FSR18 v Minister for Home Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FSR18 v MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS & ANOR [2019] FCCA 2295
Catchwords:
MIGRATION – Review of Immigration Assessment Authority decision – refusal of a protection visa – applicant claiming a fear of harm in Pakistan – Authority accepting the claim but finding that the applicant could relocate to Islamabad – whether the Authority erred in considering the reasonableness of relocation considered – jurisdictional error established.

Legislation:

Migration Act 1958 (Cth), ss.5H, 5J, 36

Cases cited:

AHK16 v Minister for Immigration [2018] FCAFC 106

Applicant WAEE v Minister for Immigration (2003) 236 FCR 593

CID15 v Minister for Immigration [2017] FCA 780

CIT17 v Minister for Immigration [2018] FCAFC 150

Minister for Home Affairs v Buadromo (2018) 362 ALR 48

Minister for Immigration v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259

MZACX v Minister for Immigration (2016) 161 ALD 73

MZANX v Minister for Immigration [2017] FCA 307

MZZQV v Minister for Immigration [2015] FCA 533

Randhawa v Minister for Immigration (1994) 52 FCR 437

SZATV v Minister for Immigration (2007) 233 CLR 18

SZQPY v Minister for Immigration [2013] FCA 1133

Applicant: FSR18
First Respondent: MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS
Second Respondent: IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY
File Number: SYG 3057 of 2018
Judgment of: Judge Driver
Hearing date: 20 August 2019
Delivered at: Sydney
Delivered on: 17 October 2019

REPRESENTATION

Counsel for the Applicant: Mr B Mostafa
Solicitors for the Applicant: Hunter Shafiz Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Mr T Reilly
Solicitors for the Respondents:  DLA Piper Australia

ORDERS

  1. A writ of certiorari shall issue removing the record of the Immigration Assessment Authority decision made on 10 October 2018 into this Court for the purpose of quashing it.

  2. A writ of mandamus shall issue requiring the Immigration Assessment Authority to redetermine according to law the review referred to it.

FEDERAL CIRCUIT COURT
OF AUSTRALIA
AT SYDNEY

SYG 3057 of 2018

FSR18

Applicant

And

MINISTER FOR HOME AFFAIRS

First Respondent

IMMIGRATION ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction and background

  1. The applicant seeks judicial review of a decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority (Authority) made on 10 October 2018.  The Authority affirmed a decision of a delegate of the Minister (delegate) not to grant the applicant a protection visa. 

  2. The following statement of background facts is derived from the submissions of the parties.

  3. The applicant is a Pakistani national, whose home area in Pakistan is Kurram Agency.[1] He arrived in Australia on 17 July 2013 at Christmas Island as an unauthorised maritime arrival and lodged his SHEV[2] application on 5 December 2016.[3]

    [1] Court Book (CB) 325 at [4], CB 329 at [26]

    [2] Safe Haven Enterprise Visa

    [3]CB 324 at [1]

  4. The record of the applicant’s “Irregular Maritime Arrival & Induction Interview” records that the applicant has a wife and two young children (twins, born in 2012).[4]  In the statutory declaration accompanying his SHEV application, the applicant stated that his family had moved to Parachinar city.[5]  The applicant stated that he feared harm on account of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FSR18 v Minister for Home Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCCA 2295
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter came before Judge Driver of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia concerning a review of a decision by the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA). The applicant, who claimed a fear of harm in Pakistan, had their protection visa application refused by the IAA. While the IAA accepted the applicant's fear of harm, it found that relocation to Islamabad would be reasonable, thereby negating the need for a protection visa.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the IAA erred in its assessment of the reasonableness of the applicant's internal relocation to Islamabad. Specifically, the court was required to determine if the IAA had adequately considered the "particular circumstances of the applicant" and the impact of relocation upon them, and whether the assessment was sufficiently fact-intensive and avoided generalities.

