Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S v Stena Rederi Aktiebolag

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S v Stena Rederi Aktiebolag [2002] FCA 1024

PATENTS – Opposition proceedings – Hearing by Commissioner of Patents – Opponent sells business, including rights in opposition proceedings – Commissioner dismisses opposition – Opponent appeals to Court against dismissal – Opponent seeks order that its purchaser replace it as appellant – Whether power to make order – Nature of appeal from Commissioner – Choses in action – Whether opponent’s appeal a chose in action – Whether a proprietary right.

Federal Court Rules Order 6 rules 8, 9, 10(2)
Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 60(4), 160(e)
Patents Regulations 1991 (Cth) reg 5.3B

Kaiser Aluminium and Chemical Corporation v The Reynolds Metal Co (1969) 120 CLR 136 applied
Genetics Institute Inc v Kirin‑Amgen Inc (1996) 67 FCR 527 cited
Dennison Manufacturing Co v Monarch Marking Systems Inc (1981) 51 OJPTMD 1716 cited
Turnbull v New South Wales Medical Board [1976] 2 NSWLR 281 considered
Builders Licensing Board v Sperway Constructions (Syd) Pty Ltd (1976) 135 CLR 616 cited
Harris v Caladine (1991) 172 CLR 84 cited
Esber v The Commonwealth (1992) 174 CLR 430 cited
Re Costello (1979) 2 ALD 934 considered
Cummings v Claremont Petroleum NL (1996) 185 CLR 124 considered
Torkington v Magee [1902] 2 KB 427 cited
Norman v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1963) 109 CLR 9 cited
Investors Compensation Scheme Ltd v West Bromwich Building Society [1998] 1 WLR 896 cited

FREDERIKSHAVN VAERFT A/S (formerly Danyard A/S) v STENA REDERI AKTIEBOLAG

V 230 OF 2000

SUNDBERG J
16 AUGUST 2002
MELBOURNE


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 230 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

FREDERIKSHAVN VAERFT A/S (formerly Danyard A/S)
APPLICANT

AND:

STENA REDERI AKTIEBOLAG
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

SUNDBERG J

DATE OF ORDER:

16 AUGUST 2002

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT DECLARES THAT Austal Ships Pty Ltd is entitled to replace Danyard A/S (now Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S) as opponent.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT

1.The Commissioner of Patents amend the notice of opposition naming Danyard A/S (now Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S) as opponent so as to substitute Austal Ships Pty Ltd as the named opponent.

2.Austal Ships Pty Ltd be joined as an applicant in the proceeding.

3.Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S cease to be applicant in the proceeding.

4.Austal Ships Pty Ltd pay the respondent’s costs of the Motion dated 12 December 2001.

5.The respondent pay the applicant’s costs of the Motion dated 1 May 2002.

6.A copy of this Order be served on the Commissioner of Patents.

Note:   Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

V 230 OF 2000

BETWEEN:

FREDERIKSHAVN VAERFT A/S (formerly Danyard A/S)
APPLICANT

AND:

STENA REDERI AKTIEBOLAG
RESPONDENT

JUDGE:

SUNDBERG J

DATE:

16 AUGUST 2002

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant (“Danyard”) applied for an order that Austal Ships Pty Ltd (“Austal”) be substituted for it as applicant in the proceeding. A Registrar made the order sought. The respondent (“Stena”)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S v Stena Rederi Aktiebolag and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] FCA 1024
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S v Stena Rederi Aktiebolag, the Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether Austal Ships Pty Ltd could be substituted for Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S (Danyard) as the applicant in a proceeding concerning a patent opposition. Stena Rederi Aktiebolag (Stena) opposed the substitution. The primary legal issue was whether the substitution order could be granted under the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976, specifically section 160(e), which allows the Court to make any order necessary for the just disposal of the proceedings. Danyard argued that the substitution was permissible under the Patents Regulations 1991 (Cth), while Stena contested the application on the grounds that the opposition right was not assignable and that Danyard had not followed the correct procedure.

