Fletcher International Exports Pty Ltd v Barrow

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      FLETCHER INTERNATIONAL EXPORTS PTY LIMITED v BARROW & ANOR [2007]  NSWCA 244

FILE NUMBER(S):
40417/06

HEARING DATE(S):               15 June 2007

JUDGMENT DATE: 13 September 2007

PARTIES:
FLETCHER INTERNATIONAL EXPORTS LIMITED
Thomas BARROW (First Respondent)
CGU WORKERS COMPENSATION (NSW) LIMITED (Second Respondent)

JUDGMENT OF:       Mason P Santow JA Tobias JA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Workers  Compensation Commission

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          WCC7860-04

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Acting Deputy President Deborah Moore

LOWER COURT DATE OF DECISION:    14 June 2006

COUNSEL:
Appellant: L King SC/ D G Saul
First Respondent: M J Joseph SC/ J W Catsanos
Second Respondent: P Webb QC/ R A Stanton

SOLICITORS:
Appellant: Leigh Virtue & Associates
First Respondent: Oates & Smith
Second Respondent: Sparke Helmore

CATCHWORDS:
WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – Liability to pay compensation – liability of employer – other cases – liability of insurer – where employer became self-insured – where injury degenerative over time – whether injury a disease – Workers Compensation Act 1987, s 16
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Judicial review – grounds of review – procedural fairness – determining matter on the papers – whether Commission required to notify parties of decision to determine matter on the papers – having regard to material beyond the record of Arbitration – Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998, s 354(6)
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Judicial review – grounds of review – jurisdictional matters – whether Arbitrator acted outside jurisdiction in determining claim – where claim for compensation non-compliant with WorkCover Guidelines – whether proceedings a nullity – Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998, s 260 – WorkCover Guidelines
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – Judicial review – procedure and evidence – evidence – whether no evidence to support findings of fact

LEGISLATION CITED:
Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998
Workers Compensation Act 1987

CASES CITED:
Aluminium Louvres & Ceilings Pty Ltd v Xue Qin Zheng [2006] NSWCA 34
Armao v Ladue Holdings Pty Ltd (1992) 8 NSWCCR 440
Berowra Holdings Pty Ltd v Gordon (2006) 225 CLR 364
Cottons Glass & Aluminium Pty Ltd v Handsaker [2006] NSWCCPD 205
Fletcher International Exports Pty Ltd v Barrow [2006] NSWWCCPD 119
Kurrajong Holdings t/as The Gardeners Inn v Carrette [2004] NSWWCCPD 8
Perry v Tanine Pty Ltd t/as Ermington Hotel (1998) 16 NSWCCR 253
Watson v Hanimex Colour Services Pty Ltd (1991) 8 NSWCCR 190

DECISION:
Appeal dismissed with costs

JUDGMENT:

THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA 40417/2006
  WCC 7860-04

MASON P
  SANTOW JA
  TOBIAS JA

Thursday 13 September 2007

FLETCHER INTERNATIONAL EXPORTS PTY LTD v Thomas BARROW & Anor

The first respondent (the worker) was employed by the appellant (the employer) between 1990 and 23 May 2002. The second respondent (the insurer) was the employer’s workers compensation insurer until 31 August 1999. Thereafter the employer was self-insured.

The worker has had recurrent problems with his right shoulder from 1992 onwards and in December 2000 the worker notified the employer of an injury to his right upper…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fletcher International Exports Pty Ltd v Barrow and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWCA 244
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this matter, Fletcher International Exports Pty Ltd (the employer) appealed to the Court of Appeal of New South Wales against a decision of a Presidential member of the Workers Compensation Commission. The dispute concerned the employer's liability to pay compensation to a former employee for a shoulder injury, with the employer arguing that its condition was a "nature and conditions injury" rather than a "disease" or the aggravation of a disease, a distinction critical to determining liability between the employer and its insurer.

The primary legal issues before the Court of Appeal included whether the Arbitrator erred in finding that the worker suffered from a disease or the aggravation of a disease, given the employer's contention that the injury was merely a "nature and conditions injury." This also involved considering whether the employer was estopped from departing from its earlier submission that the worker's condition was "at best, a disease process." The court was also required to determine if the Arbitrator's findings of fact regarding the injury and its connection to the worker's employment were supported by evidence.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the employer's appeal, finding that the Arbitrator's determination that the worker suffered an injury to his right shoulder between 1990 and 2002, which arose out of or in the course of his employment and was substantially contributed to by that employment, was a finding of fact. The court noted that the Arbitrator had considered extensive medical evidence from various specialists provided by both the worker and the employer. The employer's argument that the injury was not a disease or the aggravation of a disease was rejected, particularly in light of the employer's prior concession that the condition was "at best, a disease process." The court found no error in the Arbitrator's factual findings, concluding that there was sufficient evidence to support the determination that the worker was suffering from an aggravation of a disease.

The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal dismissed with costs

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This ground of appeal also fails on the facts and is misconceived.Was there evidence that the worker was suffering from a disease or the aggravation of a disease? (Grounds 1-4) The employer contended, as it had before the Presidential member, that it was not open to the Arbitrator to make the determination that he did, because there was no evidence that the worker was suffering from a disease, or the aggravation of a disease. The employer's case in this Court was that the worker's condition was, at most, a "nature and conditions injury" and not a “disease”. It was accepted that some nature and conditions injuries (for example skin cancer) are also diseases. But a shoulder injury was said not to be one of them, on the evidence. This issue is particularly relevant to the dispute as between the employer and the insurer because the worker's case (supported by the insurer) is that the employer was solely liable to pay compensation because it was the last (self-) insurer on risk. Section 16(1) of the WC Act provides:If an injury consists in the aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation or deterioration of a disease:(a)the injury shall, for the purposes of this Act, be deemed to have happened:(i) at the time of the worker’s death or incapacity, or(ii)if death or incapacity has not resulted from the injury – at the time the worker makes a claim for compensation with respect to the injury, and(b)compensation is payable by the employer who last employed the worker in employment that was a substantial contributing factor to the aggravation, acceleration, exacerbation or deterioration. In contrast, at the arbitration hearing the employer had argued that the worker’s condition was “at best, a disease process” (Red 515). Nor surprisingly, CGU submits that it would be unjust to permit departure from this stance. In any event, even if departure was permitted, the argument cannot be upheld. In his Determination, the Arbitrator held that the worker received an injury to his right shoulder between 1990 and 23 May 2002 and that the injury arose out of or in the course of his employment as a slaughterman with the employer. The employment was found to be a substantial contributing factor to the injury (Red 435). These, on their face, were findings of fact. The Arbitrator correctly acknowledged that the worker had alleged a nature and conditions injury to his neck and arm (Red 423L). He described the worker’s allegation as being that, between 1990 and 23 May 2002, he suffered from a degenerative condition to his right shoulder as a result of over use and repetitive trauma while working for the employer (Red 425M). As indicated below, the Arbitrator held that the worker was suffering from an aggravation of a disease in para 23 of his Reasons. In his Reasons (Red 425-431), the Arbitrator set out extracts from the medical evidence provided on behalf of the worker, including extracts from reports of Dr Rizkallah and Dr Benanzio; reports provided on behalf of the insurer from Dr Porges and Dr Bornstein; reports provided on behalf of the employer (referred to as “the Self-Insurer”) including reports of Dr Hughes, Dr Erhlick, Dr Innes-Brown, Dr Robert Smith and Dr Kim Edwards.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.