FanFirm Pty Limited v Fanatics, LLC (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

FanFirm Pty Limited v Fanatics, LLC (No 2) [2024] FCA 826

File number: NSD 963 of 2022
Judgment of: ROFE J
Date of judgment: 29 July 2024
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for stay of orders pursuant to r 36.08 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) – whether stay or rectification of the Trade Marks Register more suitable course pending determination of appeal – whether stay or injunction more suitable course pending determination of appeal – application partially granted.
Legislation:

Trade Marks Act1995 (Cth)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth)

Cases cited:

Energy Beverages LLC v Cantarella Bros Pty Ltd (No 2) [2022] FCA 394

FanFirm Pty Ltd v Fanatics, LLC [2024] FCA 764

Flight Centre Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2014] FCA 658

Minnesota Mining & Manufacturing Company v Johnson & Johnson Limited [1976] 25 RPC 671

Redbubble Ltd v Hells Angels Motorcycle Corp (Australia) Pty Ltd (2022) 168 IPR 74

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Trade Marks
Number of paragraphs: 65
Date of hearing: 23 July 2024
Counsel for the Applicant: A J L Bannon SC
Solicitor for the Applicant: Sparke Helmore
Counsel for the Respondent: C Dimitriadis SC with S L Ross
Solicitor for the Respondent: King & Wood Mallesons

ORDERS

NSD 963 of 2022
BETWEEN:

FANFIRM PTY LIMITED

Applicant

AND:

FANATICS, LLC

Respondent

AND BETWEEN:

FANATICS, LLC

Cross-Claimant

AND:

FANFIRM PTY LIMITED

Cross-Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

ROFE J

DATE OF ORDER:

29 JULY 2024

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

The respondent undertakes:

A.to pursue any appeal with expedition; and

B.until the hearing and determination of any appeal, to abide by such order as the Court may make in favour of the applicant for damages or an account of profits (at its election) after 17 July 2024 in the event that any appeal is relevantly unsuccessful.

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Orders 3, 4 and 5 of the orders made at 10.15 am on 17 July 2024 (17 July Orders) be stayed until:

(a)4.00 pm on 14 August 2024; or

(b)if a Notice of Appeal is filed, 28 days after the resolution of that appeal.

2.Order 2 of the 17 July Orders be stayed until 4.00 pm on 14 August 2024.

3.By 4.00 pm on 5 August 2024, the parties prepare, and provide to the Court, proposed redactions to the Court’s reasons for judgment. The Court will then prepare a redacted version of the reasons for judgment, which will be made available to the public.

4.The parties have leave to appeal the judgment handed down on 17 July 2024 and orders 2–7 of the 17 July Orders.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

ROFE J:

1.               Introduction

  1. On 17 July 2024, I delivered my reasons in this matter: FanFirm Pty Ltd v Fanatics, LLC [2024] FCA 764 (Reasons or J) and pronounced orders giving effect…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FanFirm Pty Limited v Fanatics, LLC (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] FCA 826
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of FanFirm Pty Limited v Fanatics, LLC (No 2), the applicant, FanFirm, sought a stay of certain orders made by the Court on 17 July 2024, pending the determination of an appeal against those orders. The respondent, Fanatics, did not oppose the application for a stay but proffered certain undertakings, which the Court accepted. The primary dispute centred around the stay of the injunction and rectification orders made by the Court, as well as the release of the reasons for judgment.

The legal issues before the Court included whether a stay or rectification of the Trade Marks Register was more suitable pending the determination of the appeal, and whether a stay or injunction was more suitable in the circumstances. The Court was required to balance the potential harm to the parties if the stay was not granted against the prejudice that might result from granting a stay.

