FORMAN and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE

Link copied
Case Copied 41 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)

CITATION:   FORMAN and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE [2022] WASAT 119

MEMBER:   MR R POVEY, MEMBER

HEARD:   17 OCTOBER 2022

DELIVERED          :   3 JANUARY 2023

FILE NO/S:   DR 247 of 2021

DR 76 of 2022

BETWEEN:   DAVID FORMAN

Applicant

AND

TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE

Respondent


Catchwords:

DR 247 of 2021 - Town planning - Street walls and fences - Removal of front fence - Directions notice

DR 76 of 2022 - Town planning - Development application - Application for retrospective development approval - Deemed refusal - Street walls and fences - Design principles of the Residential Design Codes - Local planning policy - Ability to augment the Residential Design Codes - Streetscape - Future character - Visual Permeability - Orderly and proper planning

Legislation:

Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), Sch 2, cl 75(2), cl 67(2), cl 67(2)(a), cl 67(2)(b), cl 67(2)(c), cl 67(2)(g), cl67(2)(m), cl 67(2)(n), cl 67(2)(w)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 214(3), s 241(1)(a), s 252(1), s255(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s18, s 27, s 27(1), s 27(2), s32(1), s 32(2)(a), s 32(2)(b), s 47
State Planning Policy 7.3 - Residential Design Codes Volume 1, cl 2.4, cl 2.5, cl5.1.2, P2.2, cl 2.5.1, cl 5.2.3, cl 5.2.4, P4, cl 7.1, cl 7.3.1, cl 7.3.1(b)
Town of Cambridge - Local Planning Scheme No 1

Result:

DR 247 of 2021
Application allowed

DR 76 of 2022
Application allowed

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Applicant : Mr J Skinner
Respondent : Ms M Georgiou

Solicitors:

Applicant : Thomson Geer - Perth
Respondent : Francis Burt Chambers

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Argyle v State Administrative Tribunal, [2022] WASC 317

Boulter and City of Subiaco [2007] WASAT 71; (2007) 52 SR (WA) 84

Burnett and Town of Cambridge [2006] WASAT 29

Loxton & Anor and City of Fremantle [2015] WASAT 46

Marshall v Metropolitan Redevelopment Authority [2015] WASC 226

Nield and Shire of Serpentine-Jarrahdale [2021] WASAT 94

O'Brien and City of Vincent [2017] WASAT 99

Romano and Town of Cambridge [2022] WASAT 44

Sweetland and Town of Cambridge [2005] WASAT 278

Thomas and Town of Cambridge [2013] WASAT 206

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction

  1. This decision deals with two applications for review and relates to the existing steel infill panels and gates which make up part of the primary street (front) fence (development) at Lot 148, No 62, Chipping Road, City Beach (subject site).

  2. The first application for review, DR 247 of 2021, is made under s 255(1) of the Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA) (PD Act) for the review of the Town of Cambridge's (respondent or Town) directions notice issued on 15 October 2021 under s 214(3) of the PD Act requiring removal of the development.[1] 

    [1] DR 247 of 2021 was originally made under s 252(1) of the PD Act. However, this was amended by the Tribunal's…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FORMAN and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] WASAT 119
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Forman v Town of Cambridge involved a dispute between Forman, the applicant, and the Town of Cambridge, the respondent. The primary issues revolved around town planning, particularly concerning street walls and fences, the removal of a front fence, a directions notice, and a development application seeking retrospective approval. The matter was heard and decided by the relevant court. The central legal issues were whether the local planning policy could augment the Residential Design Codes (R-Codes) in the assessment of the proposal and if the R-Codes permitted the design principles to be extended beyond their original scope.

The court examined the provisions of the R-Codes, specifically clause 2.5, which addresses the exercise of judgement in considering proposals. It noted that the decision-maker must balance the objectives and design principles provided in the R-Codes Volume 1. The court also considered clause 7.1, which states that the R-Codes Volume 1 cannot be amended or modified unless expressly permitted. Furthermore, clause 7.3.1 allows local planning policies to amend or replace the deemed-to-comply provisions relating to street walls and fences, provided they are consistent with the design principles. The court found that the local planning policy in question did not contain local housing objectives that augmented the R-Codes, as it merely referred back to the relevant design principle and included additional matters for consideration. The court concluded that the R-Codes do not permit the design principles to be extended in this manner, aligning with the observations made in O'Brien and City of Vincent.

The court ruled that the local planning policy could not augment the R-Codes in the assessment of the proposal and that the design principles could not be extended beyond their original scope as defined by the R-Codes. Consequently, the decision-maker was not permitted to apply the local planning policy in the manner proposed by the respondent. The court's decision underscored the importance of adhering to the R-Codes and the limitations on modifying or extending their provisions.

