Background
Background to the litigation
Before the Court today are proceedings between the Fair Work Ombudsman (“the applicant”), Mobile Food Vans and Trucks Proprietary Limited (“the first respondent”) and Yener Gelgel (“the second respondent”).BACKGROUND The applicant commenced these proceedings by application and statement of claim filed on 19 November 2020. In the statement of claim the applicant alleged that the first respondent was incorporated, capable of being sued, is a constitutional corporation and a national systems employer for the purposes of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (“the Act”). It was alleged that the first respondent operated a business manufacturing food trailers, vans and trucks and was located in Cranbourne, Victoria. The statement of claim also alleged that the second respondent was the manager of that business and, amongst other things, was responsible for the first respondent complying with its obligations under the Act. The statement of claim further alleged that the applicant commenced an investigation into the first respondent in 2019 following a complaint made about alleged underpayments. It was alleged that the investigation found that between May 2018 and June 2018 and again between March 2019 and November 2019, Mr Nilarumpar Gadjira was employed by the first respondent and his employment was governed by the Vehicle Repair Services and Retail Award 2010 (“the Modern Award”). It was alleged that he was underpaid by the first respondent by reference to the minimum rates in that Modern Award, overtime and that he did not receive on termination accrued annual leave. The statement of claim alleged that as a result of the findings of that investigation the applicant issued a compliance notice to the first respondent pursuant to s.716 of the Act in April 2020. It was alleged that the first respondent did not comply with that notice. Finally, it was alleged that the second respondent, who was responsible for ensuring the first respondent complied with the Act and the compliance notice, was involved in that non-compliance within the meaning of s.550 of the Act and was, therefore, also taken to have contravened s.716 of the Act. Finally, the statement of claim set out the relief sought. The proceedings were given a first Court date of 16 February 2021. The applicant subsequently served the first respondent and, as it had done during the investigation, sent emails to the second respondent annexing the same documents. The applicant subsequently received a response to that email from the second respondent on 24 November 2020. However, because of difficulties in physically serving the second respondent and prior to the first Court date, the applicant filed an application in a case for orders for substituted service on the second respondent. Also prior to the first Court date, the applicant was advised by a director of the first respondent that it was not in a position to defend the proceedings. On the first Court date and on the basis of the affidavits of Ms Laura Willoughby, filed 11 February 2021 (which was marked as Exhibit A3 on that day), and Ms Cheryl Claney (which was marked as Exhibit A4 on that day), the Court made certain orders, including orders for substituted service on the second respondent. These were as follows:THE COURT ORDERS THAT:1. Pursuant to rule 6.04(b) of the Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) (“the Rules”) that the Applicant’s Originating Application and Statement of Claim filed on 19 November 2020 is deemed to have been served on the Second Respondent on 24 November 2020 by email to cfv2013@yahoo.com.au 2. Pursuant to rule 6.14 of the Rules, until further order, or a Notice of Address for Service is filed by the Second Respondent, service of all documents in these proceedings is deemed to have been effected on the Second Respondent:(a) by sending a copy of the documents by email to cfv2013@yahoo.com.au and rozbin79@yahoo.com.au ; and(b) on the next business day after the documents were sent by email.3. The Respondents each file and serve a Notice of Address for Service by 23 February 2021.4. The Respondents each file and serve by 16 March 2021:(a) any Response to the Applicant’s Application pursuant to rule 4.03 of the FCC Rules; and(b) if a Response is filed and served, a Defence to the Applicant’s Statement of Claim pursuant to rule 4.05(3)(a) of the FCC Rules.5. If the Respondents comply with orders 3 and 4 of these orders, the matter is listed for directions 28 April 2021 commencing at 10:00am.6. If either of the Respondents do not comply with either of orders 3 and 4 of these orders:(a) the Applicant file and serve any application in a case with a supporting affidavit seeking orders against either of the Respondents who are in default, pursuant to rule 13.03B of the Rules by 31 March 2021;(b) the Applicant file and serve submissions in respect of the application in a case by 7 April 2021;(c) the Respondents each file and serve any affidavit evidence and submissions in respect of the application in a case by 21 April 2021;(d) the matter is listed for hearing as to default on a date to be fixed not before 22 April 2021.7. The parties have liberty to apply.
