Fanatics, LLC v FanFirm Pty Limited (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fanatics, LLC v FanFirm Pty Limited (No 2) [2025] FCA 241  

File number: NSD 1030 of 2024
Judgment of: BROMWICH J
Date of judgment: 21 March 2025
Catchwords: PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – costs – whether appellant partially successful in stay applications – where respondent proffered terms of a limited stay – HELD: appellant to pay the respondent’s costs of and incidental to the interlocutory applications giving rise to FanFirm Pty Limited v Fanatics, LLC (No 2) [2024] FCA 826, Fanatics, LLC v FanFirm Pty Limited [2024] FCA 920 and the costs applications for both.
Legislation: Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 36.08(2), 40.04
Cases cited:

Al Muderis v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited (No 3) [2024] FCA 204

Dyer v Chrysanthou (No 4) [2022] FCA 51

Fanatics, LLC v FanFirm Pty Limited [2024] FCA 920

FanFirm Pty Limited v Fanatics, LLC [2024] FCA 764

FanFirm Pty Limited v Fanatics, LLC (No 2) [2024] FCA 826

Monash Health v Singh [2023] FCAFC 166; 327 IR 196

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Trade Marks
Number of paragraphs: 27
Date of last submissions: 13 September 2024
Date of hearing: Determined on the papers
Counsel for the Appellant: Ms M Evetts
Solicitor for the Appellant: King & Wood Mallesons
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr C Dimitriadis SC, Ms S L Ross, Mr G Tsang
Solicitor for the Respondent: Sparke Helmore

ORDERS

NSD 1030 of 2024
BETWEEN:

FANATICS, LLC

Appellant

AND:

FANFIRM PTY LIMITED

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

BROMWICH J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 MARCH 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Fanatics, LLC pay the costs of FanFirm Pty Limited, of and incidental to:

(a)the interlocutory application giving rise to FanFirm Pty Limited v Fanatics, LLC (No 2) [2024] FCA 826 (First Stay Judgment);

(b)the interlocutory application giving rise to Fanatics, LLC v FanFirm Pty Limited [2024] FCA 920 (Second Stay Judgment); and

(c)the application for costs in relation to the First Stay Judgment and the Second Stay Judgment.

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

2.Order 1 made on 23 August 2024 provides that, following determination of the issue of costs on the papers in accordance with Order 9 of the orders made by the primary judge in proceeding NSD 963 of 2022 on 17 July 2024, any assessment and payment thereof is to be stayed until 28 days after the resolution of this appeal.

3.Order 9 made on 23 August 2024 provides that, following determination of the issue of costs on the papers in accordance with Order 4 made on 23 August 2024, any assessment and payment thereof is to be stayed until 28 days after the resolution of this appeal.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

BROMWICH J:

  1. On 17 July 2024, a judge of this Court found Fanatics, LLC, now the appellant, liable for trademark infringement of a word mark and a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fanatics, LLC v FanFirm Pty Limited (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 241
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Fanatics, LLC v FanFirm Pty Limited (No 2), the Federal Court of Australia addressed the costs associated with interlocutory stay applications between the parties. Fanatics, LLC (Fanatics) sought to stay certain orders issued against it by FanFirm Pty Limited (FanFirm) pending the resolution of an appeal. The primary judge initially granted a stay of certain orders, but Fanatics pressed for a further stay until the appeal was resolved. Fanatics was largely unsuccessful in its applications, and FanFirm successfully opposed the proposed further stay. The court had to determine the proper characterisation of the stay applications and the legal principles applicable to the award of costs in interlocutory applications.

The court identified two central legal issues: (a) whether the stay applications could be characterised as successful or partially successful, and whether FanFirm’s conduct contributed to their cost; and (b) the legal principles applicable to the award of costs in interlocutory applications. The court found that Fanatics was largely unsuccessful in its stay applications, with only a minor aspect of the first stay application being successful. The court concluded that it was not desirable to apportion costs based on such a limited success and that the default position under the Federal Court Rules should apply, where the unsuccessful party pays the costs of the successful party.

