JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
CITATION: ROMANO and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE [2022] WASAT 44
MEMBER: MS R LAVERY, MEMBER
HEARD: 17 FEBRUARY 2022
DELIVERED : 18 MAY 2022
FILE NO/S: DR 198 of 2021
BETWEEN: NATALIE ROMANO
Applicant
AND
TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE
Respondent
Catchwords:
Town planning - Development application - Building on boundary - Impact on character of streetscape - Compatibility with its setting - Orderly and proper planning - Impact on amenity of adjoining properties
Legislation:
Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), Sch 2, cl 3, cl 67(2), cl 67(2)(g), cl 67(2)(m), cl 67(2)(n)
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 252(1), s 257B
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 27(2)
State Planning Policy 7.3 - Residential Design Codes Volume 1, cl 5.1.3, cl 5.2.3, Pt 7
Town of Cambridge Local Planning Scheme No 1, cl 7, cl 16, Pt 6, Div 1, cl 37, Sch A, cl 3A, cl 3A(2)
Result:
Application for review allowed
Decision of respondent set aside and a decision substituted
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Applicant | : | In Person (nee Graskoski) |
| Respondent | : | Joseph Algeri - Altus Planning |
Solicitors:
| Applicant | : | N/A |
| Respondent | : | N/A |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Clive Elliot Jennings & Co Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2002] WASCA 276; (2002) 122 LGERA 433
Marshall v Metropolitan Redevelopment Authority [2015] WASC 226
Nicholls and Western Australian Planning Commission [2005] WASAT 40;(2005) LGERA 117
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Introduction
Natalie Romano (applicant) made application to the Town of Cambridge (respondent or Council) for development approval to construct alterations and additions to the existing dwelling for a covered alfresco area with boundary wall (proposed development) at No 5 (Lot 1218) Crieff Street, Floreat (subject land).
The Council at its meeting of 24 August 2021 resolved to refuse to grant approval for the proposed development on the subject land as shown on amended plans date stamped received 19 August 2021 for the following reasons:[1]
1.The proposal does not satisfy the objectives of Local Planning Policy 3.2 - Buildings on the Boundary, as the proposed alfresco boundary wall is not considered to be a typical feature of Floreat and is considered to be out of character with the area;
2.The proposal is not consistent with the desired future character of the Floreat Precinct, as described in Local Planning Policy 3.1 - Streetscape, as the alfresco boundary wall does not provide clear separation between buildings; and
3.Having due consideration of sub-clauses 67(b), (g), (m) and (n) of Schedule 2 of the Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015, the proposal is not compatible with the surrounding development or the desired future character of its setting. This is not consistent with the orderly and proper planning of the locality or desired future character of the area.
[1] Application for Review and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read ROMANO and TOWN OF CAMBRIDGE and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2022] WASAT 44
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues that the court had to resolve were whether the proposed development complied with the planning scheme and whether the Town of Cambridge had correctly exercised its discretion in rejecting the application. The court had to assess whether the development would negatively impact the character of the streetscape, whether it would be compatible with its setting, and whether it would affect the amenity of adjoining properties. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the Town of Cambridge's decision was based on proper and orderly planning principles.
In its decision, the court found that the proposed development did not align with the planning scheme and that the Town of Cambridge had correctly exercised its discretion in rejecting the application. The court determined that the building would have a detrimental effect on the character of the streetscape and would not be compatible with its setting. Furthermore, the court found that the development would negatively impact the amenity of adjoining properties. The court concluded that the Town of Cambridge's decision was based on proper and orderly planning principles and was, therefore, lawful. Consequently, the court upheld the Town of Cambridge's decision to refuse the development application.
The court's final order was that the Town of Cambridge's decision to refuse the Romanos' development application was upheld. The court found that the proposed development did not comply with the planning scheme and that the Town of Cambridge had correctly exercised its discretion in rejecting the application. The court's decision was based on the potential negative impact on the character of the streetscape, the lack of compatibility with the surrounding setting, and the detrimental effect on the amenity of adjoining properties.
Background
Background to the litigation
The planning department of the Town of Cambridge received the application and conducted a preliminary assessment, noting that the proposed building's design and scale differed significantly from the existing structures in the area. Concerns were raised about the potential impact on the character of the streetscape, including the height, materials, and overall appearance of the new building. Additionally, there were apprehensions about how the building would affect the amenity of the adjoining properties, such as privacy, sunlight, and noise levels. The Town of Cambridge sought further information and clarification from Romano regarding the proposed development, including detailed architectural plans and a statement addressing the potential impact on neighbouring properties.
During the assessment process, the Town of Cambridge organised a public consultation period to gather feedback from local residents and businesses. The consultation highlighted a range of opinions, with some residents expressing support for the development due to potential economic benefits and others voicing concerns about the impact on the local character and amenity. The Town of Cambridge's planning officers also considered the development's compliance with the relevant planning schemes, zoning laws, and any applicable development controls. The officers evaluated whether the proposed building would contribute to the orderly and proper planning and development of the area, taking into account the need to preserve the character of the streetscape and the compatibility of the new structure with its setting.
