Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 48 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (No 4) [2015] FCA 712

Citation: Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (No 4) [2015] FCA 712
Parties: ANGELO FERELLA and GUSTAVO FERELLA v OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY AS TRUSTEE OF THE BANKRUPT ESTATES OF ANGELO FERELLA AND GUSTAVO FERELLA
File number(s): NSD 1284 of 2009
Judge(s): YATES J
Date of judgment: 14 July 2015
Catchwords: BANKRUPTCY AND INSOLVENCY – inquiry into conduct of trustee in bankruptcy in the administration of two bankrupt estates – allegation that trustee unjustifiably failed to disclose information in legal proceedings in which the bankrupts and the trustee were parties – whether trustee breached duty owed to each bankrupt
Legislation: Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) ss 20J, 149 and 179
Cases cited: Adsett v Berlouis (1992) 37 FCR 201
Agusta Pty Ltd v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy as Trustee of Estates of Gustavo Ferella and Angelo Ferella [2009] NSWCA 129
Agusta Pty Ltd & Ors as trustees for the Cavallino Unit Trust v The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy as trustee of the bankrupt estates of Gustavo Ferella and Angelo Ferella [2008] NSWSC 685
Agusta Pty Ltd & Ors as trustees for the Cavallino Unit Trust v The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy as trustee of the bankrupt estates of Gustavo Ferella and Angelo Ferella (unreported, Sup Ct, NSW, Nicholas J, 28 August 2009)
Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (No 2) [2011] FCA 619
In re Beddoe; Downes v Cottam [1893] 1 Ch 547
Octavo Investments Proprietary Limited v Knight (1979) 144 CLR 360
Pitts v La Fontaine (1880) 6 App Cas 482
Re Alafaci; Registrar in Bankruptcy v Hardwick (1976) 9 ALR 262
Re Driller (1972) 21 FLR 159
Dates of hearing: 6 August 2014, 8 September 2014
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 105
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr RK Newton
Solicitor for the Applicants: Zali Burrows Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr AP Spencer
Solicitor for the Respondent: Sally Nash & Co Lawyers

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 1284 of 2009

BETWEEN:

ANGELO FERELLA
First Applicant

GUSTAVO FERELLA
Second Applicant

AND:

OFFICIAL TRUSTEE IN BANKRUPTCY AS TRUSTEE OF THE BANKRUPT ESTATES OF ANGELO FERELLA AND GUSTAVO FERELLA
Respondent

JUDGE:

YATES J

DATE OF ORDER:

14 JULY 2015

WHERE MADE:

SYDNEY

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicants serve on the respondent a draft of the orders they propose, which will give effect to these reasons and provide for the question of costs of the inquiry, supported by written submissions (not exceeding two pages in length) on the question of costs of the inquiry, by 4.00 pm on 22 July 2015. 

2.The respondent serve on the applicants a draft of the orders it proposes, which will give effect to these reasons and provide for the question of costs of the inquiry, supported by written submissions (not exceeding two pages in length) in the event there is disagreement on the question of costs of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] FCA 712
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (No 4) involved the applicants, Gustavo and Angelo Ferella, and the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy. The applicants sought an inquiry into the conduct of the respondent in the administration of their bankrupt estates. The main issue was whether the respondent breached their duty by failing to disclose certain information in legal proceedings involving the applicants and the respondent. Specifically, the inquiry focused on the respondent's failure to disclose an Australian Taxation Office (ATO) letter and its contents.

The court had to decide whether the respondent was justified in not disclosing the ATO letter and its contents to the applicants during proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales and the Court of Appeal. If the respondent was not justified in withholding the information, the court had to determine the consequences of that non-disclosure on the administration of the applicants' bankrupt estates and what relief, if any, should be granted under section 179(1) of the Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth).

The court found that the respondent was not justified in withholding the ATO letter from the applicants, as it came to light that the respondent's solicitors and counsel only became aware of the letter on 22 October 2008. The court concluded that the respondent's failure to disclose the ATO letter had no significant consequences on the orderly administration of the applicants' estates. Consequently, the court did not deem it necessary to grant any relief to the applicants under section 179(1) of the Act.

The court ordered that the applicants and the respondent draft proposed orders based on the court's reasons, with submissions regarding the costs of the inquiry. The parties were given deadlines to submit their drafts and written submissions, with an option to be heard orally on the question of costs or the form of the orders proposed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicants serve on the respondent a draft of the orders they propose, which will give effect to these reasons and provide for the question of costs of the inquiry, supported by written submissions (not exceeding two pages in length) on the question of costs of the inquiry, by 4.00 pm on 22 July 2015.

2. The respondent serve on the applicants a draft of the orders it proposes, which will give effect to these reasons and provide for the question of costs of the inquiry, supported by written submissions (not exceeding two pages in length) in the event there is disagreement on the question of costs of the inquiry, by 4.00 pm on 29 July 2015.

3. Copies of the draft orders and submissions served in accordance with Orders 1 and 2 be provided to the Associate to Yates J at the time of service.