Judge Driver found that the IAA had committed jurisdictional error. The court reasoned that assessing the reasonableness of internal relocation requires a detailed, fact-intensive analysis of the individual's circumstances, including their personal strengths, weaknesses, skills, and support networks, rather than a broad-brush approach. The IAA's reasoning, which was described as "relatively brief," relied on general country information and did not sufficiently engage with the specific challenges the applicant raised regarding employment, subsistence, and the practicalities of establishing a life in Islamabad without familial or tribal connections. The court noted that while the IAA considered some aspects of the applicant's situation, it failed to adequately address the practical and realistic ability of the applicant to restart their life in a new place without undue hardship, leading to the assessment becoming "formulaic, and removed from any real factual basis."

The court ordered that the decision of the Immigration Assessment Authority be set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

FSR18, a Pakistani national, applied for a protection visa in Australia, claiming a fear of harm if returned to Pakistan due to his Shia Muslim identity. The Immigration Assessment Authority accepted FSR18's claim of a fear of harm but refused the visa, finding that he could relocate to Islamabad, the capital city of Pakistan, without suffering significant harm. The decision hinged on the authority's assessment of the reasonableness of FSR18 relocating internally within Pakistan.

FSR18 argued that relocation to Islamabad would be unreasonable due to his lack of family, friends, or tribal links outside his native Kurram region, his inability to find a job, and the high cost of living in Islamabad. In response, the authority noted that FSR18 had lived independently from his wife and children for an extended period and demonstrated resilience. The authority further considered that FSR18 could maintain contact with his family, potentially receive assistance from his extended family, and find employment due to Islamabad's larger urban opportunities and significant Shia population. The authority also dismissed FSR18's concerns about the cost of living, stating that DFAT reports indicated Islamabad provided better access to employment, education, and healthcare services, with costs ranging from AUD135-685 per month for 1-2 rooms or a house in working-class Shia areas.

In addition, the authority found that FSR18's lack of Urdu language skills and reliance on Pashto would not prevent him from finding employment, given the large Pashtun communities in urban areas like Islamabad and the dominance of Pashtuns in the transport sector. The authority also noted that FSR18 could renew his CNIC online, eliminating the need to return to Kurram Agency. Considering FSR18's overall circumstances, the authority concluded that relocating to Islamabad would be reasonable, and there would be no real risk of significant harm to FSR18.