The Court examined the circumstances under which the sale agreement was executed and the subsequent efforts made by Austal to assert its interest in the opposition. The Court found that the sale agreement clearly made Danyard a trustee for Austal in relation to the business assets, including the opposition rights. Furthermore, the Court held that the substitution of Austal for Danyard was necessary to ensure the continuation of the opposition proceedings, particularly in light of Danyard’s impending liquidation. The Court concluded that the substitution order should be made under section 160(e) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976, rather than under the Patents Regulations, as the latter did not provide the Court with the requisite authority.

The Court ordered that Austal be substituted for Danyard as the applicant in the proceedings, with the necessary amendments to the notice of opposition. It also ordered that Stena pay the costs of the motion. This decision ensured that the opposition could proceed in the name of Austal, maintaining the integrity and continuity of the legal proceedings.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant (“Danyard”) applied for an order that Austal Ships Pty Ltd (“Austal”) be substituted for it as applicant in the proceeding. A Registrar made the order sought. The respondent (“Stena”) seeks a review of the Registrar’s order under s 35A(5) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth). The review is a hearing de novo. On the review Danyard has relied on the same affidavit material that was before the Registrar. Stena did not file evidence.BACKGROUND In 1992 Stena made patent application 648634. The subject matter of the application is a hull for multi‑hull seagoing vessels capable of speeds greater than 30 knots. In July 1994 Danyard lodged notice of opposition to the application. The opposition was heard by a delegate of the Commissioner of Patents on 13 April 1999. By agreement dated 16 December 1999 Danyard sold its business and the business assets to Austal (“the sale agreement”). The business assets included “Industrial Property Rights”. That expression was defined to include listed patents, patent applications, trade marks and two opposition proceedings described as follows:“the opposition proceedings against certain patent applications made by Stena Rederi Aktiebolag commenced by the Vendor before the opposition division of the European Patent Office on 21 June 1995 and before the Australian Patent Office on 28 July 1994, any appeals to the Board of Appeal of the European Patent Office … or to the Australian Patent Office as the case may be, and any other right of action, remedy or proceeding that is or may become available to the Vendor deriving or arising from or in relation to those proceedings or the Vendor’s standing to bring those opposition proceedings.”Clause 13.2 provided:“The Vendor shall be a trustee for the Purchaser in respect of the Business Assets as from the date of this Agreement until the same shall have been delivered and/or formally transferred or assigned to the Purchaser.”On 29 March 2000 the delegate dismissed Danyard’s opposition. On 19 April 2000 Danyard appealed to the Court against the Commissioner’s decision. In April 2001 Danyard went into liquidation in Denmark. The application to the Registrar was made on 12 December 2001.THE MOTION In its notice of motion Danyard seeks the following orders:“1.Austal Ships Pty Ltd be named as applicant in these proceedings in substitution for Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S and the proceedings hereafter be re‑entitled accordingly.2.Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S be removed as applicant in these proceedings with no order as to costs.3.The rights and liabilities accruing to Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S in these proceedings to the date of substitution and removal pursuant to paragraphs 1 and 2 shall be transferred to Austal Ships Pty Ltd.4.The costs of and incidental to this application be paid by Austal Ships Pty Ltd.5.Such further or other orders as the Court considers appropriate.”EVIDENCE IN SUPPORT OF APPLICATION In support of its application Danyard relied on three main affidavits. The first is that of James Black, Austal’s Service Manager. Mr Black deposes that·in 1990, before the priority date of the opposed patent application, Austal designed and built two vessels having all the features of claim 1 of the application·since 1990 Austal has built many more vessels in the same field as the patent application·Austal has an interest in ensuring that Stena’s patent application does not proceed to grant, since Austal preceded Stena in the field of the patent, still operates in the field, and will suffer a significant restriction in its business if the patent is granted·from the early 1990s Danyard marketed a Seajet type vessel with a hull design having many similarities to the Austal hull shapes and the hull shape disclosed in Stena’s patent application·Austal did not lodge a notice of opposition to Stena’s patent application, but became aware of Danyard’s opposition in 1994·from 1994 Austal, through Mr Black, assisted Danyard in relation to the opposition by preparing reports on Stena’s application and the prior art, reviewing Stena’s evidence, assisting in the preparation