Finlayson & Ors v ACT Planning & Land Authority & Ors (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

FINLAYSON & ORS v ACT PLANNING & LAND AUTHORITY & ORS (Administrative Review) [2009] ACAT 35

AT 2, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 11 of 2009

Catchwords:             ADMINISTRATIVE LAW– Review brought under Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1989 (ACT) – jurisdiction of tribunal – ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Transitional Provisions) Regulation 2009 (ACT) s 6

LAND AND PLANNING - Review of decision on reconsideration of deemed refusal of multi-dwelling development application in an A10 area -  whether revised plans should have been treated as a new application requiring fresh public notification – whether development meets requirements of 2002 Territory Plan Appendix III.2 the Residential Design and Siting Code for Multi-Dwelling Development – whether development’s gross floor area exceeds allowable plot ratio – whether development meets Performance Measures for interface between dwellings, set backs of upper floors from side boundaries, solar access to private open space – overshadowing of neighboring property – design of waste enclosure -  design and siting of basement access ramp – whether development respects streetscape – impact on amenity or neighborhood – traffic and safety – waste collection arrangements – adaptable housing requirements.

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1989 s 37

ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 9, 68

Land (Environment and Planning) Act 1991 Subdivision 6.2.4; ss 222, 226, 229, 230, 246, 246A, 284

Planning and Development Act 2007 s 442

ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Transitional Provisions) Regulations 2009 s 6

AMC Projects Pty Ltd and ACT Planning and Land Authority [2006] ACTAAT 113
Cambridge Credit Corporation Ltd v Parkes Developments Pty Ltd (1974) 2 NSWLR 590
Carter and ACT Planning and Land Authority [2007] ACTAAT 23
Collector of Customs and Brian Lawlor (1979) 41 FLR 338
Griffith/Narrabundah Community Association and ACT Planning and Land Authority [2006] ACTAAT 17
Khoo and ACT Planning and Land Authority [2000] ACTAAT 7
Kimball and ACT Planning and Land Authority [2007] ACTAAT 28
McKenzie v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2004] ACT SC 80
Marabouti v Secretary, Department of Employment, Education and Youth Affairs (1998) 53 ALD 585
Pashilidis and ACT Planning and Land Authority [2004] ACTAAT 21
Queensland Newsagents Federation Limited v Trade Practices Commission (1993) 46 FCR 38
R v Marks: Ex parte Australian Building Construction Employees and Builders’ Labourers Federation (1981) 147 CLR 471
Re Calardu Pty Ltd (No 2) (1991) 109 FLR 361
Richards v Watson & Ors [1986] FCA 160
Savaas v Commissioner for Land and Planning [2002] ACTSC 121
Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31 (30 July 2008)

Tribunal:           Dr D McMichael  Senior Member

Mr R Nichols  Senior Member

Mr S Herrick   Senior Member

Date of Orders:  25 September 2009
Date of Reasons for Decision:         25 September 2009

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY            )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          AT 2, 3, 5, 7, 8, 9, 11, of

2009

BETWEEN:

KERRIE FINLAYSON

Applicant in AT09/2

BOB AND MARGARET HARRIGAN
  Applicants in AT09/3

RG and GM BELLAMY
  Applicants in AT09/5

MARGARET CUMING
  Applicant in AT09/7

PETER…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Finlayson & Ors v ACT Planning & Land Authority & Ors (Admin... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] ACAT 35
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Finlayson & Ors v ACT Planning & Land Authority & Ors, the applicants, Ms Kerrie Finlayson and others, challenged the decision of the ACT Planning and Land Authority to approve revised plans submitted in support of an application for reconsideration. The respondents, including the ACT Planning and Land Authority, the developer party, and objectors, defended the approval. The dispute centred on the adequacy and compliance of the revised plans with planning and environmental regulations. The Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) was tasked with reviewing the decision of the Authority to approve the plans and determining whether the decision was legally sound and justified.

The legal issues before the Tribunal included whether the revised plans met the statutory requirements and whether the Authority's decision was rational and justifiable. Specifically, the Tribunal had to consider if the revised plans complied with zoning regulations, building codes, and environmental standards. The applicants argued that the plans did not adequately address issues such as setbacks, Gross Floor Area, and the impact on the local environment and community. The respondents, on the other hand, contended that the plans were compliant and that the Authority's decision was correct.

