Ferraretto and Snappy Apple Pty Ltd v Cowell Clarke

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil: Application)

FERRARETTO AND SNAPPY APPLE PTY LTD v COWELL CLARKE

[2012] SASC 224

Judgment of The Honourable Justice White

12 December 2012

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEDURE UNDER RULES OF COURT - OTHER MATTERS ARISING BEFORE TRIAL

The plaintiffs allege a breach of duty by the defendant in its preparation of documents relating to a share sale agreement, claiming that the first plaintiff has thereby been left exposed to liabilities arising under guarantees which he had given to various creditors.

The plaintiffs seek an order that certain issues in the proceedings be heard and determined in advance of others.

Held (refusing the application):

(1) The Court cannot be confident that there will not be some overlap of issues and evidence in the various stages of a split trial, (at [28]-[32]);

(2)  The plaintiffs contemplate more than just a two-stage trial, with potential for stages of the trial still to be heard as late as November 2017, (at [34]);

(3)  There is a risk that credibility findings in relation to the first plaintiff may need to be made at each stage of the trial, (at [35]-[36]);

(4)  There is potential for the Court to reach inconsistent findings of fact at different stages of the trial, (at [37]-[38]).

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) Part 5.7B; Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s 30B; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006  (SA) r 211, referred to.
Tepko Pty Ltd v Water Board (2001) 206 CLR 1; FAI General Insurance Co Ltd (in Liq) v Sherry (2002) 225 LSJS 141; Rivers v Rivers (2002) 220 LSJS 74; Duke Group Ltd (in Liq) v Alamain Investments Ltd (in Liq) (No 2) [2006] SASC 33; City of Onkaparinga v Hassell Pty Ltd [2007] SASC 163; Abigroup Contractors Pty Ltd v Hardesty & Hanover International LLC [2008] SASC 369; Wardley Australia Ltd v The State of Western Australia (1992) 175 CLR 514, considered.

FERRARETTO AND SNAPPY APPLE PTY LTD v COWELL CLARKE
[2012] SASC 224

  1. WHITE J:             This decision concerns an application by the plaintiffs under Rule 211 of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) to have certain issues in the proceedings heard and determined separately from others. 

  2. The plaintiffs allege negligence by the defendant, a firm of solicitors, in the services it provided to them under a retainer in relation to a share sale agreement.  That agreement involved the disposal of a significant number of the shares held by Mr and Mrs Ferraretto in their capacity as trustees of the A & T Ferraretto Family Trust (“the Trust”). 

  3. Harbert Australian Private Equity Fund 1 LP (“Harbert Delaware”) was the purchaser of some of the shares.   Another Harbert entity (Harbert Fund Advisors (Australia) Pty Ltd) (“Harbert Australia”) acted as its agent in relation to the negotiations and the share sale agreement. 

  4. The negotiations concluded on 21 July 2010 when Harbert Australia, on behalf of Harbert Delaware, executed a letter with Mr and Mrs Ferraretto…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ferraretto and Snappy Apple Pty Ltd v Cowell Clarke and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASC 224
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Ferraretto and Snappy Apple Pty Ltd v Cowell Clarke, the plaintiffs sought to have certain issues determined in advance of the main trial. The dispute involved claims related to a breach of duty by the defendant, resulting in financial losses to the plaintiffs. The primary issue before the court was whether to grant an application for a split trial, allowing certain matters to be decided before the main trial. The court considered the potential for overlap in issues between the proposed separate stages of the trial.

The plaintiffs argued that a split trial would allow for a more precise assessment of damages and avoid the risk of under-compensation or over-compensation. However, the court was concerned that the plaintiffs' claims were complex and dependent on the hypothetical responses of individual creditors, which made it difficult to identify all potential issues at an early stage. The court also noted that some evidence related to unknown claims might be necessary even in the first stage of the trial. Given these complexities, the court concluded that the application for a split trial should be refused to avoid any potential overlap and ensure a coherent trial process.

The court's reasoning was grounded in the need to maintain a logical and efficient trial process, avoiding unnecessary duplication of evidence and ensuring that all relevant facts were considered in a single trial. The decision highlighted the importance of carefully considering the nature of the claims and the potential for overlapping issues in determining whether a split trial is appropriate. The court's refusal of the application was intended to streamline the proceedings and ensure a fair and comprehensive resolution of the disputes.

The court's final orders were to deny the application for a split trial, ensuring that all issues would be addressed in a single trial to avoid any confusion or overlap in evidence and findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The plaintiffs also refer to the desirability of the Court being able to assess the damages to which they may be entitled by reference to established events, rather than by an assessment of a liability accruing in the future. This will allow the Court to avoid the risk of under-compensation or over-compensation.[8][8] Cf Wardley Australia Pty Ltd v The State of Western Australia (1992) 175 CLR 514 at 527.Decision on Application for Split Trials Although I understand the difficulties which the plaintiffs face presently, I consider that the application for the hearing and determination of some issues in the trial in advance of others should be refused. First, even with the assistance of counsel, it is difficult to identify all the issues which may arise for determination in the trial. The plaintiffs’ claim as to the loss said to arise from the breach of duty alleged against the defendant is a little unusual as it seems to depend on the attitude which each individual creditor would have taken to a request, had it been made in a timely way, to release Mr Ferraretto from his guarantee. This gives rise to a number of distinct factual enquiries with a variety of permutations. In this circumstance, it is difficult for the Court to be confident at this stage that there will not be some overlap of issues in the various stages of a split trial, if such a course is ordered. It does seem probable that there will, in any event, be some overlap between the issues in the proposed separate stages. The plaintiffs’ own submissions acknowledged that the exercise (and possibly the existence) of the Court’s power under s 30B to make declarations in respect of liabilities which may not yet have accrued is likely to arise. Although it is not possible to be certain, it seems that this may well require the Court to consider at least some of the circumstances relating to the 31.1A and 31.2 claims in the first trial as well as in a second or subsequent trial. Further, it seems that some of the issues of causation will require the Court to hear evidence about at least some of the potential claims of all creditors, and not just about the known claims which the plaintiffs contemplate being determined in the first trial. An example is the plaintiffs’ assertion that the parties had contemplated an agreement under which Westpac would provide an indemnity in respect of those liabilities for which a release could not be negotiated. The determination of whether such a guarantee may have been provided would seem, on its face, to require the Court having some evidence about the potential full extent of the liabilities proposed to be the subject of Westpac’s indemnity. Further again, the attitude of many of the 85 creditors to a request to release Mr Ferraretto from his director’s guarantees (had that request been made at the relevant time) seems directly relevant to the attitude Westpac would have formed in relation to the request for a guarantee. I acknowledge that this may depend ultimately on the way in which the plaintiffs present the case. However, on the basis presently pleaded, it does seem that some evidence of at least some of the unknown claims may be necessary in the first stage of the trial.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established