [2008] WASC 217 [24] - [29], [43] - [50] and [58] - [60]. As his Honour had observed at [25]:… Section 1335 [of the Corporations Act] carries both a threshold test and a discretionary test. The threshold test is whether it appears by credible testimony that there is reason to believe that the corporation will be unable to pay the legal costs of the defendant.See also his Honour's reference at [35] to observations of Pidgeon and Owen JJ in FFE Minerals Australia Pty Ltd v Mining Australia Pty Ltd [2000] WASCA 69 [11], also mentioned in Swansdale [68]. With such general observations in mind, I turn to the s 1335(1) jurisdictional threshold issue, namely, whether it appears by credible testimony that there is 'reason to believe' that the plaintiff would be unable to pay the costs of the defendant, if she is successful in her defence of the present action at the trial. Too much material as a matter of proportionality in the present dispute has been assembled concerning the parties' rival positions over the threshold question. In the end, I am of the view that, as regards what remains a predictive exercise, that the threshold has been met by the defendant: see observations in Swansdale [68] - [69]. Four main considerations lead me to that conclusion. First, the plaintiff corporation is, as seen, the trustee of a trading trust. As such, it stands reliant upon its indemnity against trust assets, which it will ordinarily enjoy in the event of the trustee incurring a legitimate costs liability to a defendant in the wake of an unsuccessful action. Here, I am left not so impressed by the state of the trust's balance sheet as it currently looks, following the asset sale of the trust's rent roll business and a realisation of the sale consideration in return for that formerly non-current asset. I do not reach any level of comfort that there is no or minimal risk to the defendant in possibly 24 to 36 months' time when, or if, a costs liability ever befalls the plaintiff, that the defendant's cost recovery position is comfortably assured against the level of the trust assets available to indemnify the plaintiff. Although the trust's rent roll business has been sold and the consideration for that asset will have been realised, I was told at the hearing that the plaintiff as a trustee of this trading trust, continues to actively trade into the future - in the plaintiff's retained and continued real estate business (see ts 136 and 157). But the vicissitudes of business are such that a capital amount realised upon the sale of the rent roll is not permanently secured against the negative vicissitudes of future business trading. Nor does the net balance sheet position of the trust on the material put before me present as so demonstrably in surplus as to lead to a level of comfortable satisfaction about the state of the plaintiff's long term future financial health. In short, I detect some level of cost recovery risk for the future (if the defendant is successful).