Davidson v ACT Planning & Land Authority & Ors (Administrative Review)

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

DAVIDSON v ACT PLANNING & LAND AUTHORITY & ORS (Administrative Review) [2009] ACAT 39

AT 49 of 2009

Catchwords:             ADMINISTRATIVE LAW– Review brought under Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1989 (ACT) – jurisdiction of ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal – ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Transitional Provisions) Regulation 2009 (ACT) s 6

LAND AND PLANNING - Review of decision on reconsideration of deemed refusal of multi-dwelling development application in a B12 area -  whether revised plans should have been treated as a new application requiring fresh public notification – whether development meets requirements of 2002 Territory Plan and its Appendix III.3, the Urban Housing Code – whether development fails to comply with provisions of the Braddon Neighbourhood Plan and the Braddon Section Master Plan regarding diversity of dwelling types and sizes - status of Braddon Section Master Plan - whether consultation with neighbours was adequate -  whether proposed development is out of character with street and neighbourhood – whether planting of a street tree should be required.

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1989 Pt 4, s 37

ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008 ss 9, 68

Land (Environment and Planning) Act 1991 Subdivision 6.2.4; ss 226, 229, 230, 246, 246A

Planning and Development Act 2007 s 442

ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal (Transitional Provisions) Regulations 2009 s 6
Planning & Development Regulations 2008 Sc 20

2002 Territory Plan Pts A3, B App III.3 (Urban Housing Code)

Downer Community Association and ACT Planning and Land Authority [2007] ACTAAT 20 (5 September 2007)
Finlayson & Ors and ACT Planning and Land Authority & Ors (Administrative Review) [2009] ACAT 35 (25 September 2009)
McKenzie v ACT Planning and Land Authority [2004] ACT SC 80
Pashilidis and ACT Planning and Land Authority [2004] ACTAAT 21 (24 May 2004)
Sullivan and ACT Planning and Land Authority [2007] ACTAAT 8 (3 May 2007)

Tribunal:           Dr D McMichael  Senior Member

Mr P Conway  Member

Date of Orders:  12 October 2009
Date of Reasons for Decision:         12 October 2009

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY            )

CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL       )          AT 49 of 2009

BETWEEN:

GEOFF & SUSAN DAVIDSON

Applicant

AND:

ACT PLANNING AND

LAND AUTHORITY

Respondent

AND:

DI IULIO CONSTRUCTIONS PTY LIMITED
  Party Joined

Tribunal:Dr D McMichael  Senior Member

Mr P Conway  Member

Date:  12 October 2009

ORDER

The Tribunal orders that the decision under review, made on 23 April 2009, to approve the revised plans submitted in support of the Application for Reconsideration under s 246 of the Land (Environment and Planning) Act 1992 is varied in accordance with the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, s 69(3)(b), as follows:

1.In Notice of Decision, para 2(a)(iv), replace the numerals 9, 10 and 11 with 15, 16 and 17 respectively.

2.        Add new condition 2(a)(v) to the approval as follows:

Planting of a street tree on the verge adjoining Block 3 Section 2 Braddon, of a species and at a place approved or specified by the Department of Territory and   Municipal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Davidson v ACT Planning & Land Authority & Ors (Administrati... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] ACAT 39
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Davidson v ACT Planning & Land Authority & Ors concerns a dispute regarding the approval of revised plans for a multi-dwelling development in Braddon. The applicants, Mr and Mrs Davidson, challenged the decision of the ACT Planning and Land Authority to approve the revised plans without fresh public notification. The decision was reviewed by the Administrative Review Division of the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal. The central legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the significant changes made to the original plans warranted fresh public notification in accordance with section 229 of the repealed Act.

The Tribunal considered the evidence presented by the parties, including the submissions of Mr Owen Pankhurst, the assessing officer for the proposed development, who argued that the differences between the original and revised plans were minor and did not substantially alter the development. The applicants, on the other hand, contended that the changes were significant enough to require fresh public notification. The Tribunal visited the site and reviewed the T Documents, which were lodged by the respondent. After considering the evidence and submissions, the Tribunal concluded that the differences between the original and revised plans were indeed minor and did not warrant fresh public notification.