The Tribunal found that the final plans, while an improvement over the reconsideration plans, still fell short of meeting the statutory requirements. The Tribunal highlighted several deficiencies, including inadequate setbacks, excessive Gross Floor Area, and potential environmental impacts. The Tribunal was also critical of the Authority's failure to properly consider the objectors' concerns. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the Authority's decision and refused the development application. The Tribunal also dismissed the objectors' application for costs and dispensed with the requirement for the Authority to notify objectors of the original application.

The Tribunal's orders included the refusal of the development application, dismissal of the objectors' costs application, and a dispensation for the Authority's requirement to notify objectors of the original application. This decision underscored the importance of compliance with planning regulations and the need for authorities to carefully consider objections and expert evidence when making planning decisions.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that the decision under review, made on 15 December 2008, to approve the revised plans submitted in support of the Application for Reconsideration under s 246 of the Land (Environment and Planning) Act 1992 is set aside and in accordance with s 246A(1)(b)(i) of that Act, the following decision is substituted for it:

1. The development application is refused.

2. The Application made on behalf of the objectors for an order for costs is dismissed.

3. Pursuant to section 284 of the Land (Planning and Environment) Act 1991, the requirement under s 246A(3)(b) of that Act for the Authority to give written notice to anyone who had objected to the grant of approval of the original application, be dispensed with to the extent necessary.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In revised plans submitted as part of the application for reconsideration (“the reconsideration plans”) one of the units had been relocated, the orientation of two of the blocks of units had been varied, the location of the waste enclosures had been changed and the car parking spaces had been combined into a single basement. Further revised plans (“the final plans”) were prepared during the course of these proceedings and tendered as part of Exhibit 9. They were intended to address a number of matters that has been raised during the first three days of the hearing, including redesigning the roofs; moving Units 5-8 west by 800mm so that they did not infringe the required setback on the eastern boundary; reducing the Gross Floor Area (“GFA”) principally by reducing the size of Units 5-8 and 9-12 by approximately 5m2 each and making them 2 bedroom rather than 3 bedroom units; and relocating the basement driveway ramp exiting to Pell Place so that it was behind the building line. The Tribunal’s decision, set out below, relates to the final plans. The hearing took place on 25, 26, and 27 May and on 9 and 10 July. The Tribunal visited the subject site on the first morning of the hearing in the presence of the parties and their representatives and witnesses, and viewed the surrounding streetscape and other multi-dwelling developments in the area. The first applicant, Ms Kerrie Finlayson, represented herself at the hearing. The other applicants and the two objector parties joined, Ms H Riess and Ms K Kelly (”the grouped objectors”) were represented by Mr M Flint of Meyer Vandenberg, Solicitors. The Authority was represented by Mr P Walker of Counsel. The developer party joined, Mr Matthew Doherty, was represented by Mr C Erskine SC of Counsel. Evidence on behalf of the applicants was given by Ms K Finlayson, Ms G Pinkas (on behalf of her parents the late Mr R L Bellamy and Mrs G M Bellamy), Mr T Willson, Mrs N Burney, Mr B Harrigan and Ms K Kelly, all of whom lived in the vicinity of the subject land. Expert evidence was given by Mr Jack Kershaw, a registered architect with extensive experience in private practice in Canberra and Mr E (Ted) Streatfeild, a town planner and licensed builder, with 30 years experience in the building and planning industry, including 16 years as a development assessment officer with the Authority, on behalf of the grouped objectors. Evidence on behalf of the developer party joined was given by Mr Bernie den Hertog, a qualified practicing architect who prepared the final plans, and expert evidence was given by Mr Paul Cohen, a qualified town planner with many years experience in urban planning and design in the ACT. A witness statement prepared by Mr Pierre Dragh, a qualified civil and structural engineer dealing with the turning circles of waste collection vehicles exiting the subject land was tendered in evidence, though Mr Dragh did not give evidence in person. The Tribunal also had before it the documents lodged by the respondent pursuant to s 37 of the AAT Act (“the T Documents).