Bradken Resources Pty Ltd (ACN 098 300 988) v Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd (ACN 059 949 469)

Link copied
Case Copied 44 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Bradken Resources Pty Ltd (ACN 098 300 988) v Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd (ACN 059 949 469) [2010] FCA 662

Citation: Bradken Resources Pty Ltd (ACN 098 300 988) v Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd (ACN 059 949 469) [2010] FCA 662
Parties: BRADKEN RESOURCES PTY LTD (ACN 098 300 988) v LYNX ENGINEERING CONSULTANTS PTY LTD (ACN 059 949 469)
File number: WAD 212 of 2009
Judge: MCKERRACHER J
Date of judgment: 24 June 2010
Catchwords: INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY – patents – appeal and cross-appeal in the Federal Court from final determination of the Commissioner’s delegate – issues to be determined on appeal – whether arguments raised in appeal of original decision can be agitated on appeal from final determination where no appeal from amendment decision – subject matter of appeal – additional evidence of prior art – characterisation of appeals from the Commissioner in the Federal Court – hearing de novo – whether appeals should be consolidated
Legislation:

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 18, 40, 59, 60, 102, 104

Federal Court Rules O 52 r 22(1), O 58 r 5A

Cases cited: Airsense Technology Ltd v Vision Systems Ltd (2007) 73 IPR 65
Bradken Resources Pty Ltd v Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd (2008) 78 IPR 586
Bradken Resources Pty Ltd v Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd (2008) 78 IPR 586
Bradken Resources Pty Ltd v Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd [2009] APO 15
EI du Pont de Nemours & Company v ICI Chemicals & Polymers Ltd (2003) 128 FCR 392
Iluka Midwest Ltd v Technological Resources Pty Ltd (2002) 116 FCR 218
Jafferjee v Scarlett (1937) 57 CLR 115
Kaiser Aluminum & Chemical Corp v The Reynolds Metal Co (1969) 120 CLR 136
Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd v The ANI Corporation Limited [2007] FCA 578
Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd v The ANI Corporation Limited (No 2) (2007) 163 FCR 372
Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd v The ANI Corporation Limited trading as ANI Bradken Rail Transportation Group [2008] FCA 555
Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd v The ANI Corporation Limited trading as ANI Bradken Rail Transportation Group (No 2) [2009] FCA 363
Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd v The ANI Corporation Limited trading as ANI Bradken Rail Transportation Group (No 3) [2010] FCA 32
New England Biolabs Inc v F Hoffmann-La Roche AG  (2004) 141 FCR 1
Perkin-Elmer Corporation v Varian Techtron Pty Ltd (1985) 5 IPR 321
Re Smith; Ex p Mole Engineering Pty Ltd (1981) 147 CLR 340
Date of hearing: 22 April 2010
Place: Perth
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 59
Counsel for the Applicant: A Fox
Solicitor for the Applicant: Griffith Hack Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: JJ Garnsey QC
Solicitor for the Respondent: Karp Steedman Ross-Adjie

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

WAD 212 of 2009

ON APPEAL AND CROSS-APPEAL FROM A DELEGATE OF THE COMMISSIONER OF PATENTS

BETWEEN:

AND:

BRADKEN RESOURCES PTY LTD
(ACN 098 300…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bradken Resources Pty Ltd (ACN 098 300 988) v Lynx Engineeri... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 662
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Bradken Resources Pty Ltd (ACN 098 300 988) filed an appeal against the final determination of the Commissioner of Patents that an amended patent should proceed to grant, following a series of oppositions by Bradken against the original patent application filed by Lynx Engineering Consultants Pty Ltd (ACN 059 949 469). The Federal Court was required to determine whether Bradken's appeal was valid, and if so, whether the court should allow further evidence and consolidate the appeals. Lynx argued that Bradken's appeal was not valid as it did not directly appeal the earlier decision dismissing the second opposition, and therefore, the arguments raised in that appeal should be disregarded.

The court considered the nature of the appeals from the Commissioner's decisions in the Federal Court. It concluded that appeals are essentially original proceedings, and the court has broad powers to admit further evidence, examine witnesses, and make any orders it deems fit. The court rejected Lynx's argument that the appeal was not valid because Bradken did not appeal the earlier decision dismissing the second opposition. The court found that the appeal was valid as Bradken had an interest in opposing the grant of the patent, and it was in the public interest to deal with the opposition on its merits.

The court ordered that the matter be re-listed for a directions hearing and allowed either party to apply in relation to the orders within 7 days. The costs of the Notice of Motion and Objection to Competency were reserved to be determined in the appeal and cross-appeal. This decision highlights the broad powers of the Federal Court in hearing appeals from the Commissioner of Patents and the importance of dealing with oppositions on their merits.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The answer to Question 1 in the Notice of Motion filed by the applicant is (c).

2. The answer to Question 2 is no.

3. The answer to Question 3 is:

The matter be re-listed for a directions hearing on 1 July 2010 at 9.45 am.

4. There be liberty to either party to apply in relation to these orders within 7 days.

5. Costs of the Notice of Motion and of the Objection to Competency be reserved to be determined in the Appeal and Cross-Appeal.

