Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 51 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2016] FCA 1270

File number: NSD 1238 of 2015
Judge: PERRY J
Date of judgment: 28 October 2016
Catchwords:

BANKRUPTCY – interlocutory application seeking orders that respondent consent to stay of order of Supreme Court of New South Wales appointing Trustees for Sale and other injunctive relief – where no serious question to be tried – where in any event balance of convenience falls heavily in favour of refusing the interlocutory injunctions.

EVIDENCE – where no evidence given by applicant or his legal representatives - where evidence in support of originating application and interlocutory application given instead by applicant’s son is highly unsatisfactory in a number of respects.

Legislation:

Bankruptcy (Estate Charges) Act 1997 (Cth)

Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth)

Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW)

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth)

Real Property Act 1900 (NSW)

Bankruptcy (Estate Charges) (Amount of Charge Payable) Determination 2014 (Cth)

Bankruptcy (Estate Charges) (Amount of Charge Payable) Determination 2015 (Cth)

Bankruptcy (Fees and Remuneration) Determination 2015 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Agusta Pty Ltd and Ors as trustees for the Cavallino Unit Trust v The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy  as trustee of the bankrupt estates of Gustavo Ferella and Angelo Ferella (Unreported, 28 August 2009)

Agusta Pty Ltd and Ors as trustees for the Cavallino Unit Trust v The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy as trustee of the bankrupt estates of Gustavo Ferella and Angelo Ferella [2008] NSWSC 685

Agusta Pty Ltd v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy as Trustee of Estates of Gustavo Ferella and Angelo Ferella [2009] NSWCA 129

Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill [2006] HCA 46; (2006) 227 CLR 57

Beecham Group Limited v Bristol Laboratories Pty Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 618

Binetter v Deputy Commission of Taxation [2012] FCA 377; (2012) 128 ALD 10

Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (No 2) [2011] FCA 619

Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (No 4) [2015] FCA 712

Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (No 5) [2015] FCA 983

Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2013] FCAFC 43

Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2015] NSWCA 411

Date of hearing: 28 April 2016
Date of last submissions: 12 May 2016
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: General and Personal Insolvency
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 82
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr RK Newton
Solicitor for the Applicant: Zali Burrows Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr T Lynch SC
Solicitor for the Respondent: Craddock Murray Neumann Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 1238 of 2015
BETWEEN:

GUSTAVO FERELLA

Applicant

AND:

OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY

Respondent

JUDGE:

PERRY J

DATE OF ORDER:

28 OCTOBER 2016

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The interlocutory application filed by the applicant on 3 December 2015 is dismissed.

2.The applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the application.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

PERRY J:

1         INTRODUCTION

[1]

2         EVIDENCE

[6]

3…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] FCA 1270
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, the case of Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy involved an application by the applicant, Gustavo Ferella, seeking orders for the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy to consent to a stay of an order made by the Supreme Court of New South Wales appointing Trustees for Sale, and other injunctive relief. The substantive issue before the Court was whether the interlocutory injunctions sought by the applicant should be granted. The applicant argued that the Official Trustee had made excessive claims for costs and expenses in the administration of his bankruptcy, and sought relief to prevent the Trustees for Sale from selling his properties.

The Court considered the evidence provided by the applicant's son, Angelo Ferella, and found it to be highly unsatisfactory, containing argumentative material, opinions, and bare assertions. The Court noted that the applicant himself did not provide any evidence and that the son's evidence was irrelevant to the applicant's claims. The Court also noted that the applicant had not shown a serious question to be tried, and that the balance of convenience fell heavily in favour of refusing the interlocutory injunctions.

The Court found that the applicant had not demonstrated a prima facie case for success in the substantive proceedings, and that the balance of convenience weighed against granting the injunctions. The Court dismissed the interlocutory application and ordered the applicant to pay the Official Trustee's costs of and incidental to the application. The Court held that the interlocutory injunctions sought by the applicant were not necessary to ensure the effective exercise of the Court's jurisdiction or to prevent the frustration of its processes.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The interlocutory application filed by the applicant on 3 December 2015 is dismissed.