Decision
Reasons for decision
In the face of those defaults by both respondents to do what they are required to do under the Rules of the Court and in the orders of 16 February 2021, Ms Willoughby sought leave to proceed with her client’s application in a case for default judgment. APPLICANT’S SUBMISSIONS ON DEFAULT JUDGMENT On 7 April 2021, the applicant filed an outline of submissions which provided:INTRODUCTION1. These submissions are filed in support of the Applicant’s Application in a Case filed on 31 March 2021 seeking default judgment, declarations and orders against the Respondents in these proceedings (Default Application).2. The proceedings concern the Respondents’ alleged contravention of section 716(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act) by failing to comply with a compliance notice issued by Fair Work Inspector Yoomin Lee (FWI Lee) on 7 April 2020 (Compliance Notice). The Compliance Notice required the First Respondent to calculate and rectify any underpayments in respect of its employment of Nildipkumar Gajera (Employee) and produce evidence of its compliance with the Compliance Notice.3. The Applicant alleges that the Second Respondent was involved, within the meaning of section 550 of the FW Act, in the First Respondent’s alleged contravention of section 716(5) of the FW Act.4. This Default Application is made pursuant to rule 13.03B(2)(c) of the Federal Circuit Rules 2001 (Cth) (Rules) on the basis that the Respondents have not participated in the proceedings, and have failed to comply with the orders of the Court.5. The Applicant relies on the following documents in support of the Default Application:(a) Originating Application and Statement of Claim dated and filed on 19 November 2020;(b) Affidavit of Cheryl Claney, sworn on 22 December 2020 and filed 2 February 2021 (First Claney Affidavit);(c) Affidavit of Cheryl Claney, sworn on 23 March 2021 and filed 29 March 2021 (Second Claney Affidavit);(d) Affidavit of Laura Willoughby, affirmed on 10 February 2021 and filed 11 February 2021 (First Willoughby Affidavit); and(e) Affidavit of Laura Willoughby, affirmed and filed on 31 March 2021 (Second Willoughby Affidavit).PROVISIONS AND PRINCIPLES REGARDING DEFAULT JUDGMENT6. Rule 13.03A(2) of the Rules provides that a respondent will be in default for the purposes of rule 13.03B of the Rules if the respondent has not satisfied the applicant’s claim and fails to do one or more of the things specified in the rule.7. For the purposes of the Default Application, the Applicant relies on the following provisions of Rule 13.03A(2):(a) rule 13.03A(2)(b)(i), which provides that a respondent will be in default if it fails to give an address for service before the time for the respondent to give an address for service has expired;(b) rule 13.03A(2)(b)(ii), which provides that a respondent will be in default if it fails to file a response before the time for the respondent to file a response has expired;(c) rule 13.03A(2)(b)(iii), which provides that a respondent will be in default if it fails to comply with an order of the Court in the proceeding; and(d) rule 13.03A(2)(b)(vii), which provides that a respondent will be in default if it fails to defend the proceedings with due diligence.8. With respect to rule 13.03A(2)(b)(i), the Applicant relies on rule 6.01 which requires a party to a proceeding to give an address for service. For the purposes of rule 13.03A(2)(b)(ii), the Applicant relies on rules 4.03 and 4.05(3) which require a respondent to file and serve any response and a defence within 28 days of service of the initiating application.9. Rule 13.03B(2)(c) of the Rules enables the Federal Circuit Court to give judgment against a respondent in a proceeding which was commenced by an application supported by a statement of claim. The Court may give judgment against a respondent for the relief that the applicant appears entitled to on the statement of claim and that the Court is satisfied it has power to grant.10. An order for default judgment under rule 13.03B(2)(c) of the Rules is available where there is a basis for the relief sought by an applicant on the face of the statement of claim and the facts pleaded therein. There is no requirement for proof of the applicant’s claim by way of evidence.[1] An application under rule 13.03B(2)(c) is therefore generally determined on the face of the facts pleaded in the statement of claim alone.[2][1] Arthur v Vaupotic Investments Pty Ltd [2005] FCA 433 at [3], cited in Luna Park v Bose [2006] FCA 94 at[2] ACCC v Yellow Page (No. 2) at [61] to [63], citing Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v Dataline.net.au Pty Ltd [2006] FCA 1427 (ACCC v Dataline) at [48] to [51]. These decisions were decided in respect of order 35A of the now repealed Federal Court Rules 1979 (Cth). Rule 13.03B(2)(c) of the Rules is in identical terms to order 35A and is in similar terms to rule 5.23(2)(c) of the current Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth).HISTORY OF THE PROCEEDINGS11. On 19 November 2020, the Applicant filed an Application and Statement of Claim commencing these proceedings. On 24 November 2020, the Applicant served sealed copies of the Originating Application and Statement of Claim by hand to the First Respondent’s principal place of business and registered office.