The court ruled that Fanatics must pay FanFirm’s costs of the interlocutory stay applications and related costs applications. The court ordered that Fanatics, LLC pay the costs of FanFirm Pty Limited, of and incidental to the interlocutory applications giving rise to FanFirm Pty Limited v Fanatics, LLC (No 2) [2024] FCA 826 and Fanatics, LLC v FanFirm Pty Limited [2024] FCA 920, as well as the costs applications for both. The assessment and payment of these costs were to be stayed until 28 days after the resolution of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Fanatics, LLC pay the costs of FanFirm Pty Limited, of and incidental to:

(a) the interlocutory application giving rise to FanFirm Pty Limited v Fanatics, LLC (No 2) [2024] FCA 826 (First Stay Judgment);

(b) the interlocutory application giving rise to Fanatics, LLC v FanFirm Pty Limited [2024] FCA 920 (Second Stay Judgment); and

(c) the application for costs in relation to the First Stay Judgment and the Second Stay Judgment.

THE COURT NOTES THAT:

2. Order 1 made on 23 August 2024 provides that, following determination of the issue of costs on the papers in accordance with Order 9 of the orders made by the primary judge in proceeding NSD 963 of 2022 on 17 July 2024, any assessment and payment thereof is to be stayed until 28 days after the resolution of this appeal.

3. Order 9 made on 23 August 2024 provides that, following determination of the issue of costs on the papers in accordance with Order 4 made on 23 August 2024, any assessment and payment thereof is to be stayed until 28 days after the resolution of this appeal.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns a dispute between Fanatics, LLC and FanFirm Pty Limited over intellectual property rights. On 17 July 2024, the primary judge delivered the Liability Judgment, which included orders for rectification of the Register of Trade Marks and an injunction, both with immediate effect. Following this, Fanatics urgently contacted the primary judge's chambers seeking a stay of the injunction order. The primary judge granted a stay of the injunction and rectification orders until 24 July 2024. FanFirm objected to the proposed stay and requested a hearing. Fanatics also sought to be heard on the matter. The primary judge proposed a further stay of the rectification and injunction orders until 28 days after the resolution of the appeal. A hearing on the first stay application was held on 23 July 2024, where the primary judge stayed the rectification orders and the injunction for a short period. The primary judge also granted leave for Fanatics to appeal the Liability Judgment. FanFirm had initially objected to the stay of the rectification orders but later withdrew its opposition. The primary judge's decision was challenged, leading to further interlocutory applications.

The case originated from the primary judge's decision in proceeding NSD 963 of 2022, which delivered the Liability Judgment on 17 July 2024. Following this, Fanatics sought a stay of the injunction and rectification orders. The primary judge granted a stay until 24 July 2024. FanFirm objected to the stay and requested a hearing, to which Fanatics also responded. The primary judge proposed a further stay until the resolution of the appeal. A hearing on the first stay application took place on 23 July 2024, where the primary judge granted the stay. FanFirm withdrew its opposition to the stay of the rectification orders but continued to object to the injunction stay. The matter proceeded to further interlocutory applications and costs applications, culminating in the current appeal regarding the costs of these interlocutory applications.