The Court found that there was a proper basis for a stay that would be fair to all parties. While there was a prima facie assumption that the judgment appealed from was correct and that the court should not deprive a litigant of the benefit of a judgment in its favour, the Court had a broad discretion as to whether to grant a stay. The Court considered that a stay was necessary to prevent potential prejudice to the respondent if the appeal was unsuccessful, and weighed the balance of convenience and the competing rights of the parties. The Court accepted the respondent’s undertakings, which included pursuing the appeal with expedition and keeping accounts of all sales of products that would fall within the terms of the injunction.

The Court ordered that certain orders made on 17 July 2024 be stayed until either 4.00 pm on 14 August 2024 or 28 days after the resolution of any appeal, if a Notice of Appeal was filed. The Court also ordered that the parties prepare proposed redactions to the Court’s reasons for judgment, which would then be made available to the public. Finally, the Court granted leave to the parties to appeal the judgment and certain orders made on 17 July 2024.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Orders 3, 4 and 5 of the orders made at 10.15 am on 17 July 2024 (17 July Orders) be stayed until:

(a) 4.00 pm on 14 August 2024; or

(b) if a Notice of Appeal is filed, 28 days after the resolution of that appeal.

2. Order 2 of the 17 July Orders be stayed until 4.00 pm on 14 August 2024.

3. By 4.00 pm on 5 August 2024, the parties prepare, and provide to the Court, proposed redactions to the Court’s reasons for judgment. The Court will then prepare a redacted version of the reasons for judgment, which will be made available to the public.

4. The parties have leave to appeal the judgment handed down on 17 July 2024 and orders 2–7 of the 17 July Orders.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

FanFirm Pty Limited, the applicant, filed an application for a stay of orders pursuant to rule 36.08 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth). The application arose from an earlier decision where FanFirm obtained orders against Fanatics, LLC (the respondent). These orders included injunctive relief prohibiting the respondent from using certain trade marks that FanFirm claimed were infringing, as well as orders for rectification of the Trade Marks Register. FanFirm sought a stay of these orders pending the determination of an appeal against the earlier decision. The applicant argued that the respondent could implement a geo-blocking facility to prevent Australian consumers from accessing websites that used the infringing trade marks, which would mitigate potential harm during the appeal period.

The matter came before the court swiftly for hearing as an application for a stay of the orders made on 17 July 2024. The court had previously ruled in favour of FanFirm, issuing orders that included an injunction and orders for rectification of the Trade Marks Register. Fanatics, LLC sought to stay these orders pending the determination of an appeal against the earlier decision. The respondent proffered undertakings to pursue the appeal with expedition, keep accounts of sales of products that would fall within the terms of the injunction, and abide by any order the court might make for damages or an account of profits in the event the appeal was unsuccessful.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Rule 36.08 of the Rules provides:36.08 Stay of execution or proceedings under judgment appealed from (1) An appeal does not:(a) operate as a stay of execution or a stay of any proceedings under the judgment subject to the appeal; or (b) invalidate any proceedings already taken.(2) However, an appellant or interested person may apply to the Court for an order to stay the execution of the proceeding until the appeal is heard and determined.(3) An application may be made under subrule (2) even though the court from which the appeal is brought has previously refused an application of a similar kind. The principles in relation to the stay of an order are well known and were summarised by Rangiah J in Flight Centre Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission [2014] FCA 658 at [9] as follows:(a) There is an onus on the applicant to demonstrate a proper basis for a stay that will be fair to all parties.(b) There is a prima facie assumption that the judgment appealed from is correct.(c) There is a prima facie assumption that the court should not deprive a litigant of the benefit of a judgment in its favour.(d) The court has a broad discretion as to whether to grant a stay, and it is not necessary for an applicant for a stay to demonstrate special or exceptional circumstances. It is sufficient that the applicant demonstrates a reason or an appropriate case to warrant the exercise of discretion in its favour.(e) The mere filing of an appeal will not, of itself, provide a reason or demonstrate an appropriate case.(f) A stay will usually be granted if there is a real risk that the applicant will suffer prejudice or damage, if a stay is not granted, which will not be redressed by a successful appeal.(g) In the exercise of its discretion, the court will weigh considerations such as the balance of convenience and the competing rights of the parties before it. A similar summary of the relevant principles was set out by Derrington J in Redbubble Ltd v Hells Angels Motorcycle Corp (Australia) Pty Ltd (2022) 168 IPR 74 at [37]; see also the summary by Halley J in Energy Beverages LLC v Cantarella Bros Pty Ltd (No 2) [2022] FCA 394 at [20]–[25].3. Undertakings proffered by the respondent The respondent proffered the following undertakings and proposed that the Court make the orders below.Subject to any further order of the Court, upon the Respondent undertaking:(a) to pursue any appeal with expedition;(b)to keep accounts of all sales of products which would fall within the terms of the injunction made by the Court on 17 July 2024; and (c)until the hearing and determination of any appeal, to abide by such order as the Court may make in favour of the Applicant for damages or an account of profits (at its election) in respect of any sales made as a result of staying final injunctive relief in the event that any appeal is relevantly unsuccessful.THE COURT ORDERS THAT:1.Order 2, 3, 4, 5 and 8 of the orders made on 17 July 2024 be stayed until: (a)4.00 pm on 14 August 2024; or (b)if a Notice of Appeal is filed, 28 days after the resolution of that appeal. 4. Evidence