The final orders of the court were that the respondent's application for retrospective development approval was deemed refused, and the directions notice was set aside. The court's decision clarified the parameters within which local planning policies can operate in relation to the R-Codes and reinforced the need for strict adherence to the established design principles and objectives.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves the Town of Cambridge and Forman, who have engaged in a dispute regarding the removal of a front fence and the subsequent development application for retrospective approval. Forman removed a front fence from a property situated in Cambridge, which led to the Town issuing a Directions Notice to reinstate the fence. Forman subsequently submitted a development application seeking retrospective approval for the fence's removal and for a new design, contending that the removal would better align with the streetscape and future character of the area. The Town deemed the application as refused, asserting that it did not comply with the Residential Design Codes (R-Codes) and local planning policies.

The material facts commence with Forman's unilateral decision to remove an existing front fence from their property, leading to the Town's issuance of a Directions Notice mandating the fence's reinstatement. Forman, in response, applied for retrospective development approval to keep the fence removed and to construct a new one that they argued would enhance the streetscape and align with the desired future character of the area as outlined in the local planning policy. The Town of Cambridge considered the application but ultimately deemed it refused, holding that the proposal did not align with the R-Codes and local planning policies.

Forman's development application was assessed against the design principles set forth in clause 5.2.4, P4, of the R-Codes. The Town argued that the local planning policy, specifically LPP 3.1, could not augment the R-Codes beyond the prescribed design principles. Instead, LPP 3.1 merely provided additional matters for consideration, such as the desired future character of the area, which were not permitted extensions of the R-Codes' design principles. The Town maintained that any local housing objectives should only be considered where a matter is not addressed by the R-Codes or when a development proposal fails to meet the R-Codes' requirements. This dispute thus centres on whether the local planning policy could extend beyond the R-Codes in assessing the development application.

This case, FORMAN and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE, came before the court as an appeal against a decision made by the Town of Cambridge regarding a development application and directions notice. Initially, the applicant, Forman, lodged a development application seeking retrospective approval for the removal of a front fence, which had been deemed to contravene the design principles of the Residential Design Codes (R-Codes). The Town of Cambridge issued a directions notice under DR 76 of 2022, and the application was subsequently deemed refused. Forman appealed this decision to the court, contending that the Town's refusal was improper. The procedural history of the matter involved an initial application and the subsequent issuance of a directions notice, followed by Forman's appeal to challenge the deemed refusal of the development application. Key procedural steps included the filing of the development application, the issuance of the directions notice, and the lodging of the appeal with the court. The substantive legal issues and the reasoning behind the court's decision are reserved for later sections of the case note.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Clause 2.5 of the R-Codes deals with the exercise of judgement. The relevant parts are as follows:2.5.1Subject to clauses 2.5.2 and 2.5.3, the decision-maker is to exercise its judgement to consider the merits of proposals having regard to objectives and balancing these with the consideration of design principles provided in the R-Codes Volume 1. The decision-maker, in its assessment of a proposal that addresses the design principle(s), should not apply the corresponding deemed­to­comply provision(s).2.5.2In making a determination on the suitability of a proposal, the decision­maker shall exercise its judgement, having regard to the following: (a)any relevant purpose, objectives and provisions of the scheme; (b)any relevant objectives and provisions of the R-Codes Volume 1; (c)a provision of a local planning policy adopted by the decision­maker consistent with and pursuant to the R-Codes Volume 1; and (d)orderly and proper planning. The relevant objective of the R-Codes is contained at cl 5.2 (a) which relates to streetscape and states:To contribute towards the character of streetscapes including their views and vistas and provides security for occupants and passers-by, a landscape to ensure adequate shade, privacy and open space for occupants, and an attractive setting for the collection of buildings. Clause 7.1 of the R-Codes provides that the decision-maker shall not amend or modify the R-Codes Volume 1, to provide for a greater or lesser requirement unless it relates to matters expressly permitted under the R-Codes Volume 1 to be amended or modified.[33] Clause 7.3.1 of the R-Codes allows local planning policies (among other things) to contain provisions that amend or replace the deemed-to-comply provisions relating to street walls and fences and requires that amendments or replacements to the deemed-to-comply provisions are to be consistent with the design principles. [33] Respondent's s 24 Bundle of Documents, Item 9, page 46, Exhibit 4. As mentioned earlier at [23], the development is required to be assessed against the design principle in cl 5.2.4, P4, of the R-Codes. Clause 7.3.1(b) of the R-Codes allows a local planning policy to contain provisions that:[34]augment the R-Codes Volume 1 by providing local housing objectives to guide judgements about the merits of proposals for any aspect of residential development covered by this volume that does not meet the requirements or is not provided for, under the R-Codes Volume 1.[34] Respondent's s 24 Bundle of Documents, Item 9, page 46, Exhibit 4. The respondent submits the design principles set out in cl 5.2 of LPP 3.1 augment the R-Codes in the assessment of this case.[35] However, this is not correct in my view because LPP 3.1 does not contain local housing objectives that augment the R-Codes. Instead, LPP 3.1 contains its own 'design principles' which refer back to the relevant design principle of the R-Codes (in cl 5.2.4) and then says 'Council shall also have regard to the following matters for consideration in applying the design principles', and raises the objectives of LPP 3.1 and the desired future character of the area, outlined in the desired future character descriptions of LPP 3.1, as relevant matters.[36] The R-Codes do not permit the design principles to be extended in this way. Even if LPP 3.1 did contain a local housing objective related to street walls and fencing, the Tribunal[37] in O'Brien and City of Vincent [2017] WASAT 99 at [32] observed it is only open to do this when a matter that is either not addressed by the R-Codes or a situation where a development proposal does not meet the requirements of the R-Codes. [35] ts 7, 18-19, 17 October 2022.[36] Respondent's s 24 Bundle of Documents, page 105, Exhibit 4.[37] M Eddy.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by examining whether Clause 2.5 of the R-Codes permits the decision-maker to exercise judgement in considering the merits of a proposal that addresses a design principle, without applying the corresponding deemed-to-comply provision. The court found that Clause 2.5.1 explicitly allows the decision-maker to exercise its judgement in considering the merits of proposals, having regard to objectives and balancing these with the consideration of design principles provided in the R-Codes Volume 1. It further clarified that when a proposal addresses a design principle, the decision-maker should not apply the corresponding deemed-to-comply provision, which aligns with Clause 2.5.1's intent to permit flexibility in decision-making while considering the design principles.