4. If the parties wish to be heard orally on the question of costs or on the form of the orders proposed, they are to approach the Associate to Yates J, by no later than

4.00 pm on 31 July 2015, for the purpose of allocating a hearing date.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (No 4) revolves around an inquiry into the conduct of the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (respondent) in the administration of the estates of Gustavo and Angelo Ferella (applicants). The inquiry was initiated due to allegations that the respondent unjustifiably failed to disclose information in legal proceedings involving the applicants and the trustee. Specifically, the inquiry examined whether the respondent breached the duty owed to the applicants by not disclosing the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) letter or its contents to them in the proceedings SC 4820/06 in the Supreme Court of New South Wales and in proceedings CA 40326/08 in the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The ATO letter concerned income tax assessments and was placed on file without the knowledge of Mr Madden, who was involved in the proceedings. The evidence at the inquiry indicated that Mr Madden did not know the ATO letter had been received by the respondent until 22 October 2008, when he was preparing for a conference with the respondent’s solicitors and counsel. Mr Madden was on leave from 14 to 22 July 2008 and was absent for other periods in August and September 2008. He was unable to ascertain how and by whom the letter was placed on the file. Mr Madden testified that had the ATO letter come to his attention before 24 July 2008, Declaration 5(l) would not have been made. The respondent’s solicitors subsequently wrote to the ATO on 11 August 2008 and 7 October 2008, but no response was received. The solicitors and counsel only became aware of the ATO letter on 22 October 2008, when it was discussed at the conference.

The matter before the court was an inquiry into the conduct of the Official Trustee in Bankruptcy regarding the administration of the bankrupt estates of Gustavo and Angelo Ferella. The inquiry was limited to specific questions concerning the disclosure of an ATO letter and its contents to the applicants in certain legal proceedings. The inquiry did not delve into broader substantive legal issues or the reasoning behind the court's decisions. Prior to this inquiry, the applicants had been discharged from bankruptcy on 3 December 2008. The respondents had filed a notice of appeal and a notice of contention challenging certain findings of the Supreme Court. The appeal and cross-appeal were heard by the Court of Appeal on 7 May 2009, which allowed the appeal and set aside certain orders made by the Supreme Court.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The inquiry is limited to the following questions: (a)In the course of administering the applicants’ bankrupt estates, was the respondent justified in not disclosing [the ATO letter] or its contents … to the applicants in proceedings SC 4820/06 in the Supreme Court of New South Wales or in proceedings CA 40326/08 in the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales?(b)If the respondent was not justified in not disclosing [the ATO letter] to the applicants as aforesaid:-(i)what consequence, if any, did that non-disclosure have for the orderly administration of the applicants’ bankrupt estates?(ii)what relief, if any, should be granted pursuant to s 179(1) of [the Act]?The evidence at the inquiry Mr Madden gave evidence at the inquiry. He said that he did not know that the ATO letter had been received by the respondent until 22 October 2008, when he was preparing for a conference with the respondent’s solicitors and counsel in relation to the appeal in the Court of Appeal, which had been commenced on 8 October 2008. The letter had been placed on file without his knowledge. The evidence shows that Mr Madden was on leave in the period 14 to 22 July 2008. The evidence shows that Mr Madden was also absent for other periods in August and September 2008. Mr Madden said that, although having made inquiries, he was unable to ascertain how, and by whom, the letter came to be placed on the file. He said that, had the ATO letter come to his attention before 24 July 2008 (when Nicholas J made orders following the giving of judgment on 8 July 2008), Declaration 5(l)—which was not in fact opposed by the plaintiffs—would not have been made. It should be noted in this connection that the respondent’s solicitors subsequently wrote to the ATO on 11 August 2008 and on 7 October 2008. In the first letter, the respondent’s solicitors sent the ATO a copy of the orders made on 24 July 2008, and noted that, as Riva was found to be trustee of the Cavallino Unit Trust, it would be Riva’s responsibility to prepare and lodge tax returns. In the second letter, the respondent’s solicitors said:As you know the judgment in this matter has been delivered in the Supreme Court. The Official Trustee in Bankruptcy holds the amount for the capital gains tax. Can you please advise the current status with respect to the income tax assessments so that the quantum payable for these amounts are certain and a further application can be made to the Court for an order for payment out. No response was received to these letters. They had obviously been written on the understanding that, as previously informed, assessments for capital gains tax would issue. Mr Madden said that he took the ATO letter to the conference on 22 October 2008. It is implicit in his evidence that the ATO letter was discussed. I am satisfied that the respondent’s solicitors and counsel only became aware of the ATO letter at this time. On the evening of 22 October 2008, the respondent’s solicitors received an email from counsel who was then briefed for the respondent. The email stated that counsel had discussed the ATO letter with “a senior member on [his] floor”. The email contemplated that a letter would be sent to the, by then, appellants’ solicitors. The email recorded the following advice:·The receipt of the ATO letter did not oblige the respondent to disclose the information in it to the appellants or the Supreme Court either before 24 July 2008 or at that time.·The orders made on 24 July 2008 did not provide for any amount to be retained by the respondent on account of any capital gains tax liability.·When advising the appellants of the amount to be paid into court, it was necessary to do no more than inform them of that amount, the amounts that had already been paid, and the amounts that were still retained by the respondent.·There was no need to inform the appellants of the ATO letter or to make reference to “the existence or non-existence of any claim by the ATO”. However, the letter should not be misleading in this regard.·The appellants should be advised, if it be the case, that the respondent’s instructions were that it would make no objection to any application made by Riva for payment out of the court-held funds.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the respondent justified in not disclosing the ATO letter or its contents to the applicants in the proceedings SC 4820/06 in the Supreme Court of New South Wales or in proceedings CA 40326/08 in the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales?
2. If the respondent was not justified in not disclosing the ATO letter to the applicants, what consequences, if any, did that non-disclosure have for the orderly administration of the applicants’ bankrupt estates?
3. What relief, if any, should be granted pursuant to s 179(1) of the relevant Act?

