Francis v Eggleston Mitchell Lawyers Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Francis v Eggleston Mitchell Lawyers Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 564

Citation: Francis v Eggleston Mitchell Lawyers Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 564
Parties: LOUISE FRANCIS v EGGLESTON MITCHELL LAWYERS PTY LTD, GESS MICHAEL RAMBALDI and ANDREW REGINALD YEO
File number: VID 5 of 2013
Judge: MARSHALL J
Date of judgment: 7 June 2013
Catchwords:

BANKRUPTCY – application to annul – whether sequestration order “ought not to have been made” – whether first respondent a creditor of the applicant – whether creditor’s petition based on a final order – solvency – discretion not to annul – relevant considerations – annulment refused.

EVIDENCE – leave granted for first respondent to re-open its case to admit further evidence located after judgment reserved – use of evidence limited.

Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth), ss 40(1)(g), 40(3)(d), 153B(1)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 64, 69
Supreme Court (General Civil Procedure) Rules 2005 (Vic)
Cases cited: Boles v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (2001) 183 ALR 239
Bulic v Commonwealth Bank of Australia Limited [2007] FCA 307
Commonwealth Bank of Australia v Horvath (Junior) (1999) 161 ALR 441
Francis v Eggleston Mitchell Lawyers [2011] FMCA 805
Francis v Eggleston Mitchell Lawyers Pty Ltd (No 2) [2012] FCA 485
Re Williams (1968) 13 FLR 10
Rigg v Baker (2006) 155 FCR 531
Sandell v Porter (1966) 115 CLR 666
Scott v Evia Pty Ltd [2008] VSC 324
Stankiewicz v Plata [2000] FCA 1185
Dates of hearing: 11, 12 and 16 April 2013
Date of last submissions: 24 May 2013
Place: Melbourne
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 47
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr A Tokley SC with Mr L Wirth
Solicitor for the Applicant: John Finlayson Lawyers
Counsel for the First Respondent: Mr D Shirrefs
Solicitor for the First Respondent: Wilmoth Field Warne Lawyers
Counsel for the Second and Third Respondents: Mr P Fary
Solicitor for the Second and Third Respondents: Mendelsons Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 5 of 2013

BETWEEN:

LOUISE FRANCIS
Applicant

AND:

EGGLESTON MITCHELL LAWYERS PTY LTD
First Respondent

GESS MICHAEL RAMBALDI
Second Respondent

ANDREW REGINALD YEO
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

MARSHALL J

DATE OF ORDER:

7 JUNE 2013

WHERE MADE:

MELBOURNE

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The proceeding is adjourned to a directions hearing to be held on 8 July 2013 at 10.00 am.

Note:Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

VID 5 of 2013

BETWEEN:

LOUISE FRANCIS
Applicant

AND:

EGGLESTON MITCHELL LAWYERS PTY LTD
First Respondent

GESS MICHAEL RAMBALDI
Second Respondent

ANDREW REGINALD YEO
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

MARSHALL J

DATE:

7 JUNE 2013

PLACE:

MELBOURNE

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

  1. The applicant, Ms Louise Francis, applies pursuant to s 153B(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) (“the Act”) for an order annulling her bankruptcy. The order is opposed by the first respondent, Eggleston Mitchell Lawyers Pty Ltd (“EML Pty Ltd”). EML Pty Ltd was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Francis v Eggleston Mitchell Lawyers Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 564
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court, Ms Francis applied to annul her sequestration on the basis that it "ought not to have been made." The application was opposed by two respondents: Eggleston Mitchell Lawyers Pty Ltd (EML Pty Ltd) and two Official Receivers. The first legal issue was whether EML Pty Ltd was a creditor of Ms Francis. The second issue was whether the order of Master Wood, on which the creditor's petition was based, was a final order. The third issue was whether Ms Francis was solvent at the relevant time.

