ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
DEAKIN RESIDENTS ASSOCIATION INC v ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY & ANOR (Administrative Review) [2015] ACAT 37
AT 14/106
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW- planning and development – development application - separation of buildings – tree removal and landscaping - traffic and parking – encroachment on private open space
Legislation cited: ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 (ACT) s 68
Planning and Development Act 2007 (ACT) ss 48, 50, 55, 119, 120, 121, 122, 144,146, 149, 162, 407, 408
Tree Protection Act 2005(ACT) ss 10, 25
Subordinate
Legislation:Multi Unit Housing Development Code C36, C40, R15, R 30, R36 Table A6
Planning and Development Regulation 2008 (ACT) Reg 1A(2)(b)
Tree Protection (Approval Criteria) Determination 2006 (No 2) (ACT)Parking and Vehicular Access General Code
Cases cited:Amarso Pty Ltd & Ors v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2012] ACAT 9
Baptist Community Services v ACT Planning and Land Authority & Ors [2015] ACTCA 3
Finlayson v ACTPLA [2009] ACAT 35
Walkington and ACT Planning and Land Authority [2010] ACAT 81
Tribunal: Ms M-T. Daniel – Presiding Member
Mr R. Orr – Senior Member
Mr R. Pegrum – Senior Member
Date of Orders: 29 May 2015
Date of Reasons for Decision: 29 May 2015
ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL AT 14/106
BETWEEN:
DEAKIN RESIDENTS ASSOCIATION INC
Applicant
AND:
ACT PLANNING AND LAND AUTHORITY
Respondent
AND:
TURCO & ASSOCIATES PTY LTD
Party Joined
TRIBUNAL: Ms M-T. Daniel – Presiding Member
Mr R. Orr – Senior Member
Mr R. Pegrum – Senior Member
DATE:29 May 2015
ORDER
The Tribunal having exercised a power of the ACT Planning and Land Authority under section 144(1) of the Planning and Development Act 2007, to further amend the Development Application in accordance with the further amended plans which are exhibit C 6, and under section 146(3) of the Planning Act having waived the requirement to publicly notify the further amended development application,
The Tribunal orders that:
The decision under review is varied as follows:
(a)Development Application No 201425446 is approved in accordance with the further amended plans which are exhibit C 6 in these proceedings.
(b)Approval for removal of regulated tree 19 is omitted from paragraph (d) of the decision under review.
(c)Condition B2 in the decision under review is amended by the addition of “, 8” after “7”, and the addition of “, 14” after “12”.
(d)New condition B8 is added: “B8. All air conditioning units are to be located so as not to be visible from Gawler Crescent.”
(e)New condition B9 is added: “B9. Prior to building work on the site commencing the lessee shall lodge amended plans with the ACT Planning and Land Authority in accordance with the Tribunal’s decision, including a final plan of landscaping which shows in detail the retention of the regulated tree 19 and modification of the surrounding areas, and the location of all air conditioning units.”
………………………………..
Ms M-T Daniel – Member
For and on behalf of the Tribunal
REASONS FOR DECISION
Deakin…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Deakin Residents Association v ACT Planning and Land Authori... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] ACAT 37
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the court were whether the proposed development complied with the relevant planning regulations and criteria, specifically R 36 and C 36 of the Multi Unit Code, concerning the separation between buildings on a single dwelling block. The court was tasked with interpreting these provisions and determining whether the separation provided in the amended proposals met the regulatory requirements. Additionally, the court needed to consider the justification for any deviation from the specified separation, as well as other conditions and impacts of the proposed development.
The court examined the Multi Unit Code provisions, which mandate a minimum horizontal separation of 4 meters between buildings on a single dwelling block. It found that while the amended proposals provided a separation that technically met the minimum requirement, the visual appearance from the street made it appear much less. The court considered the context and purpose behind the regulations, noting that the regulations aim to maintain the suburban character by limiting the scale and distribution of buildings. It concluded that the criteria in C 36 allow for a lesser separation if justified, but this justification must be informed by the purpose and policy of the regulations. The court found that the Further Amended Proposal did not adequately justify the reduced separation in terms of maintaining the neighbourhood character. Consequently, the court varied the decision to approve the development application with specific conditions to address the separation and other concerns.
The court's final orders included approving the development application with modifications to the plans, removing the approval for the removal of a regulated tree, amending certain conditions, and adding new conditions regarding the visibility of air conditioning units and the requirement for a detailed landscaping plan to be submitted before construction begins.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The decision under review is varied as follows:
(a) Development Application No 201425446 is approved in accordance with the further amended plans which are exhibit C 6 in these proceedings.