[3][3] First Claney Affidavit at [1]-[6].12. On 24 November 2020, the Applicant sent an email attaching a letter and sealed copies of the Originating Application and Statement of Claim to the Second Respondent at cfv2013@yahoo.com.au.[4] On the same day, the Applicant received a reply email from the Second Respondent acknowledging that his name appeared on the documents attached to the Applicant’s email.[5] The Applicant responded to the Second Respondent’s email on 1 December 2020 and did not receive a reply to that email.[6][4] First Willoughby Affidavit at [9].[5] First Willoughby Affidavit at [10].[6] First Willoughby Affidavit at [11].13. On 9 and 10 February 2021, the Applicant sent correspondence to the Second Respondent in relation to the first directions hearing listed on 16 February 2021.[7][7] First Willoughby Affidavit at [16], Second Willoughby Affidavit at [8]-[9].14. On 11 February 2021, the Applicant filed an Application in a case for deemed service and the First Willoughby Affidavit. Sealed copies of the Application and affidavit were served on the First Respondent on 12 February 2021 and on the Second Respondent on 11 February 2021.[8][8] Second Willoughby Affidavit at [10]-[11].15. On 15 and 16 February 2021, the Applicant corresponded via email with the Director of the First Respondent in relation to the first directions hearing listed on 16 February 2021.[9] In this correspondence, the Director of the First Respondent advised the Applicant that the First Respondent was not in a position to defend these proceedings.[10][9] Second Willoughby Affidavit at [12]-[14].[10] Second Willoughby Affidavit at [13]-[14].16. At the directions hearing on 16 February 2021, there was no appearance for either of the Respondents. The Court made orders (February Orders) that:(a) the Applicant’s Originating Application and Statement of Claim filed on 19 November 2020, was deemed to have been served on the Second Respondent on 24 November 2020 by email to cfv2013@yahoo.com.au ; and(b) until further order, or a notice of address for service is filed by the Second Respondent, service of all documents in these proceedings is deemed to have been effected on the Second Respondent by sending a copy of the documents by email to cfv2013@yahoo.com.au and rozbin79@yahoo.com.au ; and(c) provided the Respondents with a further opportunity to each file and serve:(i) a notice of address for service by 23 February 2021; and(ii) any response and a defence by 16 March 2021.17. Pursuant to rules 4.03 and 4.05(3)(a) of the Rules, the Respondents were required to file and serve any response and a defence by 22 December 2020.[11][11] By reason of the Respondents being served with the Originating Application and Statement of Claim on 24 November 2020. See, First Willoughby Affidavit at [9]-[11] and Order 1 of the February Orders with respect to service of the Second Respondent and Second Willoughby Affidavit at [5]-[6] confirming service of the First Respondent.18. On 17 February 2021, the Applicant sent the February Orders to the Respondents and advised each Respondent of the Applicant’s intention to make an application for default judgment should the First Respondent or the Second Respondent fail to comply with the February Orders. The correspondence sent to the Respondents included hyperlinks to the Notice of Address for Service and Response forms on the Federal Circuit Court’s website.[12][12] Second Willoughby Affidavit at [17]-[19].19. On 23 March 2021, the Applicant sent further correspondence to the Respondents stating that they had each not complied with the February Orders and that pursuant to the February Orders, the Applicant would file an application for the matter to proceed by way of default judgment.[13] On the same day, the Applicant received an email from the Director of the First Respondent indicating that the First Respondent would not defend the proceedings and would await the outcome of the default judgment application.[14][13] Second Willoughby Affidavit at [20]-[21].[14] Second Willoughby Affidavit at [22].20. On 31 March 2021, the Applicant filed the Default Application and Second Willoughby Affidavit.DEFAULT BY THE FIRST AND SECOND RESPONDENTS21. The Respondents have been on notice of the proceedings since 24 November 2020 and have not participated in the proceedings.22. Neither Respondent has satisfied the Applicant’s claim, nor have they:[15][15] Second Willoughby Affidavit at [24].