Note:

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 18 August 2009, the delegate issued a decision dismissing the Second Opposition (the Second Decision). On 13 November 2009, the delegate of the Commissioner of Patents issued a Final Determination (the Final Determination) in relation to the patent confirming that the amendments overcame the successful grounds of opposition which had been upheld in the First Decision. It followed that none of the grounds of opposition raised by Bradken was established in respect of the amended patent application. On 20 November 2009, Bradken appealed the Final Determination of the delegate (the Second Appeal) to this Court by commencement of these proceedings (WAD 212 of 2009). On 26 November 2009, orders by consent were made that the Second Appeal be heard concurrently with the First Appeal. Consequently, on 11 December 2009, Bradken filed consolidated points of claim. Some correspondence was exchanged between the parties in relation to the terms of Bradken’s points of claim. Differences which are discussed in these reasons were unable to be resolved and in consequence, on 23 December 2009, Lynx filed a Notice of Objection to Competency of the Second Appeal pursuant to O 52 r 22(1) and O 58 r 5A of the Federal Court Rules (FCR) and s 60(4) of the Patents Act. Essentially the ground of objection, as indicated above, was that the appeal is not an appeal from a decision of the Commissioner within s 60(4) of the Patents Act. The purported appeal, rather, is from a final determination of the Commissioner that a patent should proceed to grant. The point raised in the Notice of Objection was that Bradken had not appealed the Second Decision, therefore, various grounds agitated in the Second Opposition and addressed in the Second Decision should be struck out. That skeletal overview can now be fleshed out a little. In the original 29 November 2005 Statement of Grounds and Particulars of Opposition, Bradken recorded as ground 1 under s 59(a) that the nominated person was not entitled to a grant of a patent for the invention. Under ground 2 pursuant to s 59(b) – para 18(1), the ground of opposition was that the invention so far as claimed in each of claims 1-31 did not satisfy the threshold requirement of an ‘invention’ as required by subs 18(1), and ground 3 pursuant to s 59(b) and in relation to para 18(1)(a), the invention so far as claimed in each of claims 1-31 was said to be not a manner of manufacture within the meaning of s 6 of the Statute of Monopolies. Under ground 4 and s 59(b) the invention so far as claimed in each of claims 1-31 when compared with the prior art base as it existed before the priority date of the claim is not novel. Under ground 5 and s 59(b) and para 18(1)(b)(ii), it was asserted that the invention so far as claimed in each of the claims 1-31 when compared with the prior art base as it existed before the priority date of the claim did not involve an inventive step and in ground 6 under s 59(c), it was claimed that the specification filed in respect of the complete application did not comply with subs 40(2) or s 40(3) of the Patents Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For those reasons, Lynx contends that the answers to the Questions in the Notice of Motion should be answered as follows:1(a)As to the First Appeal, the claims that were the subject of the decision of the delegate of the Commissioner of Patents dated 13 March 2007;as to the Second Appeal, so far as it is a valid appeal from the Final Determination, the form of the claims that were the subject of the decision of the delegate of the Commissioner of Patents dated 18 August 2009;1(b)See 1(a) above;1(c)See 1(a) above;2.Yes. Each of the matters is a valid ground;3(a)The Notice and Grounds of Appeal and consolidated points of claim for the Second Appeal should be struck out in accordance with the submissions of Lynx and the Notice of Objection to Competency, and leave given to Bradken to file amended consolidated points of claim and to Lynx to file an amended defence to those consolidated points of claim;3(b)Orders and directions for the filing of further evidence on the First Appeal and First Cross-Appeal and on the Second Appeal (to the extent remaining) and Second Cross-Appeal; and 3(c)Such further or other orders and directions as may be necessary. CONSIDERATION The source of jurisdiction for the Federal Court to entertain appeals of decisions or directions of a Commissioner is found in s 154(1) of the Patents Act which provides as follows:(1)The Federal Court has jurisdiction with respect to matters arising under this Act.(2)The jurisdiction of the Federal Court to hear and determine appeals against decisions or directions of the Commissioner is exclusive of the jurisdiction of any other court except the jurisdiction of the High Court under section 75 of the Constitution.(3)A prosecution for an offence against this Act must not be started in the Federal Court. The Court has broad powers in exercising its jurisdiction on appeal. It may admit further evidence, permit examination and cross-examination of witnesses including those giving evidence before the Commissioner. It may affirm, reverse or vary any decision or direction of the Commissioner and give any judgement or make any order in the circumstances that it considers to be fit including orders as to costs. In Kaiser Aluminum & Chemical Corp v The Reynolds Metal Co (1969) 120 CLR 136 (at 142-143) Kitto J said (footnotes omitted):The appeal is, of course, only an appeal in name. In truth it is an original proceeding, being the first judicial proceeding in the matter of the opposition. The right of appeal is given to an opponent who, in the opinion of the Appeal Tribunal, "is entitled to be heard in opposition to the grant", and a person who proves before the Tribunal, as the appellant has proved in this case, that he had an interest which entitled him to oppose the grant of the patent and still has that interest answers that description. The appeal is therefore competent. It must be decided upon the evidence adduced before this Court, even though that evidence presents on the question of interest a case completely different from the case which was suggested before the Deputy Commissioner. This appears to me to follow from the nature of the jurisdiction under s. 76 (ii.) of the Constitution as to which see Federal Commissioner of Taxation v. Lewis Berger & Sons (Australia) Ltd,; Commissioner of Taxation v. Finn, at pp. 167, 168; and indeed it appears from the general provision in s. 149 that upon the hearing of an appeal the Appeal Tribunal may (inter alia) admit further evidence and give such judgment or make such order as it thinks fit in all the circumstances: cf. Jafferjee v. Scarlett,. For the reasons above stated I am satisfied that the appellant has a locus standi to oppose the grant of a patent. The respondent contended that the power to admit further evidence implies a discretion, and that I should exercise the discretion by refusing to allow the appellant to depart from the notice of opposition and to make here a case which it did not choose to make before the Deputy Commissioner. In my opinion, however, it is in the public interest that a serious opposition by a person entitled in fact to oppose the grant of a patent should be dealt with on the merits, rather than that it should be shut out in consequence of a failure in procedure, lamentable though the failure may be. (emphasis added)