FDB17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

FDB17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FedCFamC2G 626

File number: MLG 2535 of 2017
Judgment of: JUDGE CHAMPION
Date of judgment: 21 July 2023
Catchwords:  MIGRATION LAW – Safe Haven Enterprise Visa – Applicant sought protection because of alleged threats from political group in receiving country – Tribunal transcript cannot be employed to supplement Tribunal’s reasons – Whether exercise of Tribunal’s statutory discretion not to obtain oral evidence legally unreasonable – Evidence of Applicant so compromised that evidence from proposed corroborative witnesses could not affect the outcome
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss. 5AAA, 422B, 425, 426, 426A, 427
Cases cited:

Acting Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services & Multicultural Affairs v CWY20 (2021) 288 FCR 565

AYX17 v. Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCAFC 103

BTF15 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 647

DBD16 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCA 362

Re Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs; Ex parte Applicant S20/2002 (2003) 77 ALJR 1165

SZBEL v.  Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) 228 CLR 152

SZCSC v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2007] FCA 418

SZUIJ v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1574

SZVBB v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2015] FCA 1414

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 56
Date of last submissions: 9 May 2023
Date of hearing: 9 May 2023
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Aleksov and Mr Thangarajah
Solicitor for the Applicant: Bleyer Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms McInnes
Solicitor for the Respondents: Clayton Utz

ORDERS

MLG 2535 of 2017

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

FDB17

Applicant

AND:

MINSTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE CHAMPION

DATE OF ORDER:

21 July 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The application is dismissed.

2.The Applicant pay the First Respondent’s costs of $8,371.30.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE CHAMPION:

INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY

  1. The applicant is a Pakistani citizen who was 39 years old at the time of the Tribunal hearing (Applicant) (CB29).  He claimed that he ran a clothing shop in an area controlled by the Muttahida Quami Movement (MQM) and that MQM routinely threatened and extorted money from him (CB60-66). The Tribunal did not believe his account of events. The Tribunal’s decision of 17 November 2017 affirmed a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FDB17 v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 626
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved an applicant seeking review of a decision by the Tribunal which, in turn, had reviewed a decision by the Delegate. The applicant sought to challenge the Tribunal’s exercise of its discretion under s. 427(1)(a) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) not to obtain evidence from four witnesses. The applicant argued that the Tribunal’s decision not to hear evidence from these witnesses was legally unreasonable, contending that the Tribunal’s reasoning was irrational or unreasonable.

The central legal issue was whether the Tribunal’s decision not to obtain evidence from the four witnesses was legally unreasonable. The applicant contended that the Tribunal had failed to properly consider the relevance and role of the proposed evidence. The court had to determine if the Tribunal's exercise of its discretion to obtain evidence from witnesses was within the area of decisional freedom available to it, especially considering the Tribunal's concerns about the applicant's credibility and the lack of detail provided about the witnesses.

The court found that the Tribunal’s decision was not legally unreasonable. It concluded that the Tribunal had substantial concerns about the reliability and credibility of the applicant’s accounts, which had accumulated throughout the Tribunal hearing and upon reviewing the material before it. The court highlighted that the Tribunal had not rushed to a decision to refuse to hear from the witnesses and had considered the issue after the hearing. The court noted that while the Tribunal could have provided more detail about the proposed witnesses, the decision to not obtain their evidence was within the Tribunal’s discretion, especially given the Tribunal’s concerns about the applicant’s credibility and the lack of detail about the witnesses.