2. The applicant is to pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the application.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

None of the witnesses were required for cross-examination.3. BACKGROUND3.1 The substantive proceedings The applicant and his son, Angelo Ferella, were made bankrupt on 14 October 2005. They were discharged from bankruptcy on 3 December 2008 by operation of law. Prior to his bankruptcy, the applicant and his wife were the registered proprietors of four properties: 3 Chester Street, Blacktown and 15 Chester Street, Blacktown (the Blacktown Properties); 2/20-32 Hutton Road, North Entrance (the North Entrance Property); and 6 Alan Street, Box Hill (collectively, the Properties). Upon the applicant being made bankrupt, his half interest in the Properties vested in the Official Trustee by virtue of the combined operation of s 58(1)(a) of the Bankruptcy Act and s 90 of the Real Property Act 1900 (NSW): Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2015] NSWCA 411 (Ferella (s 66G) (NSWCA)) at [3]. As noted earlier, these proceedings were instituted by an originating application filed on 16 October 2015 supported by the first Ferella affidavit. By the originating application, the applicant challenges the outstanding costs and expenses claimed by the Official Trustee and seeks an annulment of the bankruptcy and re-vesting of any remaining assets or, in the alternative, an inquiry under s 179 of the Bankruptcy Act (albeit as I later explain, one such inquiry has already been undertaken). In addition, the applicant seeks an order that the Official Trustee compensate or pay damages to the applicant in respect of (unidentified) assets in the bankrupt estate said to have been “improperly appropriated or applied” and a declaration that the Official Trustee was not justified in commencing proceedings against Nida Ferella and the applicant in the s 66G Supreme Court Proceedings (which are explained below). Before considering whether to grant the interlocutory injunctions, it is necessary to set out the factual background of these and other proceedings in this Court and the Supreme Court of New South Wales relating to the administration of the bankruptcy. 3.2 The s66G Supreme Court Proceedings It is the sale of the Properties for the purpose of recouping the costs and expenses of the Official Trustee that lay at the heart of the s 66G Supreme Court Proceedings, as is the case also in these proceedings. By a summons dated 10 July 2014 filed in the Supreme Court of NSW, the Official Trustee sought an order for the appointment of trustees for sale of the Properties pursuant to s 66G of the Conveyancing Act. The parties to those proceedings were the Official Trustee, the Registrar-General, and Gustavo and Nida Ferella. In this regard, I note that on appeal, the Court of Appeal held that Gustavo Ferella ought not have been joined to the proceedings because, as a bankrupt, his one half interest in the Properties had vested in the Official Trustee: Ferella (s 66G) (NSWCA) at [8] and [49(d)] (Tobias AJA (Bergin CJ in Eq agreeing)), [66] (Emmett AJA). On 18 December 2014, Nicholas AJ made orders under s 66G appointing Messrs Steven Nicols and Richard Brien as Trustees (the Trustees for Sale) for the sale of the Properties. Those orders included that:4.… the Trustees [for Sale] be empowered to offer the Properties for sale and to sell the Properties by public auction with power to fix a reserve price, or alternatively, to sell the Properties by private treaty at the best available price.…8.…the Trustees [for Sale] pay their remuneration and the Plaintiff’s [the Official Trustee’s] costs out of the proceeds of sale, prior to any payment to either the Plaintiff [Official Trustee] or First Defendant [Mrs Nida Ferella] and the Trustees for Sale shall be entitled to be remunerated on the basis of their fees attached to their Consent to Act.9.…the Trustees [for Sale] hold the proceeds of sale … on trust for the Plaintiff as Trustee of the bankrupt estate of GUSTAVO FERELLA, and on trust for the First Defendant [Mrs Nida Ferella] in equal shares.…11.That vacant possession of the Properties be given 21 days after the date of this order.12. An order that a Writ of Possession be issued in favour of the Trustees [for Sale] forthwith.…