Held
1. The court held that the respondent was not justified in not disclosing the ATO letter or its contents to the applicants in the proceedings SC 4820/06 in the Supreme Court of New South Wales or in proceedings CA 40326/08 in the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales.
2. The court determined that the non-disclosure of the ATO letter did not have any consequences for the orderly administration of the applicants’ bankrupt estates.
3. The court decided not to grant any relief pursuant to s 179(1) of the relevant Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Another debt or liability related to a contingent liability in respect of certain unassessed legal costs (Declaration 5(i)). I mention that matter only incidentally so as to provide context for some other matters to which I will refer. By Order 6, his Honour directed the respondent to pay into court the net proceeds of sale of the Point Piper land. By Order 7, his Honour ordered the plaintiffs to pay the respondent’s costs, including reserved costs. By Order 8, his Honour granted liberty to the parties to apply, in respect of their various rights and obligations in relation to the balance of the net proceeds. By September 2008, the bulk of the applicants’ creditors had been paid by the respondent. On 3 December 2008, the applicants were discharged from bankruptcy by operation of law: see s 149(4) of the Act. On 8 October 2008, the plaintiffs filed a notice of appeal from the orders made by Nicholas J. The notice of appeal challenged his Honour’s findings that Agusta had not succeeded Riva as trustee of the Cavallino Unit Trust; that the trust property did not vest in Riva; that the respondent was entitled to assert a lien in respect of the disputed claims; that the respondent was, in any event, entitled to a possessory lien; and that the trustee of the Cavallino Unit Trust was not entitled to interest at court rates (as opposed to the rate of interest prescribed for the purposes of s 20J(4) of the Act). Shortly thereafter, the respondent filed a notice of cross-appeal and a notice of contention. The grounds of the cross-appeal were that Nicholas J had erred in finding that Riva became trustee of the Cavallino Unit Trust on 19 April 2005, and that his Honour ought to have found that the applicants had never been validly replaced as trustees of that trust. The notice of contention also took up the latter issue. The appeal and cross-appeal were heard by the Court of Appeal on 7 May 2009. During the course of the hearing, the respondent abandoned its cross-appeal. The Court of Appeal gave judgment on 3 June 2009 and allowed the appeal: Agusta Pty Ltd v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy as Trustee of Estates of Gustavo Ferella and Angelo Ferella [2009] NSWCA 129. In allowing the appeal, however, the Court of Appeal noted that the way in which the parties had approached the issues that had arisen on the appeal differed from the way in which they had approached those issues at trial. This was reflected in the Court of Appeal’s conclusion that a number of orders made by Nicholas J (including Declaration 5(l)) should be set aside. In relation to Declaration 5(i) and Declaration 5(l), the Court of Appeal said (at [34]-[36]):[34]At the commencement of the hearing of the appeal, senior counsel for the OT was called upon to explain the legal basis upon which it could be asserted that the OT had a right of indemnity with respect to the bankruptcy litigation costs, the cross-claim costs or the CGT claim given that each only arose after the date of the sequestration orders. Senior counsel was also asked whether he submitted that the OT would be personally liable for any of those costs or taxes so as to justify his claim to a right of indemnity with respect thereto and an equitable lien over the Fund to protect that right. [35]Quite properly and fairly, senior counsel for the OT conceded first, that the OT had no personal liability with respect to post-sequestration order costs or liabilities incurred in the administration, or arising out of the affairs, of the Trust; second, that no right of indemnity with respect to those costs or liabilities could arise until they became an actual or potential liability of the Trust; and third, that any such right of indemnity, arising after the date of the sequestration orders, was not after-acquired property within the meaning of the Act as a consequence whereof any such right, whenever it arose, would never vest in the OT as part of the bankrupt estates of the Ferellas.[36]In the foregoing circumstances it was properly conceded on behalf of the OT that his Honour’s Declarations 5(i) and (l) should be set aside.