In light of the above, the court dismissed the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The application will be dismissed. I set out my reasons below.THE DELEGATE’S DECISION The Delegate had accepted that the Applicant had been a member of the PSG Sindhi shopkeepers association from Karachi and MQM had mistreated him as a shopkeeper (CB157). That is, the Delegate made a finding favourable to the Applicant insofar as the Delegate accepted that he was a Sindhi shopkeeper in Karachi. The Delegate did not accept that he was at future risk of harm from MQM if he returned to Pakistan (CB 154). Subsequently, and contrary to the Delegate’s finding, the Tribunal did “not accept [that the Applicant] was a shopkeeper at a market” (CB348, [31]). In fact, the Tribunal disbelieved the Applicant as to his claims of being a shopkeeper and (in addition) disbelieved that MQM threatened him and extorted money from him. The Tribunal put the Applicant on notice that it might depart from the Delegate’s finding: Tribunal transcript (P5:L39-41–P6:L13); SZBEL v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2006) 228 CLR 152, [35]. The Applicant did not submit that the Tribunal breached its obligations of procedural fairness in making its own finding (contrary to the Delegate’s finding) that the Applicant was a shopkeeper. TRIBUNAL DECISION Before the Tribunal’s hearing, the Applicant’s response on 25 August 2017 (CB244–279) to the Tribunal’s hearing invitation (CB232–233) requested that the Tribunal obtain evidence from four named witnesses (his mother, father, brother and a friend) and set out a brief description of the evidence they would give (CB248–250). Each of the witnesses was resident in Pakistan. The Applicant provided a summary of the proposed evidence the named witnesses would give (CB251). Further details are set out below. On 6 September 2017 the Applicant appeared before the Tribunal at the hearing (CB283). The Tribunal hearing record states that the Applicant and the four named witnesses were “in attendance” and listed their international phone numbers: (CB 283). The Tribunal’s reasons included a summary of the Applicant’s key claims (CB319–20, [13]–[14]) as follows:13.The applicant claims to fear persecution in Pakistan from Muttahida Quami Movement (MQM) party activists. His key claims as summarised are:•In 2001 he opened a clothing shop named Siddiqui Cloth House at Bolton Market in Karachi.•As a shopkeeper he paid extortion money to MQM activists, until he and other shopkeepers stopped giving money in 2008. The activists then hassled and threatened him and stole shop goods.•On 28 December 2009 a Shia Ashura Day procession was suicide bombed in Karachi and that night the market watchman observed the MQM activists looting and burning market shops including the applicant's shop. The watchman phoned the applicant to tell what had happened.•On 31 December 2009 the applicant filed with the police a written complaint against a named MQM activist. A copy of the complaint has been provided.•The MQM activists became aware of the written complaint and demanded he withdraw it when they assaulted him two times in early 2012. Then on 5 March 2012 he was abducted and threatened with death.•On 6 March 2012 he went to the police and withdrew the complaint, but then also lodged a fresh written complaint about the abduction. A copy of the second complaint has been provided.•He was worried the MQM activists would become aware of the second complaint so in 2013 and 2014 he stayed for long periods with aunts in Sukkur city and Shekarbur city, and while he was away strangers asked after him three times.•In November 2015 he used a genuine Pakistan passport to travel to Malaysia.•In February 2016 he used a false identity to travel to Australia.•Since he departed Pakistan, MQM activists have asked the family where he is and threatened to kill him if he returns to Pakistan. He provided a letter from the parents and a friend to support this.14.The applicant claims he has a well-founded fear of returning to Pakistan arising from his:•Political opinion. He fears the MQM party activists will harm him because of his political opinion (actual or imputed) against the MQM party. This arose when he refused to pay money to the party, and he then refused to withdraw a police report he had lodged against the party, and he then lodged a second police report against the party.•Membership of a particular social group, of Sindhi shopkeepers in Karachi.•Race. He fears the MQM party, other ethnic groups, and Urdu speakers will harm him because he is of Sindhi ethnicity.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The relevant passage concluded in AYX17 at [96]–[99]:[96]While it is possible, by segmenting the Tribunal’s reasons, to strip the reasons of what might be seen to be any intelligible justification, and to highlight what might appear to be a misconception by the Tribunal of the scope of the evidence which each of the proffered witnesses could give, in our opinion (and not without some hesitation) the exercise of power by the Tribunal in this case is not susceptible to the characterisation of a legally unreasonable exercise of power.[97]The Tribunal plainly had substantial concerns about the reliability and credibility of the appellant’s accounts of what had happened to him in the past, and why he had fled Turkey. Its concerns had accumulated through the Tribunal hearing, and on consideration of the material before the Tribunal. It was not given details about what the proposed witnesses would be able to say (cf BTF15). It was not given any real detail at all about the witnesses themselves. They were not close relatives of the visa applicant, who were said to be closely involved in the narrative which formed the basis for his account to have a well‐founded fear of persecution (cf CZBH). The Tribunal did not rush to make a decision to refuse to hear from the two witnesses and its reasons should be read as indicating that it continued to consider this issue after the hearing. The appellant did not submit the Tribunal’s statements at the hearing were false on this account.[98] As we have explained above, the method by which evidence will be taken will generally not provide a sufficient justification for a decision‐maker to refuse to hear such evidence. Further, decision‐makers need to be careful to understand with some precision how a visa applicant explains the relevance and role of any proffered evidence. There will come a point where repeated statements by reviewing courts about these matters, if not taken to heart and applied by decision‐makers, may result in reviewing courts concluding that decision‐makers are taking an arbitrary or capricious approach to the exercise of this power.[99] However, that is not this case. Looking at the whole of the circumstances, we consider the exercise of discretion was within the area of decisional freedom available to the Tribunal, particularly given the matters to which we have referred at [97] above.[Emphasis added]CONSIDERATION As argued, the Applicant pressed a single ground of review that the Tribunal’s exercise of its statutory discretion to obtain evidence from witnesses under s. 427(1)(a) was legally unreasonable because the Tribunal’s reasoning was irrational or unreasonable in the requisite sense: see AYX17 at [77] (above).The Applicant’s response to the hearing invitation The Applicant’s response to the hearing invitation (CB248-250) set out that he wished the Tribunal to obtain evidence from three family members and a friend. He described the proposed evidence his family members and his friend would give and its relevance as follows:My mother […] will give evidence that MQM have recently attended our family home asking about my whereabouts. My father […] will give evidence that he has been approached in the community, in recent months, by MQM members asking questions about me.Mr brother […] will give evidence that I still have high risk in Pakistan and MQM party searching for me to kill and still MQM party people come our home to ask about me My friend […] will give evidence that [the applicant’s] life is not save in Pakistan many time I saw the MQM party people asking about him and they were talking about we will kill him whenever he will come in Pakistan[As written]