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Turning first to the first Ferella affidavit, it is apparent that this affidavit contains material which is argumentative in nature, expressions of opinion such as to the correctness of amounts of expenses, and bare assertions of improper conduct and overcharging by the Official Trustee (including “improper intermeddling … and thwarting of attempts” to refinance a property and “improper receipt and disposition” of proceeds of a mortgagee sale by the Official Trustee: see e.g. paragraphs 5, 31 and 32 of the first Ferella affidavit). I give no weight for the purposes of this application to such bald and serious assertions against the Official Trustee in terms of the truth which they assert, or to the opinions expressed which are inadmissible under s 76(1) of the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) (Evidence Act). In this regard, it is important to note that no evidence has been given by the applicant himself or by his legal representatives as to the grounds on which the applicant intends to pursue the litigation. This leads to a situation which is highly unsatisfactory in a number of respects. First, while Angelo Ferella deposes that the applicant does not speak English well and is elderly, that does not mean that he is unable to give affidavit evidence with the assistance of a translator. Secondly, and more importantly, this does not mean that it is satisfactory for the applicant’s son, who may have his own or another’s interests to pursue, to give such evidence allegedly on the applicant’s behalf. In contrast to a legal representative of a party who may swear an affidavit setting out, for example, the grounds on which an application is made by her or his client, Angelo Ferella does not owe any ethical or other relevant obligations to his father or to the Court as an officer of the Court. Thirdly, Angelo Ferella gives evidence such as that he is unable to identify a reason for a particular claim by the trustee or that certain matters concern him (see e.g. paragraphs 31 and 32, first Ferella affidavit). However, the fact that the applicant’s son may have particular concerns does not mean that the applicant shares them. The applicant’s son’s views are irrelevant. These matters notwithstanding, no objection was taken by the respondent to Angelo Ferella’s affidavits on any of these grounds, at least at this stage. Moreover, the present application is interlocutory in nature with the result that evidence can be given on information and belief even though this does not cure the particular deficiencies to which I have referred above: s 75, Evidence Act. In all of the circumstances therefore, and notwithstanding the highly unsatisfactory nature of the evidence as to the grounds on which the substantive application is pursued, for the purposes of determining this application I will treat the concerns expressed by Angelo Ferella in his first affidavit as indicating the grounds on which the applicant wishes to rely in support of his claims for final relief given that they are generally consistent with the submissions made by the applicant’s legal representatives.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Finally, while the Official Trustee submitted that in circumstances where the Trustees for Sale were not party to these proceedings and were in any event independent of the Official Trustee, there would be no utility in granting the injunctions against the Official Trustee. No authorities were referred to in this regard by the Official Trustee. In any event, in the circumstances it is not necessary for me to consider the correctness of that proposition and I have assumed in the applicant’s favour that there may be utility for the purposes of determining this application. However, that does not suffice to outweigh the other factors which I have set out above which in my view weigh heavily against the interlocutory injunctions sought by the applicant. 6. CONCLUSION For the reasons set out above, the interlocutory application should be dismissed with costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Finally, Ms Fu explained that, in respect of the estate of Gustavo Ferella, the “‘total costs of administration’ includes the whole of the expenses incurred jointly with the estate of Angelo Ferella which (as at 12 February 2016)” were:(a)$84,890.85 in respect of the expenses in the Angelo Ferella Transaction Report; and(b)$328,293.88 in respect of expenses in the Angelo Ferella Expenses Report. 