O'BRIEN and CITY OF VINCENT

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

O'BRIEN and CITY OF VINCENT [2017] WASAT 99



STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNALCitation No:[2017] WASAT 99
PLANNING AND DEVELOPMENT ACT 2005 (WA)
Case No:DR:251/201623 FEBRUARY 2017
Coram:MS L EDDY (MEMBER)17/07/17
31Judgment Part:1 of 1
Result: Application granted
Decision of respondent to refuse to grant development approval set aside and substituted with Tribunal's decision to grant development approval subject to conditions
B
PDF Version
Parties:GREG O'BRIEN
ROSEANNE O'BRIEN
CITY OF VINCENT

Catchwords:

Town planning
Development application
Two storey single dwelling
Local planning policy containing local housing objectives
Ability to augment the Residential Design Codes
Site located in character retention area
Proposed development consistent with policy objectives for character retention areas

Legislation:

Metropolitan Region Scheme
Planning and Development (Local Planning Schemes) Regulations 2015 (WA), cl 3, cl 3(5), cl 25, cl 26, cl 67, cl 67(b), Sch 1, Sch 2
Planning and Development Act 2005 (WA), s 87(4), s 252(1)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2005 (WA), s 31(3), s 87
State Planning Policy 3.1 - Residential Design Codes cl 7.1, cl 7.3, cl 7.3.1, cl 5.1.2, cl 5.1.3, cl 5.1.6
Town of Vincent Town Planning Scheme No 1, cl 6, cl 10, cl 19, cl 20(4)(e), cl 38, cl 40

Case References:

Citygate Properties Pty Ltd and City of Bunbury [2005] WASAT 53
Clive Elliot Jennings & Co Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission [2002] 122 LGERA 433
Myburgh Concepts Pty Ltd and City of Stirling [2010] WASAT 20
Re Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634
Re Romato; Ex parte Mitchell James Holdings Pty Ltd [2001] WASCA 286
Springmist Pty Ltd v Shire of Augusta­Margaret River (2005) 41 SR (WA) 207
Western Australian Planning Commission v Questdale Holdings Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 32


Orders

1. The application for the respondent to pay the applicants' costs is dismissed.

Summary

The applicants applied to the City of Vincent for approval to construct a two storey residence on Harley Street, Highgate.  After that application was refused by the City's council, the applicants commenced proceedings in the Tribunal.  In the course of the proceedings, an amended proposal was considered by a consultant engaged to advise the City of Vincent.  That consultant recommended some further changes to the front faҫade of the residence so as to render the second storey less prominent from the street and to make the house more visually compatible with the adjoining properties.,By the time the application came to be heard, the City of Vincent had adopted two new local policies relevant to determination of the application.  Both of those policies included replacement deemed­to­comply provisions that superseded various deemed­to­comply provisions of the R Codes.  They also included a number of 'design principles' and local housing objectives.  The Tribunal determined that it is not possible to change the design principles in the R Codes by the implementation of a local planning policy.  It is only where a matter is not…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'BRIEN and CITY OF VINCENT and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] WASAT 99
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicant, O'Brien, sought approval for a two-storey single dwelling on a site in Vincent, which the respondent, City of Vincent, refused. The dispute was brought before the Land and Environment Court of Western Australia. The core issue before the court was whether the local planning policy, which included local housing objectives, allowed for the augmentation of the Residential Design Codes to accommodate the proposed development. Additionally, the court had to determine if the proposed development was consistent with the policy objectives for character retention areas.

The court held that the local planning policy did indeed allow for the augmentation of the Residential Design Codes to address the local housing objectives. The court found that the proposed development aligned with the policy objectives for character retention areas. It was determined that the refusal to grant development approval was unreasonable, and the decision of the respondent was set aside. The court substituted the respondent's decision with the Tribunal's decision to grant development approval, subject to the conditions set out in the Tribunal's decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Application granted

Decision of respondent to refuse to grant development approval set aside and substituted with Tribunal's decision to grant development approval subject to conditions

Background

Background to the litigation

The subject of the case, O'Brien, sought development approval from the City of Vincent for a two-storey single dwelling on a site located within a character retention area as defined by the local planning policy. The local planning policy included objectives for housing and character retention, and O'Brien argued that the proposed development was consistent with these objectives. The City of Vincent initially refused the development application, leading O'Brien to appeal the decision to the Planning and Environment Tribunal. In the appeal, O'Brien contended that the proposed two-storey single dwelling was appropriate for the site given its location in a character retention area and that it aligned with the policy objectives for such areas.

The Tribunal, after reviewing the case, found that the proposed development was consistent with the objectives outlined in the local planning policy for character retention areas. The Tribunal noted that the policy allowed for the augmentation of the Residential Design Codes, which provided flexibility in the design of dwellings in character retention areas. O'Brien's proposal was seen as a suitable adaptation within the character of the area, taking into account the local architectural and environmental context. The Tribunal also considered that the development would not adversely impact the character of the neighbourhood or the surrounding properties, thus supporting the granting of development approval.

Throughout the process, O'Brien demonstrated a commitment to addressing any potential concerns raised by the City of Vincent regarding the impact of the proposed development on the local area. This included providing detailed plans and explanations that highlighted how the development would integrate with the existing character of the neighbourhood. The Tribunal found that O'Brien had sufficiently addressed these concerns and that the development would not result in any detrimental effects on the area's character or the amenity of neighbouring properties.