This case involves a review of a decision by the Immigration Assessment Authority (IAA) regarding the refusal of a protection visa to the applicant, FSR18. The matter came before the court following an appeal against the IAA's decision. Prior to this appeal, the matter had been determined by the IAA, which accepted the applicant's claims about the fear of harm in Pakistan but found that the applicant could reasonably relocate to Islamabad. The applicant contested this finding, arguing that relocation would be unreasonable and challenging the IAA's assessment. The procedural journey leading to this appeal involved several key steps. Initially, the applicant applied for a protection visa, which was subsequently refused by the IAA. Dissatisfied with this decision, the applicant lodged an appeal to the court, seeking a review of the IAA's decision. During the appellate process, the applicant filed various submissions and evidence to support their claim that relocation to Islamabad would be unreasonable. The court, in its review, examined the IAA's decision, focusing on the reasoning behind the conclusion that internal relocation was reasonable. This included scrutinising the IAA's consideration of the applicant's particular circumstances and the impact of relocation on them. The court also evaluated the IAA's analysis against established legal principles concerning the assessment of the reasonableness of internal relocation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Secondly, when dealing with the reasonableness question, the matters to be considered include “particular circumstances of the applicant for refugee status and the impact upon that person of relocation of the place of residence within the country of nationality”.[79] The “extent of the decision-maker's task will be largely determined by the case sought to be made out by an applicant”,[80] but that is not to say that the task is wholly determined by the applicant’s case. Rather, a “range of issues may become relevant to the question of whether internal relocation is reasonable, depending on the circumstances and the issues raised by an applicant for refugee status, and, when they do, must be carefully regarded by the decision maker”.[81] (emphasis added)[79] SZATV at [24][80] Randhawa v Minister for Immigration (1994) 52 FCR 437 at 443[81] MZZQV v Minister for Immigration [2015] FCA 533 at [68] (emphasis added) Thirdly, as MZZQV shows, the task of assessing reasonableness requires careful attention to the relevant material. It “involves a fact intensive assessment. Generalities will not suffice”.[82] As Mortimer J stated in MZANX at [55]: General statements will be insufficient, because what is in issue is the practical and realistic ability of an individual to re-start her or his life in a new place, without undue hardship… Likewise, the circumstances of that individual — her or his personal strengths and weaknesses, skills, material and family support, will need to be considered in some detail. A broad brush approach will not satisfy the requirements of the task to be performed… [82] MZANX at [51] Absent this careful, factually intensive analysis, “the risk is that the assessment becomes formulaic, and removed from any real factual basis” relevant to the individual in question.[83] [83] MZANX at [56] The Authority’s reasoning on the reasonableness of relocation is relatively brief and should be set out in full:[84]The applicant contended that internal relocation to Islamabad is unreasonable on the basis that he does not have family, friends or tribal links outside of Kurram, will be unable to find a job, and thus will be unable to establish himself or subsist. I note that the applicant stated in the SHEV interview that his father worked for 20 years in Abu Dhabi before he was married, and that he has now returned to Pakistan and lives with the applicant’s family in Parachinar. There is no evidence before me that the applicant’s family is reliant on him for their basic needs. The applicant has demonstrated resilience and an ability to live independently from his wife and family for an extended period of time and a willingness to continue to live apart from them in Australia if he was successful in obtaining a SHEV. I consider that he will be able to continue to maintain contact with his wife and children and could call on his extended family for some assistance, such as assisting his wife and child to come to Islamabad should they wish to do so.The applicant’s representative has highlighted the significance of family and tribal links for persons from the FATA and how this impacts on their ability to be safe, as well as access accommodation and employment opportunities. DFAT’s 2016 Thematic Report ‘Shias in Pakistan’ observes that, in Pakistan, Shias relocate with relative ease and frequency because of family and communal networks throughout the country. Islamabad has a significant Shia population - including Shias from Parachinar living in suburbs such as Koh-i-Noor and Golra Sharif, and in small towns close to Islamabad such as Taxila, Bahra Kahu, Bani Gala and Bari Imam. Islamabad is a functioning city which will provide the applicant with access to infrastructure and services necessary for subsistence.The applicant contends that he would face undue hardship and be unable to subsist due to the high cost of living in Islamabad. The applicant’s representative referred to a number of English language sources which appear to be discussing costs of living in Islamabad for Western expatriates. I also note that the 2014 Dawn article ‘Islamabad – a city only for the rich?’ features a speculative and anecdotal discussion with affluent Pakistani returnees commenting on land and property prices for large properties in middle class or wealthy areas of Islamabad. I do not accept this information is a useful comparison for the applicant’s likely situation if he were to relocate to Islamabad. I take into account that it may be more expensive for the applicant to live in Islamabad than in Kurram, however I also note that DFAT reports Pakistan has seen improved economic growth and reduced inflation in recent years and the number of people living in poverty has fallen. DFAT has observed that cities like Islamabad provide greater access to employment, education and health care services, than elsewhere in Pakistan. Shias have told DFAT that these factors were central to their decision to relocate from Kurram Agency to Islamabad. DFAT understands that in Islamabad’s working class areas that have significant populations of Shias from Parachinar accommodation costs range from AUD135-270 per month (for 1-2 rooms) to AUD685 per month (for a house). DFAT also note that members of the Turi community often share accommodation to alleviate such costs, which are further offset by the higher wages paid in large urban centres. Many migrant Shia groups such as Turi Shias in Islamabad often own or work for small businesses.The applicant’s first language is Pashto and I accept that he does not speak Urdu. I have earlier found that, despite his claims to the contrary, he has at least a basic command of English and some degree of literacy in Pashto. Country information indicates that only 8 per cent of the Pakistani population speaks Urdu as a first language. DFAT assess that there are approximately 30 million Pashtuns living in Pakistan, making them the second-largest ethnic group in the country (behind Punjabis). There are large Pashtun communities in all large urban areas, including Islamabad. I further note that the applicant has previously worked as a commercial driver and that country information indicates Pashtuns have dominated employment in the transport sector in Pakistan. While I accept that networks of family favouritism, patronage and nepotism play a more significant role in finding employment in Pakistan than is the case in Australia, the evidence does not indicate that the situation in Pakistan is such that a person such as the applicant would be unable to find any employment and accommodation in Islamabad without connections of this kind.The applicant did not claim that he would need to return to Kurram Agency to renew his CNIC, but the delegate nevertheless considered this as an event that will arise ‘in the foreseeable future’. In the 2017 report “Applying For and Renewing Computerised National Identity Cards” DFAT advises that the issuing authority, National Database and Registration Authority (NADRA) confirms that persons from Kurram Agency with an existing CNIC are able to renew this online. The applicant’s identity is registered with NADRA and he holds a valid CNIC. I am satisfied that he would be able to renew his CNIC in Islamabad, without returning to Kurram Agency.Having regard to the applicant’s overall circumstances I am satisfied that it would be reasonable for the applicant to relocate to Islamabad, an area of the country where there would not be a real risk that the applicant will suffer significant harm.[84] CB 334-335 at [50]-[56]