5. CONSIDERATION5.1 Relevant principles In seeking to require the Official Trustee to consent to a stay, the applicant is asking the Court to grant a mandatory interlocutory injunction. A prohibitory injunction is also sought so as to restrain the Official Trustee from seeking or procuring the issue of any writ for possession. In both cases, underlying the applicant’s submissions is the proposition that the interlocutory injunctions are necessary to ensure the effective exercise of the Court’s jurisdiction including so as to prevent the frustration of its processes in these proceeding: Binetter v Deputy Commission of Taxation [2012] FCA 377; (2012) 128 ALD 10 at [40]. The test to be applied in determining whether an interlocutory injunction should be granted is well settled: see Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O’Neill [2006] HCA 46; (2006) 227 CLR 57 (O’Neill) at 68 [19] (Gleeson CJ and Crennan J), 82 [65] - 84 [71] (Gummow and Hayne JJ); Beecham Group Limited v Bristol Laboratories Pty Ltd (1968) 118 CLR 618 and 622-623 (Kitto, Taylor, Menzies and Owen JJ). The proper approach is first to inquire as to whether there is a serious question to be tried, and then to determine the matter on the balance of convenience. It is sufficient to show a serious question to be tried if the applicant demonstrates a “prima facie case”, that is, a sufficient likelihood of success to justify in the circumstances the preservation of the status quo pending the trial: O’Neill at 82 [65] (Gummow and Hayne JJ). In this regard, “the requisite strength of the probability of ultimate success depends upon the nature of the rights asserted and the practical consequences likely to flow from the interlocutory sought”: O’Neill at 84 [71] (Gummow and Hayne JJ). In considering the balance of convenience and the justice of the case, the Court must assess and compare the prejudice and hardship likely to be suffered if an injunction is granted as against that which is likely to be suffered if one is not granted, including whether the applicant is likely to suffer injury for which damages will not be an adequate remedy: O’Neill at 68 [19] (Gleeson CJ and Crennan J). 5.2 Is there a serious question to be tried? As earlier mentioned, the evidence of Angelo Ferella contained various allegations which I have treated as indicating the grounds on which the applicant wishes to challenge the costs and expenses which the Official Trustee seeks to claim as against Angelo Ferella’s estate. In his written submissions in support of the interlocutory application, the applicant contended that:12.The primary relief sought in these proceedings is predicated upon the exorbitant amount claimed by the respondent in the bankrupt estate of the applicant. In general terms the following attacks are made in respect of that claim: (a)In proceedings No. NSD 1284 of 2009 [being the s 179 inquiry proceedings before Yates J], in this Court, reliance was placed on the said affidavit of Sally Jane Wooderson in establishing the level of debt to the respondent. Various components in the amount claimed on behalf of the respondent in that affidavit are challenged seriatum in the affidavit of Angelo Ferella sworn on 15 October 2015 in these proceedings;(b)In proceedings NSD 1284 of 2009 there are substantial unresolved costs orders between the parties;(c)There are pending proceedings in this Court in NSD 1391/2015 for damages against the respondent; and (d)The amount otherwise claimable by the respondent has been reduced by $210,000 paid by Nida Ferella in respect of the North Entrance property.13.The affidavit of Joyce Fu of 6 November 2015 which was read on behalf of the present respondent in the NSW Court of Appeal conceded, at paragraph 15, that the said affidavit Sally Jane Wooderson was erroneous in at least one respect. The unsatisfactory position with respect to the respondent’s claims is further amplified by material obtained under freedom of information legislation and referred to in the affidavit of Angelo Ferella of 15 October 2015.14.The various amounts claimed by the respondent as remuneration for realisation of assets are set out in paragraph 4 of the said Wooderson affidavit are quite opaque to the outside reader. That is sufficient to give rise to a grave concern that some of those amounts relate to the receipt of part of the proceeds of a mortgagee’s sale in respect of a valuable property at Point Piper which was an asset of the Cavallino Unit Trust and not an asset falling within the bankrupt estates of the present applicant or that of Angelo Ferella. It was held by Nicholas J in Agusta & Ors v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy [2008] NSWSC 685, and not disturbed in the NSW Court of Appeal, that the subject property was an asset of the Cavallino Unit Trust and restorative orders were made in favour of the trustee of that trust Riva NSW Pty Ltd.