In light of its findings, the Tribunal varied the decision under review. The Tribunal replaced certain numerals in the Notice of Decision and added a new condition regarding the planting of a street tree. Additionally, the Tribunal corrected a sentence in the Findings on Material Questions of Fact to reflect compliance with Area Specific Land Use Policies. The Tribunal's decision was based on a careful consideration of the evidence and the applicable legal standards, ultimately leading to the modification of the original decision to better align with the Tribunal's findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal orders that the decision under review, made on 23 April 2009, to approve the revised plans submitted in support of the Application for Reconsideration under s 246 of the Land (Environment and Planning) Act 1992 is varied in accordance with the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, s 69(3)(b), as follows:

1. In Notice of Decision, para 2(a)(iv), replace the numerals 9, 10 and 11 with 15, 16 and 17 respectively.

2. Add new condition 2(a)(v) to the approval as follows:

Planting of a street tree on the verge adjoining Block 3 Section 2 Braddon, of a species and at a place approved or specified by the Department of Territory and Municipal Services.

3. In the Findings on Material Questions of Fact, line 2 of the paragraph headed Control 3.5(a) Area Specific Policy, delete the word “not” so that the sentence will read:

The development does comply with Area Specific Land Use Policies – B12 Increased Density Development (maximum two storeys).

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr and Mrs Davidson had submitted an application for planning approval for a multi-dwelling development in Braddon, Canberra. The initial plans were rejected by the ACT Planning & Land Authority. Following reconsideration, revised plans were submitted which included changes to the units, building orientation, shape, and waste-collection driveway. The Davidsons argued that these changes were significant enough to require fresh public notification under the repealed Act. The Authority's assessing officer, Mr Pankhurst, considered the differences between the original and revised plans to be minor and not substantial enough to warrant new public notification. The case proceeded to the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal for review.

The matter came before the ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal for administrative review of the ACT Planning & Land Authority's decision to approve the revised plans submitted in support of the Application for Reconsideration. The Tribunal heard the case on 17 September 2009, where it visited the site, reviewed the T Documents, and heard evidence from Mr Pankhurst. The applicants presented a statement of Facts and Contentions along with additional documents and photographs. The Tribunal reserved its decision after concluding the evidence and submissions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Are the changes made to the reconsideration plans significant enough to warrant fresh public notification in accordance with s 229 of the repealed Act?
2. Did the ACT Planning & Land Authority correctly assess the differences between the original and revised plans as minor and not substantial?

Held
1. The Tribunal concluded that the changes made to the reconsideration plans were not significant enough to warrant fresh public notification in accordance with s 229 of the repealed Act.
2. The Tribunal found that the ACT Planning & Land Authority correctly assessed the differences between the original and revised plans as minor and not substantial.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In revised plans submitted as part of the application for reconsideration (“the reconsideration plans”) all the units had been changed to one-bedroom, the orientation and shape of the proposed building has been altered, and the second waste-collection driveway had been deleted, with the waste to be collected from a storage area at the bottom of the basement access ramp. Further revised plans had been prepared by the developer’s architects intended to meet the conditions imposed as part of the approval on reconsideration. However, these were not considered by the Tribunal as they had not yet been assessed by the Authority and had little bearing on the issues raised by the applicants in this case. The Tribunal’s decision, set out below, relates to the revised plans submitted with the reconsideration application. The hearing took place on 17 September 2009. The Tribunal visited the subject land on the morning of the hearing in the presence of the parties and viewed the surrounding streetscape and other multi-dwelling developments in the area. The Tribunal also had before it the documents lodged by the respondent pursuant to s 37 of the AAT Act (“the T Documents). The applicants were not represented at the hearing. The Authority was represented by Mr G McCarthy of Counsel. The party joined, Mr Di Iulio, was also not represented. Mr and Mrs Davidson had submitted a statement of Facts and Contentions on which they expanded and tendered a number of documents from the Australian Bureau of Statistics as evidence of population changes and demographic trends in Braddon, as well as photographs of developments in the area. They called no witnesses. Mr Owen Pankhurst, a qualified town planner who is the Assessing Officer - Merit Assessment (North) in the Authority’s Development Assessment Unit, gave evidence on behalf of the Authority. Mr Pankhurst had been responsible for assessing both the original plans and the reconsideration plans on behalf of the Authority.Mr Di Iulio presented no evidence. At the conclusion of the evidence and submissions the Tribunal reserved its decision. The applicants contended that the reconsideration plans were significantly different from the original plans, to such an extent that the revised proposal should have been subject to fresh public notification in accordance with s 229 of the repealed Act. In their view, there were the following significant changes made that warranted such action: Mr Pankhurst, the assessing officer for the proposed development, in cross-examination said that he considered the differences between the original plans and the reconsideration plans as minor. In his opinion there was no substantial rearrangement of either the form or shape of the building, and the view from the street would change only slightly. He said he would not regard the differences as substantial. While he had not considered the internal layout of the buildings separately, he considered that even if it is different, it did not substantially change the development as a whole