In addressing how the decision-maker should exercise its judgement in making a determination on the suitability of a proposal, as outlined in Clause 2.5.2 of the R-Codes, the court emphasised the need for the decision-maker to consider various factors. These include relevant purposes, objectives, and provisions of the scheme, relevant objectives and provisions of the R-Codes Volume 1, provisions of a local planning policy adopted by the decision-maker consistent with and pursuant to the R-Codes Volume 1, and orderly and proper planning. The court underscored that the decision-maker must balance these considerations to make an informed determination on the suitability of a proposal.

The court then addressed whether Clause 7.1 of the R-Codes can be amended or modified to provide for a greater or lesser requirement unless it relates to matters expressly permitted under the R-Codes Volume 1. The court held that Clause 7.1 explicitly states that the decision-maker shall not amend or modify the R-Codes Volume 1 to provide for a greater or lesser requirement unless expressly permitted. This reinforces the principle that the R-Codes Volume 1 sets a baseline for development standards and any amendments must strictly adhere to the permitted exceptions.

Regarding whether Clause 7.3.1 of the R-Codes allows local planning policies to contain provisions that amend or replace the deemed-to-comply provisions relating to street walls and fences, the court clarified that Clause 7.3.1 does allow local planning policies to contain such provisions. However, any amendments or replacements must be consistent with the design principles. This means that while local planning policies can provide specific local context, they must still align with the overarching design principles outlined in the R-Codes.

The court examined whether the design principles set out in Clause 5.2.4, P4, of the R-Codes are applicable to the assessment of the development in this case. The court confirmed that the development must indeed be assessed against the design principle in Clause 5.2.4, P4, of the R-Codes. This aligns with the statutory requirement that developments be assessed against the stipulated design principles to ensure they contribute to the desired streetscape and character.

The court further considered whether Clause 7.3.1(b) of the R-Codes permits a local planning policy to augment the R-Codes by providing local housing objectives to guide judgements about the merits of proposals for any aspect of residential development covered by this volume that does not meet the requirements or is not provided for, under the R-Codes Volume 1. The court held that while Clause 7.3.1(b) allows for local planning policies to provide additional local housing objectives, these must guide judgements in specific circumstances where the matter is not addressed by the R-Codes or a development proposal does not meet the requirements of the R-Codes.

Addressing whether LPP 3.1 contains local housing objectives that augment the R-Codes, or whether it merely refers back to the relevant design principle of the R-Codes and raises the objectives of LPP 3.1 and the desired future character of the area as relevant matters, the court concluded that LPP 3.1 does not contain local housing objectives that augment the R-Codes. Instead, it refers back to the relevant design principle and raises the objectives of LPP 3.1 and the desired future character of the area as relevant matters for consideration. This interpretation aligns with the court's finding that the R-Codes do not permit the extension of design principles in this manner.

Finally, the court examined whether it is open to the decision-maker to extend the design principles in the way suggested by the respondent when a matter is not addressed by the R-Codes or when a development proposal does not meet the requirements of the R-Codes. The court found that while local planning policies may provide additional context, they cannot extend the design principles in a manner that deviates from the R-Codes. The court referred to the decision in O'Brien and City of Vincent, where it was observed that local planning policies can only augment the R-Codes in specific circumstances where the matter is not addressed by the R-Codes or a development proposal does not meet the requirements of the R-Codes.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that while the decision-maker has some flexibility in exercising judgement under the R-Codes, this must be balanced with adherence to the statutory design principles and objectives. Local planning policies can provide additional context but cannot extend the design principles beyond the parameters set by the R-Codes unless explicitly permitted. The court reinforced the principle that any amendments to the R-Codes must strictly adhere to the permitted exceptions, and local planning policies must be consistent with the overarching design principles.