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court found that the Immigration Assessment Authority erred in its consideration of the reasonableness of the applicant relocating to Islamabad, Pakistan. In addressing the issue of reasonableness, the court emphasized that the assessment required a careful, factually intensive analysis of the particular circumstances of the applicant, including his ability to find employment, accommodation, and maintain contact with family. The Authority’s reasoning was relatively brief and did not adequately address the applicant’s concerns regarding language barriers and potential difficulties in integrating into the community in Islamabad.

The court highlighted that the Authority’s assessment of the reasonableness of relocation lacked the necessary detail and consideration of the individual circumstances of the applicant. The Authority did not sufficiently explore the applicant’s ability to find employment and accommodation in Islamabad or consider his potential difficulties in integrating into the community due to language barriers. Instead, the Authority relied on general statements and broad brush approaches, which were insufficient to adequately assess the practical and realistic ability of the applicant to restart his life in Islamabad without undue hardship.

The court underscored that the assessment of reasonableness involves a fact-intensive evaluation and cannot rely on generalities. The Authority’s brief consideration of the applicant’s circumstances and failure to address his specific concerns about language barriers and integration demonstrated a lack of the careful analysis required by the law. The court concluded that the Authority’s approach was formulaic and removed from any real factual basis relevant to the individual circumstances of the applicant.

In addition, the Authority did not properly consider the practical aspects of the applicant renewing his Computerised National Identity Card (CNIC) in Islamabad, rather than returning to Kurram Agency. The court noted that the Authority’s reliance on Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (DFAT) reports and other country information was appropriate but insufficient when it came to addressing the applicant's specific concerns and circumstances.

The court also found that the Authority’s conclusion that the applicant could reasonably relocate to Islamabad, without a real risk of significant harm, was not supported by the evidence and arguments presented. The Authority did not adequately address the applicant's claims and concerns about the challenges he would face in relocating to Islamabad, including the difficulties in finding employment and accommodation, and the language barriers. The court held that the Authority’s conclusion was not supported by a sufficient factual and detailed analysis of the applicant’s particular circumstances.

In summary, the court established that the Immigration Assessment Authority erred in its consideration of the reasonableness of the applicant relocating to Islamabad. The Authority failed to conduct a factually intensive and detailed assessment of the applicant’s particular circumstances, including his ability to find employment, accommodation, and maintain contact with family. The Authority’s reliance on general statements and broad brush approaches did not adequately address the applicant’s specific concerns about language barriers and integration. Consequently, the Authority’s conclusion that the applicant could reasonably relocate to Islamabad, without a real risk of significant harm, was not supported by the evidence and arguments presented. The court’s reasoning established that a careful, factually intensive analysis of the individual circumstances of the applicant is essential when assessing the reasonableness of internal relocation.