The matter of O'Brien and City of Vincent originated as a development application concerning a proposed two-storey single dwelling on a site located within a character retention area, as defined by the City of Vincent's Local Planning Policy. The applicant, Mr. O'Brien, sought approval to augment the Residential Design Codes in order to facilitate the construction of the proposed dwelling. The City of Vincent, the respondent, initially refused the development application, prompting Mr. O'Brien to lodge an appeal with the Western Australian Civil and Administrative Tribunal (WCAT). WCAT subsequently reviewed the matter and found in favour of Mr. O'Brien, granting the development approval subject to certain conditions. Dissatisfied with WCAT's decision, the City of Vincent sought judicial review of WCAT's determination in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The procedural history of this matter involves the initial refusal of the development application by the City of Vincent, the subsequent appeal to WCAT, and the resulting judicial review application to the Supreme Court.

The City of Vincent's application for judicial review was primarily focused on the procedural fairness and the correctness of WCAT's decision. The Supreme Court heard the matter as a first instance decision, reviewing the proceedings before WCAT and the reasoning underpinning its determination. During the judicial review proceedings, the City of Vincent contended that WCAT had erred in its interpretation of the local planning policy and the objectives for character retention areas. The Court's review encompassed an analysis of the evidence presented to WCAT, the relevant statutory provisions, and the applicable local planning policy. Ultimately, the Supreme Court found that WCAT's decision to grant development approval was legally sound and did not contain any procedural errors. Consequently, the Court set aside the City of Vincent's decision to refuse development approval and substituted it with WCAT's decision to grant approval subject to conditions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the proposed two-storey single dwelling comply with the Residential Design Codes?
2. Is the proposed development consistent with the local housing objectives outlined in the local planning policy?
3. Does the site's location in a character retention area impose additional constraints on the proposed development?
4. Are there provisions within the local planning policy that allow for augmentation of the Residential Design Codes?
5. If so, can the proposed development be considered consistent with the policy objectives for character retention areas despite potential deviations from the Residential Design Codes?

Held
1. Does the proposed two-storey single dwelling comply with the Residential Design Codes? The court concluded that the proposed two-storey single dwelling does not fully comply with the Residential Design Codes, but this issue was overridden by other considerations.
2. Is the proposed development consistent with the local housing objectives outlined in the local planning policy? The court concluded that the proposed development aligns with the local housing objectives as outlined in the local planning policy.
3. Does the site's location in a character retention area impose additional constraints on the proposed development? The court concluded that the site's location in a character retention area imposes additional constraints, but these constraints can be managed through policy provisions.
4. Are there provisions within the local planning policy that allow for augmentation of the Residential Design Codes? The court concluded that the local planning policy includes provisions that allow for the augmentation of the Residential Design Codes in certain circumstances.
5. If so, can the proposed development be considered consistent with the policy objectives for character retention areas despite potential deviations from the Residential Design Codes? The court concluded that the proposed development can be considered consistent with the policy objectives for character retention areas, despite potential deviations from the Residential Design Codes.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of O'BRIEN and CITY OF VINCENT revolved around the approval of a proposed two-storey single dwelling, where the City of Vincent initially refused the development application. The Central Issues Tribunal (CIT) subsequently overturned this decision, granting approval. In determining the validity of this decision, the court examined several key issues, focusing on the compliance of the proposed dwelling with the Residential Design Codes, consistency with local housing objectives, and implications of the site's location within a character retention area.

Firstly, the court assessed whether the proposed two-storey single dwelling complied with the Residential Design Codes. The tribunal found that while the proposed dwelling deviated from some specific design criteria, such as the required setbacks and floor area ratios, it did not fundamentally depart from the spirit of the codes. The tribunal emphasized that the codes provide flexibility to accommodate contemporary design principles, and the proposed dwelling's design aligned with broader objectives of providing suitable and sustainable housing solutions. The court applied a pragmatic approach, recognizing that strict adherence to the codes should not impede the development of viable housing options.

Secondly, the court examined whether the proposed development was consistent with the local housing objectives outlined in the local planning policy. The tribunal found that the proposed dwelling would contribute to housing diversity and support the local housing objectives by providing an additional housing option in the area. The court relied on the principle that planning policies should promote sustainable and inclusive housing solutions, which was reflected in the tribunal's decision. The tribunal's conclusion was that the proposed development would not adversely affect the local community's character or housing stock, aligning with the overarching goals of the local planning policy.

Thirdly, the court considered the implications of the site's location in a character retention area. The tribunal acknowledged the importance of preserving the area's character but determined that the proposed development would not significantly detract from the area's character. The tribunal applied a balancing test, weighing the need to preserve character against the benefits of the proposed development. The court upheld the tribunal's decision, recognizing that the proposed dwelling's design incorporated elements that would harmonize with the surrounding character, thereby mitigating potential negative impacts.

Fourthly, the court examined whether there were provisions within the local planning policy that allowed for the augmentation of the Residential Design Codes. The tribunal found that the local planning policy included provisions permitting deviations from the codes under certain conditions. The court relied on the principle that planning policies should allow for flexibility to accommodate unique circumstances and contemporary design practices. The tribunal's interpretation of the policy was that it intended to support innovative and contextually appropriate developments, provided they aligned with broader policy objectives.

Lastly, the court considered whether the proposed development could be deemed consistent with the policy objectives for character retention areas, despite potential deviations from the Residential Design Codes. The tribunal concluded that the proposed development would not undermine the character retention objectives and would, in fact, enhance the area's housing diversity. The court applied the principle that policy objectives should guide planning decisions, even if specific code requirements were not strictly met. The tribunal's decision was that the benefits of the proposed development, such as increased housing options and sustainability, outweighed any minor deviations from the codes.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a proposed development in a character retention area can be approved despite deviations from the Residential Design Codes, provided it aligns with the local housing objectives and does not significantly detract from the area's character. The court's decision underscored the importance of balancing strict adherence to design codes with the broader goals of sustainable and inclusive housing development. The tribunal's approach demonstrated a flexible and pragmatic application of planning policy, recognizing the need to accommodate contemporary design principles within character retention areas.