The Court found that EML Pty Ltd was indeed a creditor of Ms Francis, as it was entitled to enforce the order of Master Wood for payment of the money ordered. The Court also found that the order of Master Wood was a final order, as it directly required the payment of a sum of money from Ms Francis to EML. Additionally, the Court determined that Ms Francis was not solvent as at 25 July 2011. Given these findings, the Court exercised its discretion not to annul the sequestration order, as all relevant factors either pointed against annulment or were neutral. The Court dismissed the application and adjourned the matter to a directions hearing to enable the parties to bring in draft minutes of orders beforehand to reflect the reasons of the Court.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The proceeding is adjourned to a directions hearing to be held on 8 July 2013 at 10.00 am.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ms Francis says she has not delayed in making the application. However, the possibility of it being made was raised in proceedings before Riley FM on review from the order of Caporale R. It seems that Ms Francis made a deliberate choice to challenge the order of Caporale R, through to the High Court of Australia if necessary, rather than commence an application for annulment with expedition. Conclusion on discretion All relevant factors which may be considered in the exercise of the Court’s discretion in this matter are either neutral or point strongly against the exercise of the discretion to annul the bankruptcy of Ms Francis. The Court would not have exercised its discretion to annul the bankruptcy, had it been satisfied that the Registrar would have been bound not to make the sequestration order.ORDER At the conclusion of the hearing on 16 April 2013, the Court discussed with counsel the range of orders appropriate to be made, depending on the result of the proceeding. Counsel agreed that the most appropriate course would be for the Court to make no order, other than to adjourn the matter to a directions hearing to enable the parties to bring in draft minutes of orders beforehand to reflect the reasons of the Court. As is apparent from the content of these reasons for judgment, the first such order should be that the proceeding is dismissed. The parties should formulate such other orders they consider appropriate to be made, including orders dealing with the position of the respondent trustees and orders dealing with costs. ADDENDUM On 7 May 2013, my Associate notified the parties that the Court intended to publish reasons for judgment in this matter on 9 May 2013. The above reasons at [1] to [41] are those which were ready for publication on 9 May 2013. They are now supplemented by the portion of this judgment which follows. The Court delayed publication of the reasons for judgment as a result of the first respondent’s request to re-open its case to adduce further evidence. Ms Francis did not oppose the application to re-open. The Court permits it. The further evidence consisted of an affidavit of Mr Russell George Mitchell which exhibited a document called “Dissolution Deed” (“the Deed”). Mr Mitchell located the Deed after the Court reserved its judgment. The evidence deals with issues other than the content of the Deed. To the extent that the evidence deals other than with the content of the Deed and the circumstances of its making, the Court has had no regard to it. On 18 July 2008, Mr Mitchell, Mr Eggleston (the former partners of EML) and their associated entities entered into the Deed. The Deed provided for the dissolution of the partnership between Mr Mitchell and Mr Eggleston and for Mr Mitchell to be authorised to conduct the business of the partnership as Mr Eggleston’s agent. The Deed otherwise gave Mr Mitchell the right to conduct the ongoing business of the partnership with effect from 30 June 2008. Mr Mitchell also purchased Mr Eggleston’s interest in any partnership assets, including any book debts.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

A sequestration order ought not to have been made if, at the time of its making, in light of the true facts then existing, the judicial officer making the order was “bound” not to make it; see Rigg v Baker at [62].GROUNDS FOR CONTENDING THAT THE REGISTRAR WAS BOUND NOT TO MAKE THE SEQUESTRATION ORDER Ms Francis submits that the Registrar was bound not to make the sequestration order because:1.EML Pty Ltd was not a creditor of Ms Francis;2.The order of Master Wood on which the creditor’s petition was founded is not a final order or judgment;3.She was solvent as at 25 July 2011, being able to pay her debts as and when they fell due.Ground 1: Identity of the creditor Section 40(1)(g) of the Act provides to the effect that a debtor commits an act of bankruptcy if a creditor has obtained a final order or final judgment and a bankruptcy notice has been served on the debtor with which the debtor has not complied. Section 40(3)(d) of the Act provides:A person who is for the time being entitled to enforce a final judgment or final order for the payment of money shall be deemed to be a creditor who has obtained a final judgment or final order. The bankruptcy notice and creditor’s petition were founded on an order of Master Wood (as his Honour then was) made on 11 May 2006. On that order, the plaintiff is described as “Louise Francis” and the Defendant as “Eggleston Mitchell”. Order 2 of those orders provides:The bill of costs of the Defendant are assessed in the sum of $11,847.40 such sum to be paid by the Plaintiff to the Defendant [emphasis added]. In 2004, Ms Francis retained the services of the firm, Eggleston Mitchell Lawyers. The firm was a partnership between Mr Russell Mitchell and Mr Peter Eggleston. The order of Master Wood on 11 May 2006 followed a dispute between Ms Francis and Eggleston Mitchell Lawyers concerning the fees charged to Ms Francis by the firm. In July 2008, the partnership was dissolved. The first defendant company (referred to in these reasons as “EML Pty Ltd”) was incorporated on 30 June 2008. On 29 January 2009, all of the business, work in progress, debts and liabilities of the partnership were transferred to EML Pty Ltd. Insofar as the partnership had dissolved before 29 January 2009 the former individual members of the firm were nevertheless able to transfer any interests of the partnership to EML Pty Ltd. As at 29 January 2009 and thereafter, EML Pty Ltd became a person entitled to enforce the order of Master Wood for the payment of the money which Master Wood ordered to be paid. That is the effect of s 40(3)(d) of the Act referred to above at [9]. The Court rejects the submission of Ms Francis that EML Pty Ltd was not her creditor. Her debt, the subject of the order of Master Wood, did not simply vanish with the dissolution of the partnership.Ground 2: Final order? An anterior question arises as to whether the order of Master Wood was a final order. Ms Francis submits that it was not a final order and that the defendant in that proceeding was required to take an additional step of suing Ms Francis on the basis of the order. That submission is rejected. It is at odds with the very wording of the order set out at [10] above which requires that the money be paid. Further, the order was made by consent. This suggests that it was the intention of the parties to finalise the dispute between them by the payment of an amount of money in the sum there set out from the plaintiff to the defendant.