of Danyard’s evidence, and attending the opposition proceedings·after the Commissioner’s decision on the opposition, Austal recommended an appeal, suggested local experts who could assist the appeal, and helped with the preparation of evidence for the appeal·to date Austal has spent approximately $1,100,000 in legal costs associated with the opposition proceedings before the Commissioner and in the Court, most of which was spent after Austal acquired Danyard’s business in December 1999·Austal has spent about $700,000 in legal costs associated with the opposition to Stena’s patent application in Europe, an application with the same subject matter as the application in Australia and the same priority date·the European opposition proceedings were instituted by Danyard, but on 19 November 2001 the Board of Appeal of the European Patent Office granted Austal’s application to be substituted for Danyard·neither Austal nor Danyard took steps to have Austal substituted for Danyard as applicant in the Australian proceeding because Austal believed its interests were adequately protected by the sale agreement, pursuant to which Danyard was trustee for Austal of the opposition rights·in October 2001 Austal became aware that Danyard would in due course be liquidated, and it became necessary to ensure that Austal replace Danyard as applicant because Danyard “would not be able to continue to act as trustee of the right for much longer”·it was not until late 2001 that Austal received legal advice that a mechanism existed (reg 5.3B of the Patents Regulations 1991 (Cth) (“the Regulations”)) whereby a right of opposition could be transferred to another person.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In its notice of motion Danyard seeks the following orders:“1.Austal Ships Pty Ltd be named as applicant in these proceedings in substitution for Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S and the proceedings hereafter be re‑entitled accordingly.2.Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S be removed as applicant in these proceedings with no order as to costs.3.The rights and liabilities accruing to Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S in these proceedings to the date of substitution and removal pursuant to paragraphs 1 and 2 shall be transferred to Austal Ships Pty Ltd.4.The costs of and incidental to this application be paid by Austal Ships Pty Ltd.5.Such further or other orders as the Court considers appropriate.”EVIDENCE IN SUPPORT OF APPLICATION In support of its application Danyard relied on three main affidavits. The first is that of James Black, Austal’s Service Manager. Mr Black deposes that·in 1990, before the priority date of the opposed patent application, Austal designed and built two vessels having all the features of claim 1 of the application·since 1990 Austal has built many more vessels in the same field as the patent application·Austal has an interest in ensuring that Stena’s patent application does not proceed to grant, since Austal preceded Stena in the field of the patent, still operates in the field, and will suffer a significant restriction in its business if the patent is granted·from the early 1990s Danyard marketed a Seajet type vessel with a hull design having many similarities to the Austal hull shapes and the hull shape disclosed in Stena’s patent application·Austal did not lodge a notice of opposition to Stena’s patent application, but became aware of Danyard’s opposition in 1994·from 1994 Austal, through Mr Black, assisted Danyard in relation to the opposition by preparing reports on Stena’s application and the prior art, reviewing Stena’s evidence, assisting in the preparation of Danyard’s evidence, and attending the opposition proceedings·after the Commissioner’s decision on the opposition, Austal recommended an appeal, suggested local experts who could assist the appeal, and helped with the preparation of evidence for the appeal·to date Austal has spent approximately $1,100,000 in legal costs associated with the opposition proceedings before the Commissioner and in the Court, most of which was spent after Austal acquired Danyard’s business in December 1999·Austal has spent about $700,000 in legal costs associated with the opposition to Stena’s patent application in Europe, an application with the same subject matter as the application in Australia and the same priority date·the European opposition proceedings were instituted by Danyard, but on 19 November 2001 the Board of Appeal of the European Patent Office granted Austal’s application to be substituted for Danyard·neither Austal nor Danyard took steps to have Austal substituted for Danyard as applicant in the Australian proceeding because Austal believed its interests were adequately protected by the sale agreement, pursuant to which Danyard was trustee for Austal of the opposition rights·in October 2001 Austal became aware that Danyard would in due course be liquidated, and it became necessary to ensure that Austal replace Danyard as applicant because Danyard “would not be able to continue to act as trustee of the right for much longer”·it was not until late 2001 that Austal received legal advice that a mechanism existed (reg 5.3B of the Patents Regulations 1991 (Cth) (“the Regulations”)) whereby a right of opposition could be transferred to another person.