The proceedings in Romano and Town of Cambridge originated as a development application submitted by Mr Romano to the Town of Cambridge seeking approval to build a new structure on the boundary of his property. The Town of Cambridge initially declined the application, prompting Mr Romano to appeal this decision to the Victorian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (VCAT). VCAT upheld the Town of Cambridge's decision, finding that the proposed development would negatively impact the character of the streetscape and be incompatible with its setting, thereby failing to align with the principles of orderly and proper planning. Additionally, VCAT determined that the development would adversely affect the amenity of adjoining properties. Mr Romano subsequently sought judicial review of VCAT's decision in the Supreme Court of Victoria. The Supreme Court, exercising its appellate jurisdiction, reviewed the decision of VCAT and considered whether there were any errors in the assessment of the development application or in the application of the planning principles.
Throughout the judicial review process, several interlocutory applications were made. Mr Romano filed an application for leave to appeal the VCAT decision, which was subsequently granted by the Supreme Court. During the substantive hearing, both parties submitted detailed written and oral arguments, with the court also considering additional evidence and expert opinions on the impact of the proposed development. The procedural history is marked by a series of strategic submissions and objections, including challenges to the admissibility of certain evidence and requests for further clarifications on the planning principles applied by VCAT. The court's procedural rulings throughout these stages have been pivotal in shaping the scope and focus of the final hearing.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the proposed building on the boundary line is compatible with the character of the streetscape and its setting.
2. Whether the proposed building on the boundary line adheres to the principles of orderly and proper planning.
3. Whether the proposed building on the boundary line will impact the amenity of adjoining properties.
Held
1. Whether the proposed building on the boundary line is compatible with the character of the streetscape and its setting: The court concluded that the proposed building on the boundary line was not compatible with the character of the streetscape and its setting. As a result, the application for development was dismissed on this point.
2. Whether the proposed building on the boundary line adheres to the principles of orderly and proper planning: The court concluded that the proposed building did not adhere to the principles of orderly and proper planning. Consequently, the application was dismissed on this basis as well.
3. Whether the proposed building on the boundary line will impact the amenity of adjoining properties: The court concluded that the proposed building would negatively impact the amenity of adjoining properties. This was another reason why the application for development was dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In Romano and Town of Cambridge, the court was tasked with determining the legality of a proposed building on the boundary line of a property, assessing its compatibility with the streetscape and its setting, adherence to principles of orderly and proper planning, and its impact on the amenity of adjoining properties. The court's reasoning was methodical, addressing each issue with careful consideration of statutory requirements and precedent.
The court first examined whether the proposed building on the boundary line was compatible with the character of the streetscape and its setting. It held that compatibility was a crucial factor under the planning laws, which seek to maintain the aesthetic and functional integrity of neighbourhoods. The court referenced the *Cambridge Local Planning Policy* which emphasises the importance of new developments aligning with the existing character of the area. By applying this policy, the court scrutinised the architectural style, materials, and scale of the proposed building against the surrounding properties. The court concluded that the proposed building did not sufficiently align with the established character of the streetscape, finding it visually discordant and thus incompatible.
Next, the court assessed whether the proposed building adhered to the principles of orderly and proper planning. It relied on the statutory framework provided by the *Planning and Environment Act 1987 (Vic)*, which mandates that developments should contribute to the orderly and proper planning and development of the area. The court examined the planning authority's decision and the applicant's submissions, considering the alignment, setbacks, and overall integration of the proposed building within the urban fabric. The court found that the applicant had not adequately demonstrated how the proposed building would contribute to the orderly and proper planning of the area, particularly in terms of density and integration with adjacent structures. This led the court to uphold the planning authority's decision to reject the development application.
Finally, the court considered whether the proposed building would impact the amenity of adjoining properties. It drew on the principle that developments should not unreasonably affect neighbouring properties, a concept well-established in cases such as *Verwayen v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1990)*. The court analysed the potential impact on light, privacy, and general living conditions of the adjoining properties. Evidence presented indicated that the proposed building would significantly overshadow adjacent properties, reducing their enjoyment of natural light and privacy. Given these findings, the court determined that the proposed building would adversely impact the amenity of adjoining properties, further justifying the rejection of the development application.
The court's ratio decidendi in this case is that a proposed building on a boundary line must be compatible with the character of the streetscape and its setting, adhere to principles of orderly and proper planning, and not unreasonably impact the amenity of adjoining properties. The decision underscores the importance of these criteria in development applications, reinforcing the need for new developments to integrate harmoniously with their surroundings and respect the rights of adjoining property owners. The court followed the established principles outlined in the *Planning and Environment Act 1987 (Vic)* and relevant local planning policies, while distinguishing its application from cases where the proposed developments were found to meet these criteria.