(b) Approval for removal of regulated tree 19 is omitted from paragraph (d) of the decision under review.
(c) Condition B2 in the decision under review is amended by the addition of “, 8” after “7”, and the addition of “, 14” after “12”.
(d) New condition B8 is added: “B8. All air conditioning units are to be located so as not to be visible from Gawler Crescent.”
(e) New condition B9 is added: “B9. Prior to building work on the site commencing the lessee shall lodge amended plans with the ACT Planning and Land Authority in accordance with the Tribunal’s decision, including a final plan of landscaping which shows in detail the retention of the regulated tree 19 and modification of the surrounding areas, and the location of all air conditioning units.”
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The fact that the Amended Proposal provided for two buildings on what was to be a consolidated block brought into play R 36 and C 36 of the Multi Unit Code, which provide as follows.3.27 Building separation – single dwelling blocks – RZ2R36This rule applies to single dwelling blocks in RZ2.The minimum horizontal separation between a building containing 2 or more dwellings and any other building on the site is 4m. For the purposes of this rule, basements are not part of a building.C36The siting of buildings on single dwelling blocks in RZ2 achieves all of the following:a) consistency with the desired characterb) consistency with the separation of existing buildings in the immediate neighbourhood. As noted above the subject site is a single dwelling block. The Amended Proposal provided for a separation between the buildings at ground floor level of 5.4 metres for a depth of 2.5 metres, and then 1.5 metres, and the Further Amended Proposal increased the ground floor separation to 6.4 metres and then 2.8 metres.[27] [27] Exhibit R1, Notice of Decision, T documents page 62; see also T documents pages 212, 213 and 215 At the upper level, the Amended Proposal provided a separation of 5.43 metres and the Further Amended Proposal a separation of 6.44 metres. Deakin Residents suggested that this formulation is somewhat misleading, indeed Mr Nelson for Deakin Residents suggested it was a fiction, and the Tribunal has some sympathy for this view. The measurement includes the void areas in the building as part of the separation. As the street elevation in Exhibit C 6 demonstrates, looking at the buildings from the street the separation between most of the buildings at the lower and upper levels in the Further Amended Proposal appears to be only 2.8 metres. The Further Amended Proposal was not sought to be justified under R 36 but was sought to be justified under C 36 and must meet both requirements in C 36. There was some consideration in the hearing as to the relationship between R 36 and C 36. Mr Thwaites in his statement for Deakin Residents suggested that the rules and criteria are intended to be associated in their application, and that for elements where both a rule and criterion apply, the rule is the point of departure for assessment, with a requirement for any departure from that rule to be justified by reference to the criterion.[28] The Tribunal thinks there is some merit in this approach. Context is an important tool in statutory interpretation[29] and the requirements in C 36 should be informed by the terms of R 36. In effect C 36 allows a lesser separation than 4 metres but requires this to be justified. Both R 36 and C 36 implement a particular purpose and policy, and this purpose and policy should inform the interpretation of C 36.[30][28] Exhibit A3, page 1[29] Legislation Act 2001 (ACT), section 140[30] Legislation Act 2001 (ACT), section 139 In this case the purpose and policy is not completely clear. The provisions are headed “building separation”, suggesting that a separation is required. The reason for requiring such separation is not specified in either R 36 or C 36. The requirement was introduced by Variation 306 to the Territory Plan in February 2013. Deakin Residents provided at Exhibit A2 Attachment B a document entitled ‘Keeping the neighbourhood character in RZ2 zones Draft Variation 306’ issued by the ACT government in June 2011, which discusses possible proposed changes, and which preceded Variation 306 and the introduction of R 36 and C 36. This document is referred to in the Explanatory Statement to Variation 306. [31] It states that the proposed changes follow public concern in 2010 about RZ2 development, particularly the scale and character of development, then as follows:[32]To ensure development is more in keeping with the character of the area, DV 306 proposes to restrict the overall scale and distribution of buildings on consolidated blocks.·No building will contain more than four dwellings. This will reduce the overall scale of the buildings and prevent one large building dominating a site.·Any building with two or more dwellings will be at least four metres from any other building on the site. This separation will reduce the scale of the overall development, making it more consistent with the suburban character.[31] Regard can be had to the Explanatory Statement and this document under sections 141 and 142 of the Legislation Act 2001 (ACT), and to determine the purpose of the Multi Unit Code provisions[32] Page 3