(a) filed a Notice of Address for Service as required by rule 6.01 of the Rules or as required by the February Orders;(b) filed a Response in accordance with rule 4.03 of the Rules or as required by the February Orders;(c) filed a defence in accordance with rule and 4.05(3) of the Rules or as required by the February Orders; and(d) defended the proceedings with due diligence.23. Accordingly, the Respondents are in default as defined by rule 13.03A(2) of the Rules, thereby providing a basis for the making of orders under rule 13.03B(2)(c) of the Rules.ENTITLEMENT TO RELIEF24. The factual matters relied upon to establish the alleged contraventions of the FW Act are set out in the Statement of Claim.25. In summary, the Applicant alleges:(a) the First Respondent, is and was at all relevant times, the operator of a business that manufactures food trailers, vans and trucks (Business);[16][16] Statement of Claim at [3].(b) the First Respondent, is and was at all relevant times, a national system employer within the meaning of section 14 of the FW Act;[17][17] Statement of Claim at [3].(c) the First Respondent is an entity to which the FW Act applied in respect of its employees;[18][18] Statement of Claim at [3].(d) after conducting an investigation, FWI Lee formed a belief that the First Respondent had contravened terms of the Vehicle Manufacturing, Repair, Services and Retail Award 2010 and a provision of the National Employment Standards relating to minimum wages, overtime rates and payment of accrued but untaken annual leave upon termination of employment;[19][19] Statement of Claim at [6].(e) on 7 April 2020, FWI Lee gave the First Respondent a Compliance Notice which required the First Respondent to calculate and rectify any underpayments to the Employee;[20][20] Statement of Claim at [7]-[8].(f) the First Respondent did not take the action required by the Compliance Notice by the due date, or at all, and thereby contravened section 716(5) of the FW Act;[21][21] Statement of Claim at [10]-[11](g) the Second Respondent was at all material times the manager of the Business, was responsible for ensuring the First Respondent complied with the Compliance Notice, was an intentional participant in the First Respondent’s failure to comply with the Compliance Notice and was therefore involved, within the meaning of section 550(2) of the FW Act, the contravention by the First Respondent of section 716(5) of the FW Act.[22][22] Statement of Claim at [4], [7], [12]-[14].26. Section 716(5) of the FW Act is a civil remedy provision for the purposes of section 539 of the FW Act. Section 539 of the FW Act enables a Fair Work Inspector to apply to the Court for orders in relation to a contravention of a civil remedy provision. The Applicant is an inspector for the purposes of the FW Act (section 701 of the FW Act) and has standing to bring this proceeding.27. On this basis, the Applicant submits that it has an “entitlement” to the relief sought in the Applicant’s Originating Application, as it has made out a case for relief on the face of the Statement of Claim, as set out above.[23][23] ACCC v Dataline at [53].COURT’S POWER TO MAKE THE ORDERS SOUGHT28. Pursuant to section 545(1) of the FW Act, the Court may make any order it considers appropriate if it is satisfied that a person has contravened a civil remedy provision. The orders that the Court may make include:(a) declarations, pursuant to section 16 of the Federal Circuit Court Act 1999 (Cth);(b) pecuniary penalties, pursuant to section 546 of the FW Act;(c) an order awarding compensation for loss that a person has suffered because of a contravention of the FW Act, as provided for in subsection 545(2)(b) of the FW Act; and(d) an order for an amount of interest in relation to an amount that a person was required to pay under the FW Act, as provided in subsection 547(2) of the FW Act.29. The Court has a wide discretionary power to make declarations.[24] The Court may make declarations based on admissions taken to be made consequent on default.[25] This is particularly so in a case such as the present which involves issues of public interest, namely the enforcement of minimum employment entitlements.30. The declarations sought by the Applicant in the Default Application have been framed to identify the contravening conduct accurately and concisely[26], and in so doing they have utility. They mark the Court’s disapproval of the contravening conduct[27] and serve a public interest in educating employers about their obligations to employees and warning of the consequences of failing to comply with statutory notices. As such the declarations sought play a role in achieving general deterrence.31. The form of orders and declarations sought includes wording acknowledging that the declarations are based on deemed admissions, to reflect the suggested form of words of Kiefel J in ACCC v Dataline at paragraph 59 and adopted by this Court in Fair Work Ombudsman v Garfield Berry Farm Pty Ltd & Anor [2011] FMCA 885 at paragraphs 6 to 8.32. The Applicant submits that in all of the circumstances, this is an appropriate case for the Court to make the orders sought in the Default Application.[24] FCC Act, section 16; ACCC v Dataline at [58-59]; ACCC v Yellow Page (No 2) at [65].[25] ACCC v Dataline at [54] to [59]; ACCC v Yellow Page (No 2) at [66] to [69].[26] ACCC v Dataline at [63]; ACCC v Yellow Page (No 2) at [68].[27] ACCC v Dataline at [63]; ACCC v Yellow Page (No 2) at [69].RELEVANT PROVISIONS OF THE RULES