Decision

Reasons for decision

SUNDBERG J (dissent)
In the present case Danyard’s appeal is against the Commissioner’s decision that its grounds of opposition under s 59 were not made out. If it were to succeed, Danyard would obtain no money or other property, though it would frustrate a competitor’s application for a patent. The position is not unlike that in Cummings, where the right of appeal carried no right to recover property; just the right to have a liability to pay money set aside. However, I need not decide the point. If the notice of opposition is amended so as to substitute Austal for Danyard as opponent, with the result that the opposition will proceed in the name of Austal, Austal will become the objector in place of Danyard. In those circumstances there is every reason to make an order substituting Austal for Danyard as applicant. It is neither here nor there that, if the s 160(e) order were not made, a substitution under the Rules would not be made because Danyard’s opposition or right of appeal is not a chose in action and so could not pass to Austal. For the avoidance of doubt I should add that I see no inconsistency between saying that Danyard’s right of appeal is not assignable since it is not a chose in action (if that be the case), and the conclusion to which I have come in par 18 that for the purposes of reg 5.3B(1) Danyard’s right or interest on which it relied to file its notice of opposition vested in Austal.CONCLUSION I will declare that Austal is entitled to replace Danyard as opponent. I will direct the Commissioner to amend Danyard’s notice of opposition so as to substitute Austal for Danyard as opponent. I have made those orders under s 160(e) and not under reg 5.3B because they are not orders the Commissioner could have made when the matter was before him, and the regulation does not confer power on the Court. I will order under Order 6 rule 8 that Austal be joined as an applicant and under rule 9 that Danyard cease to be applicant. Stena must pay the costs of the motion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by:

The court considered the application by Frederikshavn Vaerft A/S (“Danyard”) to have Austal Ships Pty Ltd substituted as the applicant in the proceedings against Stena Rederi Aktiebolag. The court examined the legal framework under which such a substitution could occur, including the provisions of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 and the Patents Regulations 1991. The court acknowledged that while Danyard's right of appeal was not a chose in action and thus could not be assigned, the interest in the opposition proceeding vested in Austal through the sale agreement. The court also noted that the substitution was necessary because Danyard was in the process of liquidation and could no longer act as trustee for Austal. The court decided that Austal should replace Danyard as the applicant to ensure the continuation of the opposition proceedings. The court ordered the Commissioner to amend the notice of opposition and ruled that Austal be joined as an applicant, while Danyard ceased to be an applicant. The costs of the motion were to be borne by Stena.

In arriving at its decision, the court emphasised the importance of the continuity of the opposition proceedings, which were in the interest of preventing a competitor from obtaining a patent. The court distinguished between the assignability of the right of appeal and the transferability of the interest in the opposition proceedings under the specific provisions of the Patents Regulations. The binding legal principle, or ratio decidendi, established by the decision is that where a party has a vested interest in opposition proceedings through a sale agreement and the original applicant is no longer capable of continuing the proceedings, the court may order a substitution of applicants to maintain the integrity of the proceedings. The court followed established legal principles regarding the assignability of rights and interests in legal proceedings while applying the specific provisions of the Patents Regulations to the unique circumstances of this case.