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicant referred to the evidence of Mr Rivas that the respondent could implement a geo-blocking facility so that its websites that utilise the Infringing Marks would not be accessible to Australian consumers — a technology which was widely available and which, according to Mr Rivas, should be able to be implemented within a day or so. The applicant notes that the respondent has no evidence to show that geo-blocking would involve any significant cost or delay or result in any material prejudice. This absence was explicable on the ground that the respondent’s solicitors received correspondence from the applicant’s solicitors regarding the applicant’s intention to raise evidence in respect of geo-blocking technology too late to enable them to contact relevant personnel in the US to obtain instructions before the hearing. 7. Consideration As the matter came on swiftly for hearing, the respondent had not prepared its draft notice of appeal. I noted at the hearing that for the purposes of the argument on the application to stay the Injunction, I was prepared to assume that the respondent had bona fide grounds of appeal. I consider that it is likely that the appeal will be heard during the Full Court and Appellate sitting period in March 2025. As a result, any stay of the Injunction would be expected to operate for in the order of about a year. Conversely, if there was no stay and the respondent was ultimately successful on appeal, the Injunction would be in operation for a similar length of time. As I noted above, I am prepared to order a stay in relation to the Rectification Orders, thus removing one of the sources of potential irreparable harm relied on by the respondent. The main focus of argument on the stay application was in relation to the stay of the Injunction. According to Ms Hay the two main arms of the respondent’s business in Australia are:(a)the direct to consumer e-commerce stores via domains owned and operated by the respondent such as (see J[103]−[104]); and (b)the operation of Partner Stores. I discussed the respondent’s Partner Stores at J[117]−[119]. At J[159], I concluded that the service of designing, setting up, managing and operating an online store for a third party, such as the respondent’s Partner Stores, was a different type of service to those services covered by the applicant’s registration. The ability of the respondent to provide its Partner Stores services in Australia is not impacted by the Injunction. Turning to the other arm of the respondent’s business, the e-commerce stores. The respondent has not filed any evidence which shows the breakdown of income or profit attributable to Australian sources from the operation of the e-commerce stores as opposed to the Partner Stores element of its business. The respondent made high level submissions as to its substantial reputation and goodwill achieved through the use of the Infringing Marks in its global business, and the irreparable harm and potential irrecoverable alienation of customers if no stay was granted. Whilst the respondent may have a substantial reputation and goodwill in other jurisdictions associated with the Infringing Marks, I am not convinced that the evidence supports the claim to the respondent having a substantial reputation and goodwill in the Infringing Marks in Australia.