Decision

Reasons for decision

There are two central disagreements between the parties, which I deal with in turn:(a)on the characterisation of the stay applications, and specifically as to whether they can properly be characterised as successful or partially successful, and whether the conduct of FanFirm contributed to their cost;(b)on the legal principles applicable to the award of costs in interlocutory applications. Characterisation of the stay judgmentsThe First Stay Judgment On 17 July 2024, the primary judge delivered the Liability Judgment, including orders for rectification of the Register of Trade Marks and the injunction, each with immediate effect. Shortly thereafter, Fanatics contacted the chambers of the primary judge urgently seeking a stay of the injunction order: SJ-1[2]. The primary judge stayed the injunction and rectification orders until 24 July 2024. The primary judge’s chambers replied to Fanatics’ request, stating that her Honour proposed a further stay of the rectification and injunction orders until 28 days after the resolution of the appeal. The following day, FanFirm objected to the proposed orders and requested a hearing. Fanatics responded asking to be heard on the matter as well. Although Fanatics had not proposed the stay of the rectification orders, it clearly embraced it by its request to be heard in response to FanFirm’s objection. While no interlocutory application was filed, it is convenient to refer to the form of stay orders proposed by the primary judge as the first stay application. A hearing on the first stay application was convened at short notice, on Tuesday 23 July 2024. The outcome, as noted above, was a stay of the rectification orders (subject to Fanatics proffering the undertaking set out at SJ-1[18]), and a short stay of the injunction to enable Fanatics to ensure compliance with its terms. The primary judge also granted leave for Fanatics to appeal the Liability Judgment, which was necessary due to it being interlocutory in nature: see Monash Health v Singh [2023] FCAFC 166; 327 IR 196 at [38]-[44]. On the day of the hearing of the first stay application, FanFirm advised it no longer opposed a stay of the rectification orders, but pressed its objection in relation to the injunction order. Thus, while stay of the rectification orders was not in dispute at the first stay application hearing, FanFirm’s prior indication that it objected to that stay meant that some resources were expended by Fanatics in preparation for argument on that point. FanFirm submits that it was an order affecting both parties, referring to SJ-1[31], but that is beside the point. Fanatics pressed for and was granted this order, which had been contested until the time of hearing. That said, there was not much to this aspect of the first stay application. The evidence adduced by Fanatics at the first stay application largely related to the stay of the injunction. Evidence on the effect of the rectification order on Fanatics was limited to the following statement in the affidavit of Ms Katherine Hay:[18] Based on my many years of conducting intellectual property litigation, and based on matters on which I have been informed by Lan Nguyen, Senior Vice President and Head of Litigation and Regulatory at Fanatics as discussed below, I believe that if the Proposed Further Stay Order is not granted and Fanatics' appeal is ultimately successful, the granting of the Injunction and the Removal of the '633 and '681 FANATICS Marks and '688 Mark in Class 35 would deprive Fanatics of the fruits of its appeal and cause irreparable harm to it. In particular, I believe this because:(a) …(b)once its registered FANATICS and Marks are removed from the Register of Trade Marks, to the best of my knowledge, I am not aware of any mechanism under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) (or otherwise) whereby they can be reinstated with retrospective effect.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As reflected by the default position identified in the passage above, the general position is that a successful party gets its costs. Viewed in that way, it was for Fanatics to persuade me to depart from that starting proposition. Weighing against that is consideration of any irreparable harm that may be done to a party that is unsuccessful in an interlocutory application, but ultimately successful in its appeal, if it must pay the costs for that failed (or substantially failed) application. Where an application was successful only in part, or led to an outcome short of that sought by the applicant for interlocutory relief, the position on costs is complicated further: see, eg, Dyer v Chrysanthou (No 4) [2022] FCA 51 at [49]. Here the failure was all but complete, and Fanatics’ limited success was largely immaterial when it came to the question of costs.Consideration Despite the submissions as to principle from both parties, I do not consider these principles ultimately to be controversial. The real dispute of significance as to costs, is the proper characterisation of the outcome of the stay applications, which I have largely determined in favour of FanFirm. Though Fanatics contends otherwise, it was truly only successful in one relatively small part of one of its stay applications as to rectification, and not really at all as to the injunction. It is not generally desirable to apportion costs upon that sort of basis. I do not find compelling Fanatics’ argument that the outcome of the appeal has any substantial part to play in the determination of the costs of the two applications in the particular circumstances of this case. Weighing all of the competing considerations, I have concluded that costs should follow the event in accordance with the default position suggested by r 40.04 of the Federal Court Rules. It follows that Fanatics must be ordered to pay FanFirm’s costs of the two stay applications and, for clarity, the costs of the two related costs applications.